A Modo Mio offers many food specials. For example, on Tuesdays, that's when we stopped there for dinner, all their pasta dishes are 1/2 price. However, given that they ranked 32nd among this country's top 50 Pizza restaurants, I had to order a pizza. And I'll get to my pizza after I discuss some other things, because it all plays together. Also, during my visit, I kept drawing comparisons between this place and Pupatella, a local Neapolitan pizza juggernaut. The Big Question to answer is why A Modo Mio got a spot on the Top 50 while Pupatella didn't even make the cut. Access is easy, and parking is good. There are lots of spaces that wrap around the restaurant. That's in contrast to Pupatell, which has limited parking and where I always wind up using the Safeway lot across the street. The restaurant is clean and spacious, with plenty of comfortable seating. It also has a long, well-stocked bar where you can sit to enjoy a beverage or a meal. Pupatella doesn't have any of that. When you arrive, you're greeted by a host who shows you to your seat. A very short while later, a waiter shows up and does all the things waiters do. At Pupatella, you wait in line to place your order, then find an open table. TLDR: Your dining experience, outside of the food, is much more civilized and relaxing at A Modo Mio. The pie that earned their 32 out of 50 ranking was the Sicilia. But I ordered a 12" Casertana because I'm not crazy about eggplant and like sausage. The pie arrived a short while later, piping hot and loaded with sausage. The taste was sublime and delicious. My only complaint was that the basil was added before baking, and I prefer that herb when it's not reduced to ash. So back to The Big Question, is the A Modo Mio pizza *that* much better than Pupatella that it earned a spot amongst the Top 50 while the other one didn't even make the cut? Frankly, it's not. It is good pizza... possibly great pizza. But that's also true of the other place. What sets A Modo Mio apart from that other place, and the answer to the Big Question, is that the criteria for generating the Top 50 list included more than the pizza. It also took into account: - Hospitality and Service - Ambiance - Beverage Program. Beyond the pizza, A Modo Mio has those things in abundance, while the other place pretty much has none. TLDR: Comparing pizzas side by side, the two places are on par. However, if you take into account the entire dining experience, you will be much happier with your pizza here, as opposed to that other place or most other pizza restaurants in the DMV area. read more

A Modo Mio - My 12" Casertana, a delicious sausage pizza that's enough for two (people or meals). - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

Voted best pizza in Arlington. Boy did they have huge shoes to fill with that accolade. I came in expecting to be Wowed by their pizza and it was just alright for me. I made a mistake and didn't realize this was a fork and knife establishment. I picked up my pizza and all the toppings fell off. But to be honest... even with "fork and knife pizza" the toppings should not be goopy and slippery. Does the best pie and Arlington hold like that on the regular? Nothing special about the toppings either. The crust and dough were the best part of this experience, but an amazing pie, should have all component's complimenting each other. Is it decent pizza? Yes. Best pizza in Arlington? I don't think so. read more

A good place. Plenty of parking and an unlikely award of one the best pizzas in the world! Pizzas are ok with soft runny top on thin base. Fair chicken and ok porketta sandwich 7/10. Consistent serving. Plenty of inside and outside seating. read more

A Modo Mio - Really? - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

The flavors were there but the execution wasn't the greatest. I don't like my pizza to droop when I pick it up. Maybe if the crust were a little thicker with less grease it wouldn't droop. Sauce was watery but tasted good. The outer crust was perfect. I understand they purposely make it this way, just not my preference I guess. read more

See all

This place is a hit! We glad we listened to a recommendation and found this place. We had bruschetta which really good! The pizza we had Diavola, Prosciutto with Arugula and pepperoni. Everything was so good but my fave is Prosciutto with Arugula. The dough, taste and feels like am in Napoli again. We also ordered the lasagna, but I think it's not for our party. It's not bad but we just have high expectations. The staff were wonderful, really fast and they are there in the right time. The place was has its own character and charm from the outside to inside. Sittings are available outdoor and indoor. For sure we will go back! read more

