Best Italian food I've had in a while. Our little secret spot in broken arrow. Food took a while to get to the table but one of the best chicken Marsala I've ever had in my life. Seating is very limited recommended to go early or call ahead. read more

The service was excellent and the food was even better. Their desserts are a must, we tried cheesecake and their Italian cream cake and even being full we found room for every bite. Will be back for sure. read more

Excellent chicken picatta! The owner was very nice and his service was excellent. Lovely evening for my husband and me.

Excellent food, excellent service. We always enjoy eating here. What more is there to be said? read more

farfelle was so good!! ravioli was so good also!! my favorite meal ive had in a long time!! one of the best small italian restaurants, will definitely be reccomending to friends and family!! read more

Cheri Ann's Trattoria - Italian Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

My mother and I went there for early dinner. We shared the pork loin. It took forever to get our food. The pork was WAY overcooked. On the bright side, the waiter, bless his heart, was very attentive. But I Wll Never Go Back. read more

The dining area is small so you'll want to make a reservation during busy times, but the food is amazing. I've enjoyed everything I have had there especially the chicken marsala, but it's all been excellent. The kids meal is also of ample portion for most kids appetites. read more

Cheri Ann's is by far the best food in the Tulsa metro area. My family has been coming here since they've opened. Over all the years they've been open the food is consistent, made from passed down recipes. I'm a customer for life! We moved away two years ago and drove back from Ohio to see her and eat her food! I look forward to eating here again and again! read more

We have been wanting to eat here for years and finally got to go today. We were not even able to get in the door when an employee came out to have my walker dependent handicapped friend re-park his truck. The handicapped parking was blocked by a large SUV and we were forced to park in a regular spot in front of the building. The truck was parked between the lines and the employee was very rude. We left and ate at Ti Amos downtown where they are more than accommodating to the needs of handicapped people. If that is how this establishment renders customer service to a handicap person, I recommend people go elsewhere. We will not be returning. read more

Cute little place with great food! Reservations are recommended due to the small size, but it is worth it!

Family run and very small. Need reservations. Limited menu but thoughtful and well presented. Not your typical place to eat but highly recommended. read more

AMAZING!!! Everything we have eaten here has been wonderful! The service is also wonderful! You must give this place a try!

Probably my favorite Italian restaurant. The food is always delicious. I've tried almost everything on the menu and have been pleased with every dish. They have daily specials and they are always amazing. I love their bruschetta and the tomato soup. My favorite dish is probably the spaghetti and meatballs. It's s family owned business and they treat people like family when visiting. Quaint space with delicious food and great customer service. I would strongly recommend trying it out read more

See all

I decided to Propose to my girlfriend at Here at Cheri Ann's. I would like to personal thank the staff and employees For making it a special and memorable night for both me and my new fiancé. y'all are always going to be a great Family owned date night restaurant for us and many more couples. It couldn't have been any better and I wish I could have paid more. read more

See all

Cheri Ann's is a cute, small restaurant just off the main part of downtown. The decor is very minimal but nice. Decent wine selection. The food is good.... Not amazing, not the best Italian you'll have for a long time, or anything like that. It was just good. You could easily achieve the same flavors by opening jars of sauce from Walmart and boiling some boxed pasta. If you're looking for a decent Italian meal, then hit it up. If you're looking for something that's going to teleport you to Italy, try somewhere else. read more

Such a cute little restaurant. You will definitely want to make reservations though! Great food and spectacular service!

After seeing that this restaurant was voted the best in the burbs, we knew we had to try it. It does have limited seating and limited menu choices but there was no limit on the culinary talent here. My wife is a big fan of Chicken Marsala and she said this was the best she'd ever had. I had the Pork Loin Chops and they were awesome. The dinner salads and bruschetta along with the service were all excellent. We felt it was reasonably priced. No room for dessert so will have that on the next visit. read more

The place is quaint, kind of small, but cozy. The food is best described as comfort food and was tasty, although the mashed potatoes were overrun with Rosemary. The meal was served on plastic plates and plastic water glasses. The wait staff needs a little bit of work on basic customer service. Please learn how to serve a bottle of wine and don't ask customers to hand over the dirty dishes. I felt they were rushing us to be done and out of there by 9 p.m. read more

Cheri Ann's Trattoria - Spaghetti and meatballs - Italian Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

