Delicious pizzas! Crust is crispy and thin, which we love. Service is great. Plenty of space for dining. We got the small margherita and small meat lovers. Both for good. read more

See all

Yoooooooooo! Went to this place on vacation up here in tha boonies. #lakelyfe Drove 20 mins to get here. GLAD I DID! As your standard Gringo raised in the South, I don't know what's up with NY style pizza. But this place made me weak in the knees when I took that first bite of the pepperoni slice. The cheese was on point! The crust made it! Crispy where it's supposed to be! My only issue was that you were a little stingy in the pepperonis. But, at the same time, I'm a pepperoni nazi. I want pepperonis on top of the crust. Que sera... Anywho, this place is fire! Best pizza joint in the area. Worth the drive. read more

We have been enjoying the food this couple has been serving up since they first opened in Warrensburg. Their pizzas are delicious-thin crust, generous toppings. Their service is always friendly and helpful . Not to be outdone-their eggplant parm is one of the best. Whatever you do order be sure to save room for their tiramisu - none better around here. Eat in or take out the restaurant offers good Italian food. read more

They serve the best pizza in the Warrensburg area. The restaurant has been remodeled and looks great. The staff are very friendly and knowledgeable. The food is the best! Geovanni is the owner and he is a nice guy. They used to be known as "The Pizza Shop". The new name is "Canepa's Pizza Shop". The shop is very clean, and they have beautiful hand painted murals on the walls to admire when waiting for your order. Definitely a 5-star restaurant and they are kid friendly. read more

My experience was absolutely horrible. The lady in the shop had such a nasty, negative attitude. Please don't get me wrong; everyone has bad days, but there's no need to take it out on a customer. The food matches her attitude. The service and food were bad enough that we left and didn't even finish our food. I just went in there hoping for that small-town pizza shop. I am definitely disappointed and will not be going back there again. read more

Excellent Pizza, great service fantastic taste all at a reasonable price. Family run and it's obvious that they love their work and it shows in their products. read more

The food is always fantastic. We actually ordered food from here 2 nights in row. My favorite pizza is the Chicken/Bacon/Ranch. We tried the Bang Bang Chicken and it was good. It had a bit of bite which I liked. The meatball platter is great. Best meatballs I've ever had. You need to check this place out read more

Thought I would give it a try again. it's just not what it used to be. Very disappointed with the Italian sub this time. Last time it was the calzone and Stromboli. it was my to go to but not anymore. Such a shame, this was one of the only places I wanted to eat in town. prices went up, quality and quantity went way down. So sad read more

Pizza was pretty good. Thin crust, not super greasy. I would recommend the red sauce pizza. The white pizza really didn't have any flavor.

Pizza was fantastic and the staff were all kind and attentive. I am glad we stopped in during our time in Warrensburg!

As usual the food was very good. I would recommend that if you order pickup you not select a hot sub. It appeared to me that they didn't begin to start making the sub until I walked in the door. So instead of the 25 minutes I was told from the time I made the call it took 50 minutes until I had the subs. If they had told me on the phone that it would be 50 minutes I would have no issue and would have planned accordingly. There seemed to be no sense of urgency... And yes, it used to be better. read more

Great tasting pizza. Wonderful customer service and even better pricing. Definitely worth venturing out 10 minutes from Lake George for Great food. It's not surprising why they've won so many awards. read more

The Pizza Shop never disappoints. Awesome NY style pizza with a light thin crust and super flavorful sauce and toppings. By far my favorite pizza place in the area! read more

Canepa’s Pizza Shop - The Pizza Shop never disappoints. By far my favorite pizza in the area! - Pizza Near Me - Warrensburg, New York

This was our first time ordering pizza and we loved it! My husband was skeptical because he is from downstate and really likes thin crust with a lot of cheese and tasty sauce. This pizza was everything that we like in a pizza! It was perfect! read more

I live in Brooklyn, I'm surrounded by pizza. The good the bad and even the ugly! This pizza fell into the good pile and I'm so excited to have found them. I also ordered their Buffalo Chicken Salad w Blue Cheese and I'm telling you went home the next day and made one myself because I was craving round 2. In short, this is my pizza spot when I visit Lake George! read more

