I was so happy to find a Cattleman's Roadhouse location nearby when I was working in the area. Unfortunately my food wasn't as good as my meals at other locations. I ordered online for carry out. The bread and green beans were delicious. But the salmon was terribly overcooked and dry. Usually, I love salmon from Cattleman's as it is always cooked just right and very flavorful. But this salmon was cooked to well done and was tough and flavorless. Some of the toppings I had ordered for my baked potato were missing and the green onions had spilled in the bag because the lid wasn't on properly. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The interior was very nice, clean, and well decorated.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Service was friendly. I do love cattleman's, so I plan to give this location another try. Hopefully it was just a bad day in the kitchen. read more

See all

Wife and I arrived before noon, but had a guest joining us, who arrived at 1215. We were seated and brought some drinks, rolls and butter. Tyler is our very cordial and patient server. The cook staff was short today, so food took a while to arrive. My Angus burger and extra crispy fries were perfect. Burger had a nice charbroil flavor. Wifey and guest ordered salad bar with side of chicken. They both liked the salad bar, but neither liked the chicken much. There is a dog at home getting the leftover chicken. read more

See all

We were asked to wait because of shift change right when we walked in the door, not a good sign. [[HIGHLIGHT]]We were seated in a back bar area.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Our server was pleasant and took our drink order promptly. Then a second server introduced herself after explaining she didn't know why but they would be sharing duties. Okay. The main reason I returned to Cattleman's was because I had a delicious fried pork chop at the same restaurant but a different location 3 months prior and I couldn't stop thinking it. I ordered the same here. When it was served it was nothing like my previous. It was wet, with no breading or batter. Not crunchy. The chop was still moist but very disappointing. The service was erratic with a young man announcing they were understaffed. When I asked why there was a difference to our server she questioned if my photo from the previous experience was photoshopped. LoL, I took the photograph. The salad bar was still very good. Just disappointing. read more

Cattleman's Roadhouse - Fried Porkchop - American Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

I love a restaurant where you can get a nice salad bar with your meal. There's not a lot of those types place left, it seems. I'm sure the pandemic did a number on that type of place. So when I heard this place featured one, I was eager to give it a try. And the salad bar here lives up to my expectations. It was well stocked and maintained. But no one in my party was particularly thrilled with their main dish. My steak was on the bland side. No one had bad food. Everyone's was just okay. Ultimately, there are just better places you can go. read more

Cattleman's Service has gone so far downhill. The last time we were able to sit down and eat, the server showed up one time and that's was because I asked for the check. Not a single refill, not a check on the food. Today, on Father's Day, we were put on the list with a 45 minute wait. They called us after about 50 minutes, and we all gathered (Party of 7) just to be told they made a mistake and put 2 instead of 7. Kicking us another 45 minutes. We decided it was best to just leave. We most certainly will not be back. read more

Met a friend here for a weekday lunch at noon and easily found parking. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The place is usually packed, but was only half-full today and not surprising after a long holiday weekend (Labor Day).[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Immediate seating in a comfortable booth.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Service was attentive and not rushed. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Noise level was mild and easily able to hold a normal inside-voice conversation.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I was tempted to get the salad bar, but decided to order the bruschetta chicken from the Lighter Options section of the menu -- a grilled chicken breast topped with basil pesto bruschetta and a choice of side (plain baked sweet potato). The topping was very flavorful and a bit more oily than I would have expected, as well as the potato being buttered when baked, so I'm glad I at least attempted to make a healthy choice. I did give in and also sampled a roll from the basket brought to the table and even added a schmear of cinnamon butter -- delicious and yeasty. Great value and reasonable compared to similar sit down venues. read more

Cattleman's Roadhouse - Menu, side 1 -- September 2024 - American Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

