Last Wednesday I came in to Anthony's for lunch with my friend Carly. I am aware of the bad rep this place has, but everyone here is so nice and the food is great. The hot honey wings are so good and are always hot. The ambiance was great too, such a healthy atmosphere! When I walked in, this super nice young lady named Riley brought me to a table. She was super nice and made me feel welcomed at Anthony's. All workers should be as nice as Riley. She definitely deserves a raise !!!! read more

I was in the area and decided I wanted pizza. First time here and I was surprised at how good everything was. Everything was fresh and delicious . I had the Buffalo wings , garlic nots , the square mozzarella pizza and house salad . All shareable and great choices . All within resonance price. Would definitely recommend . read more

Went there for dinner tonight but was ignored by the waiter for about 25 minutes. I watched him walk around the room helping others, he never even stopped by our table to say anything so we left. The bar tender was actually nice though. read more

Environment was clean! Food was hot, fresh, and came out in a timely manner. The server was super attentive and extremely friendly. I enjoyed the experience + food and plan to go back before I leave NJ. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - flavorful wings. I enjoyed the rub - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

See all

Are these new owners or something? Pizza was so greasy and the wings were so bland it doesn't even taste like it used too. Must be new owners nothing else could explain both items being this off. Maybe I'll try again in Year or two if they're still open. I mean $42 for one order of wings and one pizza with pepperoni is ridiculous already but for it not even be good enough to finish, that's a shame.... read more

The service here is absolutely terrible!!! It was half empty, the waitress put our appetizers in at the same time as our pizza! Never came back to ask if needed anything, fill our water glasses, clean off the appetizer dishes. Wait staff just hanging around near the back of the bar. They need a manager there to make sure their staff is working!!! Ridiculous!! read more

Overall, I like Anthony's! I recently went for the second time in a few years so I'm definitely not a regular, but I have enjoyed my food both times. My most recent time, my parents and I came on a Sunday afternoon and were confused about the seating situation. We waited for a few minutes before we decided to seat ourselves, even though the place was nearly empty. It took a little while for someone to bring menus, but once our waitress did, everything went smoothly after that. We ordered 10 wings and a large pizza, half cheese and half with peppers and onions. The wings were just as I remembered them, hot, crispy, and peppery. So good! I'm not a big onion fan but I threw some of the caramelized onions in each bite and the sweet and savory combination was great! The bread that came out with the wings was also really good - if I come back, I would ask for some sauce to dip it in. The pizza came out shortly after. Their pizza isn't the best I have had - the sauce is a little sweet for my liking, but other than that it is enjoyable, especially with the thin crust. Overall, the food at Anthony's is good, but it's a little overpriced. There was also a strong gas smell that creeped through the restaurant halfway through, but I'm assuming this isn't a normal occurrence. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Chicken wings with lots of onions and bread! - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

See all

When I try a new place I always order something easy, like pizza and wings. I tried the pizza which was quite good and the service was good but the place needs a refresh. read more

Very disappointed not my favorite place at all. I go to Urban Coal house (my favorite) often so I expected Anthony's to have same similar taste and I was very upset with the pies and the tastes. We ordered wings and they were O.K not much flavor and a little dry.. I was very upset when I was told that they don't carry sauces for the wings.. I really was surprised because that would've made the wings taste much better. We then ordered cauliflower pie and I was extremely upset. Pie was burnt and the pizza was extremely dry. The cauliflower was very thick to the point that alll you tasted was that and the oil they use to make it. We also ordered a meatball pie and that was pretty good, little meatballs all over and overall taste was good. As you can tell good wasn't the greatest but our server was very sweet and attentive so it made the experience o.k I probably wouldn't go back because the pies didn't do it for me. read more

See all

Anthony, what are you doing charging $20 for this pizza?? This tastes like store bought sauce and lunchables pepperoni. Terrible. For shame Anthony!! With Brooklyn Boys right down the road too... read more

