As a woman in uniform, and one who has frequented this business, I will no longer be able to spend my money here because of the disrespectful employee, you chose to employ! Bad move on managements' part. Swift justice and maybe you can save your reputation Update....they fired the guy. Kudos to the boss, the right thing to do!!!! read more

I was at Tottenville Bagels last Thursday, and the employee (with the beard) was vaping as he cut/prepped my cold cuts. So unsanitary. I was so appalled and disgusted! Never going back! read more

Breakfast was cooked to perfection eggs fresh fluffy peppers onions sautéed with still a little crunch and flavorful on a perfectly made bagel. My omelet full of bacon cheese melted on top of well seasoned home fries. Great Job this was our first time of many to come. ​ read more

I've been buying bagels here for a long time now and I just have to say I always except to be better than last time but I never get a good bagel at least me. read more

We received bagels at our office from here for a colleagues last day and they were AMAZING. We're in Philly so it was a special event to have legitimate NY bagels in the office. Spreads were great and all of the bagels were soft and so great. I'll save this place for whenever we need to order again read more

Just got food from there. They completely messed up my order. Wrong bagels, wrong spreads, wrong everything. Not coming back here for a while. read more

People are very nice. Whether I go there or get delivery anyone I interact with is very helpful. Cold cuts are always fresh. A very large selection. read more

Best bagels and food around and service is the best . I come every Friday and Saturday for food after a night out only place with best customer service and grill open 24 hours read more

Great food great service the staff is so friendly and the place is immaculately kept! Camille is a kind

Been a steady customer for 10 years but today would be my last visit To say all of the counter staff are rude and just not nice would be unfair but sadly one individual has been rude to me on more the one occasion So with that said I gave him my coffee back and said you don't have my business any longer This is what happens when management is off site Just seconds down Page my new place for bagels They greeted me with a big Good Morning and how can I help Notice some regulars of my old place there as well Try it it's a lot more customer friendly read more

No one to me can compare Staten Island bagels. Tottenville is our favorite to enjoy when we go back!!!

Stopped by here yesterday and it was definitely a new experience. The place gets crowded fast, we went around 8am and people were in and out, steady flow of customers. I got coffee (serve yourself) & a cinnamon raisin bagel toasted with cream cheese and jelly. The coffee was good, but the bagel was meh. Nothing that stands out for me , I found the bagel hard and unappealing. The bagel was chewy, but NOT in a good way and it was cold when I received it like it was never toasted even though I asked for the bagel to be toasted. The service was no different from the bagel, while we were paying the coffee filters needed to be replaced and the cashier asked the other worker to refill them. The guy stomps out of the kitchen area and goes "Why do I have to make coffee? This is not my job." They went about it for a few minutes until the cashier got tired and said "Forget it then, don't make coffee." Mind you they're yelling at each other like there's no customers around. Uhm is this a business? Your arguing about who needs to make coffee? I think I will skip the bagel and the free show next time. read more

Don't even know where to begin... First of all the person who created this for yelp works there and puts a pic of himself, lol. This is one of the oldest bagel places in the area, and the food taste like it. When i walke in to place my order the person wrote it down on a container and gave me a ticket for my order, wtf? It's not like this place was busy, and now i know why. I ordered a simple bagel with bacon, eggs and cheese. The bagel was rubbery and for a whole wheat bagel way to salty. They sell other stuff such as newspapers, milk, beer, etc. Prices were slightly high and the employees are snobby and not very friendly or trustworthy. I also paid for a plain bagel and the cashier asked me 3 times if there's anything on it and each time i said no! Unbelievable!!! I'm never coming back and recommend you find a different bagel spot. read more

Tottenville Bagels - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Not sure why this bagel store doesn't have better reviews. I have been going here for years. Their bagels are fantastic and their sandwiches are true NY/Brooklyn/Staten Island sandwiches. They are super stuffed and delicious. Everything I get here is fresh and my whole family loves it. Even their Tuna Fish rocks! read more

Great place! Employees are awesome and incredibly kind and accommodating. They have everything and their quick breakfast is a staple in tottenville. read more

Friendly customer service, and an amazingly delicious Italian special wrap with fresh mozzarella, jalapenos, and jalapeno wrap. So good. read more

Tottenville Bagels - Italian special wrap with fresh mozzarella yum - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Got a dozen bagels to go and 3 with cream cheese. All 3 were soooo hard and stale, and this at 9am on a Thursday morning! We can only imagine how the dozen will taste. Keep on driving! On the positive side, the staff were very nice. read more

Fresh bagels and cold cuts. Absolutely well run! Delivery was on time and all condiments were packed neatly. A must!