See all

Most authentic Italian pizza in the DMV. The numerous awards are well deserved. I ordered a 12 inch Margherita pizza. Great balance of sauce and cheese. The crust was crispy, not too thick, and brought me back to the years I lived in Italy. The flour is even shipped from Italy! The 12 inch feeds one person quite easily, but can also be shared for 2 with an appetizer. Service was friendly, genuine, and fast. Vibe was casual. While I only ordered pizza, I'll be back for happy hour! The wine selection looked impressive, and happy hour applies to whole menu! read more

A Modo Mio - Margherita Personal - 12'' - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

The pizza that they make here is real authentic Italian Pizza. Everything from the dough, sauce, and imported ingredients. We ordered their supreme style pizza, and it was clear that they added way more veggies than what you would normally find on an average supreme type of pizza. I've had my fair share experience with authentic style pizzas, so you can take my word for it. We loved the supreme pizza that we had in the restaurant, we ordered a second pepperoni pizza to take home. My kids couldn't even wait to dig into the take home pizza, but I hope it is still as fresh if we re-heat it for tomorrow. We will see if the pizza even lasts that long in the fridge! The service was genuine and very friendly, and we all look forward to returning to ths restaurant soon. read more

A Modo Mio - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

We keep coming back for more!! Amazing seafood pasta, al dente of course. Great pizzas, thin crust and light sauce and cheese like in Italy, great coffee (try the cold one shaken and served in a martini glass, can't remember the name), great Tiramisu. Everything here is delicious! read more

See all

I thought the pizza was pretty good, but a couple of them were a little more floppy than I would like. We saw four different pizzas to share meatball egg, eggplant, pesto, and prosciutto. My favorite was the prosciutto with the fresh arugula. I also enjoyed the pesto and burrata. We got the roasted broccoli and there's nothing special. Comes with free bread and olive oil didn't really enjoy it, since the bread was hard. We were there for someone's birthday and we got free Panna cotta and an ensemble to sing happy birthday. It was really cute. It was a good vibe to enjoy dinner together with friends. read more

A Modo Mio - Meatball and eggplant pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

I had the opportunity to have New Year's Eve dinner here and I was able to score a 7:30 PM reservation using the Rezi app several weeks ago. There's so much parking in this area and they have indoor and outdoor seating. One of the things I really liked is that they seem to have specials three or four days a week if I remember correctly, I think Mondays are half off wine bottles. Tuesdays are 30% off the menu or maybe that was happy hour Monday through Friday and then Wednesdays is half off pizzas and then Thursdays was a sale on cocktails. One of the disappointing things right off the bat was that they took my 7:30 PM reservation and even texted me at 7 PM to make sure I was still coming at 7:30 but nobody ever mentioned that they would close the kitchen promptly at 8 PM, which meant my New Year's Eve dinner was extremely rushed. By 745 I already had to put in my drinks, appetizer, entrées, and desserts. Had I known that they were going to close the kitchen at 8 PM I either would have gone to another place or asked to change my reservation for an earlier time. At 8 PM most of the restaurant was empty, but they still had about four tables, including ours still filled along with two or three folks at the bar. Another thing to note is that they will automatically add 20% gratuity to your bill so please keep that in mind. As far as the food goes, I will say that the pizzas were really good and a small pizza comes with four big slices and a large pizza comes with eight big slices. Personally, I really enjoyed the dough and it was very flavorful, but slightly undercooked. They are known for their Neapolitan style pizzas, and it really shine through. I also got the opportunity to try the lasagna Bolognese, which came sizzling and what seemed to be a mini cast-iron pot. It was evident that this was pre-cooked though and reheated in this pot/pan but what was disappointing was that the bottom layers were sizzling hot but the top layers were room temperature and unfortunately, since the kitchen was closed, I didn't have the opportunity to get that taken care of. I would definitely come back and give them a shot especially because they have weekly deals, but it was truly a disappointment that they took a 730 reservation weeks ago, knowing that they intended on closing at 8 PM. As we were leaving, we got the opportunity to meet one of the restaurant partners and they were so kind; it's evident that this restaurant has regulars and I look forward to my next visit and seeing what it's like when I have more time to eat and enjoy. read more

Nice Italian neighborhood restaurant. Staff were friendly and informative convenient location. I have to say I was a little surprised and disappointed that two large pizzas enough to serve. Four people was $80. When I took the boxes of pizza out the door for takeout it was very light. I was shocked. I just paid $80 for two large (small) pizzas. In their defense, it was very tasty especially the crust ! But not $80 worth sorry read more