Fabulous food and great service. The ambiance is lovely and we were so happy to find this spot. The food is so fresh and cooked perfectly. The menu is not very extensive, but there are a few fancy pizzas and lots of toppings. The pizza is exactly what you expect, GREAT light/fluffy handmade well done crust with artisans toppings. The ambiance, the food, and the prices make this a favorite spot for a fun and relaxed evening! Absolutely coming back! Staff was super friendly and place is clean everytime we've been there. In addition to the amazing pizza, the salads are a fantastic light way to begin, plus they've lot of local beers on tap!! read more

See all

LOVE LOVE LOVE THIS PLACE! you never have to wait the service is amazing I always request alissa she's a great server and bartender! My go to meals are the meatballs and salad but you can't go wrong with the pizza everything is always on point! Highly recommend read more

Food is good. Decent atmosphere. Genesis the server gets 5stars! She seemed to be the only server on this past Saturday afternoon. It started to get busy. She stayed calm and professional the whole time. She was pretty much the server, food runner and bus person until more people started to come in around 5:00. Everything came out perfectly! read more

This place was very small as it was part of a mini strip mall across from Menlo Park Mall. There were lots of pictures of different celebrities that I really enjoyed. The atmosphere was nice. The service was very good. Our waitress was very attentive while the food came out in a timely matter. The large Philly Cheesesteak pizza was ordered ($21?). I saw a sign on the wall that said the crust was cooked well done no matter what. I was unsure how I would feel about this, but the crust was my favorite component of the pizza. I prefer crust to be less crispy, but I enjoyed the well done crust here. The rest of the pizza was decent at best. I did not think the caramelized onions went well with the beef. They were just too sweet. The beef was okay. I thought it was a little too hard. Will I go back? Ah.... read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Philly Cheesesteak Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

I usually do love this location rather then the one in Marlboro do to the pizza been cooked well and the dough isn't that chewy. Tonight I understand I ordered the wrong pizza due to not seeing the option of a margarita pizza on door dash and only seeing a tomatoe and basil and mozz pizza only with no sauce. I offered to bring back the pizza to get the one I wanted since I really paid $20 for a small pie. I'm in the industry of hospitality but the lack of costumer service and trying to find the "yes" for the customer was disgusting especially coming from the manager. The greeter in the phone was super professional and super welcoming and caring and wished she can helped but she stated she couldn't do anything. I'm just utterly disgusted with the lack of professionalism I recieved from the manager. And I early wish I was helped instead of telling me I should've looked better and it's my fault. read more

The service was beyond terrible at the Edison location. Everything took forever, didn't clean plates away until we asked. They brought out replacement food for stuff they were out of without informing us. Told the guest of honor sorry we're out of candles. Cappachino machine not working. And the absolute worst offense of all was the manager refused to come over after we asked to speak with him. We were loyal customers for years but after the manager ignored us, we will never go there again. read more

Blech. I thought I found a place for thin crust pizza. Nope. The first time it was ok-- the second time it was black all around the edge, and also on the bottom. They offered to make me another one, but it was the same. Told me that's the way it always comes out. I didn't look on the bottom last time, but I didn't taste any burn. I believe those black burnt parts are carcinogenic, so I didn't want to eat it. He gave me two meatballs instead. It was not exactly a meal. I wasted a bunch of time: calling to complain; trying to pick off the burnt toppings, only to discover that the bottom was also burnt; having to make another trip to pick up a replacement, only to get the exact same thing again. All around a strikeout. read more

Great pizza spot. Every time I have been there, the bar has always been packed. They must have a awesome happy hour or something. I had the roasted cauliflower pizza which is delicious and the wings. I'm not really a fan of the wings but it's one of those you love it or hate it. I'm a big fan of the meatballs too which is like the #1 thing on the menu. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

See all

Lunch time on a Friday and they have one wait staff doing seating, serving and bartending all alone. Service was too slow so had to walk out after waiting 10 mins with no drinks or order taken as large parties continued to arrive. Management needs to do a better job staffing. read more

Cool spot to hangout with friends and family! We had pizza and wings. It was good. But ... it'll be even better if they have choices of sauce for the wings. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Outside seating with margarita pizza and wings - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

Very good pizza ! The margarita highly recommended, meatballs are amazing as well as the chicken wings Definitely would got back this place does not disappoint!!! read more

