I think I may be a fan of Acre. I'm pretty picky on pizzas. They are not all the same. We usually order from here while having beer across the road at Crooked Goat but we decided to eat at the restaurant. It's a really small place. The staff is nice. We really came because they had pitchers of beer for $20 but turns out it's a pretty small pitcher. Still a money saver if your going to have more than one. I believe the potato pizza is my favorite. Tonight we had the poblano pepper pizza. Sure it was called something else. Very tasty. Think our bill was about $50 which for the Barlow is not bad. Sure we'll be back. Or just order from across the street. read more

Acre Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

Generally, I like the pizza at Acre, at least the NY style. However, their Detroit style is by far the worst pizza I have ever eaten, and I have consumed a LOT of bad pizza. It's an abomination of the form, an insult to the state of Michigan and a complete waste of flour, water, yeast, tomatoes and cheese. It makes me sad that a cow had to give up its milk just to used on this horror. read more

Acre Pizza - Rubbery, dense, flavorless, underbaked... - Pizza Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

Acre Pizza focuses on quality and they make everything with the best ingredients and many local ingredients too such as getting fresh mozzarella from Double 8 Dairy in Valley Ford. They ferment their pizza dough for 72 hours, which helps create a light and crispy crust. They also offer New York and Detroit style pizzas so you really have the best of the pizza worlds here! You can truly taste the labor of love they put into their food. Acre's potato pizza is a must try! I would never think of putting potatoes on pizza but the two together... boy is this good! I love the flavor with the thinly sliced russet potatoes, cheeses ranging from mozzarella to gruyere to EVOO and seasoning including rosemary and house-made garlic oil. This pizza is more complex than your average pizza. I recently had some friends try this pizza during a visit to the Barlow and they were a little skeptical at first but were pleasantly surprised! In addition to pizza, they offer salads, meatballs in marinara and cheesecake for dessert. I highly recommend their Caesar salad that comes with baby gem's lettuce, a house-made Caesar dressing and Red Bird Bakery garlic croutons as well as seasoning. This wasn't your traditional Caesar and has a lot of flavor too. read more

Z Love their pizzas - dough is chewy, but not gummy, toppings are creative and fresh- staff is friendly and patient read more

I stopped in a Sunday morning with friends. We parked by the Sebastopol Public Market and walked over to the Barlow and pizza caught our eye. I am Italian and a harsh critic, but this pizza looked dang GOOD. I vowed I would try it again because I was in the mood for a salad. After looking at the menu, I decided to get the Argula with Fennel Salad and went outside to sit. I didn't see any seating indoors, but it was warm enough that being outside didn't bother me. My salad came out quickly and my friend's pizzas came out not too long after. The vinegrette was very good, but it needed more. After shaking my salad up, I went back in and got another, at no charge. My salad was delicious and my friend's pizza slice that I tried was delicious too! The crust is thin and the space and cheese were perfect. If I'm ever in Sebastopol again, I would like to order a full pizza! read more

Acre Pizza - Arugula and Fennel Salad - Pizza Near Me - Sebastopol, California

PESTO PIZZA WAS DELICIOUS! It had walnuts, tomato, pizza and some yummy cheeses i cant remember but highly recommend!! I also suggest adding bacon to it. My only suggestion is to put slightly less tomatoes next time (so that the slices aren't so soggy) They also have beer read more

Acre Pizza - To go order - Pizza Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

Sat outside and enjoy the delicious pizza! They had some fun options and couldn't decide so we did a half and half. Friendly staff and very fresh food. read more

Acre Pizza - NY Poblano & Pig and NY Fungi - Pizza Near Me - Sebastopol, California

A very hungry caterpillar was in a Caesar salad we took to go. I don't know how long it was in the fridge at the restaurant, but it was sealed with me before I finally opened it for dinner; the worm was still alive and wiggling around vigorously. I've attached three pictures for reference, it was actually fairly small and I wouldn't have noticed it if it wasn't wiggling away where it's green color contrasted with the to go bowl. I also have a video where you can see it actively moving like it's getting in shape for the big fight with Apollo creed, but I can't upload it here on Yelp. The salad was actually really good and the dressing had a unique taste we hadn't tried before, we were excited to go back but obviously we won't be after this incident. We also picked up the lunch special margarita and pepperoni personal pizzas, they were both yummy but I couldn't finish mine as I lost my appetite after seeing my green friend. Anyway I wouldn't get the Caesar salad until they improve their food prep or change up their supplier. read more

