Carnevor is still the best steak house in Milwaukee, in my opinion! They really deliver on service and flavor, consistently, and they seem research where to get the best and most unique cuts of beef and how best to prepare it. They have steaks you won't find anywhere else in town, or they'll be the first to have it available in the entire state! Sides, apps, and desserts are always great, too! Most recently, we shared the Wagyu Brisket and Gnocchi appetizer (again, no one else has this on their menu), and it was amazing! Our 8oz filet and 20oz bone-in ribeye were perfectly cooked to temperature, and the Truffle Frites and Brussels sprouts were great options for our steaks. The Dark Chocolate Mousse Bar and added vanilla ice cream from local premium ice cream makerr, Scratch, made for the perfect end to our dinner. My girlfriend loved her Pick Me Up (Espresso Martini), and I enjoyed my Chef's A-5 Manhattan, made with Sazerac "washed in Japanese A-5 beef fat," and again - what other place is doing this?!?! Our server, Will, was excellent, as was the rest of the server/busser team! Love this place! read more

See all

We had dinner here on Friday, May 8th. Really disappointing experience at Carnevor, especially considering its reputation and price point. This was a work dinner, otherwise I absolutely would have sent my meal back. The steaks were overwhelmingly salty--so much so that it completely overshadowed the quality of the meat. Even more frustrating, every steak at our table came out rare, regardless of how it was ordered. The asparagus was overcooked, the ramp chowder was just okay, and the dessert honestly tasted like something picked up from Sam's Club rather than made in-house. The drinks were very good, and the service was attentive and professional, which is the reason I gave this place 3 stars. For the reputation and price point, I expected much better. There are MUCH better options in Milwaukee, go elsewhere. read more

Some of the most important people in our lives are those who give us AWESOME CUSTOMER SERVICE and delicious FOOD! Awesome customer service is all about bringing customers back, and sending them away happy - happy enough to pass positive feedback about the business along to others, who may then try the service and food for themselves... and in their turn, become repeat customers too! Carnevor, Mark and his team stand second to none. read more

Walking into Carnevor and ordering seafood at one of Milwaukee's most celebrated steakhouses is the equivalent of showing up at a Packer's game wearing a hockey jersey. Here's what you're getting ladies and gentlemen. The crab cakes were loaded with jumbo lump crab, none of the nonsense. The shrimp scampi was buttery and garlicky just like they should be. Carnevor has built its reputation on USDA Prime beef and Wagyu, but the seafood quietly refuses to be overshadowed. Sometimes the smartest move at a steakhouse is completely ignoring the steak. read more

This isn't Jacobs & Co. or Alexander's, but for a "small" big city, it'll do. We had reservations in the dining area, but per our request, they moved us to the bar area to watch some games, which they accommodated. If there was something that really stood out, it was the service. Everyone was attentive and had a grounded vibe that I appreciated. The drinks are the perfect blend of strength and mixology, a rare feat. The food was good. Now that there are so many cows in WI, I wish they had more local prime options. I was looking forward to their Japanese wagyu, which was advertised as coming from a prefecture that I had not tried before, but it was sold out. Their "somewhere from the Midwest" ribeye did the job. Now, the sides...they're up there. The risotto and twice-baked potatoes were perfect accompaniments. And the creme brulee and doughnuts finished the stuffing process. It'll do what it does if you're into specifics and care about where your meat is sourced, and you can taste the difference between beef from different ranches; you won't be wowed, but it'll still take care of a steakhouse craving. read more

Carnevor Steakhouse Moderne - Steakhouses Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

an amazing stop for quality steak and atmosphere. The staff makes sure your experience is top quality and worth the money. I got the waygu ribeye for the first time... and wow it was genuinely the best steak I have ever had. I recommend the caramelized Brussels and baked twice baked potatoes for sides! And I always get the crème brûlée to finish! Never have been disappointed with my experience here. read more

Carnevor Steakhouse Moderne - Waugh Ribeye - Steakhouses Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

We had a solid experience at Carnevore! Certainly not the best of the best as far as steakhouse experiences. The tomahawk was slightly underwhelming from a size perspective and sides were decent but nothing overly memorable. Fun and swanky atmosphere and we appreciated the personalized touch for our anniversary! Service was great. Would give it another shot. read more