Nutshell: Solid NYC style pizza that I'll be back to buy again the next time I'm up W-town way. I got an XL sauseeeege and it was 16 and change. Totally reasonable! Met the owner's wife and she gave me a little bit of rundown on their business. Super nice lady and she said her husband is Italian and has a flair for the pizza makin' bidness. Their 3 year anniversary as a pizza jurnt is celebrated December of 2017 and the following March of 2018, they are changing locations to just up Main Street aways. They are building their own structure and will have new pizza ovens as well, so they'll have it all set up according to their own specs. Looking forward to trying it once they've made their move. She said they do 2 slices and a soda specials that run from 5 to 7 bucks depending on toppings and they have slices available pretty much anytime they're open. Only took 20 minutes for my pie mid-day on a Wednesday afternoon. They are not open 7 days a week so you might want to call if you're driving up from Lake George just for their offerings. Sausage was home done and I liked it. As soon as I opened the pizza box on my pie it screamed NYC pizza (see my pics) and that's a good thing! I would definitely liken it to the pizza that I've gotten in NYC that use a Hobart traditional style propane or natural gas oven. It's a traditional NYC style thin crust for sure. Ample cheese and toppings and the sauce played music in the background. The sausage was the headliner on this pie for sure and Jimmy likey. FYIzzle: They have a frequent buyers card; buy 10 XL pizzas and get your 11th free. I saw at least two other pizza shops on Main Street while driving to this one, but this one has been rated the top pizza joint of the LG/Warrensburgville area. It's tasty, dough is made fresh daily, and it's priced very reasonably. Like I said, I'll be back! Next time I hope I get a chance to talk pizza with the owner as I'm pretty crazy for pizza and make A LOT of my own homemade pies. read more

See all

The food was awful, save your money. Meatballs straight from the freezer, not even warm in the middle. Chicken was over cook and hard to even bite. read more

We were up camping in the ADKs last week and stopped by here on a rainy Tuesday night. OMG it is an amazing place! We ended up going back there two more times and my parents and aunt and uncle also checked it out and loved it. We got a plain pie for the kids and the Four Seasons for us the first night (plain, white, sausage and pepperoni, Buffalo chicken). The white is out of this world amazing. The sausage and pepperoni and plain were also very very good. The Buffalo chicken could have used crumbled bleu cheese and red onions according to my husband lol. On the third trip my husband got the chicken parm sub which he enjoyed! The staff is friendly, ample seating, reasonable prices, and parking is on the side lot and on street. Highly recommend! Our 6yr old kept asking to go back lol. read more

Canepa’s Pizza Shop - Four seasons pie - Pizza Near Me - Warrensburg, New York

The Pizza has always been on the Thinner side, but the Flavor has always set itself apart from the competition. The Service is as easy as it gets for a "Pizza Shop", quick & easy. And the shop has gorgeous hand painted ambiance on the inside. read more

Amazing fresh and hot pizza and great service. Good atmosphere inside and they've got an impressive wall of stars they've served. I honestly didn't think the place would be good when I drove by it a few times during my vacation stay until someone recommended it before I left and so glad I did! This place is a diamond in the rough! I so want to go again! read more

Had a really great experience here! I would totally recommend the four seasons pizza if you are buying for a family. This pizza has something for everyone! We really enjoyed the pizza and the workers were extremely nice! Would most definitely stop by again if we are in town! read more

Awesome service, friendly and quick, couldn't ask more from a pizza shop. Awesome paintings on the walls inside. The garlic knots were amazing (sold by the dozen well worth it, snack size).We got a regular and a pepperoni slice as well, thinner crust than I'm used to but not to thin. We asked for it to be heated and crispy and crispy and heated was delivered to our seats, couldn't ask for more. read more

Canepa’s Pizza Shop - Pizza Near Me - Warrensburg, New York

See all

Their food is fantastic! They have salads, wraps, pizzas, sodas, chips and more! If you are gluten free, they even have gluten free options. I love their options of wraps and how customizable they let you be with your order. The staff is super friendly and so are the owners - give it a try :) read more

Canepa’s Pizza Shop - The Oscar Wrap! - Pizza Near Me - Warrensburg, New York

Amazing pizza, hands down the best in Town, amazing service & easily the best Pizza around. If I could give it 10/10

What a treasure in Warrensburg! Super great pizza with really high quality ingredients, very friendly staff, and you even watch the owner make the pizzas! Definitely a gem for all - has a great family atmosphere and great food to boot! read more

Ever have a craving for pizza and you take that first bite and it is EXACTLY WHAT YOU WANTED? I'm guessing it doesn't happen often, at least it doesn't for me. But holy cow, this pizza is rock star. We drove 30 minutes each way to go check it out and is was worth the ride for sure. Thin crust, good sauce, and quality toppings. And the staff was really friendly too. I highly recommend the Supreme. read more

See all

Pulled off the exit from rout 87 for a quick bathroom/food stop and ended up at this pizza place. I got two regular cheese slices and they were delicious! Fresh and had great taste! There was a few varieties of specialty slices as well. Beautiful hand painted art on the walls and was super clean with very nice staff! read more

The owner of the pizza shop is from Calabria and moved to Warrensburg after meeting his wife who was traveling in Italy. This pizzeria has excellent gluten free options. I usually place my to go order for a large pizza before leaving Gore after skiing the last chair. read more

