Have had several lunches at this location. For a quick slice of pizza Villa Monte is an excellent choice because there is a wide selection of pies and the restaurant is spacious, clean, and inviting. My slice of stuffed eggplant for $4 today was very filing not to mention delicious, lots of eggplant, ricotta and mozzarella in one slice. Service is quick, staff is friendly and all the pies essentially taste as good as they look. They are also very accommodating about made to orders for salads and sides. Definitely recommend. read more

Villa Monte - Pizza Near Me - Old Bethpage, New York

See all

Busy local pizzeria. Vast array of specialty slices at lunch time, seems like a lot less at night. Delicious pesto slice, others can be hit or miss. But there is always something new and exciting to try. I recommend. read more

Pathetic.... Some woman with a fake Italian accent who takes your order. Pizza sits out for hours and the food is terrible. But BET THERE ARE PEOPLE WHO LIKE IT- They know nothing about quality or what pizza should be. read more

Consistency is everything in the food business from A-Z! Service: As others have said the woman with the fake Italian accent is a little obnoxious at times. Today she gave me the wrong lunch order, and after waiting for the correct lunch order, she had a waiter come by the table and ask for $1.50. She made the mistake, and expected me to get up in the middle of eating for $1.50. She made the mistake, and should have let it go. Now after coming here for over a year ever week on lunch breaks, I don't think I will return. Hope it was worth the $1.50 to lose several regular customers over your mistake. I was with 5 work colleagues that thought it was a poor management decision and they too said they will not be coming back. Food: The food is hit or miss. Somedays the pizza is great, other days I've had to return pizza (calamari slice) because it was rotten. Some days the meatballs have a great flavor, other days very bland. As other reviewers have said, food sits out all day. The slice you see at 12 noon is still sitting there at 9pm. So if on the chance you get a day when things go right at Monte's then your in for some good pizza. Other than that, save yourself from the subpar service, over priced pizza and salads, and the chance that someone will interrupt your lunch to ask you for more money 20 minutes after you've placed your order. read more

Anyone who says this place is not perfect should check themselves into a mental facility for a 72 hour psych check. I used to live In NY and now I live in Florida. I dream of this place on a daily basis. Every time I drive up from Florida it's my fiancé and I first stop before we even check into hotel. With that we proceed to order at least 4/5 slices each on top of getting food for later on that night and stuffing our travel coolers with food. Thank You Montes for having the best pizza on Long Island if not the entire state of NY SALUTE read more

If you want a place that has dozens of different slices this is a most stop. The chicken roll as well is very good, if you want anything coming out hot out of the oven tho you must tell the guys behind the counter to make it hot!! They seemed to be the most unhappy countermen I've seen. Something I shouldn't have to ask for since it's common damn sense maybe I'm too spoiled with Angelas in Islip [read my review for my favorite pizzeria]. So for the fact of common sense they loose 2 stars hey if I'm going in once a week and can't figure that out by now. read more

I was on a dinner run for Dennis & me. Villa Monte & Pete the Greek are in the same Old Bethpage shopping center where the Post Office is located. I stopped​ at Pete the Greek for my dinner order and went on to Villa Monte for 2 slices of the tomato & cheese pizza. This was my first visit to both places. Villa Monte is much larger than I expected. It has a separate dining and pizza area. The was a huge selection of pizzas. At home, Dennis ate the two slices of tomato & cheese pizza but he still loves La Piazza's pizza. I loved my pork gyro at Uncle Pete's which you will have to read about on their site. read more

Great chicken a la vodka pie but the Spanish artichoke has undercooked artichokes in it. Completely ruins the pizza.

Baked clam pizza, Calamari pizza, Chicken a la Vodka pizza. Oh yeah and maybe 30 other kinds of pizza. Leave your half mushroom/half cheese pizza mindset at the door and let your tastebuds fly. read more

While in Melville on business with 2 associates we asked our hotel bartender where local people go for good Italian. The recommendation of Villa Monte was spot on! Though this is clearly a specialty Pizza place, the three of us went for the traditional Italian menu items though. sauteed calamari with linguini! Lasagna! A terrific tasting house Chianti. Great service. Very reasonable prices. Nothing fancy by any means, but if your purpose is to enjoy a great Italian dinner I highly recommend Villa Monte. Quirk: doesn't accept AMEX. Extra quirk: "Sorry, cash tips only" read more

Most of the people giving this low scores aren't ordering the right stuff. Like other reviewers have said this is a place you go to for specialty slices... don't bother with their regular slice. Their old fashioned slice and buffalo slices are bomb. Also the rigatoni slice is very good. The only reason I am not giving this 5 stars is because not everything on the menu is great, That being said there is some 5 star slices here and this place has overtaken LaPiazza as the best pizza place in the area. read more

