WOWWWW this place is amazing. Crumbl who?! Lol. This shop is tucked away in a little alley in downtown hayward. There are a few parking spots reserved just for customers of Butter Pecan. The interior is super clean and minimal. No place to sit, just look at the cookies they have, order and go! I like that. I got 6 cookies for $23... kind of expensive but in my opinion the cookies were worth! Compared to Crumbl, some cookies are smaller, but the texture is much better and the flavors aren't gimmicky. I got: (2) sea salt dark chocolate chip cookie (1) banana pudding cookie (1) banana toffee cookie (1) butter pecan cookie (1) cookies and cream cookie I couldn't pick a favorite because they were all good. I got the banana ones bc my friend recommended it and I'm not usually a banana person but they were absolutely delish and the texture was awesome! Perfect harmony of brown butter cookie dough and banana. Sea salt dark choccy chip was amazing and you cant go wrong with a classic. I had to try the Butter Pecan bc it's the signature. I was skeptical bc i do not pecans but it was sooo good and perfect balance of flavors and textures. Soft, crumbly, crunchy, sweet. The cookies and cream was the biggest cookie of the bunch and it was awesome. My sister ate most if it so i couldn't savor lol Would definitely come here again!! read more

See all

Butter Pecan Bakeshop is definitely a spot cookie lovers need to check out! My all-time favorite is the Oatmeal Pecan Cookie -- it's so delicious, flavorful, buttery, and packed with that perfect pecan crunch. I stopped by yesterday and they had a fresh batch of cookies coming out. I asked if I could get some of the ones that had just come out of the oven, and they were amazing! I also tried their Cookie of the Month, the Butter Pecan, and WOW -- it was so fluffy, soft, and full of flavor. I love that this is such a cute little walk-up spot. They have all the cookies displayed so you can see the different flavors before choosing, which makes it even harder to decide! The location is great, the cookies are fresh, and the staff is friendly. If you're in Hayward and love homemade-style cookies, this is definitely a hidden gem worth checking out. Highly recommend! read more

See all

The first time I tried these cookies, my friend had ordered a ton for her husband's 40th birthday party. And I was HOOKED! I was so shocked at how much I liked the banana ones. I might've eaten four the first time. I had been meaning to check them out myself afterwards and finally we had a BBQ to attend and I wanted to bring a dessert that people would be drooling over: bring in Butter Pecan Bakeshop! Parking was easy and the lady at the counter was super helpful. I ordered a ton of course and I really should've ordered an extra one for me to nibble on the car ride. You can get wrong with any of the flavors and I can't wait to share these with our friends! read more

Home of the best cookies in town, featuring their infamous brown butter pecan, Butter Pecan Bakeshop is a gem to seek out for cookie lovers! Nestled in downtown Hayward, just blocks from free parking lots and hosting its own shared lot (two dedicated parking spots), this cookie shop originating from Emeryville has made a mark here with their buttery yet crispy, handheld treats. The minds behind these creative flavor combinations have brought yet another bright spot to the flourishing community. As you get situated with parking which is usually available in the nearby lots or street side parking, immerse yourself in the city and how walkable it is despite sharing space with winding streets leading up to the nearby highways. Getting here can be a drag during peak rush hours but the middle of the day and weekends are pretty open. The storefront isn't too big as most of the space is taken up by their huge, clean and organized kitchen space. There's not a whole lot of space to dine in so most folks come in to grab their goodies and go to enjoy them elsewhere. After entering through their doors, the sweet smells will waft by your nose and have you salivating for the buttery snacks in no time. If you came hungry, be glad that they have boxes to fit your packs of 6 or 12 cookies. You won't go wrong with any of their flavors but some of their unique flavors are definitely worth a try! They also whip up some monthly flavors so be sure to visit every so often to get a new refreshing taste of their rotations. All of their cookies have the perfect balance of crispy and softness to each bite and are not especially sweet for those looking to cut back on calories. They're also all pretty big cookies, in width and depth! Brown butter pecan - indulgent, flavorful and a classic for this cookie sharing the namesake of its home Banana pudding - surprisingly good for someone who only moderately likes bananas. The fragrance and taste is refreshing Dark chocolate sea salt/walnut - the dark chocolate will satisfy that cocoa craving and the variants with sea salt or walnut gives you the choice for something more bold or something more earthy Cookies and cream - another decadent treat that's familiar in taste; for me, a definite comfort choice Cornbread with strawberry jam - a weird one on paper but upon the first bite of this beautiful looking cookie, I was hooked. Oatmeal raisin pecan - delicious and easily forgotten as a "healthier" option Tea cake - more mild in flavor and perfect for pairing with your cup of richly aromatic tea or coffee Overall, Butter Pecan Bakeshop is your perfect balance of a cookie shop - new innovative flavors yet harnessing traditional methods with classic flavors as their foundation. The cookies are priced reasonably given their size, complexity in flavors, and quality. With their variety of cookies available each time you walk in, it's a safe bet for grabbing something for a potluck, gathering, or simply as a dessert to indulge all on your own (I'm guilty)! If you aren't yet a Cookie Monster, one taste from this shop may have you craving mad for the next bite! read more