See all

We went here for my boyfriend's birthday. It is darkly lit and the decor was tasteful. The service was great as our waitress was very friendly and helpful. We started with the thick cut bacon which was amazing! It was tender while also having a crispy edge. For my main, I got a Caesar salad with Mac & cheese. I didn't care for the Mac and cheese as it was very sharp tasting. I think it was because of the goat/blue cheese. My boyfriend ordered the ribeye and mini twice baked potatoes. He enjoyed both! They also gave us a donut dessert for my boyfriend's birthday, so that was lovely! read more

See all

Since our last visit, we have toured other steakhouses. Like they say, distance makes the heart grow fonder. We came back tonight to find the same great service, wine and food. Mark (manager) really took care of us and made us feel like family. We love the Omar Cabernet Sauvignon reserve. The last time we were here they were out because it's such a big seller. It's a very comparable to a higher end wine but for a great value. All the steaks were, again, cooked and seasoned to perfection. Service was impeccable. Ambiance was quaint and satiable. I would be here every week if I could. Best we can do is be here every month when we visit from California. Worth the trip every time. Keep delivering that unbelievable experience. read more

See all

Visited Carnevor for the first time on my birthday and I'm so glad I did! The vibe was perfect and I appreciated the details of a personalized menu and complimentary dessert! Our service (from our server to the waitstaff) was five stars and everyone enjoyed their meals and drinks (the Milwaukee Street Sour should be a regular menu item - it was that good)! I understand now why this place is so beloved. I'll be back! read more

See all

Amazing experience! Love the ambiance, the food was incredible, and the service was immaculate. Went here for our anniversary and we had a great time. I ordered the ahi tuna and my husband ordered the ribeye. I'm sure you can't go wrong with anything on this menu! Will absolutely be back. Best espresso martini of my life ! :) read more

See all

We recently went to Carnevor to celebrate a birthday! It was really good! It was also really cute they customized the menu for Jordan's birthday! All you have to do is email them and they will put whatever you want for the occasion! Our server was great! It was really busy and lively inside. The filet was excellent as well, paired really well with the truffle mashed potatoes!! Jordan also got a dessert with a candle. It was a really good date night celebrating his birthday! read more

Carnevor Steakhouse Moderne - Customized menu for Jordan's birthday :) - Steakhouses Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

We haven't been here in a couple of years. And we remember it being much better. My filet was cooked like I asked but it was barely warm and it wasn't very flavorful. Sides were ok. Oh and the crab cake app was mushy in the middle. I guess I'm giving it 3 stars mostly for nostalgia, because it used to be one of the best in town. But based on our dinner last night, we won't be back. Milwaukee has lots of better choices. read more

The best steakhouse in Wisconsin. Hands down! Amazing experience every time. Book a reservation before you go. read more

Carnevor Steakhouse Moderne - Japanese A5 Waygu tenderloin - Steakhouses Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

I was genuinely excited for Carnevor. The space is gorgeous, the menu looked promising, and I had heard great things. But sadly, the experience I had fell flat -- and by the time anyone showed concern, the moment had passed and the damage was done. We started with the steak tartare, which was aggressively seasoned but unfortunately riddled with silver skin -- it got stuck in my teeth with nearly every bite. I gave up on eating most of it and asked the server for a toothpick. She returned and, without a word, dropped a handful of toothpicks in front of me before walking away. Not exactly the level of service you'd expect at a place like Carnevor. For entrées, all three of us ordered steaks. I asked for a medium NY strip, but what I received was unmistakably well-done. Before I could even cut into it, our server breezed by asking how everything was -- then disappeared for over 20 minutes. No check-in, no chance to get the steak fixed, just silence. I sat there, untouched plate in front of me, hoping someone would notice. Meanwhile, the sides were just as disappointing. The "cream corn" was not cream corn at all -- just dry, regular corn without any richness or depth. The asparagus was limp and soggy, and the crispy brussels sprouts were anything but -- soft, oily, and flavorless. Had someone explained these weren't traditional versions, I would've gladly picked something else. Eventually a busser came to clear plates, noticed I hadn't eaten mine, and I told him it wasn't good. He took it and tossed it without a word. Another 20 minutes passed before the server returned -- asking if we wanted dessert. At that point, my guests were finished and ready to go. When I finally explained what happened, I was met with, "Well, if I'd known you didn't cut into it, I would've come back," as if it were my fault for not signaling distress sooner. The manager did comp the steak, which I appreciate, but honestly -- I didn't come here for a discount. I came here for a memorable meal and a great night with my colleagues. I would've gladly paid full price had I been given the chance to enjoy what I ordered. Carnevor is clearly aiming high, and I saw dishes around me that looked fantastic -- just not ours. But when service is inattentive and food quality misses the mark across the board, even a beautiful setting can't save the experience. Maybe it was a bad night, but for me, it was a wasted one. read more

