We were very pleased with our visit to Your Pie. The options for toppings were endless. I loved that you could get as many toppings as you like for the flat price. It was very affordable and delicious. The staff was super friendly. They were sure to help us understand how the menu works. Great experience. read more

Your Pie - Colorful, delicious personal pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

Wonderful employees, great attitude. The food was delicious. The service was quick and attentive, and the restaurant was very clean. Usually the more that is written the more problems there were, this was such an easy experience this review is short and sweet because it was a great experience. read more

I went with three stars more as an attention getter for management than a critique of the pies. To be honest, the quality of the freshly baked, personal, customized pizzas was four star, at least. The concept of having "Subway" style ordering at a pizza place gives you one of those "Why didn't I think of that!" moments. It is simple, original and genius all at the same time. I deducted the one star because of the lackadaisical attitude of some of the staff and the fact that nobody seemed to be proactively cleaning off tables. We were in there this past Saturday afternoon, shortly after 4:00. This was our first visit. At the time, they were not busy. When we walked in, all of the booths still had items (empty cups, silverware, pizza pans, etc) on them. Some of the empty tables looked the same. The tables that didn't have items on them were still pretty messy with crumbs from prior diners. After ordering, my wife wiped off one of the tables with some napkins and gave me that "strike one" look. As we were waiting for our food, I kept looking around wondering when someone would clean off all of the remaining tables. Finally, a customer came in and requested to have a booth cleaned off. I figured that the worker would then proactively clean the rest of them too. Nope. He apologized to the customer, cleaned off the booth, then proceeded to go back to whatever he was doing before. What would he have done if they got busy? Clean each table as requested or depend on the customers to clean their own (as we did)? On the plus side, the lady who took our order was very helpful and friendly and the fire baked pies were excellent, with a decent char and a nice texture to the crust. If the pizzas were not so good, we would not be going back. Since they were, Your Pie deserves a second chance. read more

Awesomeness. We've been to a couple of other pizza joints and they just don't compare. read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

First visit. I am impressed. I used to spin pies in my younger years and know it takes the right recipe to do it. They have it. Got a caprice salad and a Mediterranean pizza with jalapenos and it was great. Clean. Lighted. Not intentionally loud with piped in music. Great staff. Gave to say this place is a keeper. read more

Your Pie - Caprice salad and what is left of a Mediterranean pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

First time at Your Pie. It's like a Subway or Moe's, but for pizza. The menu is on the wall; 10" pizza, paninis, and salads (that can be prepared in a bread bowl). I'm assuming they mean a pizza bowl. Numerous quality toppings to choose from. Everything is the same reasonable price. The pizza dough was perfectly cooked with a slight crispy outside with soft chewy inside, and perfectly seasoned. Of course, you can make it a 'combo' with chips or side salad and a soda from the self serve Coke machine for an up charge. It's a great place to go after soccer practice. Yes, they sell beer. read more

Tables are always dirty every time I come into this location. Way overpriced for fast food pizza. Owner should spend more time in this location. read more

Normally when one goes to a Pizza Restaurant, you sit at a table, the server greets you with a smile, takes your drink order and waits while you look over the menu. Here, think of Your Pie as a "Subway Shop" for Pizzas, Salads, and Pannis where you can choose from various pizzas or create your own from scratch. Can't go wrong from the various pizza and panni choices. Your Pie, in Fleming Island, is located at the west end of the Winn- Dixie Plaza. read more

Here for lunch and this place is not busy at all. Shocked considering it's at least a 5-10 minute line to get to the counter back home in the Atlanta area. Amazing pizza and unlimited toppings! The I-10 from Intuition is a great beer too!!! read more

I was working in the area and I'm Glad I found this place thru a Yelp search. The pizza is made to order with as many toppings as you want. I opted for the whole wheat crust with assorted veggie toppings and it was great. Too bad it's location is not easily visible from the main road I 'm sure they would get more business if it were. read more

