Idk why this restaurant only has a 2.8rating, but we ordered clams,poke bowl and hot pot, and everything was rly good. A few mussels had a little sand in them, but overall it was good. The service & atmosphere were nice too, and I'd definitely come back again with my friend or family. read more

Food is always good--either at the bar or in the restaurant. Nice atmosphere, even in the winter. If you are looking to eat a casual meal, the bar always has plenty of space. If you want a little quieter atmosphere, try the dining area. read more

It is supposed to be a seafood restaurant but the seafood was zero seasoned, dry and way overcooked. The place was empty so you could not blame too busy as an excuse. The prices are astronomical and even worse when you consider what they serve in terms of quantity and quality. The main course seafood sampler was a total tasteless overcooked loser priced at $49! The lobster bisque was also lacking flavor. It was sprinkled with a few random tiny lobster pieces. The clams orenginati were the little bit bigger than a quarter and had zero oregano flavor. Don't waste your time or money. I presume their survival depends on the large number of one time visitors. There is absolutely no reason to consider coming back to this place. STAY AWAY. read more

Great decor, good food, nice view and service. Not sure why so many dock it. Taste: 4/5 Ambiance: 4.5/5 Service: 5/5 Value for money: 3.5/5 We had: 1) Calamari: great way to start 2) Oysters: nice and fresh 3) Connecticut lobster roll: done right 4) Firecracker burger: this was firecracker rock shrimp, a sweet paste on deep fried shrimp that was placed in a burger. It was okay! 5) baked fish 6) grilled shrimp with risotto: pretty good! read more

See all

You couldn't ask for anything better than sitting in the beach and dining with French tourists. The food was delicious, although the halibut was a little dry. Drinks perfect and Josh our waiter was very attentive even with a huge table next to us. The clouds, boats and families was so exciting to watch! Love it and will be back! read more

Wall's Wharf - Delicious food! - Seafood Near Me - Bayville, New York

See all

Tried to go around 5:30 today. I got in the valet parking line - 6th in line, while my wife went in and confirmed there was a table for three outside. 15 minutes later I had not moved and parking attendant yelled at us to move so people can exit the too small parking lot. After 10 more minutes and no movement, we did an 8 point turn and left. The parking in the area is terrible and WW adds to it with their crappy parking process. An available table that we cannot use because we can't park our car...ridiculous! Go elsewhere read more

First, the food was great - very impressed by the Firecracker Shrimp and Spicy Tuna Tacos. Both had a perfect combination of heat and sweet. I was very disappointed in the service after a full glass of ice water was dropped in my lap. The tablecloth was not changed, I was drenched and the waiter offered a lame 'sorry about that.' Management did not visit - were they even aware? I don't think we will return. read more

Ashley was great...Hidden gem...laid back, beautiful view of the sound...lobster was slightly overcooked but good; Steamers were dry...should have been served with broth..all in all, nice experience...we'll be back! read more

Hidden Gem on Long Island, at least I thought so, I'm telling everyone I know what a great night we had and everyone knows already and says we love it there. Well if you want to feel you're on beach vacation without flying out to the Caribbean this is the place for you. You have the option on eating right on the beach. First come first serve , reservations are for parties 8 and over and made through the catering manager, Frank. There is only nature's natural music of small waves hitting the shore.. wear sandals or flip flops and get your toes in the sand and make sure you have a cool drink in your hand. Watch the boats, jet ski's and the most romantic and beautiful sunsets this side of Marco. This is why you come to Wall's Wharf to escape reality and all the noise. Food is very good, great Pork Chop and the firecracker shrimp cheese burger is a must. Start with delicious baked stuffed clams.. plenty of mozzarella in these clams. Homemade key-lime pie a must have , you'll definitely believe you're away on vacation. Restaurant start getting very busy by 6pm. Service is good not great and definitely check your bill before you pay. 4% discount on cash payment. Highly recommend read more

See all

EXCELLENTTTTTTT!!! Between the views and service plus the food was phenomenal!the lobster melted in my mouth OMG THE BEST SEAFOOD I EVER HAD IN MY ENTIRE LIFE! I'm a seafood foodie and I kid you not this will be my ONLY place I will go have seafood from now on! Luv luv luv read more

See all

Been coming here for years and have never been disappointed. Got here early to eat and watch the sunset. We were greeted when we walked in and seated immediately outside. Our waitress greeted us and offered us drinks. I got an aperol and it was made just right. We ordered a hummus appetizer with hot honey drizzled over it. It was so good. The hummus portion was very generous. To eat I had to have the mussels in red sauce. It's a huge portion and they are always fresh and flavorful. Husband got the fried shrimp salad. It was so good but could have had maybe a few more shrimp. The wait staff is so attentive and agile. read more

See all

Wall's Wharf ... Beautiful view, great food, great waiter and great valet ... the older hostess on the other hand was nasty not able to direct you and very unfriendly ... a person greeting the public should be friendly with a happy greeting not a nasty person ... why would you have a nasty hostess greet people when they first enter ... I have second thoughts about returning ... read more