Came on Monday afternoon 12:00pm. The place only had 3 other customers. Came with a friend we were immediately seated . The feel of the place was very welcoming . theres as a full service bar on the right hand side when you walk in and the kitchen all the way in the back. Its as a pretty large restaurant. It didn't start getting packed until about 2:30 pm. Ordered a Aperol Spritz which had Aperol, prosecco, soda water and an orange wedge. This was a very light drink and perfect for lunch. For our lunch I ordered a Lunch size pizza with Kalamata olives and long hot finger peppers. The pizza was just the right size for one person. The pizza was very well done and crispy. The hot finger peppers I have to say I was expecting something more spicy however I can't complain it was a very well done pizza and tasted great. My only complaint is that each additional topping was an extra $0.79. The pizza itself was $8.99 without the topping. My friend got the same lunch size pizza with Kalamata olives and mushrooms. The pizza was delicious and the drinks were very light and just the right amount of kick for an afternoon pick me up drink. This is my first time here and I have to say I was glad I decided to come here after reading a few yelp reviews. I will be back again.Great place- can't believe in all my years of passing this place I didn't come before . Paid $43.43 for two drinks and two personal pizzas- not bad! read more

See all

I love love this place. The pizza, wings and the salad are all consistently delicious. I've never had a problem with the food and find this to be a reliable go-to pizza place. Infact, after eating the coal fired oven pizza, it is difficult to go to normal pizza :(. The craft beer selection is also always amazing. One star off for the cost - 25$ for a large pizza pie sounds like a lot even though you can feed three with it. read more

We have recently enjoyed service here. However, we ordered a white pizza half with anchovy's. The pizza was soggy and had no flavor (they are known for well done crisp pizza). The half anchovy had exactly 1 small anchovy on each slice .... when asked they said this was normal. For 3$ added charge per topping this seemed unreasonable. Considering a can of 30+anchovy's is 1$. Overall a bad experience and would not return. read more

Meatballs were delicious. Smooth but retaining a good firm texture with a delicious red sauce that you want to pour over everything. They seriously outshone the pizza. The Paul and Young Ron had a lot of toppings and though the crust held up for a bit, it's definitely a fork and knife slice - that's the true Italian style anyway. Need more sauce for sure - I wished we had saved the meatball dish!. The plain pie on the other hand...I feel bad that I didn't realize it as it was put on the table, but it was not at all what I was expecting. Mostly cheesy, a few haphazard plops of sauce, and not a basil leaf in sight. What was this lame attempt at a pizza? read more

I'm always on the hunt for great pizza. I'd seen Anthony's for years while visiting Menlo Mall (across the street). I decided to try this place one night to satisfy my pizza craving. No disappointment in the flavor! Looking at the price range I figured there must be something to it. Anthony's is priced a bit higher than your local pizzerias. (Not talking about fake chain pizza here). Their combinations are different than "regular" neighborhood pizza joints and they are not skimpy with the toppings. In this post, the pepperoni is triple layered and mingled with large tender slices of sweet red and green peppers. (My favorite!) I ordered a 12 inch "Build your Own", added pepperoni, peppers and onion. It's thin, laden with toppings and oozing with flavor in every bite. Anthony's is a treat and definitely a go to place for me. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - The unboxing! - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

See all

Me and my husband had dinner here a few nights ago. Our server Samantha was so sweet and attentive. I had the Strawberry Basil margarita which was amazing! We also had The Original Wings which were so good and for dinner we had the Margarita Pizza. We will definitely be back! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Margharita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

