Good overall, but not great. Perhaps my expectations were too high but at this price point and in the Hampton Bays area, I don't think my hopes were unreasonable. Old school style with lots of wood, quiet ambiance & very attentive service. The "Eggplant Tower" was ok. The Porterhouse Steak was very large, however the seasoning felt bland as did the grilled onions on top. The baked potato was comically small and way out of proportion to the large steak. The sparse serving of broccoli was equally meager. The bread pudding and other desserts were very good. read more

See all

Nice spot for an 80th birthday dinner. Food was great and ambience was so cozy. Love the fireplace and interior. Had the eggplant parm and friends had fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp, veal Marsala and veal saltimbocca with prosciutto. The only little complaint was the bread basket. Think the bread could've been a little better. Everyone was nice and accommodating for this special occasion. Definitely will be back! read more

Came here for an early Mother's Day celebration on Saturday night and was able to get a table for two by calling ahead. We were warmly greeted at the front, and despite being 15 or so minutes early we were able to be promptly seated. The interior of Villa Paul is absolutely beautiful. It's charming and feels kind of "Old Hollywood" to me. There are two separate dining rooms with a bar in between that was incredibly busy. Every seat was taken! We sat at our table and started the night out with dirty martinis, which were impeccably made. The entire menu looked delicious to us, but I was really sold on the specials of the day (a fried swordfish tidbit appetizer and a prime rib). It must have been a busy night at Villa Paul, because our waiter Perry informed us they were out of several things including the swordfish appetizer and Prime Rib. She must have saw my face fall when she told be about the Prime Rib, because a few minutes later as I was forming a new plan of action for a main course she came back to say that they did in fact have one left, which she reserved for me while we ate our appetizers. We kicked things off with clams casino and escargot. I know this is such an annoying thing to say, but I recently went to Paris and have to say that the escargot here is just as good as the authentic version I had during my trip. I loved that you were able to choose what size clams you'd like for the casino. We went with cherry stones because it's go big or go home for me when it comes to seafood. It was delicious as well. The prime rib was well marinated, but less rare than what I typically like. I guess that's to be expected since it was the last one! The stuffed flounder special was excellent as well. We were stuffed at this point, but couldn't leave here without trying their homemade bread pudding, which was absolutely a stand out. All in all I really loved this place, my only regret is not being able to try more of the specials that sold out. Will come earlier next time! read more

See all

Food was good. We ate at the bar. Lisa, bartender treated us like an inconvenience . Hurt not like it used to be when we felt welcomed. Will never be back. read more

Old school Italian, nice menu good service at reasonable prices. Very popular with the locals.

The food is excellent and consistant. Portions are ample. Service is very efficient and friendly. A very warm and cozy atmosphere Just an all around great dining experience!! Highly recommend! read more

Went to Villa Paul For a New Year's Eve dinner ...prior to going when I made the reservation I asked about the menu and they said it was a regular menu ...when we arrived we got a paper with a price fixe menu for $98 a person!!! ... you got an appetizer an entrée and a small dessert. There was nothing posted on their website about this and it was literally the regular menu. I am very disappointed in their false advertising( or lack thereof), ...at least a glass of champagne or a cup of coffee with the dessert for $98 a person, not including any drinks at all, not even a small glass of champagne for the holiday A ridiculous amount of money for what was served sorry Villa Paul, but total disappointment in lack of communication so NOT worth it read more

A culinary institution in the Hampton Bays. My go to place for consistently great Italian fare. The food is always fresh and hot. The chicken Mauricio is my fave- don't know who he is but it's a tasty dish! Never a bad meal here. read more

Villa Paul Restaurant - Chicken Mauricio - Italian Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Exceptional service. Phenomenal food! Veal parmagiana was outstanding. Prices are more than fair

Nice Italian food. Zero Hamptons vibe. Reliable, but boring. Better in the winter. Chicken parm is very good, but the decor and interior need updating. read more

