A great place! The meatball sandwich will not disappoint. The drink selection rivals 7-11!! A must stop when I'm in town.

Excellent, unique and fresh ingredients in all their sandwiches! Affordable food, great sides and not a long wait.

Excellent! Always a pleasure to eat here. The portion sizes are huge and the prices are fair. Large selection of drinks and a fun atmosphere with playful colors and decor. Always fast and friendly. Great desserts and sides too! read more

So, after hearing incredible things about this place for years, I finally had the chance to try it for myself. I went with my mother who ordered the BBQ ribs and Mac n Cheese platter. I had a sandwich (The name slips my mind, but it was turkey, cheese, roasted red peppers, lettuce, and basil mayo). Truth be told, I came away with a lot of disappointment. The sandwich "tasted" okay, the ingredients individually were fine, but the sandwich overall was relatively dry and could've used more of the mayo (I couldn't taste it at all, actually). The bread was somewhat soggy in the middle even though the sandwich was dry, and the bread was burnt on one side. It wasn't terribly bad, just not the tastebud blowing experience I had been expecting. As for the side, I don't really like pasta salad to begin with, but was hoping to be pleasantly surprised and instead was much more disappointed with pasta salad than I usually am. My mom ordered the BBQ ribs and Mac n Cheese plate, and upon first whiff, it seemed like it'd be a great dish. But the first bite of the Mac n Cheese made my mom think of moldy cheese, and when I tasted it I couldn't quite place what cheese it was, but it didn't taste right to me either. The ribs I didn't taste, but my mom said they would have been better if she hadn't been eating the Mac with it. Afterwards, my mom felt pretty ill and was definitely disappointed by the experience. I'm hoping it was just a singular bad experience, but I'm a little too afraid to go back and try again. read more

Great place to eat. Loved it. I'm allergic to tomatoes and had an awesome white pizza!

Traveling to VA. Found the Undercover Eggplant. Sandwiches were great. Large portions, all3 of us only ate 1/2 of our sandwich. Fresh ingredients in the sandwiches , staff was country and helpful . read more

We were in town for Cooperstown All Star Village and Undercover Eggplant was recommended to us by more than one person, so we knew we had to try it out. It was delicious both times we went! The sandwiches are HUGE and are served with a generous side of pasta salad. The salads - also HUGE and very fresh. I didn't try the pizza but some in our group did and said it was very good. Great selection of bottled drinks and some baked goods, if you have room after. Check out the specials too, which are on signs near the register. It's very close to ASV (maybe 5-10 minutes tops to get there). Quick, friendly service so it's perfect for in between games. read more

Really rude people who do not participate in supporting the community . I went in to ask for an SPCA donation last year and they treated me like dirt . There is something to be said about supporting worthwhile charities in a town where you expect people to patronize your business read more

I know everyone raves about the sandwiches, but something must be said for the best pasta salad in the universe that accommodates the delicious behemoth sandwiches. Also love the many options for desserts and local drinks. read more

Great lunch here! So glad they are open again after the fire. Had a 5 month long craving satisfied today with their infamous eggplant sandwich. So flavorful! The salads are huge, too, very satisfying and filling. Friendly and efficient service. read more

As a die-hard foody, I am saying there is nothing else in Oneonta that even comes close to the Undercover Eggplant. The sandwiches are incredible! They are diverse, unique, and flavorful. I can just choose anything at random from the menu, or the daily specials, and know I'm going to get something delicious that I can't get anyplace else. My favorite is the Louisiana Locksmith, which is fried eggplant, ham, melted mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and mayonnaise. I usually order one of the specials, however, because I love the variety. The quality of the ingredients and the value for your money is without equal in the Oneonta area. The soups are terrific, as well as the salads. I like a thinner-crust pizza, but the creamy garlic eggplant pizza is still insanely good. There is also a tasty and unique selection of sides, beverages, and desserts. Lunch time can be extremely busy, so I would recommend calling in your order ahead of time. read more