Carnevor Steakhouse Moderne - Center cut to show my Over cooked Medium strip. - Steakhouses Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Went with customers on Thursday night. I had the blue cheese salad chopped and it was a great way to start. One of the most impressive wine lists I've ever seen. I ordered the filet and added two gigantic shrimp. The filet was top notch and cooked to perfection. Great ambiance and service was great. I'd eat here again in a heartbeat. The fish was superb that my friend had as well. I also liked that we ordered sautéed spinach versus the typical steakhouse creamed spinach. Desert was also insanely good. read more

One of the best choices in Milwaukee for a great dining experience. From the moment you walk in, everyone seems to be on a mission to make sure you receive the best experience possible. Carnevor has been opened for quite some time and they haven't lost a step. On our last several visits we have had Diane as our server. She is so welcoming and personable. I highly suggest asking for her when you visit. I appreciate the professionalism of every employee there. They seem to really care about making your dining experience one to remember. In my experience they have always exceeded typical expectations. This isn't a budget friendly restaurant but what steak place is? The steaks are always perfectly done. Start your meal with the beet salad. It has whipped goat cheese which really elevated it. The surf and turf is a nice switch up from the usual steak. I have tried several of the sides, including risotto. However, I am usually so full a side isn't necessary. Order the donuts. They really are special! If you are local, you should consider signing up for the Carnevor Club. You get one point for every dollar spent. Once you get 250 points you receive $25 in rewards. read more

See all

This is our favorite date night spot. Great food, bougie atmosphere, awesome cocktails.

We celebrated our fifth wedding anniversary here. Whitney was our server and she was fabulous. My husband had the wagyu I have the prime fillet we had the mac & cheese with lobster and asparagus. Everything was phenomenal and we ended with crème brûlée and a very sleek sexy restaurant. We definitely will be back. read more

See all

After many years of a visit to Carnevore, I finally experienced a meal at Carnevore. The restaurant is smaller than I thought it would be and dark inside. There was very little room between our table of 6 people and the neighboring tables. The staff was attentive and polite. The steaks were cooked well, even the ones ordered filets ordered medium (gasp). The mushrooms were really good but tiny. We ordered the steak Tartare, which was okay. I had scallops with my NY strip, which were prepared well. Overall, I recommend it. It has a cozy ambiance and good option for steak. read more

See all

Service was good. I went for dinner alone and the hostess wasn't very helpful with trying to get me a seat in the bar area. My server Diane was amazing so she made up for their lack of enthusiasm. Food was yummy, steak booked well. The welcome bread was also fresh and delish. They ambience was nice, it feels upscale but a lot of the patrons were casually dressed. read more

Carnevor Steakhouse Moderne - Steakhouses Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Delicious! Delicious! Yes, it comes with a huge price tag but was it worth it. We enjoyed every bite. Service was great. Friendly staff, gave us tons of time to ourselves and checked in appropriately. Hard to choose from menu cause everything looked good. Tried bits and pieces things between the 2 of us. Couldn't find anything we disliked that we ordered except the free anniversary dessert was lackluster, but then again, it was free. We absolutely will be back and highly recommend. Again, the price is very spendy but well worth it for a special occasion! Happy eating! read more

See all

I walked in during a somewhat later hour (9ish-10) but we were accommodated well. Make sure to ask for bar seating if they say that the floor is unavailable. Our waiters were attentive despite being somewhat busy and helped us set down the tableware/changed plates when appropriate. The room itself has nice ambiance and isn't very loud. I'd say it's lively and nice to be in. Although I didn't directly converse with the bartender, they engaged in conversation with those looking for it and overall were friendly. The food is also good. However, it did take a very long time for it to come out. We waited for well over double the time we spent eating. The steak I ordered to share along with the BLT salad both of which were excellent. For the price, both of us were extremely satisfied (we had a bone-in cut, I can't really remember exactly which) It was just the wait which was on the longer side. I would revisit with my family! read more