See all

All the cookies we picked for our box were excellent - All 5 star quality Birthday Cake Cookie Dark Chocolate Walnut Cookies and Cream Walnut Brownie The only downside is the location with limited parking. I recommend not going during rush hour after work. read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

So glad that a cookie shop has finally come to Hayward. It's located right across the public library in the opposite plaza. It's kinda hidden so drive slow through the Hayward loop , stay on the left. They have a six cookie box for $23 and 12 cookies for $39. I initially was going to get 12 until I asked how many calories were in one cookie. She, the worker, said like 500+ calories for the butter pecan. So I downgraded to a six cookie box just to have less of a guilt trip. I ordered a birthday cake and one cookies and cream for my son. 1 tea cake and one banana for myself. And two chocolate chip cookies for my husband. So far I've only tried the birthday cake and the banana. And so far I'm obsessed with the first two flavors I've tried so far. But the banana is something very unique which I've not seen anywhere else and I'm going to say that it's my favorite cookie EVERR now. Their cookies are crunchy and soft at the same time. Just how I like them. . And one cookie can definitely be shared, they're big enough. Super dangerous now that there close to home. Definitely a super buttery and sweet treat. read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - 6 pack all no nuts - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

I visited this shop on 4/17 Hands down theeeee best Carrot Cake cookie I have ever had in my life! Carrot cake is my favorite and I hope it becomes a regular menu item and not just a monthly special. We tried 5 cookies and I ranked them in order by my favorites 1. Carrot Cake cookie -10/10 the flavors are perfect and the cream cheese icing is top tier 2. Buttermilk Berry Cornbread cookie-10/10 I wasn't sure what to make of this flavor when I read the name but it tastes delightful. It's like a cornbread cake cookie, so good! 3. Banana Pudding cookie - yum it's full of banana flavor and has just the right amount of crunch outside and softness in the middle. 4. Butter Pecan chocolate - Buttery chocolate goodness 5. Cookies and Cream - The texture was a little different on this cookie, a little crunchier than the others, still tasty. Shout out to the lovely Miss Karen, she was very helpful and pleasant. Go support this business yall! read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

Stopped by for dessert after hearing and seeing so much craze about this place! They had a lot of great options for cookies, as well as monthly specials. I got a banana toffee cookie and a rocky road (rocky road was a monthly special!). The texture of the banana toffee cookie was SO good! It was on the thinner side with an amazing chew and had a great banana flavor. Loved it! The rocky road was also great, especially with the mix-ins. It's a softer, less dense cookie with less chew, but has that kind of slightly crispy exterior that's kind of addicting. I wish I could've tried them when they were fresh out the oven! I will note that these cookies are very sweet, so perfect for someone with a sweet tooth, but for someone with w not-so-sweet tooth, enjoying a couple bites at a time works too! The place itself is nice and clean and the people working there are so kind and easy to talk to! They also gave me some recommendations because I was having pretty bad choice paralysis hahah. Would totally see myself coming back to try monthly specials or getting a box to bring into work :) read more

See all

Their Butter Pecan cookie lives up to their shop name. It was so good! They have several unique flavors plus fun seasonal ones. My top 3 so far are the Butter Pecan, Banana Pudding and Corn Bread. They have a little parking spot in front of shop, but also street and free garage parking across the street. read more