One of the worst experiences I ever experienced in a restaurant or pizzeria. Food was cold, the pasta was as hard as a rock and cold and when I tried to return it they tried to charge me for it and told me I ate it. The principle is not the price of the food it's making me pay for something that was horrible. I toldher to take it and throw it in the garbage because that's what I was going to do if I took it home. The service was horrible took forever to get anything or even the attention of a waitress. read more

Over an hour and a half for deliver...of course the food came cold...wasn't a good experience at all

Always! Always always always when I'm over that way ... their speciality slices are incredible..: the eggplant parm is also probably my favorite place to eat eggplant parm.... The penne vodka was delicious tooo..: and the woman there who calls me Bella is my favorite... they are all so sweet! read more

Went close to lunch so line picked up quick.. shrimp scampi was very good was a lil scared to try it but happy I did .. my fiancé ordered the buffalo calamari and the old fashioned vodka slice .. he said he enjoyed it I don't like calamari so I didn't try it looked interesting tho .. decent sizes for the price .. I also ordered a small Caesar salad which was a pretty good size .. overall I enjoyed it .. right down the road from my job .. will be coming back to try the chipotle chicken slice read more

Villa Monte - Shrimp scampi for me ..fiancé had the buffalo calamari and old fashioned vodka slice - Pizza Near Me - Old Bethpage, New York

Just found this hidden gem recently. The staff at the counter is awesome and there is plenty of them. They have so many different pies to choose from unlike many other pizza places. If you're looking to get your pizza on this is the place to go. Even with the lunch crowd it goes fast and you will be in and out. Highly recommend this joint! read more

For both Food quality and exceptional service try this restaurant. The prices are great and you get a real good homey feeling there. The portions are heaping full and the menu exhibits some great choices. They go out of their way to give you a good experience. It's a casual restaurant and they focus more on value We eat there regularly I advise this restaurant strongly read more

It's been a long time since I have eaten on the restaurant side (since they remodeled) so I will only comment on the pizza side. They have a HUGE variety of specialty slices. Possibly the largest variety on Long Island. But.....in my opinion the pizza is nothing special. I have tried many different varieties, and while I won't say it's bad, I can't say it is better than OK. I will come here if I am in the area but won't make a special trip. read more

We did not have pizza, but I did notice that their Pizza was all the thick kind, not my favorite. Our dishes were Veal Scallopini, and Veal Marsala...HUGE portions but they were just OK, read more

Great pizza! One of my favorite places to visit for a Friday lunch. Each Friday they have their own seafood pizza's such as shrimp scampi, baked clam, calamari, everything you could think of. At any time they easily have 20 pies on hand for your choosing. Try it out, its damn good pizza. Take note that around 12/12:30 the line is out the door so come early or late unless you don't mind waiting a while for your pizza. read more

On a scale from meh to great..this place gets an "alright." After a bridal expo we were looking for a place nearby to get a quick dinner. I wanted to just grab a slice and go but we sat down and ate a meal. The restaurant is in a shopping center which is fine if not a little unexpected. It is much bigger than it initially appears. The bread was good. The appetizers were good. The soup was just ok. There isnt much to say...the end. read more

A group of about 9 of us went there after a day long picnic at Bethpage Park. We all ordered with the exception of one, hero's. Two people ordered hero's without the bread. For this they were charged two dollars more. When brought to their attention they said it was a bigger portion. It was not and they never informed us that that we'd be charged more for no bread. They refused to adjust the bill. I had a chicken parmigiana hero which was the worst I've had. It came cold and dry. I didn't eat it. I will never go back to this place again. read more

Absolutely delicious grandma pizza and the tortellini soup out of this world! I'm visiting from out of town and want to go back everyday that I'm here! Service with a smile too!! read more

Villa Monte - Tortellini soup - Pizza Near Me - Old Bethpage, New York

I wish I could give this place a negative 5 star. If you want to be treated like crap go here. I came here with my 2 year old boy for lunch today. We ordered our pizza and sat down to wait for it. My son was swinging his feet and Lightly hitting the baseboard of the wall. The next thing i hear is some POS named Tony , who I later find out is the manager, YELLS over the counter and thru about 10 ppl " stop banging the wall!!" He could easily said something to me but instead decided to yell at a 2 year old. Do yourself a favor if you have children or we're a child! Don't spend a single cent here. I will be posting this on Plainview and Bethpage mom and dads group online. read more

Went there for the second time. The regular pizza was good, nothing special, however, They offer many varieties of specialty slices, I had the Fresh Mozzarella and tomatoes it was fantastic! The Buffalo Chicken Pizza was excellent! Chicken Parmesan plate was Molto Buono! The restaurant has a nice decor,staff is friendly Table service was very good. What separates Villa Monte from others is the variety of specialty pizzas. Good place! "ottimo lavoro " Villa Monte read more

