Not extremely happy but not mad either. We ordered the pizza and salad combo, chicken wings, and garlic knots. First, we did not get our salad. We called, they were kind enough to offer to pick the salad up, credit us, or refund us. We just decided to take the credit, we will be back or order again! The garlic knots- GARLICY. Good enough if you love oil and garlic- I do so no problem, my guests not so much. The pizza was good, a thin crust pizza with thinly sliced pepperoni. I wish it had more pepperoni but for the four of us- the large size was good enough. The wings- if you get their wings prepare yourself for crunchiness and onion overload. Again- for me, loved it. My guests, not so much. I've always loved Anthony's and just happy they handled us missing our salad appropriately ! read more

So food is always great. However, if you order take out. Prepare to always be disappointed and waiting longer. 5 visits in last 2 months and they forgot half my order and had to wait an additional 20 minutes while my already prepared food was getting cold. read more

love anthonys pizza and wings. a must have for us every Friday night. The staff always makes is feel welcome.

The food is good but do not go here with a group. We went in on a slow day with a group and they brought the pizzas/meals out one by one over the course of about 45 minutes. It was very disappointing and embarrassing as I had guests from out of town with small children. The restaurant was only about half full so I'm guessing they were just short handed. Italian tunafish salad sandwich and wings are excellent as are the eggplant and other pizzas. read more

Love this place! Perfect spot to watch a game. Always consistently good affordable food. The wait staff is always friendly and bartender makes a great cosmo! read more

Great pizzas! Their wings and ribs are really good too! They are marinated the same way. Tangy and savory, not breaded. Every time we go is packed!. They also have a nice bar, tvs everywhere and different days of the week with specials on drinks. No complaints on the service. Overall a nice to place to hang out and eat! read more

See all

The food here is bomb! they really put it on the plate. The staff is awesome and the manager is stunning. slay! I was next door and my girlfriend suggested I come in for a few bites. The food is of high quality ingredients and they don't cheap out due to this inflation crisis. Great place for dinner after a long day with the family or mistress. read more

Officially my last time here. $100 for wings and pizza. 30 mins past time to pick up a take out order. Not even an apology. Just standing in a tiny wait area with a few others who are as upset as I am. Done. read more

Always been kind of curious about the hype behind Anthony's - I love pizza!! And whenever I get a pie, I ask for it well done. A pizza box from Anthony's literally says "Pizza well done", so I figured it'd be pretty bomb. Unfortunately, I wasn't that impressed. Although certainly not BAD, I think I'll stick to my regular pizzeria's from now on. For those of you that like thin crust, well done pizza, I think you'll enjoy this for sure. I think my main issue was that it was just a little too thin for me? Border line just crunchy pizza. I wouldn't NOT go to Anthony's again if somebody really wanted to, but it wouldn't be my first pick if that make sense. Oh, and the wings were not good at all imo. *Pictured: Philly Cheese Steak & Traditional read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

We have been long time fans of Anthony's. The food is consistently good and of high quality. Last night we ordered and everything was exceptional! Pizza was cooked perfectly and everything was really fresh. An additional bonus was an 'elf' joke which we all thought was hysterical and just added a little levity to the day - so thanks to the creative Anthony's staff member! Some times it's the little things.... read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

This pizza was so good the cheese the sauce everything. This is my second time there and I was not disappointed at all. I will be going back very soon. If this place is near you try it out. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - This is half caprese Pizza and the other piece is meatball with ricotta cheese. Oh so good!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

The pizza here is SO good. Cannot rave more about the quality and taste of the food. The service is also always very friendly and accommodating. Last time i was there i got the white sangria and it was VERY yummy. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - red and white sangria. $10 per glass - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

we normally love Anthony's. Tonight we ordered the Caesar Salad and it was awful. Brown lettuce, 4 tiny croutons...just not what a salad should be for $13.99. We told the wait staff and they could clearly see we barely ate any of it, but they did not remove it from our bill. Bad form!! read more

We had a great time our bartender & waitress NINA SANTIAGO was so sweet n helped us have the best drinks and food!! Yummy for the cosmo n chicken wings‼ read more

Good place for happy hour. Nice comfortable bar and good food. Staff is on the young side and make mistakes but they are so young it's mor funny than annoying. Seems like the management takes the time to train; their employees. read more

Pizza was very good, crust wasn't to thick, very tasty. Better than some of the regular pizzerias I've been to.

