I was here for the first time ever yesterday. I ordered one of the items on their specials board,…read morewhich are temporary menu items. I ordered the Apple Pie Pancakes. It's three of their pancakes with homemade apple pie filling on top. The waitress asked if I wanted whipped cream and I said of course. I was happy with the service. Our waitress was busy but made sure we had everything we needed. I changed this from four stars to five stars because there was very little wait for our food. It came out right away and I was really surprised and joyful about that. Ambiance was cute. It had some fall attributes. Price was high but it was worth it, since the coffee wasn't bad and the pancake serving size was huge. Definitely check out this fun breakfast place!!!

Service was very slow it took a long time between taking drink orders then another long wait for…read morethe food. Ambiance there were lots of dinners apparently waiting for their food. The table was still sticky and same for the menus. I had scrambled eggs rye bread toast and home fries with onions along with decaf coffee which they did refill. I had to ask for water. Eggs were ok and home fries were just passable.

food good asked for no lettuce but got lettuce but asked for well done and it was perfectread more

My favorite restaurant for gyros. The food is amazing comfort food. The service is always amazing…read moreand I love that it's the same restaurant I remembered from 40 years ago!!!

I got it to go' It was early like 3ish and I was in the old neighborhood so let's get to Athena's!…read moreLo and behold I get back to Lewiston and dove into one of the best fish fry's in the world! My gosh that was good! I can't eat a lot so we have some left over for later...Outstanding!

Been patronizing Athenas for many years. Last two times, the food was awful. Macaroni salad and…read morecoleslaw swimming in mayo and inedible! Fish was cold. VERY DISAPPOINTING

A nice surprise here. I groaned inside when an old friend suggested we meet here for breakfast. I…read moreexpected the usual mediocre food from a grumbling waitress in a greasy spoon setting. Instead I found a great experience. I arrived first. There's a very large parking lot that extends down a little hill with an entrance/exit on Sonwil drive. That's Important as Genesee st can be busy and the stoplight saves the day. The hostess offered to seat me first but I waited. We were sat immediately after their arrival and offered coffee. Our waitress was quick and gave us the opportunity to chat a bit and look through the menu. On a Sunday morning, the place was full. I ordered a pita melettes with gyro meat and feta with the addition of spinach and a side of home fries. Our waitress kept the coffee coming and the food came out within 15 minutes. The home fries were perfectly browned and had plenty of onions and peppers. The pita melette was excellent. The flat pita rolled around a thin layer of egg, stuffed with the spinach, gyro and feta. The pita was warm and soft , had ample feta and the chunk style of gyro (opposed to the thin slices). My friends veggie omelette was good with the rye toast. The place was bright and shiny clean. A large case up front selling what looked like mostly premade desserts but there was a nice baklava cheesecake and I'm kicking myself for not grabbing a piece of the spanakopita for later. Next time I won't hesitate to come here, I'll suggest it!

Olympic gas breakfast all day with many options on their menu. They also have some breakfast…read morespecials. I had special #2: 2 eggs (in my case sunny side up), rye toast and hash brown potatoes. Onions are not included, for 75cents up charge they will add them. Weird thing on their menu: #2 in breakfast all day is $1 more than #2 breakfast special for the exact same dish! Bacon is extra too, 3 strips for $2. A cup of coffee is $3,49, not really cheap but comes with unlimited refills. Our waitress was very busy with a lot of tables to cover, but she was very attentive and refilled the coffee many times.

It was pretty nice. Was quite busy and it's a small space for a lot of people. Took a few minutes…read morefor a waitress to order our drinks. The appetizers, tzatziki and spanakopita were both really good. The spanakopita tasted a lot like dill and had a strong pickle flavor for some reason, but it was still a great appetizer. To save some room for dessert, I had a cup of chicken and rice soup. It was good just nothing special. It was served with a bit of it was spilled outside of the bowl. The baklava was delicious. The extra honey drizzle on top was slightly too sweet for me. Bottom layers are very dense so be careful when you try to cut it. Overall, a nice restaurant to satisfy your Greek cravings.