We had another great dining event at V P. Last bought (2/13/21). We were greeted with a smile by the manager upon arrival and were taken to a lovely table in the corner of the dining room. The crowd was a nice side, but the tables spaced out very well. Social distancing and staff with masks and gloves were evident. Our waiter Miguel and busperson Saoulda (I hope I got the spelling correct) took extremely great care of our table. Saoulda made sure that the bread and butter stayed full and the table ckean. Miguel started us off with drinks, espresso martinis, beer all were perfect. We ordered our appetizers (fried calamari and a seafood mac n cheese with shrimp, dinner portion). The appetizers were delicious. The fried calamari were light and tender with a side of tomatoe sauce for dipping. The mac n cheese was a big hit too, nice and creamy with an aldente texture with a crispness from baking. (My mouth's watering) For dinner, we ordered chicken florentine, ravioli, and 2 roast ducks. The roast duck was a beautiful portion, the skin was a nice crispness, the meat very moist and tender, full of flavor topped with a nice cherry and wine (best guess) reduction. The duck , as always at Villa Paul, was perfect. The chicken was delicious as well as the ravioli. Dessert was also amazing, I do not remember what was ordered, I know a toasted almond joy dessert was ordered and delicious, I had a single shot espresso. All in all, dinner, nor the service has ever failed us at V.P. It is always a nice treat to go to and we should go more often. Total cost for dinner was $245 for 4. Tip was extra and I am generous :) ! read more

See all

I get Takeout from Villa pool at least once a week. I think the chicken Parmesan is excellent and and the veal caprina when I do go to the restaurant I like sitting in the room with the fireplace and the service is very good always Mary read more

Dinner for 16 they handled it without issue Good food the tuna tartare over the top Waitress had patience read more

Villa Paul is the best and perhaps last of Nassau County's "Fine Dining" restaurants. It is actually NOT an Italian restaurant, in the traditional sense, which is a good thing. Rather, Villa Paul is a very fine, "Continental" restaurant. Sort of a survey course of European Culinary Traditions, mostly French and Italian, tweaked to American tastes. They've been doing it for over 50 years and Nobody, does it better. Their Roasted Long Island Duck, served stuffed, crisp and with homemade Cherry Sauce is a standout and worth a trip on its own. Their seafood, locsl Flounder etc is clearly well sourced. The service is professional "Old School" To top it all off, they bring you amazing desserts like the famous Peanut Brickle Cheese Cake and Classics like amazing tartuffo, pistachio mousse and Creme Brulee, etc. The prices are not cheap but compared to NYC, where I'm from, are an absolute bargain given the quality, and service. Bonus: the wine list offers extremely well priced bottle options and top notch reds and whites at $12/glass! If you are a "Lawn Guyland" mook in a Jets jersey who does not own a sport coat, a shrill loud pretentious "real Housewife of da Hamtinz"type or someone more accustomed to $8 Groupon buffets in Flushing ( and dress the part) perhaps this is not your place. If however you are seeking the last of the old school South Fork Fine Dining American Bounty Establishments, get dressed up, head to Villa Paul and Enjoy! read more

Villa Paul Restaurant - Peanut Brickle Cheesecake! Awesome - Italian Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

I only went there twice and both times I had something different to eat and drink and both times everything was great . The mozarela sticks are simply so good if you go there ask them as appetizers. The service is good and helpful And the atmosphere is real nice and calm. Definitely I'm going there again and I recommend to everyone read more

Always a good experience dining in but recent large order for take out ($1000) left me with a bad taste in my mouth. Miscommunication on the restaurants part lead to the food not being prepared and packaged as expected. When I called to discuss with the manager, he lied and indicated he overheard the order being placed and implied the miscommunication was on our part. When I pointed out, the woman taking the order was at our table and he was no where in site, nothing was said. I got the feeling he didn't really care about my dissatisfaction with the service provided. Won't be going back as a result. He offerred nothing but attitude. Missed opportunity on his part to make things right. Something as simple as as "I'm sorry you weren't satisfied" would have a long way. read more

