Yummy! Support your local businesses! My husband and I took a small road trip during this pandemic just to get out of the house. The hotel we stayed in had fliers for this pizza place so we took a look. Ordered a BBQ chicken pizza to share and it was DELICIOUS!!! So happy with our choice. The ladies behind the counter had masks and gloves on and were super nice. Wish I had a Your Pie where I live! Thanks for a yummy dinner! read more

Everything here is pretty overpriced and they skimp on toppings. They try to portray a friendly and welcoming atmosphere but almost all employees seem miserable. I have witnessed the manager scolding several employees in front of me multiple times. How embarrassing , feel bad for them. Not a way to treat the people who are keeping your business running. I was excited when I saw a new place opening up but Unfortunately I won't be back or making any recommendations. The food is okay but the environment is just not good. Stick to local! There is a pizza place downtown , (Famous) that offers two large slices and a free drink to go with for only 6 dollars, I suggest going there instead. Or pizzicleta if you want fine dining. read more

Gluten free goodness!! We have tried many gf pizzas but this one is a winner! The workers were amazing! The food is high quality all the way to the pesto that I may or may not have licked out of the container! Space provided high speed WiFi which we loved after a long road trip! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

We have been to Your Pie Multiple times. I have to say my family loves it!!! My two young boys love creating their own pie!! The atmosphere is awesome, the pizza is AWESOME!! The family that owns it are great people that care about their customers and our community. The outdoor activities for the adults and children are a nice touch. Get there early to get a great spot by the outdoor warming fire and grab a cold beer from the huge selection of beers on tap. Give it a try if, you haven't already, and you won't be disappointed. read more

The people were awesome, the pizza was awesome (best crust I've had in a long time), and the gelato was awesome! Check it out!

Emma was fantastic great service and helped me choose the best gelato flavor! She suggested her favorite two and I loved them will be getting 2 scoops every time I go in now! Thanks your pie :) read more

This was my first time here, but definitely not my last! There are so many food options that allow you to really tailor your meal to fit what you like/want. The service is also spectacular! Everyone working there seemed to be in a good mood and willing to help! Also, highly recommend the gelato! read more

Great concept. You start by being offered a choice of crust (size, ingredients), then you get to choose what you want on the pizza .. and it's all prepared - quickly - right in front of you. You get to watch it go into the over and after getting a seat, the personal size pizza arrives at your table. Good quality! The crust is not quite what a Neapolitan pizza looks/tastes like, but it's good enough! read more

After being in a moving truck (California to Texas and now driving back to CA) for 8 hours this is exactly what was needed. They were quick service and awesome pizza, plus they had quite the verity of drinking options (from soft drinks to spirts). The patio seating was open, so it was amazing to enjoy good pizza and beer by the fire. Wish they were in CA! read more

Love the concept!! My husband and I were just passing by the city after a long day of driving we wanted some pizza.. searched on yelp and boom we found this jewel pizza is very tasty, prices very affordable and customer service was excellent.. great job guys!! read more

I would eat here with caution if you are celiac. My kids were fine with their GF pizza. However, I was given the wrong dressing for my salad (Caesar) which has wheat. I was very sick and will not return the next time we are in town. read more

This is not your average pizza place. They set themselves apart by allowing the customer to select everything that goes into a personal 10" pizza. They have different crusts from white to wheat, and gluten free. Vegans even have options when it comes to ordering with a vegan cheese option and a slew of vegetable toppings to choose from. The pizzas are $8.95 and that includes an unlimited variety of toppings at no extra charge. There were only a few dough options and so forth that cost extra. Your Pie also has other menu options outside of pizza, and boasts a good draft beer and wine list. Outside there are corn hole boards and other games situated next to gas fire pits with seating. Overall this is a good place to bring family and friends. It's hard to find solid and consistent food spots these days, but I believe this is one of them. read more

Pizza made with thin crust. Pasta is rigatoni with sliced meatballs. Very try with thick cheese pizza crust not enjoyable

