I've never left a negative Yelp review until now. Terrible service. MULTIPLE tables that came after my party got their meals before my appetizer came. Very inefficient. No excuses for this. The crab Alfredo was overcooked ramen noodles. The special touch was the styrofoam cups with straws at my elbow. Not sure if this was garbage or someone's order? Surely this is a health code violation. Zucchini strips were great but I'll make my own next time. AVOID this place. read more

Carmody's Grille - Gross - New American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Visited for lunch for the first time. Love the indoor patio. The BEST fried pickles I have had in a loooong time, no cucumber taste, not greasy. The seafood bisque is GREAT! I hope they keep it on the menu! I didn't love my grilled chicken salad, chicken definitely needed more seasoning. My fiancé got the chicken & waffles, he said they were delicious. My father got the crab cakes, was not impressed that the "vegetable" was corn but liked the crab cakes for sure. The brown butter cake was heavenly. 90% of the food was absolutely delicious, server could've been faster but she was also working the bar so I understand. Will definitely be back often! read more

Had lunch here after flying in on business. Service was great and the food was even better. Great atmosphere and large space.

Great food, great service!! We had the French dip sandwich and it was outstanding. Real beef, reasonably priced. A+

Pleasantly surprised by this restaurant. The food was great. Ordered the fried zucchini and crab cakes. Both were delicious and I would highly recommend checking this place out. Also the wine menu has various options and prices are very reasonable. read more

Pulled up my yelp app to find somewhere for dinner I haven't been and Carmody's came up with great reviews so gave it a try. Driving to "the island" I didn't know what to expect and was hesitant but walking in I felt right at home and comfortable. Plenty of bar space as we as table seating. Staff is super friendly and drink selection is decent, quite typical of a "city" beer list. Could have had more local craft brews but no complaints. We had German cuisine as it's the tail end of Oktoberfest season and was not disappointed. Would like to go back and try their regular menu food and give another review. Also there is seasonal Outdoor seating which makes this place ideal for warm days and evenings. Overall I really enjoyed it here and will be back. read more

Carmody's Grille - New American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Food and drinks are very good! Employees are very friendly and accommodating. They welcome large groups also.

I like it here. Good Service, And big rooms that can fit a lot of people. French Fries at Carmody's are good. The only thing I didn't like was there cheese balls there had mozzarella cheese in the cheese balls. And I wasn't a fan. I would come here again read more

The food was amazing. Great drink menu. Lou was a very friendly and attentive server. read more

See all

I ordered a salad and they forgot 3 of the ingredients. The waitress was no where to be found so I ate it because I was starving. When she arrived I told her and she apologized. Would have been nice to get at least a small discount or a free dessert since my salad was ruined. Customer service is dead. Oh, and they were not busy at the time. Other than that I think it is a nice place with good food. read more

Really large place with yummy food. Took a little while for food to come as we came in at a busy time but the food was still super hot when it got to the table read more

Carmody's Grille - New American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Food was very good!!! Bloody marys were really good!I would definitely eat here again. We had a very nice server.

Great food and drinks. Wait staff is friendly and they provide great service. There are daily specials. The French dip sandwich is excellent. read more

absolutely terrible service. showed up at lunchtime and waited 20 minutes with no sign of a hostess. was told they just got slammed - well no crap it is lunchtime. tried talking to bartender and she ignored us. very unprofessional overall. read more

So glad I found this place because I absolutely adore it. Going on a Sunday, you would think it would've pretty empty but it was pretty busy. They have a great beer and cocktail list and there menu isn't bad either. There is a patio that separates the bar from the event area and you can tell it's a great place to hang out in the summer. I couldn't tell if there was a roof over it but there were people eating there so it's definitely open all year round. Our waitress was also awesome as well. Super attentive and helpful and we loved having conversations with her. I would return simply for the fun convos. I got the steak burger and it was great. Come check this place out on a weeknight and take advantage of their happy hour specials. They don't have any specials on weekends. I will definitely come back when it's warmer to try out the patio. read more

Carmody's Grille - Steak burger - New American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Business trip. Found Carmody on the island. Outstanding Cajun Shrimp Scampi in Alfredo sauce. Not only was it great, it was memorable. I've been thinking about it for the two days since I had it. If I was there a second night, no doubt I would have gone again. Friendly, welcoming, really good! read more

Waited about 20-minutes to be seated on a Friday night, so not too bad. Fantastic service and fantastic food. I had the French dip sandwich and it was excellent! Would definitely return! read more

Such a good spot to grab anything you are craving! Their diverse menu makes it so easy to find something delicious. The owners and staff are so nice. The French dip is a staple on the menu along with the fried cheeseballs. The atmosphere is very diverse which makes it the perfect for a nice for date night but also game day with their multiple TVs. Shoutout to Sydney, Sarah and Patty being the best bartenders! read more