The worst bec I've ever had in my life. Eggs weren't scrambled, cheese wasn't melted, bagel was stale and took 20 mins to get it. Never going here again and I would never recommend it to anyone. Place is utter garbage read more

This store is out of control with the amount of people that are inside most of the customers have no masks on and the people cooking your food also don't wear masks. I have been going there for over 5 years and the bagels taste like yesterday's. They come out fresh and and hour later they get a little hard can't find a good bagel store anymore. The staff are friendly and some don't even wear masks. There is no limit to the amount of people that are in the store. read more

Best bagels in Staten Island! Ordered from Grubhub and the food came in under 30 minutes. Also went inside once and everyone was polite and respectful. Their bagels are fresh baked and delicious. The cold cuts were super tasty and the inside of the store is well organized. I love this place and will go to them as my main sandwich place. read more

Rude workers on the regular. Pretentious attitude and counter staff refuses to engage in even a "good Morning " Smh This place is only good for midnight runs when Mikey Bagels isnt open but I'm sick of giving my hard earned money to people that treat me like shit . From now on I'll wait til 6am when Mikey opens read more

WORST EXPERIENCE EVER!!! Never as a paying customer, have i been treated as rudely and disrespectfully as i was treated at this store. The older woman at the counter treated me in such a way that i have never been treated before. Between there being no formal line or check out, I was scrutinized for coming up to the counter to pay after someone let me go ahead of them leading me to believe i was next in line. She completely disregarded the fact i was there, not giving me the courtesy or decency to inform me that she was going to ring someone else up first .... again there was no formal line. The WORST part was she called me an entitled millennial telling the person she was ringing up what I did or said nothing to warrant such treatment. I also asked simple questions such as "is this cash only" and "can i have a bag" giving me the rudest response that she "wasn't finished stapling my receipt and that she's getting to it". This is no way to treat a PAYING customer. I will never be coming back again. read more

Super friendly staff to "out-of-towners" Awesome deli sammies!!! My teen couldn't finish his hero!

If you like a bacon egg and cheese with a fly inside of it, this is the go to place! Disgusting! I stopped by a few weeks ago to pick up breakfast and once I arrived home, excitingly my fiancé began eating his bagel, he starting screaming in disgust that a bug was cooked into his bacon egg and cheese. This place needs to clean their kitchen thoroughly, I won't be a customer any time soon! read more

Went into this store to get sandwiches & once inside I noticed a customer had no mask on. My husband pointed out there was no sign on door that stated to wear one either. Although in this world we live in now I don't need anyone to tell me to wear my mask! I then looked at the workers & 1 had no mask on & 2 had them under their nose!!! Seriously? I walked out. I don't need these ppl breathing on my food. No thank you.. if I can put a negative 0 I would .. read more

Terrible.. I used to go here all the time especially when I worked nights and would get off late.. the place is falling apart.. one side of the front steps are roped off I suppose due to needing repair.. the service and quality isn't the same.. the cashier was literally eating a McDonald's sandwich while ringing people up. Serious health code violation, wash your hands... Totally grossed out, will not be back... read more

i am a life long NYC girl and I just love me some fresh bagels and this place does NOT disappoint. Its delicous. I absolutely crave fresh bagels with real butter sometimes and when I do, this place fills my craving. I just love it. Its immaculately clean great service and delicious NYC bagels. wow. Highly recommend to any bagel lover like me who just loves the soft chewy bagel with the sprinkles of everything (poppy, sesame seeds, onion etc ) on the outside of the bagel. I exclusively buy the EVERYTHING bagel and it is da bomb. read more