See all

We have been wanting to visit Cattleman's Roadhouse, and we got a chance on an apparently slow night. The décor was as expected for a steak place -- a lot of pine wood. We were sat in the bar area, which was in the back. Unfortunately, were we near the door the employees used to go out and smoke. Our waiter was also the bartender. I ordered the 7 ounce Top Sirloin. I wasn't anything special, but it was perfectly OK. It was cooked properly but lacked flavor. read more

Cattleman's Roadhouse - Bar area - American Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

Food and service were great. Great way to spend my birthday. Most of our order was cooked as ordered. My husband ordered his steak blue and it was more medium rare. read more

My husband and I had the pleasure of eating at Cattleman's Roadhouse. The gets a 5 star review. I ordered the Tomato Basil chicken. My husband ordered The Chopper. We both added the salad bar. Their salad bar had so many choices. Plus so many options for dressing. We had a most delightful server. Her name is Savanna. She was one of the most upbeat person I have seen in a long time. Savanna was very professional and friendly. I highly recommend this establishment. read more

Went here for my father's birthday dinner and the food was delicious. We were sat promptly at a booth in the bar area. Our waitress (Michelle ) was great and very attentive and even picked up that it was my dad's birthday without us specifically telling her. They have another gentleman named Connor who brought out our food and he was very friendly and quick to help remove plates when bringing out your main course. All in all food was good and service was great! I would definitely recommend this place. read more

We visited Cattleman's on a Saturday night. We had to wait about 30 minutes for a table, but that was ok. Our 1st visit to this location was good. The server took our drink order but didn't retirn for 10 minutes to get our food order. No rolls were available. Our entrees took awhile. The salad bar was good but needed to have things refilled like lettuce and several of the ready made salads. Our medium steaks were medium rare but we weren't checked on to tell anyone. I was trying to ask for rolls for 15 minutes. We finally got our rolls after we finished our meal. I guess it was our dessert. There was a server running around getting drinks & rolls for her customers. The food was okay except for the steaks being undercooked. We really enjoyed Cattlemen's before this visit. We have been to several different ones. We will definitely go to a different one next time! read more

I ordered the daily special which was the country fried steak. I only ordered it because it came with the salad bar, which is $5 add on otherwise, and I figured it would be good. Well it was really bad. It had to be a frozen store bought piece of meat, something that you would get at a school cafeteria, and the gravy was unflavored. I don't usually complain and give multiple chances, but the past two times were not very good. I love the salad bar, but I don't think an extra $5 makes it worth it. Longhorns steaks are better and cheaper when you add the $5 up charge. read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]It was very busy.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Sat at the bar. Two bartenders worked very well together and communicated to cover the whole bar area. The whole staff worked together to make it a good experience even though it was high volume. Even saw the manager pop in to help them do dishes. Food came out good as usual but the staff impressed us! Great job! read more

Today was a terrible experience. We were there at 12:30. My silverware was dirty. The rolls were flat and completely dried out. The waitress said that they all looked like that. We got salad bar and had to wait a good 10 minutes just for lettuce. After watching the salad bar being refilled we totally lost our appetite. Touching each spoon with her gloves and reaching into the eggs with same glove to loosen them up...using a rag to wipe off the surrounding surface and then the plates below. I just want to say we are not those normally picky people. It was a good run while it lasted. read more

Food was prepared very well for carry out! Very tasty a prepared as ordered. The hostess staff were pleasant and very helpful!

The food was terrific, really fresh expansive salad bar and our waitress was very attentive and friendly. I always ask for extra butter on a baked potato but they gave plenty of sour cream and butter. read more

Quick easy and delicious salad bar and char grilled burgers. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Friendly staff found here in a clean establishment tucked in a side street off Charlestown Rd.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Do not go to this restaurant. They have extremely rude service. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Open seating in bar is limited to a very few tables and if they dont have enough servers they will make you move to another table.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Asked for a receipt last time and had to hunt down server to bring it to me. She got real nasty because i asked for a receipt. Management needs to take a real hard look at how they are running this restaurant. In this day and age i can spend my money elsewhere. read more

