food was very good If not great Unfortunately service was marginal at best and management was even worse. Cherry tomatoes are red not green and what we were served in our calamari appetizer were Green peppers(jalapeño) not cherry tomatoes. Management please dont attempt to educate me on what is cherry tomato and what isn't. I know the difference read more

Pizza has been one of my foodie addictions in life but who doesn't like pizza? Over the years I've eaten at hundreds of establishments from Ny city, Boston/ Connecticut, Miami and everywhere in between! From hole in the walls to nicer novelty places. I've lived in Fl for nearly 25 years now, 1/3rd in South Fl and the rest in Saint Johns county. I have worked my way through the pizza scene here. Bronx, particularly this location, has become my favorite here! My go to for a quick slice, a whole pie, or a casual sit down. Their pizza has the perfect crust! Their dinners are equally delicious! The locations are clean, staff are always friendly and welcoming! It's no secret why they are on their 11 or 12th? Location! I won't ever stop trying new places but they will be hard to beat! read more

See all

Ordered a Beast of Burden pizza for delivery. The wait was moderate- it arrived in 40 minutes. They have a wide variety of pizza variations to order from as well as some other notable Italian dishes. The crust was thin and chewy with lots of good flavor. They didn't skimp on the toppings. The price was very reasonable. Would recommend the pizza for sure! read more

Bronx House Pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

We visited this pizza place today and had an overall good experience. The garlic bread was okay -- nothing particularly special, but still enjoyable. The marinara sauce was a little too sweet for my personal taste, though it was still good overall. The chicken parm was just okay. The chicken itself was a bit bland, and most of the flavor came from the sauce rather than the meat. The pizza, however, was really good. You could tell the ingredients were high quality. The crust was crispy with no flop, but not so hard that it hurt your gums -- just the right balance. The service and ambience were both good and made for a pleasant dining experience. read more

See all

My photo does zero justice, I was so hungry I grabbed a slice and threw it on my plate! I ordered 16" Buffalo Chicken Pizza HALF Banana Peppers Bacon Ricotta It was amazing!!!!! I am so happy they opened one down the street from me, because the other two locations are a bit of a stretch. Pizza crust here was soft and airy just wonderful. Chicken was yummy tasted fresh and of quality. They were slammed I ordered online for pick up and waited a bit but nonetheless it was well worth it. Pizza was $25.99 I had 20% off for signing up so my tota came out to $22 and some change. It can't be beat because it was a Great Pizza!!! We'll be back. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Excellent service and great pizza. I called ahead, placed an order and everything was right on time.

We an awful experience we had at Bronx Pizza of St. Augustine. It very disappointing that our calzones were cold inside after a long wait of over 30 minutes. Additionally, the attitude of the server was very dismissive and didn't help our have added frustration, especially with her dismissive response about the freshness of the food. We had to wait 20 minutes to order. In addition to 30 minutes for the cold calzone to come out then. Having to wait over 40 minutes for the food to be remade is not ideal either, especially after already experiencing a long wait for the initial order. Overall, it seems like there were significant issues with both the quality of the food and the service provided during your visit.I would not recommend this business. The place is so loud. read more

See all

This pizza was so yummy! We got delivery and ordered online so not many comments on service. The food was cold when it came, but still tasted great. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Big Al and The Beast - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

I stopped by here for a quick lunch on a Saturday afternoon, I had a glass of wine with a small pizza to share and it really hit the spot for me. In the past I tried the chicken parm pizza at their other location near downtown St Augustine, that was really good as well, so when I saw another location in St Augustine I was excited to try it. To say the least, it did not disappoint. I am hoping that they can open a location in Orange park, or Jacksonville, as that is closer to where I live. I am thrilled to stop by a Bronx House location any opportunity I get. I definitely recommend this place. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

We went there not expecting such delicious pizza in St. Augustine. The antipasto was wonderful. They have a liquor license so it was nice to have a choice of cold beverages read more

Not great pizza was burnt. Mozzarella sticks were under cooked. The garlic bread was good. Cute location. Will try again maybe just an off night. Service was meh . read more