Very large bagels Excellent egg sandwiches especially Bacon, egg and cheese sandwich They make a great sandwich I have tried to eat egg sandwiches from other delis and bagels stores and people just can't make it x Correct Love they are open 24 hours a day ALWAYS fresh bagels no matter what time of day read more

One of the best bagels around. I've been coming here for breakfast for about 3 years. This place gets very crowded in the morning because everyone around here knows how great their bagels are. I always take people from out of town here and I essentially ruin all other bagel places for them. Bagels come out fresh around 5AM everyday. read more

This place is spotless..Owner is constantly cleaning surfaces and floors in this great spot..plenty of parking and well stocked...from great Boars Head cold cuts. To fresh bagels....Monte has this place on point...Batts loves this place.... read more

Undercooked bagels ...like how do you not fully cook a bagel ..service with an attitude overall dirty...never again

Savage employees. How do they stay in biz? Sometimes employees forget where the money for their paychecks come from.

Bagels are pretty rough at this place. They don't seem like they care that they have customers at all. It will probably be gone soon and that seems like a best case scenario at this point. Avoid at all costs. read more

the worst bacon egg cheese sandwich i've had on staten island. it was poorly made with zero effort and would not recommend anyone to go there ever. read more

The younger woman who took my order was soooooo nasty, I let it slide because it's 11:45am and I figured she was probably tired from being there since before sunrise. But what made this my last visit here was the old nasty woman at the register. I ordered a mini bagel with a slice of cheese for a 2 year old and 2 egg sandwiches so they wrote the price in it. When she went to ring in the mini w a slice of cheese that was marked $1.50 she had a fit how they do things at that location so she obviously was not from this location but she made it such a big deal that it was embarrassing! They are arrogant and not good with customers; do they not realize in a 500 foot radius there's plenty of other bagel stores to go to!!!! read more

I am disgusted I go here all the time but I will never go back again. I got a gold earring in my sandwich.... Do I even have to explain why I am giving a bad review. read more

Tottenville Bagels - Earring I bit into when I got a sandwich.... - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Bagel stores are busy, I have no issue waiting patiently, When you go into a bagel store on a Saturday you expect it. What you don't expect is to get reprimanded by the woman working. I stood patiently while sandwich phones orders were taken, I stood patiently when deli orders were taken with two people behind deli counter knowing the deli is separate..... The woman helping at register walked right by me to deli adding now a third person to deli and took a bacon, egg and cheese on a bagel order - I said, excuse me I was next...... Guess that was the wrong sentence . She snapped "did you hear me say bagels? I SAID can I help anyone with a deli order - he is the one who answered me "!!!! I just turned and walked out - I was there for a bagel not an argument..... There is a bagel store on every corner in Staten Island , your bagels aren't made of gold , customer service is important too. I pulled right out of the lot, right next door to 24 Hour Bagels where I was greeted with a smile , and a "how can I help you" .....the bagels were just as good and they were just as busy. read more

Tottenville bagels is one the best bagels stores i have ever been too. First off the bagels are hand rolled. everything is fresh, because this store is so busy you will never get anything thats not fresh or stale because the bagels are made there and are bought like crazy. saturday and sundays the place is packed, you need to get the bacon egg and cheese!!! amazing. the everything bagels are my favorite! Chicken salad and tuna salad out of this world. all the sandwiches are packed with meat they are HUGE! the bagels are also hugeeee. I have also received catering from there as well, which was awesome. Great Italian heros! I live in the neighborhood so I got to know the owners. They are both from Brooklyn and have been in the business for years. Awesome people. You can't visit staten island without stopping here and getting a REAL bagel or a delicious sandwich. read more

I have been going to Tottenville Bagels for many years. About five years ago I moved to North Carolina and I make sure that whenever I come up to NY I stop in and order at least three to four dozen bagels to take back with me. They have the bast bagels I've ever had. They even make low carb bagels that are fantastic. Their deli foods are incredible and the people that work there are really nice, especially John. He goes out of his way to package up my bagels so they stay fresh on the trip back to NC. Try them, you won't be sorry. Tell John that Mark from North Carolina said hey. read more