We are visiting family in the area and wanted a good pizza. After reviewing all the local pizza place menus, we decided to order from Your Pie on Fleming island. The pizza was delicious! It arrived piping hot. We ordered the Lineage Pizza minus green peppers and our special request was honored. Very good flavor! The crust was crispy but not too thin. The sausage had just enough spice to give it a little kick. We really enjoyed it and are glad we decided to order from Your Pie! read more

Our first visit and we liked it! We had the Aloha (plus pepperoni) pizza, split the huge spinach gorgonzola salad and caramel sea salt gelato. We would recommend and definitely go back again! read more

Your Pie - The Aloha pizza (plus pepperoni) - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

See all

Loved it...only complaint I could possibly have is that the buffalo pizza needed a little more sauce

For a pizza place, they make an amazing salad! I had the best salad tonight. Greek dressing was delicious and all the veggies you want in the salad! I have had their pizza as well and it is good, but the salad I had tonight was in one word perfect! My only complaint is it very hard for the people making your pizza or salad to hear you due to the noise in the restaurant. I felt like I had to shout to be heard when telling the girl behind the counter what I wanted. read more

Choice of dough, even a Glutton-free option. A great variety of sauces, cheeses, toppings. Well priced. Very helpful to the first-timer. Dough is good. (I got white) Went for standard marinara sauce. It was ok. Toppings were fresh. I will be more adventurous the next time. read more

Noah and Pedro literally crushed this dining experience. I don't think I will eat or drink any where but Vs for quite some time. Drinks were on point and food was great...but service even better! read more

Excellent pizza and excellent service. Great place for the kiddos too - they were able to play with some dough while they waited and gelato comes with their meal. Visited here twice and both times the whole family was very pleased. read more

Great quality and a wide variety of selections from pizza to salad to panini. A bit costly, but clearly made with ingredients of excellent quality. Worth visiting every now and then. Good portions, specially the gelato; don't let it fool you, you get a good amount for a 'small'. read more

Your Pie - Great White Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

See all

First time customer.....amazing!!! So glad to have found you! Fresh, quality ingredients and they deliver!!! Will order again. Awesome!

Great pizza and gelato! Very convenient location to stop by for a quick dinner. Perfect for kids and adults who want their own personal pizzas. Although there are many topping choices, it seems they have been slowly cutting back on the options. Miss the cheddar cheese, ranch marinara, Gorgonzola, and a few others. read more

We just moved to this area, we came across this pizza place and we're glad we did! Sooo good! Employees were very friendly. We chose to build our own pizza and I noticed the toppings and everything looked very fresh. We will definitely be back. read more

Thankful for a place where one of our family members, that has a severe egg allergy can dine and enjoy pizza {and I can get a salad, my way}. But the main reason for the 5 stars is the service. I can't speak for every Your Pie location, but the Fleming Island one always provide excellent customer service! Thanks Your Pie staff! read more

Cant go wrong with Your Pie. I have been to this location and the one in Tinstletown. Both are very good. You pretty much make your own pizza so if it sucks, its on you lol. The staff is always friendly. The only thing that stops me from coming here is the crowd. Always packed and always a wait but its worth it! read more

Visited this location on July 10th and was skeptical of trying a different location, especially since I am from out of town. My first impression was great! Friendly staff willing to assist me on building my pizza, discussing the process, asking me if I want more items to go with my meal, and all this with smile and great attitude. This is one spot I will come back to anytime I am in Florida. Thank you for making that experience memorable. read more

Your Pie - Pizza's in waiting! (They did not wait long at all.) - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

See all

super awesome pizza place. for two pizzas and two drinks it was 23$, the plus is that you can get any and as many toppings as you want on your pizza for a set price. wish i could've tried the gelato, but the machine wasn't working during my visit. pizza was amazing! i had the baked potato pie. AMAZING. i would recommend this place to anyone! also the staff is so friendly and helpful. love it! read more