Deliciousness. Their homemade Italian bread is worth the trip in itself, let alone the gargantuan deli sandwiches. I love the vintage 50s type feel it has, especially with the glass bottles of soda. Usually we have to wait slightly longer than expected but it is totally worth it! I like that it offers vegetarian options too - grilled tempeh is good and the hot eggplant is good too! Its especially awesome on a college budget - get two meals for one price. read more

AMAZING FOOD! Best place in Oneonta Hands down! But........ The girl who I believe is the owner's daughter is completely rude and makes the dining experience unbearable. I think someone needs to take a customer service class or two... Too bad, great place otherwise. read more

At first I was only stopping here for the Mrs. Eggplant, but one day, alas, I could not order it, and I was forced to explore their menu. I am so happy that happened because I found other really great sandwiches! Right now I really love the Mary Hedwig sandwich which as squash on it! I am a vegetarian, and I really appreciate what is available here to eat. The portions are wonderful and the staff is always very nice. My orders have always been correct, and I have always found the ingredients to be fresh! read more

It was great!!! The P.O. boy sandwich was amazing!!!! Soooo yummy! And great pasta salad too! Very impressed!

everything is so, so good. the pasta salad that comes with your sammie is non-traditional, which some people hate on, but I think its a nice accompaniment. read more

Somehow no matter what they serve it seems to be delicious. I've tried their salad, soup and pizza -- all were awesome. I've never had pizza taste so fresh. This is one place I don't care to look at the price, i just buy and eat. read more

I miss this place so much since moving back to Long Island!! Super clean and staffed with friendly people. The perfect place for a quick bite to eat. They have an extensive menu and a lot of vegetarian options, so everyone in your group will find something they like. The soups are all fantastic. I even love the name! Can't wait to stop in next time I am in town. read more

Simply yummy. Love every menu item I have ever eaten there. Their desserts are to die for. Their side pasta salad I actually have cravings for. Excellent food. They are always super busy though so call ahead. I wish they were open on Sundays and after 7pm. Undercover we need more opportunities to eat your delicious food! read more

Great place for lunch. Sandwiches are huge and the apple raisin crumb pie was yuumy. Good place to stop on our way back to Boston.

Everything made in store from the bread to the amazing pasta salad. The sandwiches leave you more then satisfied and Blue Plate Specials are pretty much home cooked meals perfect for busy people. The staff is always fantastic and helpful, while they also have a great beverage and dessert selection. read more

I've only had this place once and didn't really see the big deal. The sandwich I got was a turkey one with artichokes, but way too many artichokes. I am tempted to go back and get a different sandwich because everyone raves about this place. They do have a very large selection of beverages, and sandwiches as well. The staff seemed friendly and the place is very clean. read more

okay so if your reading this right now, stop what you are doing, get in your car/bike/ whatever and go immediately to undercover eggplant because its amazing. Literally the best you can get when it comes to delis. try the eggplant special or chicken parm and take a loaf of bread with you home. the pizzas are suprisingly great also. my favorite is the broccoli white pizza.. read more

I have not been there in a few years until last week but remembered the sandwiches being good. It seems to me they really increased the size of the sandwiches from a few years back. I got Maria's Muffaletta (an Italian style sandwich) and it was big with plenty of meat and delicious! I like the fact that the sandwiches are unique and the bread is too. I can't remember exactly what I paid but it was worth it. Give this place a try! read more

Why would you put a hot chicken Parm sandwich on untoasted rye bread? Soggy and inedible, and chicken was relatively bland. Two stars is only for the pasta salad. read more

