Castaways is a nice little place with great decor. The ambiance and environment are great. I just wasnt overly impressed with the food. The food in my opinion was 3 stars but my waitress was phenomenal, which boosted the score up to a 4. I got the oysters rockafella and they were just OK. They tasted premade, frozen and deep fried when ordered. Did not taste fresh at all. Next i got the grouper imperial. This was better, the plating was awesome but still not what i was expecting. It just didnt taste fresh to me. Like i said the service was exceptional but the food just wasnt all that great. read more

See all

Had our first trio couple dinner out plus 1, so 7 total diners. Ashley was our server, she was spot on all night. Kept the drinks coming, was as kind as a neighbor and made us all happy this was our selected restaurant. Everyone was thrilled with their choices. My red snapper was to die for. Our party had red fish, salads, burgers and shrimp & grits. Party of seven and no complaints. To be honest, they seemed unstaffed, but that's to be expected now. The delay was actually a great thing, as visiting these faces was overdue. The fans were blowing, and bugs were abated. We tried to tip especially well. Parties can't filter through as fast with limited staff, we get it. We were so glad this was our first real "post" covid gathering. (Bless the vaccines!) read more

Castaways - Red Snapper - New American Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

We went here because The Driftaway was closed for the virus. They should take some lessons on fish sandwich from them. It wasn't bad, but it was just OK. Needed some better sauce on the bun. Fries were a bit undercooked. Wife had shrimp tacos, which she said were good. So, we'll have to think hard about going back. read more

Been here's couple times. Small place that fills up. Calamari is a winner. Service is directly tied to how crowded. Empty place excellent service, crowded and you're flagging down you server read more

A great hole in the wall with awesome service. I highly recommend the Yellow Curry shrimp and salmon!! read more

Castaways - Salmon and shrimp with yellow coconut curry - New American Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

Yum! So good and great service! The patio was in direct sunlight ~6pm with little airflow, but other than that it was fabulous! read more

Castaways - Maine Lobster Grilled Cheese Sandwich - New American Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

See all

Great place, is a Friday night so was busy. Live music playing, great atmosphere Wife have the fish and chip ,I had the fried shrimp both very very good. There is seating outside but this time of year The Sandgnats are bad. Check them out great place, will be back. read more

This was a Restaurant week visit with another couple. While most restaurant week menus offered an average of three entrée choices for this event, Castaways Sandfly offered five to satisfy a wide range of culinary appetites. The noise level as noted by other reviewers was noticeably higher than other restaurants, and I did have to lean over the table to talk and listen with other guests. However, this did not detract from the wonderful service and food provided. There is an exterior dining section available, along with a full bar and several televisions on the inside of the restaurant. I selected the firecracker shrimp, black and blue prime rib, and Bombay mango cheesecake for the evening meal. All of the items were excellently seasoned, and our server kept our glasses full and was very attentive. I enjoyed the evening as the food and staff it presented a wonderful atmosphere for everyone. I plan to revisit Castaways Sandfly very soon. read more

Castaways - Black and Blue Prime rib, roasted garlic potatoes, grilled asparagus spears, fried tobacco onions, blue cheese crumbles. - New American Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

See all

The entire menu sounded delicious. And everything we ordered was just as described and better!!! Definitely my new favorite resto and I am Glad I ventured out to find it since it is out of the way of mainstream Savannah food choices. Thinking of the Tuna tower is making me want to go back For dinner, and I was just there for lunch!!! I had the scored flounder and I left nothing but fish bones!! Sooo yummy!!! read more

Castaways - New American Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

See all

Restaurant Week was a bad time to visit. This is small establishment with an outdoor seating area. The indoor and outdoor area were packed to capacity. It was extremely noisy. We were unable to really enjoy our conversation. The door to the outside seating area was left open which made the inside very warm and welcomed flies in. This is extremely troublesome for me as I have a bit of a fly phobia, if that's a thing. The food was tasty but my mind was a bit hazy as I was competing with the little critters! The service was good. Our waitress was very familiar with the menu and was able to answer all of our questions. I would be willing to try again, only if the doors are closed! read more

Castaways - New American Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

See all

Looking for good She Crab soup and based on some recommendations here, went to Castaways. Bad decision. It could have come out of a can. However, Firecracker Shrimp Salad was excellent. Wife had BLT Crab sandwich. Felt that the crab cake had a lot of bread filler. Cole slaw side was excellent. We sat outside in the heat and even with fans blowing, we were inundated with flies. Hard to eat chasing flies off the food. Our server, Cole, was excellent, quick and efficient. read more