The pizza at Anthony's is absolutely fantastic! I am thisclose to giving them 5 stars, but I have to try a few other things on the menu first. I really don't understand why I don't eat pizza here more often. It probably has something to do with my hatred for being anywhere near the Menlo Park Mall. As you will see posted on every wall, Anthony's only makes their pizzas "well done," which is the only way I order pizza when I'm out. If the crust isn't charred and crispy, and cheese isn't brown and bubbly, and the pepperoni isn't curled and crunchy, well, then you're already a second-tier pizza joint in my opinion. The coal fire oven is no joke. You just peer inside and see the glowing coal embers and know how scorching hot it is inside there. This is key to cooking up some of the best pizza in the world. The thin, but not-so-thin-I-think-I'm-eating-a-cracker, crust is just perfect. The edges get a perfect black char every time, and it's the kind of char you can eat because the crust is soaked with a heavy dose of olive oil that keeps it moist and flavorful beneath it's burny edges. It's just so good. I love it. Pretty much everything about the pizza is in line with how I like my pizza. The sauce is a little sweet, but not Sciortino's sweet. The cheese is layered on in perfect proportions to the other ingredients. Perhaps the only thing that makes me slightly disappointed is the pepperoni. They use the typical thin-sliced pepperoni here, like the kind you find in the supermarket. I would much prefer thick slices sheared off a long, fresh link, like they do at Di Fara in Brooklyn or Star Tavern in Orange. With a coal oven this hot, those thick discs would be so perfect on top of this pizza. Extra points for having a full bar and a great collection of Hollywood and Rat Pack memorabilia. Service at this location is also excellent. All in all, it's a great value for your money. Get ready to see a lot more of me and my family, Anthony. Because we're coming back very soon! read more

Had a horrible experience as we had specifically mentioned we dont eat beef or pork they messed up with the order adding pork in there which we had half eaten already but coal oven pizza was good. Every Time we had to call our waitress as she was busy eating behind bar counter even we were there to Dine in no attention on us we had to call her twice to get our attention later we got new dish without pork but in the end there is no apologies by anyone not by our waitress not even by their manager who was busy arranging chairs even she knew abt it and above all they charged us for both dishes with pork n without pork i had to go and get it taken off my check ridiculous never coming back again. A Big NO to this place read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

Placed an online order for a certain time and when I got there the order was ready. The staff was very professional inside and we were in and out with the food , no waiting. Got home and everything was perfect. The food was very good . Would go back there without a doubt l. read more

Yum! Anthony's is a good place, and underrated in my opinion. It is not overly advertised, and is right across Menlo Park mall. They have great coal fired pizza. For the people who complain that the pizza is burnt.. its supposed to be a little charred! Hence, the name Coal Fired Pizza Many different varieties of pizza. I cant say how their other food tastes, but I am a fan of their pizza since its the only thing I eat when I am there. They have a great happy hour too. I forget what day of the week the martini special is, but they have a Martinin happy hour special on a certain weekday. Great for a girls night out. Has potential to be a good sports viewing bar, will have to give it a try this football season. Definitely recommend read more

Coal Fired Pizza! It sounds great because it is great! This one isnt hard to find. Its right across from Menlo Park Mall, its inside the complex where Target is. Its actually right in front of Target. Now that you know where its located, its time for you to go in there and check it out. They have a nice bar with flat screens all over the moment you go in. On your left is where all the seating takes place and all the eating happens too. Im going straight to the point here and not waste time: Appetizer: Coal Fired Chicken wings is the SH*%! The onions on top of it just makes this chicken wing one of my favorites! No sauces here baby! Just straight up cajun burnt flavors! Entree: Large Pie with pepperoni, garlic, and basil! The crispy burnt crust just adds to the whole experience. Atmosphere was always great. You can watch your favorite sports team play. Bathroom is clean and the Men's Bathroom have hot girls from the 60s hanging on the walls. Staff are very attentive and nice and they would even ask you if they can serve you the first slice of pie on your plate! What more can you ask for. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Pepperoni & garlic - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

They won't be seeing me again. How do you ruin salad? Yet, their Classic Italian Salad was just about the worst salad I ever had. Other than a lot of water logged lettuce, there was barely anything in it. I told out server how bad it was and asked for more dressing because the thing was tasteless. For that I was rewarded with a dirty look---she wanted to take the rest of our order and I wanted the dressing before we ordered. Sorry to upset your workflow. Anyway, the bottom of the salad bowl contained a puddle of water. I also complained to the hostess about the salad and at some point you'd think the manager would come over. If there was one, we never saw him or her. My companions told me the chicken wings were OK. I had the onions that the wings were in and enjoyed that thinking too bad they couldn't have put them in the salad. Our pizza selection was the Fresh Mozzarella, Sliced Tomato and Basil pie. Overall the pie was pretty bad. The crust and the cheese were good but the tomatoes had absolutely no taste that I could discern and there wasn't much basil on the pie. And at $20, way, way too expensive. Lewis was there for the 3rd time and said that he really enjoyed it the first time, it was just OK the 2nd time, and after this visit, he probably won't be going back again. I will gladly join him in not going back. read more

The best charcoal chicken wings! I ever had. This is our third time here and so far everything we ate was consistently good. Their thin crust charcoal pizza is delicious! They also have an arugula pizza that is very good! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Charcoal Chicken Wings! The best! - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

Hubby and I love pizza. This was really good and coal fired made it even better. The margarita pizza was good. Sweet sauce!