See all

Great cookies! Ordered for pickup around 2pm on a Sunday and the earliest pickup time was 4pm (but got an email saying my order was ready at 2:44). As others said, they have a small parking lot which makes pickup easier. Cookies themselves were great. Haven't tried all flavors as we got half a dozen but I did take a quick bite of the cookies and cream along with the brown butter pecan. Microwaving them is even better. Slightly crispy edges and soft middle. Brown butter was my favorite over the cookies and cream, but both are good. Dark chocolate chip is tasty as well - can't really tell that it's dark chocolate and didn't have much salty, but just tasted like a good chocolate chip. Banana pudding is on the lighter side, although the name makes it sound more rich. It reminded me of a snickerdoodle in a way but the banana isn't overpowering at all. Will return to try out their other flavors. read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Dark chocolate, banana pudding, and cookies and cream - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

Butter Pecan Bakeshop opened recently where Soheila Bakery was. Same serving counter. Same lack of adequate parking spaces. No seating. Greeted courteously quickly upon entry. Ready to serve. Deferred until more cookies arrived. Got service when I was ready. Limited 12 different cookies served daily. "Southern- inspired home style cookies baked fresh" cooked in 12 cookie batches. Quick turnover. Cookies tend to be crispier, crunchy & smaller than competition. Also more dense internally. Not as chewy. Cookies 3.95@. Buy 6, get 1 free with coupon on back of flyer showing cookie selections. Bites: cookies 3.95 each. -brown butter pecan: crispy, crunchy exterior. Firm inner texture. Buttery essence, crunchy pecans faintly noticed. -dark chocolate+sea salt: crispy, crunchy exterior. Moist gooey interior from dark chocolate chips. Slightly buttery. Faint sea salt prescene. 4.5 stars. Worthy occasionally. Service great. quality: baked fresh in small batches. Quantiy: smaller than competition. read more

See all

A new establishment, clean and well organized. Have good parking where you don't have to park on a heavy traffic Main Street. The gals are very welcoming and friendly. Explaining the diff fav and mixture of cookies. We love them all and will definitely visit again. read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Stopped by Butter Pecan Bake Shop after a soccer game and instantly got hit with the most amazing buttery smell, seriously heavenly. Came around 4pm on a rainy Saturday and there was still a long line out the door (always a good sign). While waiting, I watched cookies disappear one by one, but fresh batches kept coming out. I ended up waiting about 15 minutes for my cookies, worth it. Tried the cookies & cream, chocolate chip sea salt (perfect sweet/salty balance), and banana toffee, which was surprisingly delicious and not overly banana-y. Loved that they don't rush the process, they make you wait so the cookies set properly. Also, the crowd was just as sweet as the cookies, everyone was chatting and in a good mood. Pro tip: There's a parking lot in the back, and order ahead if you want the best chance at trying all the flavors! Will definitely be back (earlier next time!). read more

See all

I've been seeing so many posts about this new bakery on all my social media! Facebook, Instagram and TikTok! For my boyfriends birthday I decided to bring him here to get him some celebratory cookies. They bakery is conveniently located and I love that they have a sign that shows where to turn! It was super easy to find! The inside is cute, basic but warm. The gal at the counter was so kind, she let us know business has been very good and that made me so happy! She answered all my questions and I found out that they have limited edition cookies! From what I understood, at least 2 cookies change every month. The cookies were absolutely delicious! We tried 6 different cookies; 7up cake, birthday cake, dark chocolate with sea salt, brown butter pecan, cookies and cream, and their tea time cookie! They were all absolutely delicious! The perfect size which was bigger than we imagined- my boyfriend thought they'd be very flat but they actually had some good height to them! We loved the crunchy buts around the cookie and absolutely loved the softness of the inside! They were delicious and the price point to me doesn't matter. I love supporting small business' and with them tasting so good- I didn't mind paying a little extra. They were delicious! We will be back soon and can't wait to see the new limited flavors for next month! read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

Butter Pecan Bakeshop first opened in Pinole about 5 years ago and has since franchised 5 other locations: Emeryville, Pleasant Hill, Fairfield, Vallejo and now Downtown Hayward. Butter Pecan is known for their thick and chewy cookies with their signature: Brown Butter and Pecans. Nutty, buttery, toffee-ish with a soft center and crispy edges. I'm a big fan of their signature but they offer many popular (at least 8) flavors like: Cookies & Cream, Banana Toffee, Brownie & Walnut with unique Monthly Specials like a 7-Up and Mint Cream for the Month of March. Place no nonsense with cookies displayed behind glass with simple signage. Service friendly, storefront is set up for pickup only. No seating available. PRICING: $3.95/cookie, 6/$23, 12/$39 Located across the Hayward Library near Falafel Flare (worth a visit!) and Rummi Market (check it out) with reserved spots for each place. I only saw 4 designated spots reserved for Butter Pecan with more in the municipal lot. NAVIGATING the ridiculous Hayward Loop: once on Mission (southbound), get in your far left lane to make that quick turn into driveway after B Street. read more

