The sauce is amazing, the crust is slightly chewy, the toppings are perfectly proportioned and the owner and staff are always happy to see you. Big ups! read more

In past years I would order from here all the time. The last few have been pretty awful. During the most recent occurrence (which will be the last) we got 1 of the 2 correct dishes, the wrong dressing, and no garlic knots (supposed to be included). Delivery took over an hour and we're only a few blocks away. I called to try to have the correct order delivered. A guy with poor English tried to convince me that I got the right order because he "cooked it himself". He said "you go enjoy your meal and call back another time and we'll take care of you". When I asked why he wouldn't send another order out I was told it would take too long. The food we did get was dry & tasteless. Not sure what happened to these guys but it's not worth ordering from them anymore. read more

Pizza was decent, however delivery over an hour late! Seamless gave 20-30 minute time frame, I called after 35 minutes and was told "6 minutes". After another 15 minutes, I called again and he said "I'll call the guy". He never called me back. After a full hour from when I ordered, I called again and was told he was almost there. 10 minutes later he arrived. Somehow the pizza was hot, so I'm assuming they were lying about it being out for delivery. I checked back on seamless and they were still advertising 20-30 minutes despite the delivery guy telling me "very busy night". I will not be ordering again. read more

Oh my goodness. These guys are great, and I hope they are making gobs of money. Their portions are seriously generous. These guys are an 'old school' trattoria-style pizza/pasta place. My SO grew up in Long Island and the food is very similar to some idealized pasta place in his memory banks. Nothing fancy or strange, just solid good fare. We've often gotten the chicken caesar salad and eggplant rollatini, which comes a small salad garlic knots and a side of pasta with marinara sauce. Tonight I got chicken with spinach and feta cheese, which is delicious (also with the small salad, garlic knots and side of pasta). My SO got the eggplant parm hero which is gigantic. Holy cow. I would give this place a solid 4.5 stars. Would be a great place to order for a young family, since the portions are so large. read more

This place is great! I always do the lunch deal (which they now extended to any time of day) of two slices of pizza and a medium soda for $5! You cannot beat that. Plus it's in a cool area, which isn't yet like the rest of Park Slope but definitely developing as we speak. The service is friendly and there are always places to sit (inside or outside) so I would definitely recommend it. read more

Really nice and consistently reliable pizza. The same friendly guy, who I assume to be the owner, is always there. We often get the four cheese pizza, which is rich and satisfying. Everything is reasonably priced, and pick-up orders are always ready on time. I always get the sense that the food is prepared with care. read more

Fantastic pizza, great price. My wife and I were in Brooklyn for the weekend and looking for a small local place to get pizza, this was right across the street from where we were staying, it was convenient and delicous. read more

Got a couple slices from there a couple years ago and both of them had long curly hairs on them which was absolutely disgusting. I didn't notice until one was in my mouth, but up until then I don't recall the taste being anything to write home about. read more

I ordered from Grubhub and received my order faster than expected. The Margherita pizza was delicious with the very fresh mozzarella and very flavorful sauce - best crispy crust I've had. Unfortunately, as I was eating I did find a staple in one of the slices of pizza. I didn't notice it until I was biting into the slice as the staple was underneath the sauce as if it was baked into the pizza. However, this did not take away from the fast delivery and otherwise fresh ingredients. read more

The nice man behind the counter was actually the owner! The food was great. My daughter and I had just returned from a two month trip abroad and could NOT wait to eat American food again! Our hotel recommended Villa Mia, as we wanted to have some REAL NYC style pizza. Huge pieces. I had a slice of spinach and artichoke pizza with garlic knots and a Coke. Everything I've been dreaming of for weeks. If you have a moment, stop in. Friendly, authentic, clean, inexpensive, and TASTY! Thanks pizza dude! read more

I love this place. The margherita pizza is phenomenal from the slightly sweet plum sauce to the gooey mozzarella cheese; I can and have eaten four slices in one sitting and I see myself doing it again in the not-so-distant future read more

I had walked into Villa Mia a few times and while the food wasn't stellar, it' was at least on the cheap side. And I loved that they filled the canoli per order. That is unless you order them for delivery, then you get a half-empty shell with a dollup of filling on each end. They also over charged me by almost $6 on an order of ziti, a hero and one canoli (i ordered 1 and was charged for 2). The receipt that was stapled to the menu they sent with the delivery verified that over-charge. Their lunch specials used to be worth the walk down to 3rd Av, but I will never have them deliver to me again. I doubt i'll even go down for the specials as often just because I'm feeling so taken advantage of. Villa Mia would have gotten a better rating before that delivery of doom read more