We waited several months to finally try this steakhouse due to how crowded it's been since opening. We stopped in on a Thursday night and were seated right away at a table in the bar area. After being seated, it was 20+ minutes before anyone acknowledged us, brought menus, it took drink orders. Once our drinks and rolls came out, it took another 15 minutes for a different waitress to take our order. We ordered a steak, the grilled salmon with bourbon glaze, and both got a baked potato. We also both added the salad bar after hearing rave reviews about it. We proceeded to the salad bar, where an employee was refilling all the salad ingredients -- dumping plastic pales of cheese, dressing, etc. into the containers. Obviously the dressings here aren't made in-house, and nothing on the salad bar is chopped or sliced, it's all pre-packaged. Overall salad bar impression: lettuce was fresh, ranch dressing was not to our taste. Tasted like bottled dressing, like Kraft. Won't get again, especially not for an upcharge. As far as entrees, they were very generic? I guess that's the word I'm looking for. The steak was bland, the salmon was decent but the bourbon glaze kind of killed it for me -- it tasted like a cheap glaze out of a packet or something. Following our meal, it took almost 30 minutes to get our check and finally pay so we could leave. This entire meal and service was a huge disappointment, especially for $70. Will not return. This is a knock-off steakhouse with cheap ingredients from a food service supplier. read more

See all

We were traveling and wanting something that was not fast food. After continuing to drive for over an hour, we saw the sign for this place. We had the lunch sirloin special and it was delicious. Very tender and perfectly done steak. Salad bar was great. Service also good. We will try to find another one in our travels! read more

Love this place! Awesome salad bar and excellent food. Prices are pretty good, too. Must try this place!

Great salad bar - always on my to do list when we head there for a family meal. Service is always pleasant and the price is nice for the wallet read more

Food was a tad bit price. However the portion sizes made up for it. Our server was very friendly and attentive to detail. [[HIGHLIGHT]]overall the atmosphere was nice and very clean.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] definitely will be back again. read more

Today was a great day for steak and we decided Cattleman's Roadhouse.Service was excellent and the atmosphere calming.I ordered the top sirloin steak(The Sheriff 20oz). It was tender,delicious and man I enjoyed eating that steak. read more

Cattleman's Roadhouse - 20 oz Sirloin Steak - American Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

Food Auful. Salad bar used to be the best around. No more, Brown lettuce, Soupy Cole slaw,Potato salad tasted old and Rotten, over all salad bar was a mess. Stake was Ok, Frys over cooked and tasted like a wild boar. Your oil needs changed badly. Waitress told the manager several groups of people were complaining, He or She never came out. Its the managers fault, For not over looking over the resteraunt operations.3 pm jun 27 2025 read more

It was nice inside and had good service all around. Steak was okay, didn't have much flavor going for it. Will most likely come back to try some of the other things on the menu. read more

Cattleman's Roadhouse - 10oz Sirloin - American Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

Great food. Great service. [[HIGHLIGHT]]A country setting on the inside.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Plenty of seating with a great salad bar.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Great salad bar, all our steaks were perfectly cooked and seasoned, [[HIGHLIGHT]]excellent family friendly atmosphere[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]].

Short staffed at the bar. Nice when he was available. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Definitely seems like a local place.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Not sure if they are part of the national chain but no bread and no salad bowl. Steak was average. We'll see I I go back. read more

Food service at Cattleman's Roadhouse was very efficient and we enjoyed the fresh salad bar for lunch. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The restaurant did seem to need a little bit of housekeeping (dusting, mopping), but it wasn't enough to detract from the rustic character.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Menu prices were surprisingly fair too. read more

I have ordered take out twice, first they messed it up a little bit, second time they were not even close to getting it right. Called them and was told they would send gift certificates and have not heard in 4 weeks. Can't recommend read more

