Man. If you love greasey... and not just a little bit a grease... GREASEY fried heart attack food... this place is JUST for you! And me. I love their italian beefs with mozza! They put sooo much cheese on and their hot peppers are to die for. Their pizza is filling and cheesey! Burgers are... burger like. And their fries are hot and salty. Just do it. read more

Your quintessential he-in-the-wall pizza place that rolls its own crusts and the cooks them in a beautiful large vintage rotating pizza oven. The pizza is way more delicious than Connie's where I ate recently and the cheese for IRS are outstanding. The only drawback is styrofoam beverage ware. read more

See all

Wonderful atmosphere the owner took out samples of wheat pizza. They supported the CTA and SEIU giving out free pizza. read more

Benny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I've been sitting here trying to start this review like its my life's work. You know why, because I stand true to Benny's. Benny's is absolutely the best. Yes the crust is hard, and no there aint none seasonings. Neither of these things are problematic while eating a slice, and when you mix it with a 40 of your favorite Malt, you've got yourself a good night ahead of you. Also, if youre not drinking, they have squirt, which is like Carl's Jr. Anything that's like Carl's Jr. is good in my book. Benny's other menu items are also delicious. They make hot dogs. I would compare the hot dogs to buying something from a dollar store. Its cheaper, and there isn't as many doo-dads, but its good. And i'm pretty sure vienna beef, and fries are free, and they have Squirt. Deep fried mushrooms with a side of ranch is also a delectable menu option. The italian beef is up to par. You can put cheese on it for to be even better. The ambiance at Benny's is also quite mouthwatering. There are wonderful enlarged foodstuffs painted on the walls and an epic mural outside of the establishment portraying what I can only assume to be the Central American mountain range where the Aztecan gods lay the food for Benny's. The man in the mural then hand delivers this food, cutting out the middle man, and Benny's, quite like furniture liquidators, passes the savings along to you. read more

I'm no pizza aficionado. I like things that taste good. Their pizza tastes good. I'm also poor. They catered to my waning bank account. It's really that simple and beautiful. read more

Good stuff. They make Chicago tavern style pizza. Aka the other Chicago pizza. Thin crispy crust and square cut. Good cheese. The small feeds about 3. Reasonable prices. Overall very happy to discover this place for delivery. read more

We ordered delivery and got pizza with cheese sticks. The service was good and they arrived on time. The quality was pretty good for the price. I especially liked how much cheese they put. The only thing that threw us off was the pizza came in a bag, not a box.. Pretty weird! I could see the grease, which wasn't pleasing to the eyes. The pizza wasn't completely cut, so we had to improvise. And the crust was a bit thick and not crispy like we prefer. It was more chewy than anything. Still unsure if we'd order again.. read more

Benny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Sorry Benny's but, I have to put you and your cucarachas (roaches)on BLAST! So, the Boo and me went out for my lunch break and since I patronize everything PILSEN we decided to eat at Benny's. We ordered 2 slices, 2 drinks, and yup, you guessed it cheese fries! As we waited for our comida, my Boo was like we r leaving! I was like HUH? I quickly followed his gaze and BAMMM, a freakin cucaracha! The Boo asked for our dinero back and the young lady hesitated and said sorry no refunds but after pointing out the cucaracha; who by the way was staring me down, she quickly had a change of heart and stated "sorry guys it's the neighborhood." GTFOWTBS, don't blame the neighborhood, call the ORKIN MAN! My only regret was not telling the other couple about the creepy crawler! SHIT! Shame on me! read more

I got a slice of sausage, fries and garlic bread, nothing special but it wasn't bad, the bread was kinda hard

Nothing to rave about, but still good enough for those late nights out when you're in the Pilsen area craving something good, greasy and cheap!! read more

Benny's Pizza - late night pizza by the slice - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Pizza is alright. Nothing to rave about. What's exciting about this place is it's cheap, convienent and open late. Happy pizza eating! read more

What makes this place good are tactical considerations rather than the food itself. Consider: - They take credit cards - Open late - Liquor store nearby - Pizza by the slice - It's cheap! Yeah, the pizza is greasy, but sometimes that's okay. One other thing: the guy behind the counter is always super friendly. read more