The most horrible experience started with a 45 minute wait for valet to park my car. Topped off by an additional 40 minutes if I wanted to sit outdoor. The kicker was the lack of items they didn't have that were on the menu. Paid $7.00 for a few pieces of bread and butter. Food was inedible. Never again. Thank goodness was they had bread and water. read more

The atmosphere is all this place really has going for it. $45 for a teeny tiny lobster roll with tough and flavorless meat is not worth the views at all. To add insult to injury: the baked clams come in an order of 5 and not 6 or 12 like you would typically find in any restaurant. read more

Wall's Wharf - Seafood Near Me - Bayville, New York

See all

Where else can you eat an old meal, have drinks, directly on the beach on the North shore? HERE, that's where. One of the best locations, Bayville. Totally chill and relaxing. Starring at Stamford CT. Food was good. New England clam chowder very good... more like a seafood chowder, but great. The service was very kind and good. read more

Wall's Wharf - Palm trees - Seafood Near Me - Bayville, New York

See all

Overly expensive. Rude reception. Charge to put bread on table? Totally go somewhere else. read more

Really great environment. And I ordered the chicken one It is great. I remember one server is speaking mandarin and very sweet. And we were there just after the rain. So it was a really exciting and cozy time to see the sunset and enjoy the food. read more

Wall's Wharf - Seafood Near Me - Bayville, New York

See all

Wall's is such an amazing hidden gem! Very good food and just the perfect atmosphere, right on the beach!! read more

Good service, nice views and ok drinks but food is inedible and way overpriced. Furniture is filthy and run down.

So .. I have driven by this place 100 times .. it's right on the Long Island Sound .. first ..no street parking, all valet . I went in in the afternoon .. on a Wednesday .. Woody, the bartender, is old school, classic, knows everybody in the place, all o er 70. He was super welcoming to me and others that obviously were not regulars . The menu is what you would expect .. except overpriced. I just had two beers and they were really good .. great tap, well maintained . Just so you know, if you have not gotten it by now .. Fox News was in and the volume was up . read more

Walls Wharf in Bayville has truly become a second home to me over the years. There's something special about this place--from the stunning beachfront views to the welcoming, laid-back atmosphere, it never disappoints. The food is consistently amazing--fresh, flavorful, and served with care. Whether you're craving seafood, a burger, or just drinks by the water, Walls always hits the spot. The bartenders are all fantastic--friendly, attentive, and just genuinely great people who remember your favorites and make you feel like family. A special shoutout to Julia, one of the best waitresses we've had! She took such great care of us--professional, warm, and on top of everything. You can tell she truly cares about the guests' experience. Whether you're going for a casual lunch, sunset dinner, or just a drink at the bar, Walls Wharf is a place that pulls you in and keeps you coming back. Highly recommend--it's a Bayville gem. read more

We went primarily for the ambiance, given the sunset views, but the food was fantastic and the entire staff were incredible. Our server, Tara, brought a great energy to the experience and made sure everything was perfect. We had fun interactions with several other members of the staff during our visit as well. Highly recommend. We visited from out of town with family, and we'll definitely dine here again on future trips. read more

Tasteless and overpriced food. watered down drinks. Terrible service. I was amazed at the uncleanliness of the restaurant, especially the bathroom. read more

A magical venue on Long Island Sound. Outdoor beach seating, an indoor pubby bar with views of Long Island Sound, an indoor nautical themed dining room with an oceanfront feel. The food is artfully presented and creatively prepared. The highlight today was our patient, delightful, efficient waitress Gisele who engaged with us, explained the availability of items and championed the menu and its choices. Walls Wharf is enhanced by her presence. Highly recommend! read more

See all

While setting on the deck and watching the sunset was great, I can't say the same for the service. Athena, our waitress seemed uninterested in her job, often disappearing. We had to remind her of our drink order (our food arrived before the drinks). My spouses meal included mash potatoes and we had to ask for butter? The food was ok, did not make me want to come back anytime soon. read more

One of the best unobstructed water views on Long Island. Service is excellent and parking is plentiful. The weekday lunchtime customers are well behaved. Menu is fairly extensive. The margarita flatbread was a poor attempt at pizza on a cracker. The $45 Lobster rolls are miniscule and disappointing. The accompanying fries were great. I just should have ordered what I saw on other people's tables read more

if you love your animals, please do not eat at this restaurant!!!!!! my husband and i with our little 5 lb dog who by the way was in a dog carriage, came all the way from florida, to visit this restaurant that i haven't been to in 10 years!!! the place wasn't even open yet, no cars whatsoever in the lot. we were told no dogs whatsoever even service dogs must provide proof!! on line it stated dogs were allow only outside!! there is a tremendous area outside on the beach . there was no one there!! we told them we came all the way from florida and they were rude and unsympathetic!! this place was really only nice because of the location on the beach! the food was only mediocre!! i will never step foot on this property ever!!!! please dont patronize this establishment who hates animals!!! read more