The food was great. We had lunch twice during our trip. Our server Gordon was so nice and helpful. The place has a nice atmosphere with outdoor dining. read more

We found this restaurant by chance and so glad we did. It's Neville Islands hidden gem! Family friendly as well as a great place to meet up and have a drink. They offer a full bar menu and a smaller dinner menu. Fish to prime rib they have something for everyone. They have a kids menu to please your little ones with pizza to peanut butter and je. You can't go wrong with any salad option in my opinion. My husband enjoys his bowl of turtle soup every time we come. This restaurant also offers a beautiful party room and indoor/patio seating too. Parking is easy as they own a side lot as well if street parking is tough. read more

See all

While on Neville Island for business I stopped in here for lunch on a weekday and from the outside it looked like it was dead. I walked in and this place was packed! They have 2 huge outdoor patio areas as well and everything was packed! I opted for a bar seat and the bartender, a beautiful red haired lady was very friendly and helpful. The inside has nice décor and is really clean. They have a full bar, featuring cocktails and beer. For food, there were so many items on the menu that were appealing! I opted for their French Dip with onion rings and it was pretty good. The onions used in the sandwich and rings were nice, but several had the onion wrapper (the paper around the outside of the onion) and were non-chewable, thus I had to spit those out. I asked for jalapeño peppers in the sandwich and a few had stems, again, had to spit those out. The peppers were quite hot and tasty tho! The au jus and the horseradish sauce were both delicious. Overall, I'd definitely come back, just get other items. Definitely suggest stopping in for some good eats! read more

We are here on a Saturday early afternoon. They're understaffed. I understand that and very sympathetic. My wife and I are in the area for our daughter's hockey tournament. We figured we'd get a quick bite to eat. Instead of waiting in line, we decided to seat at the bar. There was one couple sat before us and then one couple that came after. The bartender clearly knows there is a staffing issue. She was very chatty with the first couple and comes over after a minute or two and says she'll be with us. I decided to go to the restroom while waiting. When I come back, the couple that was sat AFTER us already got drinks and she had failed to take our drink orders. To add more insult to injury she brought drinks to another table that was poured AFTER the couple that sat AFTER us. This is all BEFORE she took our drink orders. I wanted to leave immediately but my wife wanted something. I ordered nothing as I refuse to give an establishment with crappy service any money. I reiterate, I know exactly what it is like to deal with staffing issues, but the order of events that happened is really inexcusable. The bartender continues to be extremely chatty with certain patrons while not adequately multitasking and attending to as many as she can. read more

Happened to be in the area picking up some uniforms and wanted a bite to eat before I got home. So glad that we chose Carmody's! First as we entered, we saw the great effort they took to keep everything safe and clean during covid. We ordered the pickle chips to start. We order fried pickles everywhere that has them, but these are hands down the best we've encountered. Potato pancakes were on point too. My girlfriend had a Ruben and I had the fish tacos. Both were amazing. Our server was always present when we needed her and checked on us frequently. I'm so glad we opted for dessert. Brownies are my favorite, so we ordered the brownie with ice cream to share. They hand make all their desserts there, and you could tell with this brownie. It was a huge slice and the perfect chewy goodness. We both agreed it would be our goto regular spot if we lived closer, and being only 25 minutes away, we will definitely be back. read more

Food used to be better, just average now. Service is very good! Ambiance is good. Would recommend with limited expectations. read more

But I can't even the bus if you're nearby you have to come here the food is absolutely fantastic all fresh made from scratch and the staff could not be more friendly helpful and enjoyable food is off the hook to steal a phrase read more

Carmody's Grille - Phenomenal, fresh homemade meals, wonderful staff and a at home comfortable vibe. - New American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

A great spot on Neville Island, kind of a diamond in the rough. There is plenty of street parking. They have a large bar and indoor space but today we ate on the patio which was really nice. Staff was friendly. Menu has a lot of variety, everything from sandwiches and salads to more proper entrees. We started with the pickle fries which were awesome, breaded very lightly. The spicy turkey melt I had was also very good. Prices very reasonable. Would definitely recommend checking this place out. read more

Carmody's Grille - Spicy Turkey Melt - New American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Busy place at lunch time. Interesting long narrow place with a long bar with windows that open up into a outdoor type of place that is covered & walled by that old ripple fiberglass and has some space heaters. A nice list of beers on a chalkboard. Also a small chalkboard with daily specials and soup of the day. Was interested in some of the appetizers but not real hungry...probably should have gotten a couple of appetizers instead I ordered the Bacon Turkey Swiss on a croissant with lettuce and tomato. The sandwich that comes with a choice of fresh cut fries or power slaw. The sandwich and fries were good. Service was fast and friendly. read more