Have to quote destiny's child for this one: "SO GOOD SO GOOD SO GOOD" I was in Chicago for a week and a half and had the Benny's three late nights. It was perfect. Great price, great sauce, crispy crust and cheese was perfectly melted. Whole house of people I stayed with loved the Benny's. Also the guys who work there are really polite. Rare for cheap pizza joints! Tip Benny nice! read more

I don't really leave reviews but I feel like I have to. I've been ordering from Benny's for as long as I can remember. I love their pizza. I don't know what happened. But lately they have been TERRIBLE. Customer service is terrible. I complained about a pizza I ordered that I ordered was taking too long, they said it is "about to leave". I said ok. 45 min passed so I called again and they said "it's leaving now." I asked for my money back and never got it back. Nor did I receive my pizza read more

Ordered a sausage,pep,and green pepper fam. Size with cheese fries. They laid on serious cheese on the pizza 10/10. Good crispy crust, what stood out was the quality and the price was just right. Hit this place up! The cheese fries were good too read more

The pizza here was inedible. It was gross, cold, old, and crusty. We came here around 7pm to get a slice of pizza and the minute we walk through the door, the lady taking orders tells us the wrong information on questions we had and then spent the whole time on her phone. We got our slices of pizza and it was disgusting. I love pizza but I never had 95% bread and like 5% cheese. Not to mention that you could tell they reheated it in a microwave because it was super rubbery and oily and crunchy at the same time. I don't understand how you can mess up pizza that much. A couple of times and that was it because we couldn't take any more of that. read more

Since Chubby's lost their lease, Benny's is our new pizza standby when I'm visiting the girl. It's about like Chubby's but not quite as good somehow. It's your typical run-it-through-the-dough-sheeter-till-it's-round-and-has-cracker-consistency kind of Chicago thin-crust. Nothing to die for, but good, cheap, quick, and near my girlfriend's place. I hesitate to give this kind of pizza four stars, but the people there haven't done anything wrong so why not? I recommend dining in or picking it up (if you live nearby). The closer you eat it to just-out-of-the-oven, the better. read more

It is delivery and it is Digorno. I really think they cooked a frozen pizza and delivered it to us. You really are paying for the delivery of the pizza, not the pizza. And this was my poor boyfriend's first glimpse at Chicago (we are from KC). Such a bummer. read more

This pizza does not even smell like anything, and it tastes like nothing with salt. They should get a prize for being able to make a pizza of such outstandingly poor quality! That must have taken them a lot of practice. Salad was washed: the water was still pouring from the vegetables. :( read more

Beyond amazing! The cheese compliments the bread and the sausage and the pepperoni and the jalapeños... I could honestly keep going with it but basically it's amazing! Every friend and family member I've taken there has loved it and keeps asking for more ! A must try pizza spot in Pilsen ! read more

I love bennys growing up in pilsen made love the neighborhood pizza and i still go here and there to get slice de queso

Any place that is open late into the night & accepts credit/debit cards is ultimately A-OK in my book... Their pizza is pretty damn tasty and a good value in today's economy, however I am particularly fond of their oven-roasted Italian beef sandwich... Adding red sauce and/or mozzarella to this sandwich will only result in a much-satisfied stomach... Great fries too! Reasonable prices, fast service and close to the crib... That's all this hungry man needs. read more

I would give it a 5 but they forgot my garlic bread one time in the delivery. This ain't a place to take your hot date to for a romantic meal. Nah. You go here for good mediocre pizza. I think people are too into finding the "best" of anything --- best place to eat this and that. Oddly enough, what attracted me to this place was their flat, non-deep-dish, lunch-only-type pizza. Their hole-in-the-wall appearance. Serving your top working class. I was looking for just... good pizza. Good pizza that didn't break the bank but tasted good enough to come back. And here it is. I get the 3 topping --- sausage, pep, and mushroom. I can't stop at two pieces. It's just effin good. To me. Crust is good. Toppings are good. I'll be coming back. read more

I usually order a sausage, pepperoni, & mushroom pizza and I've yet to be disappointed. If you ask for extra cheese, they bake it longer which makes the cheese extra tasty 'cause it's golden brown. What's nice (and convenient) is that they take your credit card over the phone so you don't have to worry about gathering up cash. Forget Pizza Nova, this is the best pizza in Pilsen. read more