Anthony's coal fire pizza is a good place to go if you're trying to figure out where to go for a last minute dinner. It's quick, easy, and tastes good. They're pizza is good, it's not the best pizza out there but it'll definitely satisfy you. However if you really want to get something good you should order their eggplant parm and their wings. They have the BEST wings, they don't have hot sauce and they aren't made with hot sauce (people will bring their own and they don't mind haha) but they are so flavorful, they are juicy and crispy and tender. The meat falls right off the bone and they're served with caramelized onions, the perfect topping. I could eat a whole order to myself but unfortunately I'm always stuck sharing. Their eggplant parm is also a huge hit, my parents order both the wings and the parm almost every weekend, and they don't order out much, so that means a lot. The eggplant is sliced incredible thin, it almost looks like the crepe cake from Mille-Fueille. They are stacked perfectly and layered with tomato sauce, mozzarella and basil, it is ON POINT! So if you do go, and maybe aren't in the mood for a pizza those two dishes are the best way to go! The most recent time I went with a big group of family and friends about 18 of us, and they were very accommodating. Their salad was very good and the give you different dressing options, and cheese options. And their pumpkin beer with a cinnamon sugar rim is delicious. read more

See all

well today I had ordered a lunch salad from anthony's. it looked wonderful on their website and when I called them to ask the what exactly was in it- it sounded delicious. I am disappointed because it's really just basically lettuce. just spent 12$ on lettuce and 2 slivers of tomato. this place has good pizza and some other additional items off their menu. But really? the salad was a waste. Threw it out. I will return for everything else but a salad. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

I love this place! Their pizza is so good from the sauce to the dough. Staff is very nice as well. We come WAY too much these days. Probably twice a week (summer is close by I gotta chill lol) but it's just a nice chill place and the pizzas amazing! There was this one time our pizza's came out like a cracker. It was so small and thin and we were so disappointed but my husband everybody has off days it was the first time and when we went back the following week it was back to amazing I just hope that never happens again because it was so thin and crispy that I didn't enjoy it that much but they redeemed themselves last night it was on point perfect! read more

Staff was rude, mocking patrons, and completely disrespectful. Second time my pizza was ice cold.

The wings are not your ordinary wings, they are coal fired to perfection with grilled onions. Pizza done well, almost as good as Patsy's in Spanish Harlem. Don't want to sit at a table the bar is great also and the drinks are really good , so get there for happy hour. Plenty of parking and outside tables, with friendly wait staff (Johnathan A). I know they are a chain but they do it right. Caio for now. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

Love this place when we are in the mood for the white pizza with prosciutto and arugula. It's made to perfection and the arugula is dessert lightly to make every bite flavorful. They always have beer, wine and cocktail specials, so check with the bartender. The place is usually packed so prepare to wait a little bit. They have a simple menu and most of the items are delicious. They also have a great salad. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

To me the mark of a good Italian food establishment is its marinara (red sauce). The marinara here is excellent!! I had the hand-rolled meatballs in Marinara with ricotta and basil. It was wonderful! The weather was great so we asked to dine al fresco and were ushered to a table outside close enough to still feel just a bit of the restaurant's A/C. Any closer might have been too cold. Might want to bring a jacket just in case. Service was also excellent. Our waiter, Ralph, was knowledgeable and accommodating and has been there for years. On his recommendation I ordered the house Chianti which paired very nicely with the food. He also saw to it that we got slightly more than their average pour in our glasses. While I cannot argue with the business model, I must say that one drawback is the limited menu. (They have a chicken sandwich but no chicken parm. Hmm...) Still, if you're going to have limited offerings, make sure you execute well and that they did... right down to the cheesecake and cappuccino, which you have to have!! Great meal, great atmosphere, excellent service and a decent price. Like Arnold said, we'll be back. read more

We been to this location many times always great service especially Nick the bartender. He's got a great personality and treats customers with great respect. He's a true professional. The pizza is awesome along with the meatballs and chicken. You will never be disappointed at Commack Anthony"s. Eggplant MarinoMeatball read more

For a highly hyped up place (got recommendations from locals to try it) I was slightly underwhelmed by their New York "well done" pizza. The pizza was served slightly burnt on the bottom and overall the flavor was just boring. Nothing really made it stand out to deem its name as true NY pizza. Which is sad since it's a pizzeria. However, it is definitely a step up from the typical $1 slices you find every other block. We ordered the lunch size pizza (4 small slices for $8-great option for those who can't finish a whole pie) and the broccoli rabe and sausage. I definitely enjoyed the broccoli rabe and sausage; the sausage was seasoned perfectly: not too salty but very flavorful. The foccacia that came with the dish complemented the broccoli pretty well. If anything, the individual dishes on the bottom right corner of the menu are the way to go, you won't be disappointed! Our waitress was very helpful and friendly, but only when she was around. It was irksome how there were 4+ waitstaff around, but none responded when you try to wave them down. However, Anthony's is not bad; it's just not great. The ambience is perfect for taking a date or for a nice family dinner. I can see myself coming here in the future...if I ever find myself in Commack again lol. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Broccoli rabe and sausage (delicious!) and lunch size pizza with sausage, mushroom, and pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

