Driving down Manchester headed towards Brentwood and I happened to look to the left and saw this gem of all gems. I had to make a U turn. I haven't seen an Amighetti's in years and I often have flashbacks of when my mom would bring these sandwiches home after work. To my excitement, all the old favorites are still on the menu. The new owner was working the counter and he was so friendly and funny. Even though the pasta looked good, I had to go with my old favorite, the classic Amighetti sub...beef, ham, salami and all the fixin's. I got the sandwich to go and devoured it when I got home. It was great, just like I remember it. I'll be visiting here again and again. read more

8-31-2020 Take Out Order - FOR 2 This is the same famous Italian Food that started on THE HILL in 1917. - Excellence - Building & Parking Lot - New brick Building , Excellent signage, parking & take-out area are Excellent. Menu selection - Excellent Staff - very polite & very efficient. Excellent & high quality. Eating area - nice selection of inside booth/tables. To Go Orders brought to your car in designated pick up area. Ordered: 2 "Little Bit of Italy" Hot Sandwich's. Beautifully wrapped with inner aluminum foil plus paper wrapped outer paper. Everything is Excellent and First Class. Hot Italian salami, cheese, mild delicious onions, olives with their personal Bakery buns. Delicious & unbeatable flavor. YOU WILL LOVE THIS Looking forward to returning very soooon. read more

bread was so very hard not just the crust but all of it. felt like jaw gymnastics to eat.

Walked in and felt like I had to get their namesake's special. It was awesome. Great collection of tastes and they somehow pulled off an unprecedented deli sandwich. Service was fantastic: everyone had a smile, super friendly, and they brought the food right out to us. read more

Amighetti's - Amighetti Special - Sandwiches Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

wrong salad and made the food so slow with no butter on my butter noodles and no silverware and wrong sauce on salad and ran out of the sauce we ordered for $7 read more

I returned to Amighetti's last week with my mom and I have to say that my second time around, I much better than my first time! The service was superb, just as it was the first time I came. This time, knowing that the lasagna was not really my thing (as it turns out, it's a vegetarian dish. Who knew?), we had salads, bread, and sandwiches! Things that we liked: - Brussel Sprouts and Cauliflower! I typically hate both, but these were so well seasoned and well cooked, that they were both delicious! It was quite a surprise! - The Special Salad! It's really good and really loaded with all the fixings; meat, veggies, and cheese! -The Loaded Special Sandwich! A classic sandwich loaded with meat, lettuce, and cheese, a bit messy but still pretty good. -The Little Bit of Italy! A really good toasted salad with just enough meat, onions, and black olives. -The Italian Beef Sandwich! OMG! I don't like gravy, so this sandwich scared me, but it had excellent flavor and the meat was very tender! I really liked this one. -Brownie for dessert! I took half a brownie to go and it was rich and delicious! Very chocolately and soft. It tasted homemade for sure. I'm glad I gave this place another chance and highly recommend you check this place out! It's casual dining but has a lot of good options beyond your standard sandwich shop. I'll be back! read more

See all

I have eaten here many tomes for both breakfast and lunch and the food is always delicious!

So delicious you can't go wrong here. The sandwich just melts in your mouth. The bread and cheese is so fresh and tasty. Get a loaded if you're hungry. read more

Amighetti's - Loaded special - Sandwiches Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

Always get the special, never disappoints. Bread was a tad old and hard but everything else was great

I stopped in for a quick weeknight dinner after work. I think I made the wrong choice when ordering. In any event I got their duo with an order of cheese toasted ravioli and mostaccioli in meat sauce. Yes, very St. Louis. The toasted ravioli ranged from a little cold in the center to reasonably warm. They would have been fine if they were fully cooked. The sauce on the mostaccioli tasted a little acidic and the pasta was a bit overcooked. I wasn't expecting a gourmet meal but I wouldn't get it again either. Probably the best thing to order here is a sandwich since that's what they're known for. I think the menu is a little different than on The Hill but all your favorites are there. If I return I'd go for a sandwich and skip the pastas! read more

Amighetti's - Duo: Toasted Ravioli & Mostaccioli - Sandwiches Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

I find the offering not what it use to be. Bread is not special. Ingredients seem average.