PATHETIC EXCUSE FOR GARLIC BREAD - DO NOT ORDER!!! Pizza is just ok. I paid $3.30 plus tax for the sorriest, toughest, most lacking in flavor hard brick of dough that is what I received. Like a shrunken size of a Subway 3" bread roll that was sold 5 days past expiration. I will leave a link to the picture comparison here: imgur.com/VT3OpB9 read more

Benny's Pizza should be purchased one day in advance of when you plan to eat it. The pizza on the second day is top notch reheated however on the same day is less than ideal. Would suggest Whole Foods pizza as a better option than same day Benny's. Great local business but could use some work if they want to get into the same day pizza market. read more

Benny's has seen its better days... I grew up eating Benny's Pizza... and i have been away for awhile, i came back home expecting what I had always loved about Benny's and to my surprise it wasn't the same. I think they are cutting back costs and not using premium products... its a shame! I still visit Benny's as a last resort cause they are cheep and open late ad very fast! but I am no longer a dedicated regular. WHERE DID MY BENNY'S GO???? read more

This place is legit! The pizza is really great and hot, and everyone who works there is so friendly and cheerful! Our order was ready on time -on a Sunday at lunch. read more

Pizza was not good. The pizza was over cooked, bland, lacked an adequate amount of sauce and the dough was tough. They also put the toppings underneath the cheese which makes no sense. I would not order from here again. They should not have delivered a semi burnt pizza to my house. read more

Benny's Pizza - Over cooked pizza... - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Great prices, good pizza and they deliver to Bridgeport. If you haven't tried there chicken wings you should. Definitely a great for a night of football. read more

I tried Benny's based off of the recommendation of my friend who grew up in the Pilsen neighborhood. He said, "Benny's has the best pizza in Pilsen." I stand by his words. Benny's has since been my stop to fulfill my pizza cravings. *Pizza slices are $2.50 *Don't be fooled by the "small" in small pizza, it's big enough to feed three normal men. read more

I've been eating Benny's many many years and it's always a hot cheesy and a fluffy pizza dough. A Pilsen gem that is a must try! read more

Benny's Pizza - Pizza and cheese fries 6 bucks ! - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

This place is really nothing to write home about, but they take credit cards and they're open late. Pretty cheap too. The pizza is decent if you order a whole pie, but the slices alone are inferior. The burger isn't bad and the fries are nice and crispy. They always seem to change the style of fries they serve, which is weird. They should just stick to the crinkle-cut. read more

This is our local delivery pizza joint. Very consistent, and concerned about keeping customers happy It's that really good, thin but not too thin, cut in squares Chicago pizza with plenty of cheese and not too sweet of a sauce. In terms of their service, the other night we ordered a couple of pizzas and the person who took our order misunderstood us to mean that we wanted the ingredients for the two separate pizzas all on one. He quickly corrected the order when informed we were short one pizza, and gave us the second order for free, which was unnecessary but extremely customer focused. Benny's has earn our loyalty as our regular pizza spot. Great movie-night delivery pizza joint read more

Benny's is an awesome little neighborhood place. My number one choice for pizza in Pilsen for sure. Haven't tried much else on the menu, except the chicken patty which is also good. Really want to try the ribs sometime... It's super cheap and so delicious. The people there are very nice, especially when you're a regular, which I expect many of their customers are. Benny's has my loyalty and support! read more

I use to eat this pizza growing up, my tastebuds have changed this pizza was terrible from the separated cheese to the funny tasting sauce the crust was also very hard. Ordered at 5:13pm received at 5:55pm the pizza was warm??? I live 5 minutes driving time from there. So this pizza is what it is cheap and fast. Don't waste your money and to the person who said it's up there with Beggars Pizza is fucken delusional it is not! No where near the level or close to it. read more

When I'm broke I go to Benny's... I get a cheese slice & fries for less than $ 5 bucks... PERFECT FOR ME! :) P.S The people that work there are very friendly :) read more

A little pricy, but delicious pizza and great customer service! This place has quickly become a favorite for my husband and me

I tried Benny's Pizza for the first time and it was SO DAMN GOOD!!! It fulfill my Pizza cravings! For sure I'll be ordering more from Benny's Pizza!!! Thanks! read more

I had a taste for a slice of pizza so I decided to try Benny's. The girl at the counter was not very friendly. I order a slice of pepperoni and a slice of sauce. The pizza was way too greasy. Also, this place is dirty inside!! Please clean and be more FRIENDLY to your customers. Thanks. read more