Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Chillinghams Steak

    4.4 (48 reviews)
    Closed 4:00 pm - 9:00 PM
    Updated a few days ago

    Chillinghams Steak Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Chillinghams Steak

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Keith S.

    So the location and feel was great, the service was great, and the taste was good...but they missed the temp on my rib eye by a country mile. When I saw the menu stated l the recommended temps and basically anything over "medium" was sacrilegious, or something to that effect, I was stoked. I am a black and blue, or Pittsburgh rare guy, and when I requested a great steak house when visiting, this seemed like the right call. My exact statement, as always, when ordering a steak, was "I will 1000% never send it back for too rare, and cold in the center is fine", so when my ribeye was served at BEST medium, it was disappointing to say the least. At $50, I expected the temp to be spot on. The waitress seemed "meh" when she came around and I noted that the temp was well over, she did apologize, but that was about it. In 1000% transparency, I've had way better temps at Texas Roadhouse. Flavor was fine, the sweet potato side was nice, but for a $50 steak to miss temp by that much? Very, very disappointing. Next time I visit, certain I'll look elsewhere. The most disappointing thing is that a black and blue temp is not hard. Yes, its a PIA to get out with a three top, but a 4-6 minute ribeye to miss by that much, at a steakhouse, is a bit of a travesty.

    10oz Flat Iron steak with chimichuri
    Mark B.

    Second time here! Flat Iron steak was even better than the first time I came here. Service was great at the bar and at the table. Mushrooms on the filet and cinnamon butter were a great addition. Both steaks were cooked perfectly. Chips with onion dip for an app is perfect to get you ready for dinner. I recommend the Caesar salad and onion rings as your sides. The other steak options looked huge as they walked by us... It's location is awkward, but there is no better steak place between here and Mohegan Sun. Prices a perfect for a full meal With sides like onion rings or a sweet potato and a salad vs the a la cart menus at the chain steak places. Great date place, clean single bathrooms. And it has an outdoor patio on the river. Can't say enough about how great my steak was. And consistently cooked perfectly. Bartenders pour well and mix a great drink. Wine and beer list is just right. Go around 7 and you'll still have plenty of time to eat and enjoy. Couples nights with friends or sitting at the bar with a buddy, are a guaranteed good time.

    Filet mignon
    Karissa C.

    Couldn't wait to try this place and so glad we did! We were a party of 10 celebrating our friend's birthday- and all of us had a wonderful time- great ambiance, fine service and excellent food and drinks!! Super great quality food and chefs were top notch! Loved the whole night- we will be back!

    Absolutely amazing. You must try the tomahawk for two. This restaurant rivals any of the popular steak houses. Amazing flavor. Amazing service. Amazing drinks!!!

    Bacon with dipping sauce
    Jeanmarie M.

    3rd time we've been here. The ambiance downstairs can be on the louder side if busy, but upstairs is a bit quieter if you would prefer. Steaks are all cooked to perfection and you can't go wrong. I was able to finally try the hanging bacon and was glad I did! Also, if you're up for a French onion soup this is the place.

    Caesar salad
    Monique W.

    WELL. This place is exactly what Westerly needed! From the same folks that bring you all fun in the sun all summer long at the Windjammer, Chillingham has shown the refined side of what a steakhouse can be. From the moment we walked in, the service was astounding. We were seated upstairs, with a view of the executive chef, Lenny, and his team delectably cooking each meal to order. The exposed beams and rustic decor lend themselves beautifully to the country western vibe of Westerly's newest eatery. Now. For the food. As a person who cannot consume gluten in any form, this was a dream meal. The staff was attentive to my allergy and made sure that every bite was safe. We began our meal with the carpaccio, which honestly had no right being that delicious. Next was a pair of ribeyes delivered to the table, both beautifully cooked to the most incredible, tender, medium texture. There was absolutely no need for a steak knife. The drink menu has been crafted to complement the dishes perfectly. Thank you for an incredible meal!