See all

Having to attend a party tomorrow, I contacted the store earlier today. I wanted to place an order for pickup at 10:30am tomorrow morning. My first call to the shop, the person who answered the phone said that I would have to place my order online. Sure. The earliest pickup is 12:00pm. That does not work for me. I called again, no answer. The third time I called I explained that their online ordering only allows 12pm as the earliest pickup. The young lady on the phone said that she would speak to her manager/owner and get back to me if they could move the time up. They close in a few minutes and no one got back to me. I will be going by Denica's in Castro Valley tomorrow morning for cookies. They are always delicious and consistent in service. read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Poor communication. - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

Yea, we ate most of the cookies. Best picture I can get. I love this place. Have been coming here for a while. I love the texture of these cookies. Usually, they are too dense or too light but the spread on these cookies is just right. Gooey in the middle and a good crunch on the outside. Also such great flavors. One of the only places I frequent for cookies. read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Inside - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Staff was friendly. Easy to order. These cookies were delicious. After reading reviews of the cookie not being fully baked, I can tell you these were definitely baked and very delicious. It had a slight crispy edge and chewy inside. We ordered a dozen to try several flavors. The banana toffee was my favorite!! And the butter pecan was also really delicious. read more

See all

Stopped by during their soft opening today and got a box of 6 cookies. They had a great variety of flavors. The cookies are delicious and the staff are very friendly. We got the birthday cake, strawberry cream, strawberry cookies and cream, tea cake, and banana toffee. I'm so glad they've opened in Hayward because I had their cookies at their Emeryville location last year which were also delicious! Can't wait to come back and try some more flavors. Definitely recommend! Favorite cookie shop in the bay! read more

See all

After having their cookies from an event, this has been on our to go places to grab some cookies for events. Each cookie is delightfully unique and tasty so you cannot go wrong with them! The brown butter pecan is a staple, the banana pudding is exploding with banana, the walnut is nice and nutty and the lemon pound cake is essentially lemon-y goodness. We'll be back for more flavors~ ! The service is quite speedy and I love seeing all the cookies on display~ read more