See all

Very small dining area. Nice but can get very loud. Food was good. Limited menu. I personally think $11.00 is a bit much to pay for spaghetti with marinara sauce. Grandson rated it a 5 with a 10 being excellent. Waitress was very quiet and hard to understand. Needs to speak up especially when it gets loud. read more

With all the "great" reviews from what I assume are locals, I'd rather not tear this place apart. I had the chicken piccata. Who doesn't tenderize and pound out a chicken breast when making chicken piccata?!?! The meat was chewy and too thick. The sauce and pasta were just OK, not bad. The menu said bread was included. We got our salads, no bread. I asked the waitress for bread and she said that they had to charge $0.50 each for the bread?!? ...and they did. Sad, sad breadstick ...sub-par to even Olive Garden. Probably food service crap not made in house. Then the main meal showed up with another breadstick (apparently that's the "included" one). The place is very plain, no decor at all. It echoed in there terribly and having a conversation with my guest was difficult. I certainly won't give this place another chance. read more

Food is authentic and very yummy!!! Service is outstanding! Small and quaint inside and the Building is adorable!

Food sub par, atmosphere fair Nice people but need a lot of help with quality of food, presentation and menu Felt like I got microwaved food 20 min's leaving to get home and extremely sick Wont go back read more

We chose this restaurant because my name is Sheri Ann AND SO HAPPY WE DID! It's a clean, quaint place with excellent and friendly service. The food was delicious, a lot of it, and reasonably priced. My husband and I are visiting the area on business but will definitely return next time we're in town. read more

I really wanted to love this place but the food just isn't that good. The service is good and our server was friendly. We ordered the bruschetta and it was very plain, under seasoned and strong hits of raw garlic. The toasted rounds were good but the dish needs olive oil, balsamic and fresh basil. Next was the tomato Florentine soup and it was odd and not anything I was expecting. It was nice and hot but the flavor was sweet and did not compliment our wine. We shared the Farfalle pasta (bow tie) in cream sauce and added chicken. The portion was huge and plenty for us to share between the two of us. However, the chicken was bone dry and the cream sauce was very bland. The pasta was cooked el dente and was good but overall this experience was disappointing. The dinner salad that came with the pasta was fresh, crisp and good but had more iceberg lettuce than anything else. This place has potential, they just need a better wine selection and better food. Especially, with the limited menu offerings, all of their dishes should taste AMAZING!!! read more

See all

This was a our first time and it was absolutely PHENOMENAL!!! My husband isn't an Italian fan and he was surprised at how much he enjoyed the meal!! This place is worth every bite!! This is a MUST for anyone who love authentic Italian food! read more

Absolutely wonderful food! Inside seating is limited but well worth the wait ! So fresh and never disappointing, cheesecake is also amazing! Must try read more

Omggg the food.....just AMAZING and we had the best server Marcus, thank you for making us feel at home!

Cute little family owned Italian restaurant with great food! The meatball appetizer was yum and flavorful. The marinara sauce had a little sweetness to it, and the white wine sauce was very good. Pasta cooked perfectly (al dente). We will be back for sure! So glad we came across this place. read more

Second visit to Cheri Ann's Trattoria did not disappoint. Cozy place with a small, well executed menu is just the fit for the Rose District in Downtown Broken Arrow. There is some serious experience behind this endeavor and it's apparent in the food. Take a chance on this little gem, but you might want to call ahead because it's small and the word will get out. read more