The pizza here is so tasty! We got a pizza that was half Arlington, and half Casertana, both great options! The food came out pretty promptly. The drinks were also strong in a good way. They give complimentary bread, which was nice to eat since we were all really hungry. Service was very helpful and great! The restaurant is a bit congested but it has the vibe of an old diner, which I liked. Their Happy Hour deals are great too, so would love to come back and try other dishes. read more

See all

I love this place, probably my favorite Neapolitan pizzeria in DMV. I like the variety of options, good sides and desserts as well. The staff is also very cheerful. They have specials on everyday with some days with half off pizzas. Check the website for details. read more

See all

I was able to walk in without a reservation with a party of four for a girls dinner. We were graded with a cozy family, friendly environment that had no frills and was low-key but still a little upscale. They have a nice outdoor patio as well and plenty of parking. The food is really authentic and feels like you are in Italy. The pizzas, especially feature amazing mozzarella Cheese and fresh tomatoes. I highly recommend the pesto burrata pizza. It was very unique and tasty. read more

See all

This pizza tastes just like the pizza we had in Naples. Crust is light and chewy. Sauce, cheese and toppings were perfect. Highly recommend if you like Neapolitan pizza. Rated #32 of the top 50 pizza spots for 2025 but better than ones we've had higher on the list. read more

See all

The pizza here was ok, but I was surprised at the expensive cake fee. At other restaurants, I don't have to pay an insane cake fee and they will store the cake, add candles, cut the cake, and provide plates and utensils. Here, they charge way too much just to store the cake. The pizza was nothing special, so the service really soiled my experience. read more

A Modo Mio - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

Came here on a Saturday around 7ish with my fellow pizza aficionado. Very nice. The dough is really really thin and soft before it gets airy and a little more dense (and nicely blistered). Sauce is EXCELLENT. I thought the tomato pie (no cheese) was outstanding (but could be further enhanced with a sprinkle of fresh garlic and pecorino). The red Modo Mio(?) with the prosciutto, arugula, olives and ricotta(?) was my favorite. The white porchetta with shrooms was almost equally outstanding. Maybe add sauce and make it red? REALLY really good though. The 4 Cheese was my buddy's fave, and he's as sick in the head (we've traveled for pizza...more than once) for za as I am. Lastly the Margherita. Very good, cheese to sauce skewed way too cheesy (cant believe I typed that) and should've been fresh mozzarella. But still quite a delicious slice. read more

A Modo Mio - Modo Mio, 4 Cheese, Tomato Pie, Margherita, Porchetta - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

We came in here for a Friday night dinner and made a reservation because at 7PM on a Friday, they were quite busy. The place feels very inviting and like a place that is popular with the community - tons of regulars, people getting takeout, talking to staff, etc. We were sat in the bar area where we had close access to the drinks and the view of the pizza making process. Our waiter I think was also the bartender - we were able to order drinks quickly. The cocktail prices were super fair ($13 for a Cosmo) and Peroni on tap, which my husband loved. We started off with a small caesar and the 2 meatballs - both were super reminiscent of good, home style Italian. The sauce with the meatballs was fantastic and the salad dressing was not too anchovy forward. We then ordered our mains- the lasagna and the Arlington pizza. We wait awhile for our mains - I thought maybe it took a while for the pizzas to bake but we saw groups around us come in, order pizza and pay before we got our entrees. The bartender/waiter came over and apologized, as he had forgotten to put in our entrees. We weren't to perturbed- it was a Friday night after all but was a bummer to wait so long. Only then, after his mistake, did the waiter bring us the free bread that I saw the other waiters bringing to other tables. I'll chalk it up to a one time thing or maybe he was new. Once our mains did come out, they were fantastic. The lasagna was great and the pizza was huge, loaded with so many toppings and the crust itself was fantastic. Definitely something to split or take home leftovers of. We also ordered dessert (the gluten free cake) which was fantastic and not overly sweet. Overall great time minus the snafu with the late food - we thought maybe we would get the dessert for free or something but oh well. Definitely need to come back another time to get more pizza or try their half off pasta night! Felt like a great neighborhood spot! read more

