Some good food, some okay food, and some fairly off-putting service.
The food was mostly a win, but the overall experience was a little unusual.
The server explained that the menu is designed as a tapas/sharing experience (no problem), and then explained that most people either order 2-3 dishes per person or else order the $65/person six-course tasting menu. Very helpful guidance.
But after that, things got a little weird. We asked for some examples of what's on the tasting menu, in order to make an informed decision between that approach and the published menu. "I can't tell you that." But how do we decide between that vs. ordering a la carte if we have no information what we're choosing between? "I can't TELL you because that's part of the APPEAL of the tasting menu, that it's all a SURPRISE." But I do have some allergies and would feel a lot better NOT being surprised. "Of course we wouldn't give you something you're allergic to! Maybe you two should just think about it for a while." And then . . . she walked off! No "let me get you some drinks while you think." She just left.
So there we sat, still with no idea what we were choosing from, as the waitress actively avoided us, and even avoided making eye contact with us, for the next 10-15 minutes. Meanwhile we sat there at an empty table with no drinks, staring at each other, watching other people being served their food, and mostly trying to figure out if we'd committed an unforgivable sin and they were just going to freeze us out until we took the hint and left of our own accord because we weren't cool enough for this place.
But having watched what food arrived at other tables, we got a better idea what was on the tasting menu in a roundabout way (wouldn't it have been easier for everyone if she'd just told us upfront?) and decided to go for that after all. To save the rest of you that trouble and give you a general idea what to expect from the tasting menu:
- Homemade sourdough bread with creamery butter and maldon salt [on menu]: Terrific! Really really good. I assume they do this every day, so it's something you can count on.
- Charcuterie plate with homemade salami, pickles, and kimchi [pickles were on the menu, but salami was off-menu]: Also really good.
- Pan-seared peppers with shaved almonds and olive oil [off-menu]: Not bad. Needed a bit more seasoning. My wife liked this more than I did.
- Garden-grown tomatoes with fresh basil and feta cheese and anchovies [off-menu]: Probably the best-tasting thing of the night. The tomatoes were fresh-picked and lovely, just like out of your own garden, and unlike some other dishes, appropriately seasoned.
- Buttermilk fried chicken thighs (boneless) with a homemade cucumber and yogurt sauce [on menu]: Pretty good, although it was a little bland, and there were some bone fragments in one piece.
- Roasted radishes with fermented rice broth [off-menu]: Okay, but the broth wasn't remotely "bursting with umami" as the waitress claimed and the whole effect was dull. The staff were clearly more enthusiastic about this dish than it deserved, setting an expectation it failed to meet.
- Spaghetti with ground pork ragu in a carbonara-like egg sauce: Satisfying in a comfort-food way, but unlike most of the other dishes, actually TOO salty rather than under-seasoned.
- Fresh ripe figs with honey and yogurt: Really nice.
- Homemade torrone nougat: A nice ending.
Some other observations that may be helpful in your visit:
* Reservations are recommended, but easy to make (even same day) via their website.
* As other reviewers have mentioned, the prices seemed a tad high, especially considering the inconsistent food and wine quality. I would have been a lot more forgiving of some of their faults if this had been an $85 meal for two rather than a $198 meal for two.
* The tasting menu was indeed a good deal: about the right amount of food for two people, and at a cheaper cost than ordering everything separate -- especially considering it was even more food than "six courses", depending on how you do the math.
* I'm pretty certain the wine we ordered was corked (i.e. had oxidized in the bottle). When I raised this to the waitress, rather than trusting me or tasting it herself, she defended it and said it was supposed to taste that way (online wine reviews confirm it ISN'T supposed to taste tart in any way). Maybe other staff members are more responsible, maybe not. Perhaps better to stick to the beer.
* The music was very loud, so conversation is a little difficult.
* Although being very supportive of vegan and vegetarian diets, they struck me as far too lackadaisical regarding other eating restrictions like allergies or religious constraints. Especially the refusal to talk about the details of the dishes until after they were served. Proceed with caution -- they seem not to care much if they send you to the hospital, because the "surprise" effect is obviously a higher priority to them than your health. read more