Ordered delivery from this location while staying at a local hotel in the area. We ordered a 16 inch Hawaiian pizza (pineapple, ham and bacon), meatballs, and buffalo wings with ranch. Note, this option does not show up on the on-line menu but will pop-up in the on-line ordering option. The on-line ordering option is pretty easy to navigate but they do charge an extra fee for using it and certain items on the menu don't show up (Hot 97 is on the menu but not in on-line ordering). Our delivery took close to an hour bc it was a Saturday night. Our driver arrived early and was very polite and we actually had pleasant conversation past the pizza. I took the food back to our room and everything was well prepared and looked amazing but my wings did not have the buffalo sauce we asked for but they did give us extra ranch. The pizza had a nice crust and the toppings married together well. The wings were good even they were not sauced. The meatballs (you get 4) were my favorite, they were dense and flavorful with a nice red sauce and ricotta covering them. Great local location but some hiccups made this review a 4 star review and not a 5 star review. read more

See all

Absolutely awesome pizza. I will definitely go here again, Nothing more needing to be said!

New York style pizza authenticity with a nice crispy crust and great tasting. I have had many and also worked in an establishment like this. I have tasted many across central Florida non-chain restaurants and this one is comparable to the original Italian style that I was raised with however, if you're looking for a family dine in, Bronx misses the mark on service, which is awful here. Your best option is to order it to go, I prefer all the toppings, minus the olives, which to me tastes bitter. I am Italian and believe that family, food and hospitality are what makes things more enjoyable. Good luck and enjoy. read more

Wife and I stopped in for a slice. They are working on the new Publix building and now have the parking lot messed up. But we found a space in front. Really good crust. We each got their meat lovers. Yeah you're going to love this place. Friendly staff. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Slice. - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Get the Detroit style. It's a perfect Sicilian style pizza. Reheats great next day if you can't finish it all.

This was by far the best combo pizzas salads carryout! I loved the sauce and I'm extremely picky when it comes to sauces! Just saying! It took everything I had not to delve into this food before the photo hahaaa but I did just 4U. Give em a call or stop on in! read more

See all

The food was delicious! We ordered ours at 7:48pm on a Monday and was given 20-40 minutes as the ready time, got there at 8:10, they said 20 more minutes, so we came back at 8:40, they said 15 more minutes, then said 5 more, and finally at 9:16pm it was ready! There was no explanation to why or a straight answer ever through the process of when the order would really be ready, it was very frustrating having young hungry children ready for dinner. The food was delicious when we got it- I wish the experience and service level matched the delicious food. I'm not sure that I would go again or order take out unless there was no rush and 2 hours was ok. The salad was delicious, the pizza was great, the dressing was amazing- it just took so long it was hard not being upset when we got it! read more

See all

Just finished dinner at the Saint Augustine, A1A restaurant My chicken Parmesan with spaghetti usually has a very generous portion tonight it was skimpy even the pasta with sauce was very light. The amount of chicken we got was ridiculously small. I will think twice twice about returning to that restaurant read more

Very good service and food. We ordered a parmigiana pizza, ordered wings, and spaghetti bolognese. So good! read more

See all

service was terrible, the girl was unhelpful and took over 10 mins to even get us our drink orders and another 5 to get them to us. After 45 mins we finally got our pizza and it was cold and hard. very disappointed and would not recommend to anyone. read more

BEST PIZZA ON ANASTASIA ISLAND!!!! every time I visit I have to make a stop to grab a slice! 10/10 food and the people working there are the most friendly. 10/10 recommend read more

Bronx House Pizza - Pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Still searching for that NE style Pizza? I have had good luck here ...IF... IF... you order the pizza with extra sauce, extra cheese, and crispy on the bottom. I enjoyed this much more than their standard pizza. read more

Everything we ate was absolutely delicious! We couldn't finish, and I literally made two more salads using the very generous toppings we had leftover! The smoky flavor is addictive on the chicken and everything else that comes out of that gorgeous pizza oven! We can't wait to come again! read more

We have been wanting to try their pizza and we ordered the small Beast of Burden. It comes with pepperoni and meatballs. We asked to just have meatballs. I really liked the addition of some whipped ricotta. Place was very pizza with full tables and a lot of carryout orders. The service was very good. I want to try some of their other menu items next time. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Beast of Burden Pie with no pepperoni - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Amazing pizza - you have to go there - I was soo full I wanted more - heheh Excellent service ! read more