Visited this new Butter Pecan Cookie shop in Hayward the day after their grand opening, and while I'm optimistic about the potential, there are definitely a few things that need some fine-tuning. First, the cookies themselves are quite tasty with a good base and flavor, though I did find mine to be slightly undercooked--though that could just be a result of the high demand as they're trying to turn them out fast. The prices are in line with places like Crumbl, but I'd say the texture could be a little more consistent. However, the biggest downside was the business process and customer service. The store seemed a bit overwhelmed with the crowd, and that affected the overall experience. I was told that a couple of cookies I had ordered were "on pause" and would need some "extra time" to cool. That was fine, but after about 10 minutes of waiting, we were informed that the wait would be 30 minutes (a time point of reference was not given at first just a "couple of minutes"). At that point, we had already paid for 12 cookies but were still waiting on just two. Meanwhile, they continued to serve other customers, which was frustrating as most of the cookies were gone by the time they addressed us again. I think the shop could benefit from clearer communication around wait times--perhaps updating their verbiage to manage expectations better. For example, if cookies aren't available, it'd be helpful to be given a realistic timeframe or just suggest another cookie already on display, especially when customers are already waiting. It just felt a bit disorganized, and I'd chalk that up to being a new store with employees still finding their rhythm. While I'm not sure I'll be back until enough time has passed for the kinks to be worked out and the crowds die down, I'll give another location a try in the future. There's potential here, but a bit more polish on the process and customer communication would go a long way. That said, the cookies do have a solid foundation, so I'm hopeful they'll improve with time. read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Set up - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Newish cookie shop in downtown Hayward. Not visible from the main streets, gotta go into a parking lot between big buildings. It's next door to a middle eastern market. Upon walking in I knew it was going to be legit just from the aroma lingering in the air. The smell of butter, sugar, vanilla and chocolate hung thick in the air. I just knew they were using honest basic ingredients versus industrial baking ingredients. It's basically a counter with glass case, with cookies of various flavors lined up in display. Just pick and point or create an assortment that they'll put in a bag or box. Cookies were about $4 ea, 6 for $23 or a dozen for $39. Not cheap but most of these cookies are pretty big, like the size of my palm. And is anything really cheap anymore? But I did find the price to be justifiable after trying a half dozen, they do make people happy. The one thing I did find a little strange is that their cookies can vary in size and weight. The basic chocolate chip type cookies are thinner and develop a nice crisp undercarriage. Then they have these more cake-y types (maybe from their 'Southern' selection) that are much thicker and heavier. Those aren't as crisp and definitely deviates from most people's association with cookies. Brown Butter Pecan (5*) This one is one of their thinner types, which I prefer as I love a crisp bottom but a semi chewy interior. Totally taste everything in the name in good balance. Will be one of my anchor cookies from here on out. Dark Chocolate + Sea Salt (4*) Their Chocolate Chip but made more adult with big pockets of melted dark chocolate. And love how the sweet butter flavor mingles with a touch of salty. Totally elevates their product. Lots of chocolate too, almost seemed 50% chocolate. Banana Pudding (3*) This is one of their thicker and cake-ier types. Heavy like I eat these thicker ones in 2 servings. Very faint banana flavor, actually get more vanilla. And I saw a big lighter hued spot that may have been a vanilla wafer, but not sure. Walnut Brownie (4*) This is a thick and dark cookie. Semi crisp yet thick and chewy. Very rich but the walnuts complements that richness. I would get this again. Berry Cookie (3.5*) Another thicker type, white basic cookie dough with dabs of strawberry jam in the middle. Euro in concept but American in sensibilities. Dark Chocolate/Walnut (4.5*) Pretty much that Choc Chip version but with added nuts, which imo makes it better. I would always get this version over the one without nuts. They seem pretty popular already so be patient if a line does form. If more than 5 people line up then it may start to reach the door. Imma try and always get a cookie or 2 anytime I'm eating in this downtown area. I prefer a basic crisp cookie with chocolate and nuts over a fancy slice of cake/pastry. Call me a simpleton, I'll take it as a compliment. read more

See all

We bought a dozen to try as many flavors as we could on our first visit and let me tell you...it was a tough choice picking our favorite flavor because everything we had tasted so divine! Would definitely come back for more and soon. read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

OMG OMG! This is what living is all about! Eating cookiesssss! Lots of them! For each cookie that I ate... crispy edges, chewy in the middle, loaded with buttah that will make your eyes water without even knowing. I cried a little happiness out of my eyes. The star of the show was obviously the brown sugar pecan cookie - spectacular! But my heart was also sweet on brownie walnuts and walnut dark chocolate chip. I'm a chocolate girl, what can I say?? Small shop with no seating, its to-go only. But there's plenty of parking and a few other shops to patron (if you choose to). There's only 1 person there, so, just be patient when there's a few people in line ahead of you. read more

Obsess w this place! So excited to have them in the neighborhood. Stopped by after lunch to grab a few cookies - we grabbed the banana pudding cookie, banana toffee cookie and both were amazing!! They also have seasonal monthly flavor which are always great. We've been meaning to comeback but we keep on missing them as their hours on the weekend is very short. Service is quick and friendly! Cannot wait to go back and try more things. read more

I've been here a few times and somehow forgot to post a review! I tried it when they first opened this semi new location! It is tucked away in the back entering the parking lot but you can smell it on the walk in! I did a yelp elite event with butter pecan a few months ago and it was just me selfishly getting the same cookies I like. Banana pudding cookie. The best tasting cookie in my opinion. I'd have those cookies at my wedding for sure! I'm a sweet treat girl so of course this is a place I'd recommend again and again! read more

I tried 6 different cookies today. I was disappointed by how sweet they were. I only took a few bites and had to drink it with a lot of coffee. I love the crunch on the top and the soft chewy inside. read more

I recently found out about this cute cookie shop through family and let me tell you these were easily some of the best cookies I have had in a while. Some of these flavors were so unique and tasted exactly as described. They were light and fluffy but full of flavor. The lovely lady by the name of Karen helped us out and I will definitely be back to purchase more. I noticed some of the signs had dates at the top so I am unsure if they change by season but I look forward to all of them. Go support your local businesses! read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