Best pizza on Long Island. It's a memorable slice. There are so many mediocre pizzerias on the Island. These places seem more interested in spending their money on the rustic decor vibe. They should be spending their money on fresh, quality ingredients. These places, you see basil on the pizza. However, you don't taste it. Not at Anthony's. Their pizza is better than most places in Manhattan. (IMHO DiFara's has the best pizza in NY.) Anthony's also makes an excellent salad. Place is always busy, even during lunch. Friendly staff. These people from FLA know what they are doing. read more

Great service and great pizza! Can't go wrong here! They also have beer and wine specials! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - White pizza with prosciutto and baby arugula!! - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Ordered a 16" Margarita Pizza and no basil when it's delivered. WTH?? Never again. This is the second time this happened. Ugh read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - No basil leaves!! - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Come here every week at least once or twice with my daughter and friends for many occasions. Sometimes for a quick drink and app, sometimes for a meal, takeout is quick and reliable and always fresh. Amazing happy hour deals, Great music and overall vibe, and exceptional service. Alex the bartender is THE BEST!!!! read more

Amazing food, great time, Alex the bartender was absolutely the best. Friendly, professional, funny, on point with everything. Will def come back. read more

Excellent place for a low key lunch or dinner. Pleasant staff especially the bartender Alex who always remembers returning customers. Wings are great and I love the margarita pie with sausage and broccoli rabe. read more

The original wings and salad was delicious! Service was great.! Alex the bartender was friendly and informative.

Great neighborhood place! Service is friendly. Atmosphere is somewhat of a sports bar with a nice large bar and plenty of tables. They also have outdoor tables, but too close to the parked cars. Just make sure you like your pizza well done, because that's what they're noted for. Also, the chicken wings are excellent. The meatballs are great, and I'm very picky about eating meatballs out. But my absolute favorite is the eggplant. Then they have this delicious tuna sandwich that is different from any I've had anywhere. Anthony's is a great go-to neighborhood place! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - The Margherita pie - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

Not as good as previous times. Stopped in this afternoon for lunch and service was extremely slow despite it not being all that busy I had cappuccino and a chicken panini, both were good. My friend ordered a pizza that came out 10 Minutes after my panini and her pizza was burnt. It took overall 10 minutes to get a cappuccino and setlzer after we first sat down. read more

Look forward to our Wednesday nights!!! Nick the bar tender is great. Food is delicious and nice crowd! Very comfortable and friendly!!!!!

Usually a reliably good place for a pizza, we ordered a plain pie with 10 chicken wings yesterday and the food was dismal. Pizzas from Anthony's are generally well done, which we like, but when I got it home for dinner and opened the box the damned thing was burnt to hell. The chicken wings were well done but edible. This is the third time this year quality at this store was completely missing. Now everyone has a bad day, but if I order from this Anthony's in Commack again with the same results then they're dead to me. It's hard enough to get a consistently good pizza on Long Island and with Anthony's out of the picture I'm gonnas start making them at home again. read more

This place has the best pizza in town. It's got the perfect crust, everything has the perfect amount of sauce, and the toppings are always perfection. My favorite is the regular cauliflower pie, it's huge and all of that roasted garlic and cauliflower just melts in your mouth with that cheese. I didn't even notice that it's their only pizza with no sauce and that it's more like a flatbread because it's that good! Eggplant Marino is my second pick here, the sauce and the eggplant are so good on that crunchy coal fire crust. My favorite thing to do is go during the happy hour special on Wednesday's. Drinks are all discounted and there are samples of appetizers circulating around the bar area to try out. Get a drink, and personal pie to split, and wait around for some appetizers and you're set. read more

They say it's "well done" because it's burnt.... the chicken wings were burnt. The pizza was okay, a bit bland. I got half of the fresh tomato basil pie, and half of the eggplant. read more

We have been going to anothonys coal fired pizza in commack n.y. Since it opened. We don't go often because it's a little pricy for us, most of time I cook home, but when we want to treat ourselves... while over the weekend we did a take out order ..pizza and wings, wings always the best, the the pizza... I was so upset.. the dough wasn't cooked, the sauce was off flavor and the cheese wasn't even melted, looked like they cut it and placed it on top without putting it in oven.. I would not recommend to go to the commack location, I'm definitely not going back!! read more

Ordered 20 wings, 10 original and 10 dry rub. An hour and a half later they still weren't delivered. We called door dash and they said the order was not there. I called the restaurant and they confirmed that they never acknowledge the order. They finally delivered the order which was completely wrong and ice cold. There goes $50.00. read more