Family-owned and operated; great selection of food and drink; and an inviting bar where you can while away an hour or so with a cold draft. read more

Castaways - New American Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

We love this place!! It's local and has an amazing chef. Everything is great! My favorite appetizer for sharing is the tuna tower, it so fresh and flavorful. The tuna tacos are also amazing! The kids love the fish and chips and the nachos. read more

Castaways - Tuna Tower - New American Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

After a disappointing meal on the river walk, this was exactly what I was looking for! Amazing food, terrific service. My only disappointment is I don't have time to eat here again before I leave. read more

Castaways - Tybee Tuna - New American Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

The staff was so sweet to my pup when we came in for dinner one night. We sat on the patio and enjoyed a nice night. Food is pretty standard bar/basic seafood. What really sells this place is the local feel and the lovely staff. read more

There were literally only probably 10 people in the whole place. I sat at the bar. The waitress was nice but, She never came back to check on me if I needed anything. She was at the end of the bar talking to I guess regulars, which is fine but, when you have people waiting to check out and you see that they're ready to check out and you're not taking care of your tables then there's a problem, the firecracker shrimp were disgusting and the fries were cold and hard. I'm sure that they have good food there, but what I had was not. read more

Nice restaurant scene with some indoor (and bar seating) as well as outdoor seating. Nestled in a shopping center, Castaways has a nice chill ambiance about it. I was invited out for a going away dinner and this place definitely worth the wait. Service: excellent. Even though the place was full, our sever never left us waiting for anything. Fast. Efficient. Friendly. Drinks: the bar is full up, feel free to ask for your favorite libation. There are TVs at the bar too so you can watch your favorite sports team. Menu/food: the menu is extensive and chocked full of delicious choices. I ordered the tuna tower and the calamari. Both were large enough portions by themselves to be a meal, but I was starving...so I ate them both. ;) The tuna tower was fantastic, fresh (not fishy flavored I.e. old tuna) the spicing was spot on and the amount of tuna was a pleasant surprise. The calamari was lightly battered (thank god! I'm not asking for onion rings yah know ) and had a wonderful spicy chimichurri sauce (don't freak out it's not THAT spicy ) All-in-all a good place to bring friends and family for a good seafood meal. Come early...this place gets packed fast!!! read more

Food and service was great. Inside seating is a little loud, I would opt for outside.

I ordered a calamari chimichurri appetizer. The calamari was served on thick layer of mayo based sauce even though it was not listed in the ingredients on the menu. There was very little chimichurri even thought it was in the dish's name. As someone who does not like mayo it was disappointing to be served a dish that has heavy mayo even though it was not on the menu. read more

Castaways - Calimari Chimichurri - New American Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

It was good food but the service was struggling that night. My shrimp Caesar salad was sad. The shrimp were tiny and the salad felt soggy. The she crab soup was just okay. My wife's mahi salad was really good. My other dining companions enjoyed their selections, so maybe I chose poorly. There are a lot of things they seemed to not be able to make at the bar, like a mojito. Maybe it was an off night? Either way I wasn't impressed. Will try again another time and pass on the Caesar. But we're not in a hurry. read more

I live in Charlotte, NC but have family in Savannah, so I visit fairly often. My sister doesn't eat fish, can you imagine? So I tried Castaways for a solo lunch. Facebook friends kept posting how fabulous this place is, but Savannah being a tourist town I was skeptical. Off the beaten tourist path towards the southside, you have to be willing to drive or Uber out here. The lunch menu seems abbreviated, so you may want to try them for dinner. The place is TINY but has a decent size outside area. And it was difficult to find as its tucked away in a strip mall. I drove the parking lot 5 times and almost gave up. I persisted and found they were BETWEEN two of the buildings near a chicken and waffles place. See photos Service at noon on Saturday was friendly and prompt as it was still fairly early for a sarurday. After contemplating the lunch menu - tacos, sandwiches and apps dominate - I settled on one of the few full entree options. Blackened Red Fish over rice and green beans with a mango salsa. The plating was beautiful and the portion large! And to my surprise, it was absolutely delicous! There were also 4 blackened shrimp included...SCORE! There is really nothing bad I can say about this dish. I'm SUPER critical when it comes to entrees in the $20+ range, but this was worth it at around $20. I wish I had saved room for dessert. This will be one of my go to spots when I'm in town! I imagine at prime time there is a wait so be prepared. Worth it. read more