Carmody's Grille - Turkey Bacon Swiss - New American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Ordered via uber eats. Order arrived very skimpy and missing a side of pickle chips. My husband ordered the salmon salad and I ordered the house salad. I ate the house salad in less than 5 bites, see photo of salad order upon arrival. Our dinner totaled $33 + service fees and tip for uber driver so more like $40 and we were left feeling hungry and having to cook :( Giving 3 stars because the woman I spoke to at Carmodys was very nice and provided good customer service. She is refunding the pickle chips that were missed on their behalf and said she will send a gift card. If we do get the gift card, I will give them another try. Just really disappointed in the price for the quality/quantity. read more

Carmody's Grille - "Large" $8 house salad :( - New American Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Came here before Monday night bowling @ Paradise Bowl. Carmody's Grille was a delightful find on Neville Island. They have a handful of items on the menu and everything we ordered was prepared well. They also had some good specials! We took advantage of the happy hour from 4-6pm (Monday-Thursday) and ordered fried pickles for $3 plus a couple of drinks. The pickles were crispy and comes with a dill ranch sauce. They were a little salty, but still yummy. Recommend cutting back on the salt in the batter just a bit. I ordered a Reuben. Toasted, hot, and filled with beef, sauerkraut, and thousand island dressing. All of it topped with melty swiss cheese. No skimping here! Their onion rings were coated in the same batter as the fried pickles. I recommend you get regular fries instead! They are hand cut skin on fries. My friend ordered fries and those were tastier. Whole meal topped off with cheesecake covered in caramel sauce. Tasted homemade and even had a buttery graham cracker crust. Service was prompt, attentive, and kept our drinks full. We'll definitely be back! read more

See all

Came for the first time last night. I'll definitely be back! Loved the mussels, loved my burger. Decent beers on tap. Bartenders were awesome. Food and drinks were priced well. A bright spot on "the island". read more

1st time there. Was pleasantly surprised. Got a grilled chicken sandwich and was good. Service was good time. A nice local restaurant. We sat in enclosed patio and was comfortable in there read more

Great locally owned and family run restaurant. Excellent food, nice menu selection, and really friendly service.

Very VERY dissatisfied with the prime rib. Had to have been frozen/thawed. Disgusting.

The chicken and waffles here is one of the best ever. A savory and sweet combination with delicious cheese and maple syrup sauce.

Limited but delicious menu, friendly atmosphere, nice beer selection. Kitchen stays open till 10 so a great spot for a late bite.

I ordered take out steak burger and pasta w/meatball. Food was very good, cooked properly and ready on time at reasonable price for places today. Sara, our hostess was very polite and I will definitely go back for another. great place for quick, good quality food.....give it a try read more

If stumble upon Neville Island - give Carmody's Grille a try. Don't turn left towards Paradise Bowling - turn right past King's - and keep going until you find Carmody's on your right. This restaurant was original off the Wexford exit, but the location has been open for a least 2 years. I believe they are going to expand in the next store front, but this restaurant & bar has plenty of room for the whole family. We hit the restaurant around 6pm on Sunday evening - it wasn't busy, so we got seated right away. To start we ordered a bottle of Shine Riesling & my dad ordered a Yuengling draft. They have plenty of drafts on tap. For our apps - we ordered the zucchini appetizer and the fried cheese balls. They were both good. For my entree, I ordered the large fish sandwich with a side of fries. This sandwich was delicious and the fries were were good. I would definitely order this fish sandwich again. Overall, I'll come be back to Carmody's again s read more

See all

This place is unassumingly tucked in Neville Island, and it's just a couple blocks away from Neville Roller Drome. For me, Carmody Grille has been a stop for before or after skating. The food here I think is just a touch pricey for what it is, but everything I've had here is very good. On my most recent visit, my friend and I split the deep fried pickles and we both ordered the steak salad. The meat was excellent (sometimes restaurants use Steakems but this was legit steak) and perfectly cooked medium (as requested, since sometimes restaurants overcook the meat). Our deep fried pickles were tasty, but with the breading being a little crumbly, I think the fryer could've been a little hotter before they were cooked. The seasoning on them was spot on though. Also, our waiter seemed to be annoyed with serving us, even though there were only a couple other customers around when we were there. My friend asked for a different drink when her iced tea tasted overbrewed, which I didn't think was unreasonable, but that seemed to set our waiter off. Oh well. read more

We were so pleasantly surprised since we had never been there! the parking was easy right in front) and the food was delicious! i had. a godo drink at a very reasonable price and my husband enjoyed his beer. We sat at the bar area and enjoyed a delicious dinner. My husband lover the prIme rin with very ample portions so he enjoyed it the next day too! I had the French dip and it was so good! Definitely will be back, in fact we did, 4 daYS LATER! Sydnie was a good bartender too and very attentive! This is a very good local restaurant that you'll enjoy! read more

Great food and awesome beer selection. Staff is really nice and atmosphere is very relaxed. A local favorite for our family!