Delicious steaks, some of the best we've had for a long time. Plus they had a wonderful salad bar for less than $5 to add to your meal. They also had daily specials (like 6oz steak, fried chicken, or country fried steak) that included the all-you-can eat salad bar for around $15. Definitely a place we will visit again when in the area. read more

Went in to this place after a sales call day, was greeted immediately at the door. The hostess asked me if I would like to go to the bar area which I did. I sat immediately and was quickly offered to order drinks. The restaurant was spotless with a cool vibe. The Server/Bartender Brandon is completely on top of his game. One of the best severs I've had in a while. He offered suggestions for steaks. I said I was rather hungry. He suggested the Sheriff, which is a 20oz sirloin and was cooked to perfection. Thanks Brandon for making the experience fun and entertaining. If in New Albany, look up Brandon and order the Sheriff. read more

Stopped by Cattleman's for lunch. Had the black and bleu burger and the unlimited salad bar. The waitress, Vanessa, brought us some rolls with cinnamon butter and kept our glasses of water filled. She was very attentive. The salad bar had quite a few choices and the blue cheese dressing was good. The burger was cooked nicely and very tasty. Will have to return and dry a steak for dinner. read more

It's great to have Cattleman's join the southern Indiana food lineup! I've eaten at other cattlemen locations and enjoyed every visit! Tonight was no exception. Prompt greet at the door (no wait) for a table we were set immediately. Our server was great. She took drink and app orders on her first visit to the table..this is a steakhouse so eat steak! I had the 7oz sirloin cooked to perfection with a side of white Mac and cheese. Presentation was appetizing the food was great! Prior to your meal you get to graze the salad bar..seriously I could eat just salads here a lot of choices on salad bar..fresh greens veggies, fruit and they had beets! I love those nasty tasting beets! Our service stayed consistent the food was great. I dined with three other guest, there wasn't a complaint. As usual we will be back, welcome to Southern Indiana we are glad you are here! read more

We live the salad bar...it is always fresh! Meals are reasonably priced. Clean bathrooms.

Love the salad bar which has a reasonable price of $9.99 on its own. Included free with daily specials and around an additional $5 for other entrees. Prices are very reasonable with good sized portions. We take advantage of salad bar and take the entree home for a 2nd meal. read more

Cattleman's Roadhouse - Chopped Steak - American Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

See all

Really good steakhouse that we enjoy going to for dinner. They have good prices on their steaks and taters. Before covid they had unlimited trips to the awesome salad bar. We need covid gone so we can get that going again. This is a great place to go to. Go check it out read more

First time eating here. My brother's and I brought my dad here for his 74th birthday. I arrived first, about 15 minutes before. I procured a seat for us. Not once during that 15 minutes did I see a waitress after being seated. My father and younger brother came in next and was seated. After about another 10 minutes my other brother joined us. Again no waitress. It was not until I caught attention of a waitress did we get waited on. It was my understanding the waitress who was to take our table was doing other things. The one who did serve us was great. What started out as a bad outing became one that was worth the frustration. The steak was tender and seasoned just right. I ordered it medium rare and it came out correctly. I had fries that I can only describe as some of the best I have had for a steak house. I look forward to going back and hopefully get a even better experience. read more

Cattleman's Roadhouse - The 20 Oz sheriff. - American Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

Second visit to Cattleman's Roadhouse in New Albany, IN. Good steak and excellent salad bar. Nothing fancy here, as you will see by the food photos, but you will get a good tasting steak for a decent price. Good yeast rolls with butter & honey butter. I had the Tender Tips with onions & Mushrooms & a plain sweet potato. Mike had the Cattleman's Sirloin with a buttered baked potato.Of course, you don't get to fix your own salad at the salad bar, but it is not a disappointment. Lots of choices. Our server's name tag said, "Beef." Beef was very pleasant & did an excellent job checking on us. I notice there were 3 large parties. They are social distancing well. Oh, if it's cold outside, don't sit by a window. You will be eating with your coat on. read more