Ordered from seamless, I was at work and needed something delivered fast so I could eat quick before my next appointment. Not only was the delivery there after an hour (seamless said 20-35 mins), but my fettucine alfredo was probably the least cheesy thing i've ever eaten in my life. Bland as could be (so were the garlic knots) and no cheese in sight. This was literally a butter sauce. I added mushrooms and spinach (which were good) and opted for "fresh fettucine" which was an extra dollar but I figured if they're making the pasta on premises who can resist that...but it might as well have been Barilla out of the box. To sum it up, fettucine alfredo sans alfredo. Disappointing. Won't be ordering again. read more

This place is garbage. I came in and ordered an eggplant parm. The guy asked if I wanted the lunch special or the regular. I opted for lunch special, because why not chose a cheaper price for the same item? When it came time to pay, I pulled out a debit card because he had the Square sticker along with the cc stickers on his front door. He started screaming a out how I had to ask before ordering in if he would accept my card? Welcome to America, a$$hole, I don't ask before I pay if you ADVERTISE you take cards. The way business operates is you take my money in any form for services, if younwish to stay in busniess. Also, if you want cash for certain menu items, you're supposed to advertise as such. He yelled and screamed and threatened to call the cops....All because he didn't want to take a credit card. After that, I was not about to pay for my sandwich. He bet me $100 the place next door didn't take a card....and guess what? I've got my food in my hand and my credit card slip in my hand. Go to the Spanish spot next dopr, lovely ladies and lovely food!!! read more

made an account specifically for this, as I have never written on yelp before. I received a call after placing a delivery order...at work...to tell me that my food would be arriving later then I wanted because the online tip I made was not sufficient enough. You have got to be kidding me. I was bothered at work to be told that I need to tip the driver at least 3 extra dollars (after already tipping that much on a 7 dollar order) or else my food would be slower and slower. After asking for a manager or owner, I was told there was not one and maybe I would receive a call without them taking my information at all. TERRIBLE SERVICE. read more

The BEST local pizzeria....watching the pizzamen use fresh ingredients is really a treat and they really love to see you happy...great service. The pizza is absolutely delicious and the sauce is perfectly balanced. I love the specialty pies, especially the fresh mozzarella. I have tried almost every pizzeria in the hood but this is the one I always come back to. Great lunch specials too! read more

My favorite place for a slice or two anywhere in Gowanus or Park Slope. Lucky it's down the street. They must do a lot of takeout to survive - I walk in and never see more than one other person there. Had an excellent eggplant slice the other day, which the guy was justly proud of. What they have left over at the end of the day they make sure to give to local homeless folks. read more

Great food! Slice of pepperoni pizza, huge and tasty, spinach, mozz and black olive roll stuffed and satisfying, and fried calamari a bit chewy but flavorful. Super affordable, good service. No complaints here. Bonus: grab a beer next door 100s of choices. read more

Ordered a pizza at 9:30 Saturday night and when it arrived was very clear they just threw my toppings on a previously cooked pie (meant for sale as slices) and heated it up. The sausage was also very bland and in general was sparse with both the sausage and peppers. Tasted okay, but when you order a pizza you expect to be fresh. This tasted like day old pizza reheated. read more

Worst service ever. Aggressive and rude staff on the phone, won't order again and will definitely not recommend eating there

Fresh ingredients, great price, great service, delicious pizza! We spent a week in Brooklyn and tried several pizza places. This one was the best. read more

amazing customer service! It was a hot day and the dude brought be like 6 refills of tap water. Lots of pizza places in ny won't even give you tap water! Pizza was great too. read more

I can't say enough about this place, the food, the service, absolutely everything is fantastic. The pizza is wonderful, I always order either extra cheese, or extra cheese with pepperoni. The crust is always perfectly crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, almost has a subtle sweet flavor to it, the sauce is delicious, perfect balance of flavor, and the cheese is top quality, mates very well with all the other flavors. Now, let me talk about the homemade mozzarella sticks. They will absolutely ruin you for all other mozzarella sticks you may have ever had in the past. These are not your typical frozen, then deep fried logs of fake cheese, no, these are hand rolled, baked, using fresh mozzarella, pockets of awesomeness. Get them, you will not be disappointed. Then there's the chicken francese. This dish is beyond delicious. Homegrown herbs and spices, along with fresh chicken, and the magic that Alberto does in the kitchen with the sauce, it is absolutely to die for. To. Die. For. If you eat this and don't like it, you have no soul. Bottom line, it's a little, unassuming place you may walk by without thinking twice, but stop in, grab a slice, talk with the guys for a minute, because they are very proud of the food they serve, and love to see others enjoy their food. read more