What a great surprise! We wanted to try somewhere new and looked up restaurants in the area. Husband and I ate a great spaghetti dinner and one of the specials. Also the crab cakes are really tasty! I do not think this was overpriced at all, about the same as Olive Garden and this is much better quality. You also get salad and bread with your meal. We will come back again! read more

Salads are great but food is overrated here and pretty pricey for all you get. Basically it's a fancy restaurant in a house

I love the food at Uncle Primo's! I've eaten here several times over the years and I've never had a bad meal. Last time I was there - about a week ago - I had the crab cakes with pasta and it was delicious! The time before that, Bob, the owner, came out and greeted us. The only complaint I have is that when you call to make a reservation, you still end up waiting 30+ minutes for a table after you get there, which is a little frustrating, especially when you arrive there hungry. read more

I love this restaurant the prices are great and the settings are intimate. It's a nice date nite place.

We ordered appetizers, wine and dessert. The crab cakes and stuffed peppers were amazing, hot but amazing! The mozzarella sticks were pretty standard, but delicious. We ordered the homemade cream puff for dessert - wow! Highly recommend! The wine was only ok, we ordered a bottle of the chianti (the only one on the menu), and I would order something else next time. Overall, we had a good experience, food was great and so was the service! read more

The food is always outstanding and the service is great. Love the huge bowl of salad they bring before your dinner. The only problem is that no matter what day you have reservations for... you wait. We have had to wait forty minutes before. They need to work on that. read more

Friendly wait staff and great food. I had the mahi mahi blackened on cedar. Portions were well sized. Save room for the cream puff which is perfect to be shared! read more

Looking for a local Italian place with great food- this is a gem!!! Had the penne pasta with basil and chicken. Great favor, fast service and delicious food!!! Wish it was near my house. read more

Absolutely amazing!! Great food, great atmosphere, and hands down great service. I never wrote a review before, but had to about uncle Primo's!! Just make sure you have a reservation for the weekends. read more

Likely the best restaurant in Tuscarawas County. Spectacular service, fascinating menu, and amazing food. Also, taking quality into consideration, it actually provides good value. Blackened salmon is a favorite. Everything we've tried over the course of several years has been good and some things have been truly great. Thank you! read more

Visiting from Wisconsin and absolutely love Uncle Primos! Excellent steaks, great service, welcoming cozy atmosphere.

Absolutely delicious food, feels like genuine Italian/German/American cuisine. Charming and a bit off the beaten path as far as location, which only adds to the general feel. Bundle up though, the dining areas are fairly chilly! read more

Our group of six was looking for a place to eat after disc golf. We were underdressed and unprepared but they accommodated on a Saturday night at about 5pm. Food was excellent. read more

The staff is really friendly. I was a little disappointed the food didn't have more flavor. The chicken Alfredo was ok but bland and the same with the steak. They have a sweet house dressing which I loved but my husband didn't. I will probably give it another chance because everyone else has left great reviews. read more

Stopped in for dinner on a Saturday night. This has always been know for great Italian food and we were not disappointed. Spaghetti and steak at our table. They served a big salad with house dressing and home made bread. The spaghetti was really good with home made meatballs. The steak also was delicious and prepared spot on. Great service topped the evening off. read more

Reservations were made on the phone. Upon arrival, no reservations were on file. Service was average and restaurant appeared clean. Filet was ordered medium well butterfly and was received very red and not cooked thoroughly - immediately got sick and threw up. Waitress offered to take $10 off $25 meal despite not being able to eat the meal. This was the worst fillet I've had in my life and will not revisit this restaurant. read more

Dont let the outside scare you away!! Best food anywhere!! And the staff is extra friendly and do a great job taking care of you!!

Got the Mahi Mahi blackened tonight wife got ribeye. Exellent as always. Never got anything here that wasn't great. Small out of the main drag restaurant but locals come here worth finding. read more

One of my lunchtime favorites!!! Food is great and so is the service!!! They get me fed and on my happy way when I'm rushed and I love that!! Parking can be tricky...but even if you have to park and walk....it's worth it!! read more

The salad is amazing! I've been going here for many years and have always been happy with the service and quality of food. The only bad experience I've had was she charged us for the first round of bread and it came out to be about 1.00 per slice. It may have just been an honest mistake since we ordered a second round and she didn't bring it out to us. read more

My wife and I heard about this little diamond and went there for our seventh anniversary. The food was excellent and the service was great even the owner came over and thanked us for coming in. What a great place, will definitely be back. Oh and by the way try the creampuff to end your meal it was absolutely delicious. read more

We're from out of town visiting the Walnut Creek area. We had already visited the Amish restaurants and we're looking for something different. That brought us to New Phillidelphia, Ohio to visit Uncle Primo's. We enjoy and appreciate local mom and pop establishments not so much the chains. There we had the best "Shark" I've ever tasted. Being big seafood fans we were somewhat skeptical. The owner presented us with the meal and it was beyond our expectations. As well as the shark, we had Filet Mignon, and New York strip which were prepared to perfection. To top off the dinner was the homemade cream puff which was absolutely fantastic. We understand that everything is homemade. The staff as well as the owner Bob were as curtious as can be. We will definitely recommend to our friends and family Uncle Primo's if they ever visit this locality. Thanks Uncle Primo's for such a great experience! read more

Yes, I'm a fan of Uncle Primo's! The food is delicious and the price is great. The only thing I didn't love was the salad (pretty much iceberg lettuce and cheese) but I didn't come for a salad! THE RAVIOLI IS WORTH A TRIP IN ITSELF! read more

Uncle Primos have been around for quite a while. Food is top notch, occasionally i feel "squeezed" in and a little crowded during busy times. read more