See all

Overall, this pizza was delicious. Crispy bacon with thinly sliced and flavorful potatoes and caramelized onions - all a great combination. My only qualm with this meal was the amount of rosemary. Rosemary is such a strong herb, that too much can overpower the dish. Some bites I could only taste rosemary. I would return, but try a different pizza. read more

Acre Pizza - Potato pizza with bacon - Pizza Near Me - Sebastopol, California

I have tried the traditional and deep dish pizza from Acre Pizza. While there are both worth eating, neither was impressive. The spicy sausage was not spicy and the deep dish was a mess. The deep dish required a fork and knife or 15 napkins. Additionally, the box was saturated in oil and transferred to anything it touched. My recommendation is stick to the traditional round pie and don't expect to be wowed. read more

Acre Pizza - Deep Dish - Pizza Near Me - Sebastopol, California

Great pizza good service I like the outdoor seating. Especially good for families with little ones. read more

Absolutely mind-blowing Detroit style pizza, passable New York thin-crust, and exceptional cheesecake at outrageously high prices! Call me naïve, but I've never paid $10 for one slice of pizza before. I would give this place 5 stars if the prices weren't so ridiculously out of reach for enjoyment on even a semi-regular basis. read more

Great Pizza. That's really all you have to know. I was too hungry to snap a picture. Their Detroit Style Cheese Pizza was heavenly. The crust was fluffy and focaccia like. The cheesy edges were burnt to a crisp. Sauce was tangy and flavorful. Finger licking good. The only downside was I wish the pizza was bigger! Also tried their Farm House 26inch New York Style Pizza. Great crust. Delicious when warm, still great when cold (we had some leftovers). The ingredients were really farm fresh. This was one of the best things I ate during our Sebastopol day trip. I need to come back for another slice of the Detroit Style Cheese. read more

My favorite pizza in Sonoma County! Love ordering online and taking pies to go for at home or just eating out on the lawn at The Barlow. Love the seasonal ingredients they use in the specials and the fun things they create around fun holidays, like the heart shaped pizzas for Valentine's Day. Also the take home cookie dough is to die for! It's delicious enough to eat raw, if you're into that kind of thing. read more

Yes I do recommend this place the pizza is very good but damn expensive it was 9 dollars for a slice of pepperoni Chicago style pizza look great but I am not spending 9 bucks on a slice of pizza sorry . We ending up getting a spicy sausage pizza a whole one fed all four of us very yummy the sauce is very good non acidic very tasty sausage was great had a little bit to it perfect like I said it's a very good pizza but get ready to open your wallet. The Barlow it's a nice place to walk around nice afternoon very good time with my wife and son and his girl good times read more

Acre Pizza - Spicy sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sebastopol, California

As a born and raised New Yorker recently relocated to Sonoma, it's been an ongoing quest of mine to find decent pizza. We stopped by to check out the market on Sunday and decided to pick up a margarita pie at Acre with not too high hopes. The pizza took about 20 makes to make and we sat at one of the outdoor tables and dug right in. I was immediately impressed by the nice crispy bottom on the outside and warm bread once you bite through the slice. It was not too thick and not too thin. Sauce was just right, not too wet. The basil was fresh and in large pieces. My only complaint and a minor one was there were only a few basil large basil pieces and I ended up having to rip them up and spread it around the slice before devouring. Dare I say this might be the best pizza place in the Santa Rosa area (not restaurant style)! read more

I love the pizza here, even my kids enjoyed the pizza. I always get the pizza with potato slices it's my absolute favorite one to get. 9/10! read more

Acre Pizza - Cheese pizza and Potato pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sebastopol, California

The gluten free Detroit is the best thick and delicious gluten free pizza I've had. Didn't tell the difference it the dough

We finally were able to try Acre Pizza and it was delicious. I was a little disappointed to see that there was no garlic bread or breadsticks on the menu... just pizza and salad. We ordered the Detroit Style Pepperoni and the suspense was killing me while we were waiting. When it was ready we were shocked on the size. For $20 I was expecting something bigger than a 4 slice 10"x6" pizza, but when I opened the box it was love at first sight! I removed a slice and was all smiles when I took a look at the other crust. It looked so delicious. The first bite was heavenly, the dough is light and fluffy. The outer crust is perfectly cooked and is crispy crunchy deliciousness. At this point I was no longer disappointed about the breadsticks not being on the menu, the price or size. It was worth it! The Detroit style pizza's outer crust is like a cheesy breadstick, it's built right in! Now I get why they don't offer them. Everything about the Detroit Style Pizza was awesome... but order your own pizza. This bad boy is not meant for sharing! read more

See all

Been back several times back to piZza perfection. The crust is just so so on point. Light and airy. Perfecto.