We came here on a Wednesday and it was packed, we could not find parking in the actual lot so we had to park on the street. Luckily we did make a reservation so we had our table ready. The free bread and oil were fresh and great. Wednesdays they have half off pizzas so we got those and I tried the Gnocchi Sorrentina. The pizza was great and the gnocchi was really good sadly I just wish it came with more. We also got the tiramisu and mini cannolis, both were just ok. I would definitely come back on Wednesday and get more pizza or even on Tuesdays where they have half off pasta. read more

A Modo Mio - Gnocchi Sorrentina - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

Great pizza. The crust is the star here, and I would like to think it's very similar to true margherita style pizza. We also tried a few of the non-pizza dishes including the lasagna and it was great. read more

The food was so good! Prices were very fair. Everyone working there seemed to enjoy their job and we're great at customer service. I wish I loved closer cause this is definitely the best Italian food I've had in a while. read more

A Modo Mio - Limoncello spritz - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

Great restaurant. The food was so delicious. A little pricey for the portions but each dish really tasted great. Cute inside. Their kitchen is totally open which I love. Added a really cool element to the ambiance. Service was overall good. read more

See all

I'm giving this place a 5 because it's very nice, clean, and well presented. The advertising they did about being a top 50 pizza got me in the door and I'm glad I checked it out. I went on a Sunday and it was pretty crowded. Great experience. read more

A Modo Mio - Pizza with mushrooms and onions. - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

Pizza was ok. Pretty greasy and floppy compared to pupatella. Their pasta looks really good! Will try that next time

Need to report from pizza experience from last night. Fantastic!!! They've recently gotten some international awards about their pizza and ili completely agree! Fantastic, delicious neopolitan pizza! Wednesdays are half-price pizza nights and restaurant was packed (inside and outside). Delicious margarita pizza, chewy crust, sweet tomato sauce and just enough cheese. Pompeii salad and spaghetti were also on point. Crowded, lively atmosphere. Glad too see they've maintained their standards. Still some of my favorite pizza in the area. Too hungry to take pix of food, next time! read more

Disappointing service and our order was completely messed up. (Despite that, there's a mandatory 20% tip). For the pizza itself, the crust was thick and the rest was soggy. Best to avoid Wednesday nights as you might be waiting a while. read more

Place is easily on par with patella and crust for Neapolitan pizza but priced lower. The octopus was really well prepared and at the price ($13) it's a no brainer. read more

A Modo Mio - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

A Modo Mio is a lowkey Italian restaurant that is about a mile away from the busier Arlington neighborhoods. My friend and I stopped by on Friday evening for dinner after seeing good reviews. Overall, I'd say our pizza was tastier and more flavorful than our pasta. The pricing is good and fair. The complimentary bread was enjoyable on its own and a slight bonus with the olive oil on the side. GNOCCHI SORRENTINA - 20 The gnocchi was fresh, but not much flavor -- tasted like any other pasta. The tomato sauce was on the bland side and the mozzarella didn't add much flavor to it either. The fresh tomatoes mixed in the sauce were a pleasant surprise. Overall, if you're just looking for carbs to fill you up (which we were that evening), this is a good option. It doesn't taste unhealthy, and it's very homey and fresh. I probably wouldn't get this again in the future, though. MEAT LOVER (PERSONAL) - 19 The dough was a bit too burnt on the crust, but there was plenty of meat (pepperoni, ham and sausage) that were well seasoned and salted to give the pizza more depth. The dough was very chewy and fresh, the mozzarella and tomato sauce were light. Pizza was pretty solid. Both pasta and pizza tasted pretty fresh and not too greasy -- definitely very homemade and mellow, which I enjoyed. I liked that I can leave the restaurant without feeling bloated. read more

A Modo Mio - Meat Lover Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

Really good food, pizza and pasta are a must. Food came up quick, old service, relaxing atmosphere. A little pricey and not huge portions, but oh well, order more and it's worth it. We'll be back. read more

We always been been able to get a parking space. Our go to meal is a large pizza, the crust is very good if you like Neapolitan style wood fired pizza. I've tried all their entrees, have enjoyed all of them. Highly recommend! read more