We initially discovered this place when we, non-locals, were doing research for a dog friendly establishment. The food was good, service was good and we were satisfied with the ambiance. Since then, we stop at Your Pie every time we swing by for pleasure or business related trips. Recommend for not only the food, but for a dog friendly (patio), casual, warm ambiance place that has a discretionary process of pizza topping creation. read more

Do not go!! This place used to be great. The past two times have been a nightmare. We have placed orders for several pizzas for takeout. You have to bug bug bug them to make your pizza when it should be ready. Last time I waited 40 min past the time it was supposed to be ready and today we waited 30 minutes extra. read more

Fantastic pizza -- the patio is great and I bring my dogs. Two stars are deducted for the unbearably slow service. Word to the wise: if you're in a hurry order online for pickup, then it will be ready when you arrive. read more

everything in my previous review is still true, but this time we ordered a salad that was so bad it wasn't worth any money at all. it wasn't tossed, the dressing came on the side in a very small plastic container and i don't want to build the salad myself if i'm going to a restaurant. let alone the fact that there was so much lettuce in the bowl you couldn't mix the dressing in without everything falling out. a good amount of the lettuce in the salad looked on the verge of going bad, and the proportions of lettuce to topping were way off. read more

I hate to give a bad review, but our experience was terrible. We ordered four pizzas, a pasta dish, and a salad. The four pizzas came out fairly quickly. It took 45 minutes and three visits to the front counter to finally get the pasta dish. it was pure chaos behind the counter. I felt bad for the staff, they were trying their hardest, but they were so disorganized and it seemed like nobody was clearly in charge. I had a gluten-free pizza, prep was handled well and the pizza was good. Although, it was missing half of the toppings, and the first time they delivered the wrong pizza to me altogether and had to go back and trade it for the right one. We won't return. read more

Greek Salad was awesome! Pizza just as good. Variety of beers on tap. Warm inviting atmosphere. Our 3.5 year old loved their pizza too!

We went after the lunch-hour rush so that the line wouldn't be overbearing. There were six customers ahead of us in line. After a 40-minute wait, we finally got to order our pizza. During this time, we watched the guy cashier berate one of the women working the pizza oven. Apparently, she made the wrong pizza for a family who was seated. When it came time to pay, we could not find the cashier. He was too busy dealing with the family that received the wrong pizza. When he finally brought them a new pizza, it was still not the right one and it was not cut into slices. Absolute disaster. I handed him our laminated order sheet and told him to come get me when it was time to pay because I was tired of standing and watching the chaos. He was aggressively rude about it. After another 10 minutes, we finally left. I'm sure the pizza is amazing, but if I were the owner, I would fire that kid. read more

Been waiting for 1 hour for a pizza. Poor management and poor organizational skills. Saw my pizza made sitting on shelf for 20 mins. I had to yell at them to put it in the oven since I already paid 30 mins prior. Also saw many sitting for a good 30 mins to 1 hour as well while 2-3 staff are chatting, rolling doughs while there was no in person line. How about helping out with the behind orders for those who called, paid online or sitting inside? Manager needs serious re-training or demoted or worse case let go! BTW my order was not 100% correct but don't want to wait another hour to have it remedied. read more

As locals, we do enjoy Your Pie. Such a shame, this place could be great because it offers a unique menu but their service is terrible. If you go, plan on waiting a very long time for your food. And forget ordering online. read more

Excellent food & drink ! I couldn't believe how fast they served the yummy pizza. You build your pizza as you progress thru the line to checkout. So fresh and cooked just right. Beautiful building and outdoor dining. read more

Generally the food is really good if not a bit expensive. There is now a "service fee" added on all orders, dine in, carryout, or delivery regardless of party size or order size. That and a few other less than great experiences with botched orders and excessive wait times beyond what was promised. All these factors have pushed me to not frequent this place anymore. read more