This place has gone down hill. They recently are consistently skimp with the toppings. If it's a 33$ pizza with a single topping, the least you can do is make it look like the picture on your website. It tastes good so I keep reluctantly coming back, only to leave disappointed 9/10 times. Acre pizza Barlow - DO BETTER read more

This pizza is so good, with a thin crust & not soggy. The dough is the right amount of chewy & crunchy. There are a lot of vegetarian and vegan options here. I still have more to try, but the NY Fungi was a great start. read more

Acre Pizza - Ny fungi - Pizza Near Me - Sebastopol, California

This pizza was DELICIOUS! I ordered the Green Detroit and the flavor was fantastic... I really love the fermented dough. It was thick like a deep dish, but soft with crunchy borders. I never tried a pizza dough with that flavor. The roasted tomatoes were full of flavor and the seasoning in general, was on point. I am removing a star because: The wait time was almost an hour. The pizza was pretty greasy (it had pesto and it was OILY but still good). The arugula salad was just a bowl of arugula with a few pieces of other greens and the dressing was bland! The price of the pizza was over $22 and feeds only two people (2slices each). The salad was $9 for a bowl of arugula. I felt both items were overpriced. But the pizza was worth it...The salad, did not. I forgot to take pictures because the wait time was so long and it was pretty cold that night (it was outdoor seating) that I just wanted to eat asap. I will return to try other pizzas on their menu. Not so sure about giving the salad another chance. read more

We worked with Acre Pizza on a catering order for our wedding welcome party and were so happy with how everything turned out! I reached out to Courtney/Claudia a few months out to start organizing - both were super helpful and responsive to our questions. I placed the final order about a week prior and Claudia went over everything with me to make sure it was correct. We even had some special requests due to guest dietary restrictions and they were very accommodating. On the day of our event, they delivered everything on time and correct. The ladies that delivered were helpful and friendly. All of our guests commented on how great the food was! We would highly recommend Acre Pizza - great food and great customer service. read more

Last night my family ordered a couple of pies and all of them were disappointing. Who came up the the Puttanesca? Absolutely horrible, why would there be Anchovies, kalamata olives, and ANCHOVIES???? Thea worlds three saltiest Foods on a single pizza???? Disgusting salty, why not just chose one of those things? Also the shrimp pizza was one of the worst, overcooked nightMare. Also the girls at the Sebastopol store were pretty rude and unwelcoming considering we dropped like $150 on this garbage pizza. The only saving grace for this restaurant is that they sell really yummy sourdough pizza dough, the pizzas we made at home were 5x better. Somehow the pizza dough they sell doesn't taste like the ones they use for their pies. Edit. Also burnt to hell on the bottom, thanks for the cancer. read more

Consistently excellent. Been here many times over several years and it's always great. Everything is always fresh and ready to go. Just a basic cheese slice is a transcendent pizza experience. read more

Acre Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sebastopol, California

Super good pizza, nice people and apparently their ranch is super good so I had to buy it lol

Way overpriced mediocre pizza, and the gluten free crust is just plain bad. Maybe it's the distance from the city/lack of competition that keeps Acre going and at ridiculous prices? read more

This is it for me and pizza in Sonoma county! They have at least 3 different kinds of vegan pizza and the two Iv tried so far are totally perfect. I love the open air space at Acre pizza in the Barlow. Everyone there is hustling and even with a line the food come out in about 20 mins. Hot and perfectly baked in their high heat pizza ovens. The vegan cheese is melty and the vegan pepperoni is just the right amount of spicy! Great beer and cider in the fridge, nice looking salads, and lots of indoor and outdoor seating as well as the option of sitting in the grass across the street. The pizzas aren't cheap but it is the Barlow and it is delicious! Today we had the vegan pepperoni a Ny style round pizza with perfectly foldable slices and fresh basil on top. A few weeks ago we had the square Detroit deep dish style veg pizza and the vine tomato sauce they ladled on top is perfection. Cannot wait to try the vegan sausage pie! read more