If an outdoor beach vibe and a beer is what you are looking for this is the place. Unfortunately, the food and service leave a lot to be desired. Party of 6 ordered three lobster rolls at $45 a piece that were very disappointing. Meager size, lacking flavor and served with luke warm fries. Disgusted just thinking about it. Swordfish was a better entre. Scallops will leave you hungry. Pleasant service but unattentive. Ketchup and something else we requested showed up after a second request at mid-meal. We were left with the impression that no one really cares. We've eaten here once a year for a decade or more. Always just long enough between visits to have forgotten how bad the previous meal was. Two stars for hard working friendly valet guy and beach front location. read more

Service was horrible. From the parking lot we waited in line for 30 minutes for valet parking. And if that wasn't bad enough we waited 1 hour for table outside (granted it was peak dinner time- the staff couldn't manage the tables accordingly to accommodate the customers.). We arrived at 6:50 Seated at 8:15 only to be told kitchen closes at 9pm. During that time the waiters were more concerned about collecting the table umbrellas rather than waiting on the tables. Food was ok. Not worth returning. Poorly managed. read more

I came for dinner on a busy July 4th weekend. They have valet parking but it took a while to even get in. We also had to wait for a table since we had a huge party of 17 people but it was fine since it was a great day. It wasn't too hot out by evening time, the sun was still up so we took a few pictures on the sand with the palm trees. We were lucky to get seated outside, so we were literally eating on the sand, by the water. The view was amazing! We were able to see the sun setting while we dined. Service was decent - they took a while to take our orders as well as for the food to come out but no one was in a rush in our party anyway; must be the beach vibes. The menu isn't that extensive which is good since it allows everyone to be more decisive. I was able to try the beach ball appetizer, salmon teriyaki bowl, horseradish truffle salmon, shrimp scampi, crispy chicken milanese, and Mediterranean chicken sandwich. Everything was very flavorful and I enjoyed it all but the portions are a bit small which is why we ordered a few additional things on our end to share. Come for the vibes and beautiful ocean view! Food is also tasty but prices are on the higher end. read more

See all

I have now come accustomed to seeing Palm Trees on the Beach since I spend most of my winters in Florida lately. The appearance work for me at this point. Walls Wharf is one of my popular restaurant choices when wanting to dine seaside on Long Island. I have brought many out-of-town friends here for lunch for the pleasant calming views and especially the out of towners that still believe that all Long Island is flat. The restaurant has an indoor traditional wood bar that overlooks the Sound while seated. It is spectacular seat at the bar to relax while dining. There is seating indoor dining room with large window views of the Sound. We sat on the lower outdoor patio with a clear view of the Long Island Sound. The sky was clear enough to see Connecticut across the sound. Our service was good, and attentive as enjoyed the relaxing lunch in afternoon. For lunch, I chose something unusual, a Fried Shrimp BLT which was delicious. As mentioned on a previous review, the restaurant is not all about the food, it is all about the pleasing view on any given gorgeous day. read more

Wall's Wharf - Seafood Near Me - Bayville, New York

See all

Great views! And oysters! Love it for watching the sun set on a summer night with a simple glass of wine on the semi rocky north shore beach

Pure filth. The glasses were filthy. There was dry food stuck to the plates. The place is filthy. Can I give it zero stars?

Love this ! Been going here 2 years every summer. Food is sooo tasty and delicious. The view even better (; read more

See all

Been there many times, but went back a few days ago. Prices are up, but I understand they have to make their money in a few months. Food was good, service was good. My only problem is $17 for a glass of cheap wine and it was a lousy poor. Give us a break! read more

While the view is great, everything else has gone down hill. We haven't been here in years and were thoroughly disappointed. Going to be seated at a table on the beach and the chairs and table were filthy. Waited 5 mins for someone to come clean them so we could sit down and they didn't do all the chairs so I had to wipe down on my own. For 3 people to come and spend $300 I shouldn't have to wipe down my own table. Food was meh, drinks were meh, service was horrible. I never ever complain about service and I think I have wrote 3 reviews ever, but this is worthy. Do yourself a favor and go elsewhere. It wasn't busy on a warm Friday night, I should have known why. Such a shame. read more

Turned away by valet bc we left our tesla valet key at home so we were not allowed to self park lol. Disappointed to not have been able to experience the food here, but after glancing at other yelp reviews, I consider it a blessing in disguise. read more

Went here this past week with my friend Veronika and have to say the food & drinks were delicious! Great view and overall great time, little gem of a place in oyster bay! Highly recommend and will definitely be back! read more

See all

Went on Mother's Day. First should have stated speciaI' menu. Half the entrees were not available. Lobster rolls etc. We finally found something on the menu and after waiting almost 2 hours for dinner for the first time in my Life at 74 we walked out. No one came over had to ask even for bread. Wouldn't go back. If you're going to have a special me u then when ordering buy enough for your customers read more

There menu is excellent, which offers a variety of option.when we look for fresh fish options, they offer numerous options. Last time there we had the seafood grill, which included a flakey flounder, two huge scallops and 2 shrimp, with wild rice, fresh carrots and string beans. Service was excellent, our waiters was an attentive, young man that , oftener checked to see how we were enjoying our food and if we needed anything else. Their restaurant, is divided into outside dining on the water, as well as a huge bar, and an elegant dining room, with water views. They also have a venue for special events. read more