I was hungry. A family-style restaurant was just what I wanted. Talk about a great menu, fast,…read morefriendly wait staff, and excellent quality food! The prices are low and there's even a cash discount! Cheesburgers are cooked to order. The pot roast is sensational. Pork chops are juicy. Fish is crispy. French fries aren't salted to death. Loving this place.

one of my favorite restaurants i love going to every time me my mom and dave stop in for dinner…read morewe are always treated like family i always enjoy the food we get everything is delicious Pegasus is one of the best greek restaurants i've been to amanda and staff and themy and nico are 2 nicest owners i ever met

All menu items are overpriced! Portions are small! My order came out cold! Will not dine there…read moreagain!

I was hesitant at first when I saw that the menu is mostly American food, with a heavy focus on…read morebreakfast and brunch. Why would I come to a Greek restaurant for American diner food? With a careful look through the multi-page menu to seek out the Greek items, they are there, you just have to search. And they are GOOD. The spanakopita was especially outstanding so I'll start there - it's a circular roll-up style, a bit heavier on the filo dough and lighter on the spinach filling, with excellent flavor and textures. I loved the hummus and tzatziki (and I make these at home so I'm pretty picky about them). The pitas were hot, fresh, and fluffy. The spicy dip is good but *very* spicy which I wasn't prepared for! I didn't love the dolmades since they were cold and I prefer them warm (seemed actively chilled, not like "plate was sitting", so I assume this was a purposeful choice, just not my thing). The Royal Open Greek Souvlaki is a gigantic salad with a pita on top. This was excellent with char-broiled chicken; it was topped with a very generous pile of feta cheese and came with spicy vinaigrette on the side. We enjoyed the baklava so much we got a second one to take home. It's very filo-heavy with not many nuts and not overly honey-sticky; I couldn't quite place the flavor but it's almost like a cinnamon roll version of baklava. They are pretty large for the price and I'd definitely recommend ending the meal with this if you still have room. The dining area is nice, well lit and with beautiful decor that gives a fun Greek vibe to the space. The ceiling is painted to look like blue sky with clouds, and there is a lovely mural near the back. Noise level was reasonable so you can have conversations at the table without yelling and also without feeling like everybody hears you. Our server was friendly, although we were surprised that she hadn't tried some of the menu items and couldn't give us her opinion on them. Please try the food! Also we didn't get water refills and it didn't feel so busy that water should get ignored. Overall I was very happy with my meal here and I will be craving that spanakopita for a long time.

OMG this food was amazing. I was hesitant because I wanted Greek food, but the menu had everything…read moreBUT Greek almost. The waitress was also not familiar with the food. Usually a bad sign. The Greek items are buried in the menu and need to be dug out. HOWEVER... once you find the Greek food it is absolutely STELLAR!!! I'm late with my review and I don't remember all the things I ordered now, but when family comes to town, we will 100% be coming here. It's absolutely outstanding! My only complaint is that they don't seem proud of their Greek menu and those items are buried instead of easy to find and order and the waitress wasn't knowledgeable about all the food. "Back in my day" it was a requirement that servers knew the menus and tastes all the items. Times be a changing. Still, I can't knock a star off because of how amazing our food was.

I almost don't want to review this place because I'm sure it serves a very particular niche of…read morepeople who are satisfied, it's well kept and quaint. The interior was pleasant and clean, my kids thought it was very fancy. The employees were friendly and kind and kept our drinks and coffee filled. Unfortunately we thought food was mediocre - the breakfast potatoes were definitely not seasoned, the breakfast sausage were freezer sausages that were cold in the middle, and the portion for the chicken souvlaki which was supposed to be a meal was very small and included one olive and one pita with a little lettuce and some chicken on the side. Many small things had an upcharge- onions, American cheese, additional kid's drinks, which we did agree to, but still found it kind of rough that our bill was over $70 for the food we received.

This seems to be a restaurant in transition ... no staff, perhaps just the owners ... I will not be…read moreback.