COVID protocol needs to be reviewed with employees. I watched as a customer did not get the right order, so the employee took back the food item, after the customer had left the store and returned. The container was place on the food line prep, where all the pizzas are being made... This is a good example of how the virus spreads. read more

I've been here 3 times since it opened. My first experience wasn't great. Pizza was just okay and service was not outstanding. I figured I'd give them another try since it was the first week of them opening. The second time I went in was just to get a beer. Once again, experience wasn't great. Staff weren't around to refill beers so we left after 1 beer. Went back again yesterday to sit outside and get some beers. We walked in, weren't greeted at all. Stood at the bar for probably 8 minutes and nobody said anything to us. I then walked to the cash register where the employee working was helping someone who walked in minutes after us. Another employee, who I believe was working in the kitchen when we walked in, started filling pitchers of beer for another table... still no greeting or a "we'll be right with you"... we finally got service after being there for about 15 minutes... just standing... waiting to be served. We finally got our beers and sat outside. The reason I'm giving this a 3 star is because the beers aren't unreasonably priced (even though they should do a happy hour with at least a dollar off beers), the outside is nice when it's warm, and the place is clean. It's a huge bummer the staff isn't more inviting when customers come in (especially when there is maybe 2 tables filled in there). read more

Super disappointed in the gluten free pizza. The crust was like a cracker and they burned part of it. We ordered it with vegan cheese and there was hardly any on it. Sorry but I've had frozen pizzas that were way better and don't cost anywhere near $15! read more

Online system did not work well. Called on the phone and someone picked up finally. Pizza was 10" inch and cold when I picked up. Slightly better than buying a frozen pizza. read more

I gave it 3 for the salad. This is very mediocre pizza. Not a fan of the cracker thin crust. Would not frequent again but at least I gsve

Absolutely delicious! Great variety of toppings to choose from, good selection of craft beers and outstanding customer service! The restaurant is super clean and comfy. Great for a date night or an evening out with family and friends. We are just passing through while on vacation but would definitely be regulars if we lived near. read more

Nothing but great experiences at Your Pie. Hard to believe Krista E didn't get her salad tossed while she was here! Amanda W probably got diarrhea from eating here with her gluten sensitivity, but diarrhea isn't always bad. Statistically speaking, most of America could lose some weight and diarrhea may help with that. Grant S had quite the lengthy review. Very dexterous with the fingers. Gloves cover fingers and he is really focused on gloves in his review. Personally, if it's going in an oven I say bare hands *All day* I'm officially giving their reviews a one star review. read more

The pizzas are absolutely delicious!! I highly recommend the cauliflower crust because it is fresh, flaky, and actually tastes like cauliflower. The pizzas are thin, so please load up the toppings!! **can add up to 20** the staff was very friendly and made sure that your orders came out fresh. read more

Your Pie Pizza - The boxes are amazing! - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