Although this place is pricey the food is fantastic! I had some steak from my husband and pork from a friend, and both were tender and juicy. The waiter and staff were always checking on if we needed anything and were very polite. The decor was masculine and it was somewhat small inside but it wasn't noisy. You couldn't hear anyone else's conversation. If you have a special occasion coming up definitely go!! read more

Loved the atmosphere. Wait staff was extremely attentive. Food was AMAZING! Absolutely try the beet salad, dishes were innovative and unique! Wish I lived closer to eat here more often. read more

My group and I made a reservation for dinner on a weeknight. The restaurant was quite busy so it was very loud inside. The restaurant is dimly lit and it was kind of difficult for us to see the menu and in general. You get free bread and butter for the table once you are seated. We all ordered steak and Brussels sprouts and mash potatoes to share as recommended by our waiter (staff are attentive and helpful). Three of us ordered the NY strip steak, medium rare, and one person ordered the ribeye, medium rare. I guess the ribeye was cooked perfectly, but all the NY strip steaks were cooked rare, like unmistakably undercooked, even the fat wasn't cooked through yet. I wish I got a picture of it to show. But the steak was perfectly seasoned, no sauce is needed. The sides were ok, nothing special. read more

Carnevor Steakhouse Moderne - Steakhouses Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

This may easily be the best food I have ever had. First time here I was with two friends from work. We ordered some appetizers and got a wine selection from their Sommelier. The appetizers were rich and flavorful. Could be a meal itself. My ribeye was AMAZING! Perfectly seasoned and cooked. Had some mushroom risotto and asparagus with it. Oh, My. GOD! I was so impressed that I brought my wife back here for our anniversary. It is on the edge of being pricey. My wife was concerned about the price. I reassured her that I am worth it. read more

I made a reservation online for Saturday at 530 Pm for 2 people. The parking situation is horrible but they do have valet parking. We parked two blocks away in a public parking lot for $12 for two hours. When we walked in we were greeted by a hostess who sat us immediately. The restaurant is very dimly lit which gives it a very romantic vibe. Good place for an anniversary night. Our waiter came over and got our drink order within minutes of sitting down. My Prosecco was $14 but was amazing. You can order wine by glass or bottle. I ordered the 8 oz filet mignon which was divine. Best steak I've ever had. For sides we ordered truffle mashed potatoes and Brussel sprouts with bacon. Both sides I couldn't stop eating because they were so good. We were given dessert complimentary by our waiter. I didn't catch his name but he was great. read more

See all

Wow, is all I have to say. Everything about this meal from the romantic low lighting, the rustic cave-like decor, the amazing food.... The meal was pricey, but we went in with an open mind, since we were celebrating our anniversary and hardly ever get out without the kids. We started with lobster bisque. It was creamy and had a unique taste. We both really enjoyed the flavor combinations. For dinner, we both ordered the Japanese Wagyu after asking the server if she recommended the domestic Wagyu ribeye or the Japanese Wagyu. She had a very quick response to say Japanese, so we went with it (when in Rome, right?). The meat was melt in your mouth delicious. It was so tender and amazingly delicious. We were really glad we chose the Japanese! All of the sides we chose were good - we had crispy Brussel sprouts, butternut squash risotto and truffled mashed. The truffled mashed was THE BOMB. I could not stop eating it.... The texture was perfect and the flavors were so perfect. Highly recommend, if you like truffled flavor. For dessert, we went the ice cream route. It was creamy and delicious... nothing to write home about, but still very good. Definitely recommend this for steak lovers! read more

Carnevor Steakhouse Moderne - Japanese Wagyu Filet Mignon - Steakhouses Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Had dinner last night with a friend, amazing steak and excellent service. Not too many places can cook a juicy and tasty NY close to well done. 5 Stars all around! Kudos to the chef. read more

While visiting our son in Milwaukee, my wife and I stopped in as walk-ins on April 29, 2025. We were kindly greeted and told no seating was available, but we could sit at a corner table in the bar. Shortly after sitting down, we were greeted by a beautiful, professional young lady named "Gina V". From there forward, our experience was fantastic. As a retired NYPD Detective who has eaten all over the world, and is pretty skeptical to boot, I was beyond expectation. This is not your spot if you expect Texas Roadhouse on a budget. However, the food and ambience were top shelf and beyond expectations of anything a big city could provide...Bon Appetite! read more