Some of my favorite slices are found here. The penne ala vodka slice are incredible as are the grandma slices, to name a few. The myriad of slices is overwhelming, but you can be confident they are all fantastic. The ingredients are fresh, the mozzarella is legit, and the staff is friendly and authentic. The restaurant portion is very good too, although the 5 star rating is really for the pizza they offer!. read more

Hands down one of the best places to grab a slice of pizza, as long as you don't have the urge ON A SUNDAY. Here you can find quite a healthy variety of pies, including special flavors that are even available as gluten-free or with whole wheat dough. How convenient! Just don't get your hopes up if you want such a classy meal ON A SUNDAY! read more

Haven't been here in 2 years, but remembering how good their pizza used to be i decided to go for lunch today. I can honestly say this was the worst pizza I've ever had. Looks like chuckie cheeses pizza and tastes no better. I have no idea what happened in the past 2 years but i know I will certainly never go back read more

When it comes to pizza near work this place really is the best I've had. A large variety of slice options and combinations that is second to none of pizzeria's I have been too. Last time I was there I had a Sweet and Spicy Calimari slice which was a little messy but absolutely delicious with the perfect mix of sauce and calamari. Also had there regular slice which was well above average and the service there is fantastic. I highly recommend if you like difference styles and combos of pizza. read more

I had a slice of chicken, bacon and ranch And it was delicious They have plenty of varieties I will keep trying different ones read more

Great food, large variety of delicious pizza to choose from and great staff. What more can you ask for? I've been there 30 or 40 times and have never been disappointed. If someone gives this place a bad review, I suspect the problem is with the consumer not this establishment. read more

My husband and I have been going to Villa Monte for years. Everything they make is delicious. They offer the largest variety of pizzas that we have ever seen. Their dinners are also wonderful. The staff is friendly, hardworking and relate beautifully to their customers. I definitely recommend going there read more

They bank on having a large variety on top of their pizzas. I when and got a crazy looking slice, and a normal slice. The normal slice was bad. So I don't suggest getting "normal" pizza there. The crazy slice was okay. I went with other people who were drooling over their crazy toppings, so maybe I just picked some mediocre slices. I'm gonna go back and try more slices, but I'm not expecting much more they what I already experienced. I will say decor was nice, staff was nice, place was clean and pizza was hot. So, maybe I just didn't pick their strongest slices. read more

Lots of pizza choices. Today I had the chopped grilled chicken ceasar. They accommodated our party of 12 which isn't easy during lunch hours read more

Amazing Pizza! So many different slices. I have been going here for year's and the keep creating new types of slices or other delicious sandwiche types foods. My favorite slice is the chicken Alla vodka slice. Honestly, anything with their vodka sauce is amazing! read more

Pizza was great, ordered online and the pizza was fresh and hot. I will definitely be ordering from Villa Monte the next time I'm in the area. read more

Best pizza and Italian food around . Dinners are delicious. Pizza'a are amazing . Too many types to pizza to try , you can always have something different . Excellent place to sit down for dinner or a slice . read more

Possible the best specialty pizza pie restaurant on Long Island! The amount of pies they have out on display is overwhelming. Yes, it can take you ten minutes to decide what to get, it all looks amazing. The staff are always nice and helpful, the restaurant is clean and always packed when I go. I wish I had a place like this by my house, ahh I am better off i dont live close! One of my favorite pizza places, and they are up there with New Park Pizza, Gremaldi's, John's, Lombardi's, Umberto's new Hyde park and others read more

I ate the baked ziti pizza, it was DELICIOUS. The pizza is hard to pick up with all the pasta on it, but you can cut little pieces or you can eat some of the pasta off of it then eat it. The crust isn't too thick or too thin, it's just right. I would recommend the baked ziti slice to people who love pizza and pasta with sauce. I LOVED the baked ziti slice! read more

Nice place, was nice and quiet. My partner and I were the only customers in the restaurant half. We had just commented how nice and quiet it was when a staff member from the pizza side came and put on a big screen TV rather loud. He did not consult with us which would have been courteous since we were the only ones there at the time. I didn't go to watch sports - that's what sports bars are for. Went to enjoy a good meal in a pleasant surroundings but unfortunately that wasn't the case either. My partner ate chicken picata which he seemed happy enough with. I ordered vegetables with marinara which was way too greasy and nothing special. When the bill came, we were charged an extra $2 for fettucine which I was not informed was the case when I ordered. We were not told in advance that there would be a surcharge for paying by credit card nor were we given the opportunity to pay with cash. the card was processed before we could add a tip which forced us to leave a cash tip. All of these instances shows that the owners do not respect their guests. we will not be back. I do not recommend you choose this place. read more