Trattoria- A trattoria is an Italian-style eating establishment, less formal than a restaurant. There are generally no printed menus, the service is casual, wine is sold by the decanter rather than the bottle, prices are low, and the emphasis is on a steady clientele rather than on haute cuisine. Cheri A's is definitely small and informal. When I say small it is small like maybe 12-15 tables. They do take reservations which we found on arrival so if you do decide to go I would call ahead. The place is small so I could see a long wait. The Menu is very limited which is fine if you pick a few things that you do very well. Of course being our first time, our experience of what the menu has to offer was a small sampling in fairness. We started with the bruschetta which was a special. The tomato, garlic, basil topping was good. It did need seasoning at the table, but it certainly was better than average. However the crostini it was served on tasted a bit stale, but more like it was toasted in advance and left out for prep. It was an awkward chew. We followed with a pasta dish with a cream sauce as a safety net and also had the chicken piccata which was the special. The defining factor of a scallopini or of piccata is meat cut or pounded thin. We received a chicken breast dredged in flour that was 3/4" to 1" thick. Of course the chicken had dried out a bit, but it was the most edible part of the dish. The sauce was sweet. Like orange juice or sugary sweet. This killed any sharpness from the capers or lemon to cut through the fat and enhance the dish. This was also served over spaghetti and was drenched in the same sauce. We were hungry and ate the protein, but left the majority of the pasta and the store bought bread stick. The bow tie pasta with cream sauce was good and the grilled chicken accompaniment was just fine as well. The dish lacked "pop" but was just as good as any other wine cream sauce I've had locally. Not bad, not something to remember, but good. Overall prices are way to high for the quality of the prep. A bowl of bow tie pasta costs about $10-12 at a better restaurant and it was $14 here. Not going to go back here, but it may be fine for someone who thinks Olive Garden is Italian food. Pasta isn't fresh, prep is so so. Enjoy if you want, but if you really know your food I would chose something else. read more

Surprise! Cute remodeled hipster building was somewhat misleading. There wasn't much advertisement around the building but we heard it was Italian. So, we have it a try. In a word, BRAVO! I have now had the chicken Parmigiana which was the best I have ever had. It made me realize that all these year I have been given microwave pre-prepared. The bread is excellent as well. My wife had a chicken lemon sauce with capers dish and it was wonderful. The service is good and the prices are great for the value. KEY HINT: you sometimes have to ask about the wine selection. read more

A 35 minute ticket time produced cold meatballs and over cooked, under-seasoned chicken parmesan. Both on a bed of store bought spaghetti with one note tomato sauce. As is, the otherwise nice, extra large portions hardly matter. Maybe it was an off night. But I wonder if you're not better off at Olive Garden. read more

We had a lovely dinner, a nice change from the overpacked restaurants we avoid. The Chicken Fettuccini was on point. All scratch made sauces and dinners were delicious. read more

Tiny little Italian restaurant. Wait staff very inexperienced. Food was good but plates were flemzy. Like they were on a shoe string budget. Not a repeat read more

Been looking for an Italian restaurant for a while, and thought we would try this. We know going in that it was small, it is, family owned, and newly opened. Nice cozy place, not at all upscale. Didn't make reservations on a Saturday night about 7:30, but had no problem getting a seat. Waiter was super friendly and professional. Menus were small, as expected, and received bruisetta, soup (Tomato Florentine), salad (House Greek) , and two specials ( Chicken Piccata, Chicken Alfredo). Piccata was very good. Lemony for my taste not overly done. Alfredo was very good also, but needed little more sauce. Bruisetta was great, salad, nothing special (dressing was a little too sweet), soup was outstanding! Dessert was also spectacular! Could use a few adjustments but over all way above anything "Olive Garden " could ever do! Don't listen to those bad reviews, try this place, it's delicious! read more

I love Italian food and Cheri Ann's is so good! A must is the cheesecake with berries.

Very quaint. Not very large dining area. We had spaghetti and meatballs with salad. The dressings for the salad are made in-house. These were delicious and salad was a variety of lettuce. The spaghetti and meatballs cans out and the portion was very large. Meatballs are large. This could easily be shared. In-house sauce was again delicious. Staff was so friendly. We went early at 5pm and was able to be seated easily. read more

This was great! Our guest were wanting Italian cuisine last night. This little gem is a mile away and what great food! We weren't sure how the experience would be as we were at first told they might not be able to handle 7 to go meals. Well they did it!! My husband said it was the best pork chops he's had!!! That in itself is amazing. We had spaghetti and meatballs, chicken Marsala, and 2 more chicken Dishes in white wine sauce, and chicken parmesean. The breadsticks were amazing and the salad fresh! We will do this again and thanks for providing a great meal!! read more

Wonderful from start to finish! Friendly service, pleasant atmosphere, delicious feel good food. Cheesecake was the best I've ever had!! Thank you for a lovely experience! read more

Our experience was great from the moment we walked in the door. We were met promptly and professionally, and were well taken care of throughout our dinner. Food was great ! We also ordered the Cheese cake and it was wonderful! We will definitely return. read more

Cheri Ann's Trattoria - Italian Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma