2017-09-02. So we stopped by the Union Pizza Company to pick up dinner because we were staying at the Manhattan Marriott and the place was undergoing renovations, including their restaurant which was at the time a makeshift tent. Mind you it was a very nicely decorated tent, but we didn't want to pay the absorbent hotel prices for tent-dining.
There wasn't much choice, and it was getting late, so dine-in restaurants were closing. I did a quick yelp check and the place was rated 4 stars.
Union Pizza is located in a plaza with plenty of free parking. The place was small for a restaurant, with accommodations to seat a couple of dozen guests inside. Outside is a different story; pergola seating accommodated another 30 and additional seating for about 20 had umbrellas. I'm not sure if the outdoor seating was exclusive to Union Pizza, or a common space for the strip mall but it was directly outside of this shop. Inside, the decor was very modern, and the place was very clean. Solid tables and chairs made of wood and steel. softer lighting in the seating area and brighter lighting behind the cash counter to light up the menu written on a large chalk board mounted to the wall. Menu cards were also available for you if you preferred to sit and peruse.
The menu consists of Salads; Sandwiches; Pastas; appetizers; wings; and of course, Pizza. Pizza came two ways, Chicago Deep Dish style, and New York thin crust style. They have preset pizza or you can build your own. The place boasts fresh, never frozen, all natural ingredients (no nitrates or preservatives).
Before I continue, I need to warn everyone that I'm not a fan of pizza in general, but do consume my fair share of it because my family likes it; that is, I'm not a fan, but I don't dislike pizza either. It's just not my preferred food. However, I have my preferences. I definitely favor New York style to Chicago, but even within NYC, "New York Style" pizza varies greatly between the five boroughs. I prefer the Bronx's thinner crust to that of the original Naples (Neapolitan) style pizza made famous by Gennaro Lombardi where they were heavy on the sauce, and the cheese was smattered on. Naples style leaves the pizza soggy, but it was meant to be eaten with knife and fork. The original Naples pie is the basis by which all American pizzas are judged; and the ban on the use of coal fired ovens spawned the American-Neapolitan pie, where cheese blanketed the entire pie and ovens moved from coal to gas. In my experience, Brooklyn style pizza's tends to keep more true to the Naples recipe, and some places still use coal fired ovens. Union Pizza advertises Brooklyn style pies, but much like Manhattan, they can't use coal, so the word "style" is appropriate.
To me a pizza is no good if it's too hot, too wet, or burnt. If it's too hot, it'll burn the roof of your mouth. If it's too wet, the dough will not cook evenly and will be soggy in the middle. If it's burnt, well, it'll just taste like what cardboard smells like (unless you're that CEO from Kashi, you probably won't like the taste either). A good pizza IMO has a solid bottom crust, and will sag a little towards the center, not flop over and let all the toppings slide off. The top crust should be firm, not wet (under-cooked); and it shouldn't be too greasy, which means ingredients play an integral part (Yeah, I'm a bit of a pizza snob when I do eat it...)
I noticed that all of their specialty pizzas contained 5 toppings or less, which is ideal for cooking (the percentage of getting a soggy pizza goes way up with thin crust when you're 6 toppings or more). We selected The Village specialty pizza, NY Style, easy on the sauce. It came with pepperoni, sausage, ham, and mushrooms.
Visually, the pie looked great. The dough was cooked well and wasn't wet enough to require "The Fold Hold" to eat it. The proportion of toppings was equally well executed. The cheese was ooey gooey, but the downside was that they were slightly lacking with it, more Naples than American. 3,5 stars.
Prices are definitely on the high side, even for NYC standards. A 16" pie with a couple of drinks ran me just over $38 out the door, and for this I'm rounding them down to 3 stars overall.
BTW, You can find Neapolitan pies with the smattered cheese all over the city. Brooklyn, Manhattan, and Queens tend to stay closer to the Naples Pies, while Staten Island and the Bronx tend to have a crunchier crust (some places add cornmeal to the crust to make it crunchier which I'm not a fan of). If you're in NYC, you need to check out Nick's (Queen's); Di Fara (Brooklyn); Totonno's (Coney Island); Joe & Pat's (Staten Island); and Coals (Bronx) for thin crust grilled pizza. Of course, if you're in Manhattan you should try Lombardi's to see what started all the hype.
If you would like to experience more, come dine-with-me.yelp.com I'd love to have your company... Bon Appétit! read more