I recently hosted a celebration of life luncheon at Villa Paul. They were super accommodating and understanding. I wasn't sure what time the funeral services would be completed and so we arrived very early en mass at the restaurant. We were greeted graciously and welcomed to come in as they set up. The food at Villa Paul never disappoints and was plentiful and delicious. The service was professional, polite and very helpful. The ambiance is cozy and welcoming. I highly recommend for special events as well as for a nice evening dinner out. read more

Villa Paul! I'm a Southampton local and I'll admit that I haven't been to VP in a very long time, but when a friend wanted to go to dinner "someplace we haven't been", this gem came to mind. The service was friendly and attentive even though they were understaffed. The calamari and clams casino hit the spot. And we all shared the fabulous ravioli, the linguini with white clam sauce which was a straight on, no frills classic; and oooooh, that duck with the black cherry sauce. Oh, boy the stuffing... Thank you, Villa Paul, for a tasty and fun evening. We'll be back for sure! read more

First time there. Friendly. Old fashioned scene. Family restaurant. Duck was very good and a large portion. Bread basket pedestrian. Moderately priced. read more

Time honored to always be exceptional. Food and service above par consistently. Will always recommend this place for dinner.

Authentic Italian food just like Nonnas! Excellence in service - beautiful dining rooms - reasonable prices - This is not to be missed so make a reservation! read more

See all

This reastuarant is the worst. I got yelled at for not wearing a mask for one second as I was leaving the restaurant to get into my car. There was 1 customer. The waitress was not wearing the mask the whole time while talking to customer. This is ridiculous. Also the food is trash. They say filet mignon but the piece of meat that I received I wouldn't even give it to my dogs. Trash place. So rude, called my wife a bitch. This place should be closed and the food is awful. read more

Villa Paul never disappoints! We had our family Easter dinner there and everything was terrific . 10/10 from carla the best waitress to lisa the best bartender ... and the best busers and runners in the business Thank you for making our holiday amazing ! read more

Do these people realize we're in the middle of a pandemic? I've been making it a point to eat out to support local restaurants but when I see staff handling food and NOT WEARING A MASK PROPERLY it truly makes me want to take this restaurant off my list. It's so reckless to be wearing the mask under the chin or not at all. People, science is real and we are all doing our best to protect each other by following the cdc guidelines...so why isn't this place doing that? :( Plus when I brought it up to management they totally invalidated my feedback! Who does that to a customer?? Sadly they lost my support for life. read more

Only reason why I cannot give 4 stars (almost NEVER give 5), is that my lobster stuffed flounder was like warm (temperature wise). Being a special, is of thought it would've been better prepared. As usual however, all was just fine. Service was good, the venue is always comfortable, and as we've been patronizing Villa Paul's since 1976, it is a nice, steady establishment. We always go back. Fast forward to this past weekend (2/1/19). My wife & I took her aunt out for an early dinner by the fireplace. We had the liver special, veal stroganoff, and the penne pasta carbonara. EVERY dish was fantastic. We had a very nice dining experience, albeit the place started to rapidly fill up & get busy and the service dropped off a bit. This establishment has been around for a few generations- which we all know is not the norm for any restaurant. There is a good reason why. It is consistently very, very good. read more

Villa Paul Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

This place frickin' sucked! Got innstant wet shits after eating the pasta carbanera and my friends steaks were wayyyyyyy burnt. Waitress tried to blaim brunt steaks on marinate. The bread and butter tasted like what I imagein santa clauses toe cheese to taste like. Also a lot of loud drunks at the bar but to be fair they were pretty damn funny ngl. read more

This place was good, the porterhouse was cooked rare to perfection, the shrimp scampi and clams with white sauce were also super yummy, their red sauce and their chicken parm was a miss - sauce was too sweet and the chicken wasn't crispy. Oh, and the garden house salad was very fresh. The service was ok, the server wasn't too confident about her knowledge of the menu, the bus girl kept the table clean and waters full. They didn't have an alcohol menu or offer desert, and took wayyyy to long to get the check. Also it was a Monday after 730p. read more