See all

Stopped in with a group for Savannah Restaurant Week 2018. And must I admit what a blast. Simply finding this restaurant was a treasure hunt. Out of all the years I lived in Savannah I've never knew this place existed. As we drove past we caught wind of the sign then it seemed to disappear. So make sure you remember that the restaurant is located in the courtyard behind Loc's Chicken and Waffles. As we walked in the restaurant the space was slightly smaller than expected but the walls had the most unique mural on all the walls. Absolutely stunning! While we waited for our table we headed to the bar to grab a drink. I grabbed a glass of Pinot Noir ($9 a glass) and within 10 minutes our table was ready. We were given the regular menu along with the Restaurant week menu and I went to town. For an appetizer I ordered the Firecracker Shrimp, entree I ordered the Grouper Imperial, and for dessert I went for the Key Lime. The appetizers came out first as always. The Restaurant week appetizer is slightly different. The restaurant scales it back so you can sample different menu items. The presentation was amazing but the flavors seemed to lack. The sauce was reminiscent of Chick-Fil-A sauce but not as bold. I ended up trying my friends Ahi Tuna Tartare and I was in love. The ginger, seaweed salad, and the tuna made the dish delicious. I really wanted to switch dishes but I didn't. Next the entrees. When the Grouper Imperial arrived to the table it was gorgeous. The colors were vibrant the and the presentation was to die for. One bite and I melted. Whatever sauces they drizzled over the dish was phenomenal. I literally ate the entire plate! The last dish came out and it was the Key Lime pie. Again the presentation was awesome. However as a suggestion the restaurant can scale back the whipped cream. I want the flavor of the pie not the whipped cream. Excited to try I took a bite and I seemed to search for the tartness of the Lime. The flavors weren't bold enough to call it Key Lime. More along the lines of a cheesecake with hints of lime. Overall the restaurant deserves a B+. The hostess Charlotte was very courteous and she moved quickly to prepare us a table, the murals on the walls are inviting and I cannot wait for the summer time to see the restaurant with the doors open, the Ahi Tuna is worth the try (especially is you like Asian flavors), and the Grouper Imperial was one of the most amazing dishes I've had in a long time. Pitfalls, the restaurant is smaller but lively, the Key Lime dessert could use a "recipe-lift", and the restaurant requires a keen eye to find. Either way I'm coming back for that Grouper. read more

See all

Second time in for lunch! Loved the tuna tower, calamari, and buffalo shrimp during our first visit! The tuna and shrimp were fresh and perfect! The calamari has a new twist on the old boring and has a delicious sauce. Today we had lunch again! There's casual in the door seating as well as outdoor seating. They have heaters to keep you cozy warm if you choose to sit outside. The Crabcake BLT had plenty of crabmeat! The fish sandwich was made with grouper today! The buns are soft and warm served with warm food items, great care in the little things make a difference! Service on both occasions was exceptional! Friendly and helpful staff that work as a team! read more

See all

You can't beat the food served here - it's excellent and portions are perfect. The fish sandwich is the best I've ever had. You have to try the lobster grilled cheese sandwich. The full plates can't be beat; there is a wide choice of sides and appetizers. Cocktails are excellent. Eat inside or outside! I'm read more

Castaways is supposed to be a top recommended restaurant suggested by locals. Well the locals know what they are talking about !!! Lots of choices on the menu, I wanted shrimp, so I ordered the shrimp platter with rice and the cucumber / jalapeño slaw. They also have a great beer selection, I chose Creature Comforts Tropicalia, one of the best beers out there from Athens, Georgia. Friendly waitress, took my order and was quickly served my hot meal. Everything was fresh and delicious, loved the shrimp and really loved the cole slaw, one of the best I have ever had, great flavor. The rice was very good too, nice compliment to the meal. Usually I don't get desert, but since the meal was so good I opted for the Key Lime Pie. A huge slice arrived and it did not disappoint, yum !!! I'm all about small business owners, this one knows how to run a show. Sandfly is an interesting little community just outside Savannah too. read more

This place is exceptional! Our first time here I had a salad with crab cake and mango something. My husband had tuna tower. We both thought our meals were fresh and delicious. The menu has wonderful fresh seafood Our bartender Shannon was so pleasant and friendly. I would return for her alone. Definitely a place to come back to read more

Food was very good and hot. Service was terrible. There were 4 girls working and maybe 10 people total at the bar and restaurant. We were there early. We waited at least 10 minutes before a waitress came to our table. She didn't see us-----what? Did I mention there were like 10 people there and it's a small restaurant. Ordered and had to listen to the girls at the bar complaining about another girl that worked there rather loudly. Got our food had to ask for napkins and silverware. Never got a drink refill. Had the place been packed I would have had a different experience there was just no excuse for the service that we received. We won't be back read more

Umm drove out of our way to eat here bc of reviews from a local write up. NO!!!! Food is just ok at best. My shrimp and scallop scampi looked like something from a frozen food dinner. Terrible. I sent it back and didn't even eat dinner. My daughter's and husband's food was just ok. Extremely disappointing food read more

Good food, services excellent, prices good, parking is easy. Good place to meet friends.