I Ordered two half sandwiches, one was an inch smaller than the other. Both sandwiches where excellent, however both together was a snack. Around $18, who shrunc the sammich? read more

Amighetti sandwich is the best sandwich in town. Always a good option for lunch. Online ordering is fast and easy. Highly recommend!

Not much to say. Yes the Sandwiches are pretty much the best around. But the service was very slow. I waited 20 minutes + for 3 Amighetti specials. Bummed that The Hill location is closed. read more

This is by far the worst sandwich I've ever had. The chicken is burnt , not even edible. It's like they don't care. Looks like they just threw a couple pieces of burnt chicken on the bread and slapped some marinara on it. I ordered a pasta salad and it was literally t 2 tablespoons read more

Amighetti's - Chicken Parmigiano Sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

Simple menu that pleases everyone--sandwiches and pasta--made to pasta. My grandkids, Naomi & Elias, like it just as much as I do.

Food is good. If you are going on a picnic, float trip, they will pack the sandwiches specifically so the bread doesn't get soggy.

Been going to Amighettis for as long as I can remember. Lots of memories. I'll never stop eating here. I've been to every location they've ever opened with my Dad. We've seen locations open then close down after awhile. But there has always been one thing that's consistent in all of them. That's gotta be that they serve the greatest sandwich ever made. However.... My Dad and I both have gone to this rock hill location and this location is different. The staff there are incredible! We even got to know the owner. Which is awesome! The food there is better than any of the other locations that has ever opened. If you want true St. Louis food. Go to the amighettis on rock hill. It's amazing. Order the Amighettis special. It's the best sandwich you'll ever taste. I recommend you get it with a Fitz's Root beer. An Stl sandwich with an Stl soda. I call it the Saint Louie Combo. read more

Amighetti's - Best sandwich ever!!! - Sandwiches Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

Used to be the best sandie in STL. No more. It's lost it's essence in Warson Woods. It as the best. No more. read more

Waiting 40+ minutes for a sandwich is a bit much...I get that you have pre-orders and pickups but for christ sake, how about you communicate to walk-ins that now is not a good time to order food...Need to do better if you want repeat business read more

Great service, great food that is fresh, amazing bread. What more can one wish for? Indoor seating, outdoor seating. Mom & Pop charm. A must go to for out of towners and locales. read more

So sorry to say that we were really disappointed with the new owners Amaghetti's sandwich! It used to have more meat and cheese. Now, it's like there's some meat and cheese with the bread. The bread is not the same homemade Amaghettis used to use. Our over all opinion is it's a skimpy version of the sandwich! I hate when something I love is down graded for profits sake! read more

Deli with some indoor seating. "Amighetti Special" is the claim to fame, loaded with meats, cheese, peppers and Amighetti's special dressing on Italian bread. Friendly people, and sandwich was prepared very quickly, but I was not a fan. It was just on basic white bread, and had way too much sauce that tasted like big-mac sauce. read more

See all

Had never had Amighetti's before....doubt I'll have it again. Was hungry and found them through DoorDash. Saw a pic of the lasagna and it looked so go I figured I had to try it. Big mistake. It was awful. Stouffer's makes a better frozen lasagna. The noodles were so gummy they stuck together and it was a mess of cheese on top but dry in the middle. It was inedible. At least I had salad to eat or I would have remained hungry. The salad was decent. read more

Amighetti's - Lasagna - Sandwiches Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

Very fair prices and AMAZING sandwiches. I definitely recommend the loaded special. Will most certainly be returning!