Acre Pizza - Detroit style deep dish veg pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

First time here. Came in for a slice and it was sooooo good! I had the vegetarian and husband had the Sicilian. Two slices equals one slice. Heck yeah. :-) read more

Acre Pizza - Thin crust vegetarian with a lemon slice and asparagus. Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

Best pizza in Sonoma County! Friendly staff, amazing service and relaxed atmosphere. There's a bit of everything for everyone's needs. If you're on the go, slices ready to eat, salads, and delicious meatballs in marinara sauce. Go check out Acre Pizza if you're looking for something fresh and delicious! read more

Acre was so good when it opened in 2020. It has gone steadily downhill and last night was the final insult. We were served a $40 sloppy tasteless over-cooked pizza. I'm never going back. read more

Acre Pizza - This piece of crap cost $40. - Pizza Near Me - Sebastopol, California

Detroit style pizza! The sauce is perfectly seasoned on a fluffy cloud of thick pizza dough with the right amount of cheesy goodness and the slight crisp on the edges that gives a satisfying crunch. I don't know why, maybe it's the rectangular shape, but it's strangely nostalgic and reminds me of the elementary lunch pizza, but a million times more delicious. I am a sucker for the plain pepperoni Detroit style pizza and haven't wanted to try anything else because it's that good. You definitely have to try it. read more

Had the worst deep-dish pizza of my life. The cheese was not melted and looked like a combination of Velveeta and American cheese that was so thick that even my three kids wouldn't eat it. Really disappointing for $28. They were not even that busy, where they had no excuse for the poor quality control. Have enjoyed their pizza previously but this was a big miss. read more

Tasty & worth the wait. Vegan pizza options were nice, but I wish they had more veggies. Hard to complain because it's so delicious but I like my toppings-a-plenty.. Got the Vegan Detroit Veggie read more

This place is Legit! It was my first time going to the trendy Barlow shopping center. I knew that Acre Pizza had just opened, so I made it a point to visit Acre and The Barlow. This is a small pizza shop... not a table service restaurant. You order at the counter as you would expect from most pizza shops. The food was absolutely fresh and delicious. The service and staff were warm and friendly. The only reason for my 4-star review instead of 5 Stars, is because the interior seating consists of four picnic style tables with long benches. There were no booths or individual tables for say, a party of 2 to sit together and have a more private conversation. You might end up sharing a table with another group. If community seating is your thing, great. But I prefer individual seating with more space. read more

See all

We were here several months ago. Was impressed then and still am! We ordered the mushroom pizza - crust was soo good and Ill definitely come back for more! They moved across the street to a much bigger spot! Not sure if they substituted spinach for arugula but it was still scrumptious! The Italian soda was a perfect pairing! read more

Acre Pizza - Mushroom pizza thin crust - Pizza Near Me - Sebastopol, California

See all

Ordered sausage pizza only had five pieces of sausage on the whole pizza. Very scarce toppings.

Holy cow is this great pizza! I went back today for the second time and brought my husband and he also loved it. He devoured the farm pizza which was loaded with perfectly cooked broccoli and mushrooms, light on the cheese and perfect crust. I am addicted to the cheese pizza. The crust reminds me of the type we get in Rome. The staff is super friendly and the owner was there today. He gave us a taste of the soft serve salted caramel made from buffalo milk - wow was it delicious. Nice to have Acre Pizza in our area - probably the best pizza I have had outside of Italy. One other beneficiaries - Red Bird Bakery is right next door! read more

Acre Pizza - Pizza slices - several options every day - yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Sebastopol, California

This place has become our go-to pizza spot since moving to Sebastopol. The thin crust is divine, especially if you like a slightly chewier dough that bubbles up at the crust. It's hard to order anything other than the pepperoni, it's that good. The salads are solid and they do slices at lunch now too. We usually just call in our order and they are efficient at getting a warm pizza in your hands and out the door, but since they moved across the street the new location has lots of room indoors and outdoors. read more