We love this place so much! We are so happy that there's one closer. We used to go to the one in Emeryville all the time. I get so excited for the monthly specials, but my all-time favorite will always be the banana toffee and the banana pudding. We came on a Saturday morning and were greeted by a nice and sweet gentleman that helped us. The place is nice and clean. All the cookies were on display early in the morning. This place is fairly new. Some of our cookies were burnt on the bottom but the others were delicious. read more

Delicious cookies every cookie is full of awesome flavors and always oooey gooey edges crispy the center perfect they should sale milk with them read more

F Crumbl!!! I don't know what the hype is about that over priced under cooked crap! I'd rather buy some Nestle cookie dough and eat it raw!!! Butter Pecan Bakeshop has REAL cookies!!! Thick, fluffy, flavorful, and cooked all the way through at a reasonable price!!! The place is simple and clean! It's a modern-old school feel of a bakery! The staff were all helpful and swift! They had SO many different flavors to choose from! And you can't go wrong with any of them! It's a matter of preference! I love the chocolate mint chip and tea cookies! Go there and find your favorite cookie!!! This place is BOMB!!! read more

See all

TLDR: You won't be disappointed if you're in the area. Offers a variety of standard and unique flavors, fresh made so they've got a nice chew, pleasant texture and flavor. Ambiance (4/5): * Clean, organized, easy to follow menus. * Walkable from any part of downtown Service (5/5): * The staff and manager were all very nice and helpful with suggestions. Menu (5/5): * All the hits plus some unique flavors, like the banana Cookies (5/5): * I got a variety dozen and all were consistent in texture, not the hard crispy type cookies, which I'm not a fan of. * I could taste the variety in each flavor, ie, they didn't taste like clones of each other. * I brought my mom with me and she called them "dangerously good." read more

There's no shortage of cookie spots in the Bay Area, but Butter Pecan Bakeshop is a standout. I was gifted a box for my birthday and have enjoyed every cookie in it. Unlike some pink box companies, the sugar isn't overpowering and the cookies aren't covered in frosting. Whenever I'm craving cookies I'll make the drive to Hayward for a box from Butter Pecan read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

WOW! Best cookies around. Good variety, some seasonal cookies, good service and decent prices for a delicious cookie ($3.89 each/$23 for 6/$39 for 12). read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Top L: cookies/cream, mint c/c (seasonal), banana toffee (half eaten :p). Top R: dark choco walnut, oatmeal raisin pecan, butter pecan. - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

Review for 2/28/26 We stopped by Butter Pecan Bake Shop on a Saturday afternoon during their soft opening. Even though they had just opened, it was still pretty busy. I'd definitely recommend ordering online and doing a quick pickup if you can. We ended up trying 6 cookies for $23. The favors we got were banana pudding, cookies & cream, oatmeal raisin with walnuts, brown butter pecan, dark chocolate with sea salt, and dark chocolate walnut. Some cookies were really good while others were just okay for us. Our favorites were the banana pudding and the oatmeal raisin with walnuts. We'll come back to try some of their other flavors. read more

I'm so glad they opened a location in Hayward! I went to their grand opening and got a dozen of cookies. Here's my order: butter pecan, cookies and cream, banana pudding (my favorite!), oatmeal and raisins, strawberries and cream, and tea cake cookie. My favorite is the banana pudding and oatmeal and raisins! If you're not eating it right away, microwave it for a few seconds and it'll be soft and buttery again I also heard that putting it in the air fryer is good too but I haven't tried it yet. You definitely need milk with your cookies, trust me haha. Definitely will come back again! The staff is friendly and parking was easy. Make sure you sign up for their rewards program! read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

Im back! I love it here! Flavors rotate btw. Parking lot is small, but worth the squeeze.

Butter Pecan's cookies are the best cookies! I'm giving this location 2 stars because I drove to this location from San Ramon (half an hour) to buy cookies and my favorite Butter Pecan cookie was empty in the case. The man behind the counter said the cookies were cooling and I could wait or come back to purchase them later. Neither of these options worked for me, so I left the cookie shop to go home. I wrote this review to express my disappointment that their most popular cookie wasn't available at 2:45 pm on a Saturday. read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - No Butter Pecan cookies available - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

These cookies are so good & if we are not careful, we can go broke here lol We tried the 6 pack, 3 for me & 3 for him. My fave are the tea cake & the chocolate sea salt cookies. Which ones did he like? He liked them all lol read more

All cookies were delicious! Place smell so good right when you walked in. Easy parking. read more

Butter Pecan Bakeshop - Bakeries Near Me - Hayward, California

See all