This place opened recently. I ordered coal oven roasted buffalo wings (served with caralmelized onions and focaccia bread) and eggplant pizza marino (named after frequent customer Dan Marino's favorite choice of ultra-thin slices of eggplant dusted with Parmesan cheese). The buffalo wings and eggplant pizza marino both taste good. Each was cooked through authentic coal-burning ovens. Each pizza is cooked for about 4 minutes. The service is excellent. Also, customers can choose arugla or anchovies, prosciutto or pepperoni as well as Anthony's specialties like White pizza (ricotta, mozzarella and Romano cheese), calzones, and Italian Soul Food. Anthony's serve a full-service bar. The setting is more sports and family-style restaurant with TV screens surrounding around and pictures of famous people's autographs. You can also go to the restaurant to order take-out. I'll come back again to try out their Italian Soul Food, Traditional Calzone, Salads and Coal Oven Sandwiches! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Coal Oven Buffalo Wings with caramelized onions and focaccia bread - Pizza Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

See all

I've driven past this place hundreds of times but never thought to stop in and try the food. I'm not necessarily a big pizza fan but charred crispy brick oven crust, fresh mozzarella and basil can change my view on pizza in an instant. I ordered the square margarita pizza and a traditional personal pizza for my picky child! First of all the fact that my kid is raving about this pizza is a big deal! The crust was perfect charred and crispy. Pizza and the sauce was tasty. Not necessarily the best sauce I've ever tasted but still up there in flavor. The ONLY issue I had was with the basil. Large leaves were resting on top the pie. I enjoy the flavor of fresh basil and I wished they would have chopped it and sprinkled it all over (next time I'll ask for this). Our server was excellent and answered all of our questions. Nice presentation of the dessert. I will definitely be back and it's unfortunate that I've never come here before today. read more

See all

Love love love this place. Good food. Good wings. Meatball pots to go. Great bar and friendly staff! My kids love the pizza. Always a good time dining in. read more

Let me tell you, my wife ADORES NJ pizza. Anthonys did not let us down. It is in the most unsuspecting location across from Menlo Park mall in along with the Target store. We were greeted very promptly but told the (I believe owner) we wanted to sit at the bar. You see, we have 3 levels of grading a restaurant: Friday night-low key, not dressy and relatively inexpensive. Saturday-this is all out, get dressed up, longer experience, no real limit on $$$ Sunday-just an all round bumming meal. Hang at the bar, watch football or some other sport and not have a care of where to be or what exactly we are eating. Anthonys is very nice inside but after dining and some of the nations best places I have become somewhat snobbish. Anthonys is none the less a chain. It was great thought, dont get me wrong. Nick (female) was our bartender and a firecracker. The girl is on the money. We ordered drinks, she let us sample the beer on tap and was very aware of everything in the restaurant going on. She really should be a manager in my opinion. For the food, we ordered the house salad being this was a Sunday lazy day and split that. I ordered a personal pie with prosciutto and my wife got a personal with sweet and hot peppers. All pies are cooked well done, just the way we like them....DEFINITELY going back! Highly recommend for a chain!!!!! and better than many private pizzerias read more

See all

I had stopped in randomly after passing it up for other mall options across the street... BOY WHAT WAS I WAITING FOR!!! I really liked the atmosphere here.. Service was great.. The food was better than I expected.. My food was really good. Here's the deal. I had a personal pizza that was very tasty!! crust was flavorful...(not a bland cracker)...The wings w/ caramelized onions were amazing!!! I saved some onions and put them on my pizza insane!!! Not sure why there were some negative reviews... (I think someone didn't get a job and was pissed)... I think this place is really good and certainly worth going to again... read more