Just got a nuts and bolts pizza. Very small, was not even warm, sauce was thrown on top after pizza was cooked. Very disappointed that you have to pay this much for a specialty pizza and get gipped!! read more

Great thin crust pizza. We've dined in and ordered take out and both were satisfactory. We recommend this restaurant!

Everything was delicious, great service . Very cool place , the garlic knots were great and the pizza was amazing

Good crust and yummy sauce for pizza!! Good variety but I am always looking for my favorites and this place was a score!

Bronx pizza is the best they have everything you can think of and all good. They just opened up a new location the food is fantastic. I love this place service. The pizza thin crust is the best. read more

Saw good reviews of this chain and tried the Anastasia island location on a Thursday night. Side salds with house and balsamic dressings were good. Went for the Haymaker Detroit style upon recommendation from our excellent server, Tanner. I was at first taken aback by the sweetness thinking that the tomato sauce was adulterated with sugar and then realized this was the bacon jam topping, ha! Pinot noir was nice as well as Peroni. Will defintely be back to sample more Detroit style pizza. Nice to have this chain in the area. read more

Love this place! Great service great owner great pizza great food. Everyone should come here for a good dinner experience.! read more

See all

Skylar was our waitress and very sweet and friendly and the pizza was some of the best we've found in Florida! The sauce had good flavor, plenty of toppings and offered my favorite type of pizza (deep dish). Restaurant was very clean and beyond a little bit of stale beer smell near the hallway to the restroom it was an all around pleasant experience. read more

Just ordered 2 pizzas ...have not tried them yet but beware of the 20% discount scam for registering and providing your email! When I picked up the pizza they said it only works if you on line order. When I tried to order online I was told to call and order because I was unable to order online! I had called them to make sure the coupon would work and they said we will try it. Did not work! Not a good impression so fra! Just had the pizza it was mediocre at best! would not order there again! read more

First time eating here and it has the best tasting pizza around. The service was fast and friendly . Prices were fair and the atmosphere was good too. We will be back ! read more

Great Pizza, Luv the St Augustine Location. We Love the Butcher Shop with all the Meat's read more

Was so looking forward to trying this place. We ordered 4 large pizzas all different toppings. The crust and sauce were good. The toppings were so scarce. That was very disappointing. Not sure if we will go back. Forgot to take pics unfortunately. read more

I walked in and placed an order for two pizzas large and small. I paid and was told approximately 20-25mins wait.... I pulled out an hour later... never going back, never recommending. I would get them a clock so they can tell time but it wouldn't matter. There were people that came in after I ordered and placed their order... I was the last person to get pizza as they cleared their computer screen of all orders. pizza was poor to fair quality and I learned a lesson. Worst food in Saint Augustine! signed, worst pizza I waited an hour for! read more

The pizza is seriously the real deal. It is in their ingredients. They use the best. Those ingredients are not cheap. Especially the cheese. I bake pizza at home and have done so for years and years. I know pizza. I have taken classes to bake pizza. What you will get besides layers of flavor in each bite, zero flop, is digestibility. The dough is prepared for 72 hours in a cold, slow rise. You can taste that. You do not feel like your stomach is full of raw gummy dough like the cheap pizza chains. Light, airy, great leopard crust on bottom. If you're in St Augustine this is your go to pizza joint. I am heading down to Orlando today. I see they have a location down off the 4 at Lake Mary. Guess where I am stopping for lunch? Thank you Bronx House Pizza. Thank you for quality over profit and corporate greed. Not many of you left! read more

NY pizza shop in the area. They are well worth a try. The pizzas were fresh and crust was thin and crispy. The service was good and waiter was attentive. It looked like a NY subway station. read more

See all

We've been a couple of times and it's great! The pizza is so fresh. The drinks are great! The service is great. The wait staff is attentive and funny! You can also watch them make the pizza which my son loves. Fun place! read more

Great pizza and a friendly crew! On our list of places to come back to when we visit st. Augustine!

Small pizza shop. Excellent pizza. Perfect pizza dough for a crust. Sells full pizzas or by the slice all day. Calzones, pasta, salads, Great for on the go, lunch sit-down, or take-away. Good service, friendly, courteous. Only down side - they sneak in a 3% service charge on your bill if you pay by credit card. Not readily apparent or discussed. It would be better just to add a few cents to every item's menu price. read more

server referring to me as "honey". Never asked if I wanted another glass of wine or dessert. I Asked if I could have some bread and butter with my spaghetti and meatballs, which were good. She said that we don't have that. Just garlic knots. I am thinking to myself that you make hoagies! Of course you have rolls. Take a roll. Cut it in half. Put some butter with it and charge me. I would had paid. You make a profit. I could return tomorrow night and no one would recognize me. I am of an age of invisibility now. However, I was in this service industry for 30 years. Such a shame how there is no effort made to accommodate the guests in their restaurants. Deplorable sometimes. Stupidly I still left an above 20% tip. I can't help myself. Stop with the "honeys." read more