Pizzas were large and delious. We got the lasagna pizza and pepperoni pizza. Plenty of toppings. Counter staff was very friendly. read more

We were looking for something to eat on a Saturday night.....OMG!!!! The best tasting pizza we have ever had. We only got a small not know how we were going to like it. We should have gotten the biggest size pizza they make! We wanted more. Staff were warm and friendly with smiles on their faces. We will be back. Thank you! read more

A Pizza Shop in the heart of Warrensburg, sitting slightly off the street with ample parking. I stopped in and treated myself to "a slice". Wow was it good! I engaged in a conversation with a great young couple about the differences between New York Pizza and what they serve, using the same name in California. Seriously, California Pizza makers should either be arrested for fraud or sent here for cooking lessons. Seriously, this place is clean, we'll run, lots of personality and they make an awesome product. If you live within 5 miles, they'll deliver for free. Unfortunately my campground is just outside that radius...however it's worth the trip into Warrensburg for what just may be the best Pizza I have ever eaten. read more

See all

Italian-owned place with a very sweet love story. Pizzas are nice. The thin 10in gluten free pizza was pretty good, and the regular eggplant lovers was nice (although I would add just a bit more salt). The most important things: clean place, good service, and good pizza made with care, a notch above those chain restaurants. If they had a woodfire oven, it would undoubtedly be a five-star place. read more

Just had a great slice of cheese pizza. AND chicken parm hero. Shared with my friend. The crust was light and crisp, sauce was flavorful. The chicken "boat" was done perfect too. It was dough had to be home made and chicken tender and crispy. Sauce was rich and just the right amount. Staff was friendly and clean. Come check out amazing art on walls also. Great pit stop away from the crowded area of LG! read more

I am originally from Long Island, and we love our Pizza! When we moved up North I knew I had to say goodbye to bagels and Pizza. Until I found The Pizza Shop! This is it!!!! I am back home!! This Pizza is the real deal. It's no wonder they win Best in the Region!! read more

Great pizza! I love that it is owner operated. My family is a bit picky (I'm being nice) about food and pizza in particular. This pizza was incredibly delicious; fresh and nice tasting ingredients. Also...the young staff was professional and kind; they actually smiled and said hello...go figure. Clean and spacious. Will DEFINITELY get pizza again when in town. Nicely done! read more

Fantastic! Very impressive! Would recommend to all. They were able to make me personalized small calzone type pizza bowls as seen on Yelp, even tho they are not on the menu. Much appreciated and delicious. read more

Best pizza in the area. Great staff. Don't skimp on the cheese. Always busy with heavy takeout business. You become a regular visitor in no time. It is an easy stop on my way home as in the heart of town on Route 9. read more

There's a good reason this place has so many 5 star ratings. I've been meaning to write this review for a while, and now I'm finally getting around to doing it. A few months ago, me and some friends went to stay in Lake George for a weekend. Saturday night we were looking for some good, inexpensive food. We were told about this place by one of the locals, so we came to check it out. It's a small shop located on a main road. I imagine they get more take out than people dining in, because when we got there, only one other table was taken. We ordered an XL Hawaiian Pie and pasta with meatballs. Now, while the pasta and meatballs were great, the portion size was a little small for the price. However, it was more than made up for with the pizza. An 18 inch XL specialty pie for $13.50. I think this is the best priced, and some of the best tasting pizza I've ever had in my life. Between three adult men and a woman, we all loved it and could hardly finish the last slice. Everything just tasted so fresh, and it was hot, but not so hot that the cheese was falling off and you burned your mouth. The staff was also super friendly, as was the woman that owns the place with her husband. The store itself is also very pleasant. Like I mentioned, it's a relatively small place, but it's also spacious enough because they don't overcrowd it with chairs and tables. It has a simple, and charming feel to it. My only regret is that we didn't order another pie to take with us and eat for a meal the following day, because sadly, they're not open on Sundays or Mondays. :( Tl;dr: DELICIOUS pizza, amazing price, nice shop and friendly staff and owners. Note: Place is not open on Sundays or Mondays. read more

The best Pizza, salads and "Subs" in Warrensburg. Very friendly and efficient service. Very clean restaurant and they have beautiful murals hand painted on the walls. Geovanni is a master pizza chef who is "old world Italian" and also owns the business. You won't forget their delicious pizza. read more

Stopped at The Pizza Shop for lunch after Oscar's Smokehouse. When had xlg half cheese and half mushroom pizza. The crust perfect, nice and thin. The sauce, cheese and mushrooms were also delicious and perfectly balanced. The crew behind the counter were friendly as on previous visits here. read more