Great stop, not far off from I-88. With Sis and two nieces (11 and 8) - We ordered two pizzas, one with just meatballs and the other was a signature pizza with meatballs, onions and ricotta cheese - both excellent - Loved the crusts. The size is definitely enough for two people. We also order the open faced eggplant sandwich and the chicken Parmesan sandwich ... the eggplant was excellent (would hope so since eggplant is in the name of the restaurant) ... the Chicken Parmesan was so so ... just wasn't out "cup of tea" - thought it would be breaded chicken. Both sandwiches were what I would assume on inhouse baked bread - great bread, just didn't translate to the chicken parm sandwich. Both came with pasta salad which I found to be excellent! GREAT value ... 2 pizzas, 2 sandwiches, 4 beverages - $47. Not your usual sandwich / pizza / salad place. The desserts looked really good - just no room! Try this place - it's Mom and Pop and definitely worth it! read more

Great sandwich shoppe. Piled high with fresh ingredients. I give it a 4 only because it is a self serve with no wait staff. But a definite 5 star sandwich shoppe. Would come back again. read more

I've only been there once, but had an excellent eggplant sandwich - would love to go back and try more of their different sandwich options. The homemade bread was fantastic, and the service was pretty good for a not full-service type of place. Food was also prepared fairly quickly - perfect for on the go take out. read more

Delicious eggplant sandwich, lemongrass tea, and very fresh garden salad with wonderful balsamic vinaigrette. Reasonably priced too.

Excellent lunch spot. We ordered the Cuban special and the Rhode Island Deli Hot. Fresh real delicious

Delicious food! We love the sandwiches and pasta salads. The dinner salads are huge and Delicious also. We also ike the pretzel bread, very tasty! They can be very busy so best to call in order ahead of time. read more

Great sandwiches! My husband loves eating here when we pass through town, and he's a picky eater. Undercover Eggplant never disappoints!

Every sandwich is absolutely amazing because they make it on their fabulous homemade bread. The Eggplant special is my favorite but you really can't go wrong with any of them. The interior is cold and unwelcoming but the food more than makes up for it. Their salads are wonderful. The desserts are a little on the cafeteria/diner side but the portions are huge. read more

Came in here from All Star Village to get out of the rain and have some lunch! Delicious! Pasta salad was very good. We were so tired of fast food and this was definitely home made. read more

Wonderfully fresh food, sandwiches, salads, pizza. Lots of room to sit down and enjoy the food and their huge selection of non-alcoholic. beverages. You can get cocktails in their liquor store. To top off this great place is friendly people who work there. What a great treat. read more

1st time here. Sandwiches were delicious and too big to finish. Took mine with me and had a second serving at home. I had the Cuban which was different from ones I've had in Northern New Jersey. My wife had some kind of vegetable sandwich. She said it was interesting AND delicious. Will try a different sandwich next time. read more

Got food poisoning along with other people who ate at this restaurant. Good food but not worth getting sick over.

I went out to lunch on a Wednesday, we ordered sandwiches off the menu. The place wasn't too crowded, most of the tables had people at them but the turnover was pretty quick. The place was clean and surprisingly peaceful given the crowd, and we only waited a few minutes to place our order. The wait was reasonable, we sat at a table for about ten minutes until our pager buzzed and the waitress brought our food. I had their corned beef sandwich, hot corned beef with coleslaw on italian bread with pasta salad on the side. I don't usually eat a lot of coleslaw, but theirs was flavorful and the cool slaw perfectly balanced the hot corned beef, and the bread was very tasty - it was one of the best sandwiches I've had in a restaurant. The pasta salad had a very nice sauce and made a good compliment to the meal. We paid $6.95 each for our sandwiches (we didn't get beverages) and I found it to be a very good value and I'll definitely go again. read more

The sandwiches here are amazing. I am stuck on the eggplant sandwich as it is OMG, good! The pizza here is also good compared with the cardboard slabs that are served downtown. But the sandwiches, oh, wow, the sandwiches. If you haven't eaten here, you need to go for a treat. They're very generously sized. I can only eat half of a sandwich in a single sitting, but it gives me lunch the next day and it's VERY affordable, especially for the quality. read more

A wonderful find! Sandwiches were huge and delicious and served on lovely homemade bread. The sausage mushroom soup was also amazing! Looking forward to returning! read more