Unfortunately we got zero service. Server did not check on us one time. Wouldn't recommend unless you want to keep getting up and asking for utensils, food or drinks Pizza maker was amazing though, very hard worker read more

Place was gross! Not happy at all. My ex family used to own the place and lost it due to bad economy at the time. The place doesn't look better it's small and overloaded read more

Bronx House Pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Newest location of theirs I believe. The one down in Flagler beach is a bigger size restaurant this is more like a small NY shop where you can get it by the slice. Food was great, store was clean, service was friendly and efficient. Glad to see St Augustine getting some more quality food places read more

See all

Tried Bronx House for the first time yesterday. It was delish, just as I had heard! We tried the fried ravioli, meat calzone, and a large pizza. All were best in class! Ingredients were super fresh, dough was delish, cooked to perfection. The staff was attentive and excited to be there! Clean and efficient location. We even received a complimentary cannoli, which I would absolutely order again! We will be frequent consumers, I can't wait to try the meatball hoagie and the chicken parm which looks amazing! I just know they are going to be hoppin all the time! read more

Finally true Bronx Pizza in Fla! Eat at the restaurant for the best experience! Friendly service, reasonable priced!

Came here on vacation and was pleasantly surprised. The pizza was fresh and crispy, classic NY style. Service was nice and fast. Ranch was delicious. 8/10 read more

Food was so good, everything was super fresh and they were super busy!! Very impressive! We had a salad, pizza, garlic bread & the meatball sliders 10/10 will be going back (Togo order) read more

I took the pizza to go and it was very. This service was quick and the pizza took a reasonable amount of time to be made in the servers were pleasant. read more

Amazing food and AMAZINNG service! The place was packed and we got food and drinks quickly, presentation was perfect and we will for SURE be back again. Our server Angela was what made the meal! Prompt and super personable, give this gurl a raise!! WOOHOOO BRONX PIZZA read more

Loved their pizza. Highly recommend this place. Great great pizza. Cheese cake was great also

As a native NYer, this pizza is spot on; will quickly outgrow this locations space. The pizza, staff and service is that good! Took 1 star away for my only suggestion would be possibly another 1-2 minutes of cook time for a crispier less floppy crust! Look forward to this becoming my go to Pizza place and hope more locations are to come! read more

Outstanding across the board! From quality of ingredients to the crust and overall flavor. Staff was kind and courteous and pizza was at a good price point for what you got. We would def go back. read more

If you enjoy long waits (not at the door, but in general after you order), migraines from screaming other customers, incorrect bills, missing parts of your order, and incorrect bills, but delicious food, this is the best restaurant in St. Augustine. The negatives outweigh the positives. We might consider ordering takeout in the future but we need some distance first! But hey, if you write a good review, you get a free mini cannoli. So that explains how we ended up here. I would take every good review with a grain of cannoli read more

I LOVE BRONX HOUSE PIZZA it is very very yummy I got a Cesar salad and the rest of my family got pizza and garlic knots 5 star review will be coming back everyday. Server was very friendly, food out quick, and tasted delicious. read more

Awesome little beach find. Dave Matthews playing in the background, plus 10 points! Very chill. Clean and neat. The pizza was very good. read more

Stopped in after a long Tuesday and loved this place. Staff was friendly and the New York style pizza was amazing! Perfect crust

Food was good and server was nice, but they did forget to make our pizza. 2 tables that came in after us were served first.

The young Bartender is terrible, worst I've ever come across. She doesn't need to tell customers how much she hates her job., most of us would be happy to be employed. It's only been open for two months and I've been there a few times and the food is amazing but ambience of the Bartender is terrible. Need to find somebody who can treat customers with a smile instead of complaining about her job. read more

Amazing - I grew up in NYC and had pizza at least weekly - mostly whole pizzas but sometimes slices. The pizza here at Bronx House is NY pizza. Many Floridian pizzerias make this claim and I've never had a Florida pizza that delivered in 25 years. The crust is amazing - just the right amount of char/crispiness - a slight flop which is a must - but your toppings are not going to fall off - you can taste the result of the 2+ day cold ferment creating a dough with great flavor. The cheese is wonderful and not over done - and the toppings were top of the line!! A bit of oil - but not too much. The pizza was done 10 minutes before they said it would be done - I got there a little early and they told me 7 more minutes and it was 2 more not 7. It was 8 pm on a Thursday and they were slammed with pizza coming out one after another - among other items on the menu. Kudos to the owners and the employees at the Anastasia location. This is not fine dining, this is fine pizza - and that is the correct priority at a pizzeria. read more

Ordered for pick up and everything was fantastic! The dough they use is amazingly good. The meatballs were so good I actually dreamed about them and got up in the morning and ate some. Prices are not out of line. Very good place. read more

See all

We happened upon this place after Hurricane Milton when there was very little open. Our server, Tom, was outstanding - very friendly & helpful. We enjoyed our food immensely and Tom was a pleasure. Highly recommend! read more