Villa Paul Restaurant - Stellar Shrimp Scampi - Italian Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Octoberfest special terrific. Chicken liver, sauerbraten, red cabbage and potato pancake all excellent. Even the pretzel before the dinner was great. Service excellent. Price very reasonable for 3 courses. read more

We enjoyed a wonderful meal with amazing duck as always and a liver special that brings me back to my childhood!! Thank you for a great experience and looking forward to our next visit!! read more

Do yourself a favor and get the duck but ask for it extra crispy and sauce on the side. It's like a Thanksgiving Day meal but better because you didn't have to make it and it's duck instead of turkey. read more

Villa Paul Restaurant - Roast Long Island Duckling Fried Soft Shell Crab Linguine with White Clam Sauce - Italian Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Great place to eat, went with family and all the food we ordered came out great and very good tasting. The staff was great and friendly never had to wait for anything. little pricey but the food was wonderful. You can smell the garlic as You are in the parking lot. read more

Service was wonderful, but drinks and food were so-so, especially with the high price. Very disappointing

I wish the Pandemic mask warriors would finally give it up. You have politicized a simple public health consideration. Do you realize how unfair and improper it is to severely damage a restaurant's food reviews over a non food or service observation? Go post your nonsense on twitter. As to my own proper review, it's good, local, normal, and fairly priced. Unlike all the HOT Hamptons restaurants of the moment, this place has been here forever. Wonder why that is? read more

Wonderful Food, Fabulous service!!!! Best Clams Oregano on the Island, Bar None! Fantastic Duck! Wonderful fresh flounder. The cocktails are a work of Art!....Unbeatable ambiance...Love the fireplace! Hats off to the current owners for Honoring a wonderful tradition! read more

We loved this place!!! Called last minute for 4 people to dine outside and were kindly accommodated. Nice music playing, pretty setting with lights and comfy couches on the grass. We had a table on the porch, service was excellent and food was classic NY Italian! We would definitely recommend a visit here for dinner. read more

The mussels we ordered were fine but nothing special. There isn't much to review on the take out order but I will likely order elsewhere if we return to the area. read more

Food: 4/5 Service: 2/5 Decor: 3/5 Overall, the experience was ok. Our waitress wasn't very aware of the menu, we asked a few questions about how the pasta was prepared and she didn't seem to know. There was another waiter who briefly stopped by our table and he definitely knew what was going on. The food was pretty good once we eventually got it. It took a pretty long time and we were starving and the restaurant wasn't too pack, so it was a little strange. After we finished, the busgirl cleared our plates, we ended up sitting for a while before we could flag someone to grab our check. Eventually we got the attention of the manager(i think) and she helped us out. Our waitressed finally stopped by while the manager was helping us. I would give this place another shot and hope that we get a different server. read more

I called for a reservation for two and asked if we could sit at the bar, I was told they would have to call me back because they had to ask the bartender who wasn't in yet? Seriously well the answer was no apparently if your not a regular the bartender has no interest in you! She could care less about new business only about her local guaranteed tips. Well we have been back again and she is worse than the first time. read more

Came here with my boyfriend on Valentine's Day , they asked if we had a reservation we said no (because my boyfriend tried calling but they wouldn't answer) so they did mention the line was a bit long for that day but they would see if they had a table available which they did and sat us down quickly :) we order our food , it was so good and our dessert was the peach Melba it was amazing!! Overall a very nice place with amazing service!! read more

Good food, good service. Has a family feel. It's not the nicest restaurant in town but it has people with experience, and the owners really care for the place. I had my rehearsal dinner here in 2016, and they did a great job. It's worth stopping in. It's not a fancy Italian restaurant but it's better than other local Italian restaurants! read more