SAFE FOR CELIACS OR SOMEONE WITH GLUTEN ISSUES! I wanted to share an amazing experience with the both of you so that you know how appreciated you are! I have mentioned to Pete before that we rarely go anywhere to eat as my boyfriend has a serious gluten allergy (super celiac) and myself an egg allergy. We have tried "gluten-free" pizza before at Fratelli's. The experience there was quite the miserable one. Them throwing the dough in the air (breathing it in made him sick in 10 minutes), cross-contamination (no attention to this detail at all), and just the overall experience and service were quite miserable. Nobody seemed to care at all. We avoid restaurants like the plague as somehow, we both end up seriously ill. I took a chance with him on Saturday afternoon and mentioned Your Pie again to him as somewhere I thought might actually be a great place to at least try. Did I mention that his favorite thing is pizza and if he even gets exposed to gluten at all he can be ill in bed for weeks at a time? He rarely eats anything anyways? And once I mentioned this he was reluctant understandably to even step foot in the door? The overall environment is calming and very inviting, to begin with there. Kudos on making it a fantastic and comfortable place to relax and enjoy the people, food, and company. From the minute we stepped through the door I could feel him getting a little anxious about a pizza place. I was waiting for his typical I will wait in the car while you order your pizza and let's go home. But I got a relaxed feeling from him as he read over the menu. I pointed out the gluten-free pizza and I could see as he was asking them about all of the ingredients to be added which were gluten-free or not, his attitude changed to a happier one. I believe only one item was not and cannot for the life of me remember which one that was, no matter, he seemed happy. I am super impressed with your level of training with everyone there and stressing the importance of what all of this means for someone with these allergies. If a worker did not have an answer as to what was or was not gluten-free, they were super quick to get a response from a manager or someone who did know. Most people just say "I do not know and I have no way of knowing". We usually walk out at that point as they obviously do not care at all and do not care to understand. Your workers took the care and caution needed to create a pleasant experience for someone who can rarely eat anyways, let alone his favorite thing...PIZZA! It did not even matter that it was taking "longer" to make as I knew it was cautiously being prepared in the back of the house and that was a very refreshing and appreciated detail for this particular situation. Most do not care. Our other favorite detail was the games in the back area. Since our wait was going to be longer it gave us the opportunity to play some Yahtzee and enjoy each other in ways we do not usually get to. Being out, away from the home and enjoying our atmosphere elsewhere. Super refreshing to be able to do that! We had a BBQ planned with family on Tuesday night August 28th (tomorrow) and his first idea was to have the family meet us there as it will be their first time there and had heard rave reviews about it, especially since he spoke so highly of his experience there as well. We are looking forward to a family night out at "Your Pie" and are super excited to receive the exact same service we already have, nothing short of Wonderful! I wish I could remember one young man's name but he was so personable and came over to where we were to check on us and engaged in wonderful conversation. He was a wonderful young man, not that any of the other employees were bad in any way shape or form at all. He just seemed to be an overall neat kid. I will find his name out and let you know as we appreciated his attitude, personality, and overall care to see that we were okay. I know this is lengthy, but I felt it necessary to let you all know you are extremely appreciated and your attention to all details are over the top!! Thank you kindly again for allowing us to be able to eat out, somehow I think it will be a more regular thing now and we have you to thank for that. read more

What a great restaurant with the coolest build your own pizza idea!! We loved everything about this dog friendly place!! We will be back!!

Food is okay, definitely not worth the high price however. The owner has no clue what she's doing. I won a $50 gift card, and she didn't even know how to use it on my order, so I didnt end up getting to use it fully. We've been in a couple of times and everytime she is always running around like a chicken with her head chopped off. Last week while waiting in line, we were right next to the register when she comes storming through and and yelling to workers who were trying to help guests in line, right in our ears. Decent food, if you like over paying, but probably won't be back until management learns how to do their job. read more

Great food and atmosphere. I only give 4 stars as they could have better heating at the tables by the windows. Also would be nice to have anchovies and or shrimp as topping options. Great location to bring kids/ pets. read more

Nice pet friendly patio. Food was fresh and tasty. Large selection of brews. I would come here again!

One of the worst Pizzas we have ever eaten. It was essentially crust with a little cheese on top. It was like thin and tasted like the cardboard box it was in. Do not recommend. read more

I do not recommend this place. Time after time we come and give our business and they disappoint. Today they made a mistake with my gluten free pizza (I'm glad they realized and re-made it) and we had to wait over 20 minutes for them to fix it. Finally they brought us our pizza and forgot that we asked for ranch so we had to go back and remind them. There are so many other good pizza places in flagstaff. Take your business to the other great places in town. read more

Went in to grab a combo with a pizza, drink, and side salad. I got the great white pizza and thought it was cooked well. I am a fan of white pizza and thought this one was pretty good. The side salad is taken very literally because it was very small and appeared to be sitting in the cooler for some time. I'll be back in the future to try other items on the menu. read more