We came here for dinner over the weekend because our kiddo had a hankering for garlic knots. When we arrived the parking lot was slammed (just beware you may have to park and walk). When we arrived there was about a 35-40 minute wait, which is to be expected on a busy night. We waited outside until our table was ready. My husband did get me a lemon drop at the bar. I will say, it's not one of my favorite places to get a lemon drop, it's not as balanced as it is as a competitor's location. At about the 30 minute mark we were called and our table was ready. Our server was attentive, both serving and handling the bar. My kiddo ordered a whole order of garlic knots for himself as his entree. My mom and I split the chicken milanese and my husband got the meatball/garlic knot sliders for his meal. Service was quick and the food came out piping hot. My kiddo ate EVERY garlic knot. My husband loved his garlic knot/meatball sliders. I loved the chicken milanese topped with the salad. Whatever dressing is used on this, it's great. read more

Nice place for pizza good calzone. The dough is really tasty and they have a nice oven and they cook the food right. The staff is very cool. It's in a Publix parking lot so I can't say a whole lot for the ambience. read more

Bronx House Pizza - They make it right in front of you! - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Unbelievably slow service for delivery... app said 60 minutes, received in 130 minutes... not once but twice within our week vacation. Chalked up first one to it being a weekend, but then happened again during week. Pizza was pretty good, thus the reason for the second order, but could never order again after timing/delivery issues. read more

Stopped here for some food to take out after a long conference. We got the pizza, the baked ziti, and the meatballs - all were really good! We hung out and had a glass of wine while our food was being prepared. Would definitely recommend this place if you're looking for some convenient carry out pizza and sides! read more

First time here and my family really enjoyed their pizza. My son and I had the cheese, and my wife and daughter had the Popeye. We also had their mozzarella sticks which was super cheesy. My wife said it has now dethroned her favorite pizza, which really says a lot since our favorite pizza place has been our favorite for over a decade. Service was very friendly and we look forward to another visit in the near future. =) read more

See all

There are several locations. We went to the one on Ponce de Leon. Great atmosphere. The antipasto salad with house dressing was the best I've ever had. Tried a Detroit deep dish pizza for the first time and was delicious. Light and crispy, different from Sicilian. Our server Jack was the best! read more

Bronx House Pizza - Nuts & Bolts pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Had the department of sanitation pizza.It has a little bit of everything on it. Was delicious! Had the department of sanitation pizza.It has a little bit of everything on it. Was delicious! read more

Bronx House Pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Bronx House Pizza is the real deal a no-BS tribute to New York-style pizza done right. The crust is perfectly crisp and chewy, the cheese melts like a dream, and the sauce has that fresh, homemade tang you can actually taste. Their specialty pies (shoutout to the Hot Honey Pepperoni) are creative without trying too hard just bold, balanced flavors in every bite. The vibe is welcoming with a touch of New York edge, and the staff make you feel like a regular even if it's your first time. If you're craving pizza with soul, Bronx House is where you'll find it. Come hungry. Leave obsessed. read more

Great food and service. Pretty pricey for a pizza but a nice date night out with a friend. Went again with my husband and had a similar experience. Not gonna be a regular unless they start doing slices like other spots. Enjoyable enough. read more

Pizza was good but if you want "no flop" ask for well done otherwise it's floppy Taste was good crust was good, topping were really light, my wife got half pineapple and there were Ike 4 tidbits per slice like they counted They were extremely busy. I was watching people picking up takeout orders of four, five and six pizzas. Great for them. The only thing they should do is better communicate the wait times not just to the people who are getting to your orders who are frustrated, but the people sitting there. It took us almost 45 minutes to get our pizza Service with her waiter I forget his name was very friendly, but you could also tell everyone was under pressure that night because of how busy they were But that's a good thing in this economy I'm happy to see a place that's busy and I don't mind a longer wait because they're busy that's beyond their control Just like I said, it needs to be better communicated read more

Wings were big and cooked perfectly. Pizza was very good NY style but didn't get a picture. Service was good and the restaurant was nice and clean. We would return if we come back to the area. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Buffalo wings, delicious! - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Great food and great service! Cool decor will definitely be back upon a return trip to st Augustine read more

Bronx House Pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

mediocre pizza, definitely not close to being NYC pizza, but great service small pizza plain caesar salad and calamari $47.00 expensive ! read more

Awesome pizza. The New York is awesome. The deep dish is massive!!! Good service, good music playing....u won't be disappointed.