The staff is awesome!!! I finally can have a Amighetti's sandwich again because the have gluten-free bread and take celiac seriously. Thank you for making my day! They also have gluten free pasta! read more

Stopped at Amighetti's for a special. The service was good and received the sandwich quickly. It's still one of the best subs around, much better than the franchise box stores. The bread is the only item keeping it from being as good as the original on The Hill. It's soft. The original had a crispy crust which is missing. read more

I ate my first Amighetti's special sandwich in 1978 and thought it was absolutely the best sandwich I ever had. I enjoyed many more until I moved out of state in 1980. When I returned in 2016 I learned the original location had closed and the business relocated to Rock Hill. I went there and ordered one. As soon as I saw it I thought it wasn't the same because it was about half as thick. After one bite I KNEW it was different because it didn't taste anything like I remembered. What a total disappointment. Whoever is responsible for that change should be ashamed of themselves. The best sandwich St. Louis ever produced is now only a memory. I will not be back read more

Anthony, I appreciate the response. Not sure how I can respond outside of another review. Just to be clear: 1 - I called in the order and waited 20 min before showing up and 2- I added a cannoli... Thanks for the getting back to my review. Spencer read more

I can remember going to Amighettis on the weekends on the hill as a child. Have some of the best sandwiches in St. Louis.

This is my first review ever but here it goes. Went there on12.19.2022 and order one 6" special to stay and two to go. My wife opened hers for lunch today and found a fake acrylic fingernail on her sandwich. I called the location today and started with "not looking for anything for free, but I thought you should know". My mistake was calling at lunchtime because the team member didn't have time to listen. Really discussing! read more

If you go there you have to try the Amighetti's Special sandwich, and any of their sandwiches in general are very good. The lasagna on the other hand, meh, nothing Italian or special about it. read more

Super impressed with Anthony & Crew! I picked up a LARGE order in the middle of the lunch rush! Anthony & cashier were so professional, calm & kind! It was AWESOME to see a local business so busy post COVID! The food was fresh & AMAZING! Enjoyed by ALL! I highly recommend Amighetti's for TEAM lunches! We will be back! Thank you :) read more

Just get the special. Look for the pepper. It's the special for a reason! The signature dressing is the best. Love that they have gluten free bread. With the location on the hill would get it! They consistently ask if I have a gluten allergy, even when ordering over the phone, so I would feel comfortable eating there if I needed to for celiac. read more

Love the food but the service is horrible. They are not respectful of the timeline they give. Always slow. And unapologetic. Willing to be patient if it's a show that they care. read more

service stinks and if you complain you get attitude directly from the owner. waited 45 minutes for two cold sandwiches and a pickle. asked for my money back, this is when suddenly my food was ready. the owner did not want to deal with me, his only response was a smug "have you ever worked in a restaurant?". never again. read more

I cannot recommend this place enough. I normally get a sub to go and it's always fresh and yummy. Today I went crazy and ordered the Tortellini Alfredo w Peas. OMG soooooo GOOD!!! I definitely recommend this item. read more

We walked in a few minutes before 8pm on a Tuesday night. Not knowing that they close at 8pm. We placed our order to dine in. They didn't say anything about closing soon. We sat down to wait for our food and noticed that every one else was leaving. We went and asked when they closed and they said 8pm. We told them that we could take our food to go so we didn't hold them up from going home. They insisted that we stay and enjoy our meals that they had to stay and clean up anyway. They went above and beyond for us and made us feel welcome even though they were closed. Not many places would do this for two people. We thank you and appreciate your time. As always the food was amazing. read more

You can do better if you want Italian food. There's too much onion in the marinara on the chicken Parmesan sandwich. There needs to be more marinara. Maybe they've lost their way? I hope they come back and focus on the original recipe. Really not much difference between this and a chicken Parmesan sandwich from BK read more

This quaint sandwich shop was so much more than I ever expected. It seems like the whole family was working the place. Bread was great. I got the meatball, my wife got the turkey special. We split a chocolate chip canoli. All was great. The service was phenomenal. The owner greeted us, explained the menu, his favorites, customer favorites and the history of the place. Food came out promptly and he even visited us to make sure everything was perfect. In short, go here, get a sub and be happy. read more