This has been rated as one of the best pizza places in the country. The pizza really is delicious as the toppings are fresh and the crust absolutely delicious. Their pasta is also fabulous and maybe better than the pizza. The service and ambiance is fantastic, friendly knowledgeable staff, clean, beautiful pizza oven, family friendly, comfortable seating. Parking on premises. I think the pizza could have a bit more (quantity wise) toppings - that was my only disappointment. read more

Family style Italian restaurant. Caesar salad and octopus were delicious appetizers. I enjoyed the gluten free options; GF penne with meat sauce was tasty and especially appreciated the range of GF desserts. read more

Amazing. This is my favorite Neapolitan pizza and pasta restaurant. There isn't anything fancy about A Modo Mio. But the food is seriously amazing. Protip: during the week, they have different nightly specials like half off pizza or pasta. In these crazy inflationary times, these prices are better than reasonable. I highly recommend the gnocchi, margarita pizza and the pesto pizza with ricotta!!! Chefs kiss!! read more

Food was excellent Out sever was spot on Danilo !! Shout out to him 3 of us came out after a long long day of moving ! We came on a Thursday 1/2 price cocktails. What a pleasant surprise--the restaurant is family friendly but also good for all has real silverware and napkins. Would highly recommend read more

See all

Unbelievable pizza. The dough is perfect every single time!. Some topping could be better, such as the Casertana which use slice piece of sausage. In Italy would be grounded cooked sausage which has much more flavor. Other than that. They all taste good. read more

Delicious, authentic certified Neapolitan pizza with large pies - great for sharing! I spotted the pizza place while driving to Pie-tazza next door, and so glad I went back to try Modo Mio! There's plenty of indoor and outdoor seating and love the adorable little Fiat! The pillowy charred crust with sweet marinara sauce and fresh mozzarella cheese topped with basil was truly divine! The pizza was a generous portion and large enough for hubby and I to easily share the pizza without bickering over the last slice! The pizza was ready within a few minutes and cooked in a dome oven with propane gas. A glass of Chianti paired well with the pizza. The housemade creamy cake-like tiramisu with cappuccino was the perfect sweet ending to our meal! The service was great, when hubby spilled his cup of cappuccino, the waitress promptly cleaned up the mess and made a fresh cappuccino for him. There are daily deals and will come back for the 1/2 price pizza on Wed and happy hour on Thurs sounds good too! read more

See all

We had a family pizza dinner here and everything was excellent. We were warmly welcomed upon arrival, the staff was very attentive and accommodating! The focaccia bread, house salad, beets with burratta and the prosciutto melone was all delicious! Everyone in our party (18 people) thoroughly enjoyed the pizza! It was all scrumptious! read more

I've driven by Modo Mio a few times, on a recent Friday I decided to grab some pasta there before running some errands. I was impressed when I walked inside, it was a much nicer ambiance than I expected. I bellied up to the bar where I was greeted by a very friendly bartender. There were also a few locals at the bar that were busy chatting with the manager. My meal started with some bread and olive oil: really enjoyed the thick and chewy texture of the French bread. Gnocchi Ai 4 Formaggi: Fantastic cheese sauce- it hit the spot and my craving for cheese + pasta. Meatballs: Medium size, a nice thick texture, and beef blend but just OK. Overall I'd give this establishment something between a 3 and a 4 (I still wish I could give half stars!) With friendly service and ambiance, I'll round up this time around. read more

A Modo Mio - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

See all

(Updated review reflecting my dine-in experience.) This is a lovely local Italian spot that specializes in brick oven pizza. I'd say that the pizza is a must! The crust is on the thin side and always served super fresh right from the oven. The rest of the menu has a good selection of Italian-American staples. Takeout is good, but dine in if you can to get the best experience. (There is both indoor and outdoor seating.) Service here is friendly and fast. This is a great place for a family dinner with grandparents, babies, and everyone in between. It can get packed at peak hours, so plan accordingly. read more

A Modo Mio - Margherita - Pizza Near Me - Arlington, Virginia

Pretty authentic italian food! The pizza is great! pasta is great! They also have daily deals that are amazing! check them out and make sure you go on your favorite deal night. Every time i've gone the staff was very nice and polite. The ambiance is very family friendly. read more