The food is always good and sometimes even better here. The inside is beautifully decorated and the wall murals are extraordinary. There is a good selection of affordable wines and a very good selection of beers including on tap. They have a good assortment of bartenders with engaging personalities. It's full of regular customers and sometimes it's a little tough to climb through that crowd to get to the bar, but I guess that's a good problem for them to have. The male waiter that's been there for a while - I can't remember his name - tall guy - is really good at his job - efficient but friendly. My ONLY complaint is that whenever they prepare a dish with shrimp they always leave the tails on. Imagine how frustrating it is to dig shrimp out of a shrimp and grits dish! read more

You would never think that you would get the quality of food you get from this hole in the wall place. It was extremely good! The service was spot on and the atmosphere was fun and casual. I would highly recommend the calamari if you like that! read more

Excellent service and the food was delicious. We all ordered different items so we could sample several dishes. There are way too many delicious choices to choose just one dish for yourself! The best dish is the shrimp and grits. The hog fish over mashed potatoes was the best we have had. The scallop carbanara was delicious and filling. The guys raved over the steaks. The flash fried scallops were amazing. The mac and cheese was a big hit as a side dish! We will for sure be going back to this lovely restaurant! read more

I really really like their food and the location is super convenient for a bite. My wife and I just went, waited 5 minutes to be seated at the host stand with no line in front of us. It's a weekend, it's a weird time so I get it. Not ideal, but it's understandable. Our hostess sits us at our table of choice outside but neglects to leave us menus. The waitress taking care of the table directly next to ours looks our way and never approached us. Ok, that's fine, it might not have been her table in rotation. We continue to sit as people are continuously led to other tables and provided menus while we still have not had a word sent our way. Now I'm typing a petty review as I eat my entree at Tequilas Town next door in less time than I was ignored at Castaways. I'll be back for Castaways nachos eventually. read more

1st time there. Great Tuna Tower and fresh cocktails. Service was very friendly and a wonderful experience. A bit confusing to find the front door but after 1st time, no problems. read more

Excellent butterfly shrimp. The best thing on the menu. Coleslaw is very spicy with a horseradish type dressing. Rice is good. Hub said fried fish was ok. But he really liked the shrimp much better. Fries were excellent. read more

Wow! This place is a hidden gem. We got the tuna steak appetizer and it was INCREDIBLE. I could've made a meal out of it. Cooked to perfection. My husband and I both got the surf and turf entree, the steak was perfectly cooked, the shrimp perfectly grilled and the sauce was delicious. We will definitely be coming back! read more

Great food and service. Beautiful mural on the wall. Appetizer of crab cakes was a perfect lunch portion. The Beer Batter Fish and Chips was enough for two to share. Fries are homemade and so big. Watermelon Margarita was a perfect afternoon cocktail. This is a hidden gem and a must go to. Hidden in a shopping center but so worth the drive. read more

Yellowfin tuna bites were very good! Also the crab cake BLT was spot on. Mac and cheese was ok, and the fries although they looked good, didn't have much taste. Still deff worth going to for the fresh seafood! read more

We were in the area and were looking for some good food before we hit the road. We had a little trouble finding the place, but I am so glad we did. I had the shrimp and grits special. It was phenomenal!! My husband had the shrimp and grits the night before at Alligator Soul. They were good, but in my opinion these were better. My husband had the bolognese, which was also amazing. We'll be back! read more

The atmosphere is kind of casual for the price point. If I'm spending $80 for dinner for two, I expect cloth napkins and a table that doesn't wobble. As far as the food, the chef needs to get over his love affair with too much garlic and jalapeños. The former shouldn't be so heavy handed that it's the only thing that you taste in the salad. The jalapeños have no place in either an Imperial sauce or a Ponchartrain. I ordered snapper Ponchartrain and I couldn't taste the fish, the shrimp, the mushrooms, or the wine in the sauce. And I pulled out all the chiles I could see in the dish. Overall, our experience was a major disappointment. read more