Carnevor Steakhouse Moderne - Steakhouses Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Thanks Carnevor for making my birthday extra special! We arrived super early - 5pm when they opened, but I'm glad we did. We were able to enjoy some quiet time before the restaurant got busy. I loved the Carnevor martini - highly recommend. Our waiter, Will, was great at his job. We had several people stop by the table to help and offer bday wishes. The tomato mozzarella salad was the perfect place to start. Fresh and flavorful. I had the bone-in filet and my husband had the bone-in ribeye. Sides were yummy - risotto, potatoes, mushrooms. Removing a star because the shrimp I added on were almost inedible to me. They were so salty and overly grilled. Could use some acid to cut through the salt and burnt flavor. My husband ate them for me and said they were fine, so to each their own! Free dessert donuts were lovely and we liked the sauces. Price was steep but we had a lot of fun and felt well taken care of. Thanks again! read more

Carnevor Steakhouse Moderne - Steakhouses Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

5 of us dined on Saturday night. Two of us had Filets that were over-cooked, 2 steaks were fine, and the seafood entree was good. Granted, even at over-cooked they still tasted good. Our food was delivered by food runners to make sure it was hot, but our server didn't do her check back for a a little bit of time so by the time she asked how everything was, we said it was fine. Great dessert ($16). read more

Carnevor Steakhouse Moderne - a piece of chocolate cake on a plate - Steakhouses Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Dark, steakhouse ambience for a delicious dinner. Be sure to make a reservation. Food was made to perfection and service was kind and attentive. This place sure knows how to make a mean steak and I can't wait to get back to have more! read more

See all

Decided on Carnevor on our anniversary dinner spot and was not disappointed. The steaks were perfect, the service was excellent on a very busy night, and the wine selection was endless. Great experience! read more

Carnevor Steakhouse Moderne - 16oz Ribeye w/ garlic herb butter. - Steakhouses Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Carnevor was a great hidden gem! We started with the filet risotto and it was absolutely divine. I ordered the 5oz filet plate and it melted in my mouth- it was so tender. Our server was attentive and gave great recommendations for each course of the meal. If you're looking for a fancy date night- this a spot to check out! read more

See all

Great steakhouse in downtown Milwaukee! it doesn't really look like your classic steakhouse from the outside. Located in a bit of an up and coming area is this modern steakhouse. We made reservations to celebrate my husbands birthday, and upon arrival, he was treated with a "Happy Birthday!". They took our coats and lead us to our table. The decor is a bit cave themed and reminded me of the cave where the hyenas live in Lion King. After getting to our table and handed the menus, they really paid attention to detail and made you feel special, with a custom birthday menu. (Same menu, just with "Happy Birthday" along the top) served up with some warm bread and butter. So many great menu options! We got a bottle of wine from the expansive wine list. We both enjoyed a bowl of the Lobster Bisque and steak, with sides of mini twice baked potatoes, and sautéed mushrooms. Everything was so good! When we finished, they kept the birthday celebrations professional and brought out a plate with their donuts and various sauces. The donuts were a lot like beignets and served with chocolate, vanilla, berry sauce. Overall, we had a great time, the staff was super friendly and the service was great. read more

See all

Amazing place. Food is excellent. Our steak not quite right. They couldn't have been more concerned. Excellent care serving it just right. Will most definitely be back. Don't..no never miss dessert. To die for. read more

Wow! This place is awesome. I had the best bone-in ribeye ever. The flavor was on point!! Hubby had the bone-in filet and loved it. It's a day later and I'm still thinking about how good my steak was! Really good martinis too!! Eric was our server and he was great. Super helpful and knowledgeable about the menu. The atmosphere was really cozy and comfortable. We will definitely be back! read more

The service from Will was out of this world as he recommended several things but was not pushy. He never tried upselling our wine and was just pleasant even though we had a late reservation. The steaks (strip and filet) were both cooked perfectly and within steak prices for the cuts/type. The goat cheese salad was unique and tasty! Mac n cheese was nothing fancy but certainly a nice touch. Give this steakhouse a try for a quiet and great decor that makes you feel like a date night or for a big party... wow! read more

See all