See all

Now I have been to other My Pie's in town. This one for some reason seemed crazy. The place wasn't even half full and the owner lady was there freaking out. We are so backed up and I'm so sorry for the wait. This place was very hectic behind the counters. I mean they had one guy making dough and taking orders. One guy making pizzas and sliding them down the bar. Then another guy cutting pizzas and trying to put them into the oven. He wasn't putting anything into the gas heated oven with any quickness. I stayed away from the pizzas and went for the Italian panini. Which started out with a bread that was hard to cut for the guy behind the counter. Then he moved it down the way to the guy making stuff. Ok he really could have put some meat on this thing. I little pepperoni, and a little ham, then a whole lot of spinach leaves. He continued with a few tomatoes and then even less cheese. Then he moved it down the bar to marinade or sit for a bit. I went over to the drink machine and waited for my sandwich to find some heat. It did and I took it back to work where I took a couple pf bites and left it alone. It was not good at all. The bread/thin pizza dough was tough and hard to bite though. There wasn't much meat either. In all a crazy place that wasn't run very good and my sandwich was left for whoever wanted it. read more

Your Pie - The maker Guy - Pizza Near Me - Fleming Island, Florida

See all

I absolutely love this place. The people are super friendly and the food is awesome. A great alternative to the big box pizza places and it's not too much food. $3.14 beers on Thursday :) read more

Every time I come here I am greeted immediately. My pizza always comes out perfectly as I ordered it. James, a shift leader, has been very helpful in the past as well as polite if I ever have a question about the menu. They also do lots of fundraisers for Fleming Island which is wonderful to see! read more

My wife and I were in the Fleming Island area and decided to grab a bite to eat. We pulled up our trusty yelp app and after reading the reviews we were led to this local eatery. Really great pizza and the staff is very cordial as well. I'll definitely be back again. read more

Too fun,,,, we love going there and making our OWN style of Pizza. The atmosphere is always pleasant and yes the food is GREAT. This place is alive with joy. read more

The service was great the little young let the young lady at the register name Tyler she help me out and it was quick easy and fast love the service great pie read more

I just found this place a month ago. The pizza is amazing, you can create your own. It's such a great concept , the staff is great , always get excellent service. They also have pasta , panini's , and salads. I also had their gelato , the birthday cake is amazing , this place rocks!!!! read more

I took the family here for lunch after church. I had no idea what this place was about, we just wanted some pizza. The staff asked us if we ever ate here before and we said no. They took the time to explain how to order and they were extremely patient with us. The staff was extremely polite and the pizza was to die for. We will definitely be coming back. I highly recommend this place:) read more

This Your Pie is our favorite out of the ones in Jacksonville. The crew is always extremely friendly and doesn't get an attitude if you have picky requests (like I always do). Definitely one of our go-to dinner places! read more

Definitely my favorite pizza place of all time. I love how you specifically choose a ton of different toppings to customize your pizza for you and you alone. read more

Your Pie....another great pizza place, very different than the others. It's like a Subway concept only a pizza concept instead. Love they Pizza read more

I can't see what the hype is all about with this place. I went during lunch time recently and the place was dead. It was fun to pick out my toppings while ordering from the line, but then again, isn't this what you do with any pizza that's made to order? The crust to me was flavorless. More similar to a Totinos crust that I remember from my childhood. I wouldn't say it was speedy, just slightly faster than a place with a better crust. Whoever states that this place is better than Mellow Mushroom is out of their mind. Mellow Mushroom is far superior to this place in every regard. read more

Best pizza I can remember! I went there this afternoon & the kids making my pies were so sweet & professional. They do it right in a brick oven with fresh top grade ingredients. We will absolutely make yourpie our go to place:) for the best pizza on Fleming Island. read more

Yeah !!!! Finally a place with great crust and you get to make your own pizza. Wonderful, different sauces and toppings available. Respectable beer selection. Quick, efficient service and they give a military discount. My new favorite place for pizza read more

There are lots of fresh toppings to choose from and it was all so so tasty !! The staff was friendly and it was nice and clean. I highly recommend eating here!! read more