    Tomahawk Ribeye

    See all

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 1
    Love this 2
    Oh no 1

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Great Food and Great Service. My Ribeye was a 10 out of 10. My wife had the filet and loved it. I can't wait to go back.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Chillinghams Steak

    Review Highlights - Chillinghams Steak

    It's great to have a steakhouse in town and Chillinghams didn't disappoint.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Owl & Dove

    Owl & Dove

    4.6
    (85 reviews)
    0.1 mi

    We stopped in here on Valentine's Day on the way home from Mohegan Sun. There's a pretty large…read moreparking lot behind the building so it was a short walk. This place is adorable. I actually expected it to be really busy when we got there around 10:45, but there were quite a few open tables. They sat us in a queue table right in the window near the water. I couldn't decide what to get because everything looks so good. I ended up with the Patatas Brava which had soupy in it. I haven't had soup in years and they made it really stand out with the home fries, eggs, and crema. My wife had the basic breakfast, and everything was fresh and cooked perfectly. We ordered an apple crêpe for the table that had caramel and toasted almonds on it. The staff was also great. We had one waitress, but a second one was always there to check on us. The service gets five stars for sure! I wish we had a place like this near our house. It's right on the line of Westerly Rhode Island so we were able to walk around downtown Westerly which was really nice.

    My husband I celebrated 4th of July Sunday at the Owl & Dove. The restaurant is close to town and…read moreoffers plenty of municipal and street parking. The food was exceptional!! I dined on Seacoast Mushroom Toast, Crunchy Fish Sando (best ever), Burnt Orange Brulee (my favorite dessert in any flavor). Started with an orange Mimosa and ended with robust coffee in an adorable mug that sells out. 5 stars***** across the board. Cheers to Johnson & Wales, Culinary program:) The chef is prepared to impress.

    Photos
    Inside
    Inside
    Striped Bass Special
    Striped Bass Special
    Shrimp po boy

    See all

    Shrimp po boy
    The Shipwright's Daughter

    The Shipwright's Daughter

    4.4
    (418 reviews)
    7.3 mi
    $$

    We'd heard from friends that Shipwright's Daughter in Mystic was a must-try. Wow, were they right…read more From the warm greeting at the door to the beautiful decor, the experience started strong. We were seated at a lovely table for two overlooking Main Street - watching people stroll by from that elevated perch behind glass felt almost cinematic. The real star of the show was the food, which is ultimately what you're there for, and it delivered. The menu offers plenty of options without being overwhelming. I started with the Crispy Pig's Head as an appetizer - a bold choice that turned out to be outstanding. For my entrée, the bucatini with seacoast mushrooms, sherry, parmesan, mushroom cream, and fine herbs was perfectly cooked, and carried a subtle but deeply flavorful sauce. And the housemade sourdough with poblano honey butter? Absolutely outstanding. To be fair, our server took a little time to warm up but found their footing and gave us everything we needed. Parking in Mystic on a busy weekend night can also be a challenge and expensive. Neither is reason enough to skip this one. Ship Wright's Daughter is exactly the kind of restaurant Mystic deserves. Don't wait for a special occasion -- just go.

    I really didn't want to write this review, but potential patrons should know what they can expect…read morewhen working with the event staff at Shipwright's Daughter - if they plan to have a private dining experience and event there. My husband and I got married last December. We decided we would hold off on celebrating with our family and invite everyone out from California to join us for a weekend full of activities in Connecticut and a special dinner at Shipwright's Daughter during Memorial Day weekend. We contacted the restaurant's events team to work out high level details starting in late January - to book a private room and hold a date and time. From the get go, the communication we received from the event staff was dismal to say the least. Not only did the events manager misquote the estimate for the room reservation, she came back and asked for a much higher price (up charging by an additional 30% of the original minimum fee) two months after we confirmed and discussed the date. She then explained it was due to the holiday weekend. Our date had never changed from the moment we inquired, so we would have appreciated knowing this upfront. Over the course of several months (and an absurd number of emails and a few calls), we tried to solidify the menu and wine selection and made multiple attempts before hearing back from the team. It was about two weeks before the big event when we were able to confirm a menu. It was about four days before the event that we heard back from the beverage director, but by then, my husband and I had already decided we would bring our own wine bottles, not wanting to leave it to chance with this team. I won't go into further details about the frustration we felt regarding their system for communications (they use an internal system that doesn't make it easy for guests to know who is copied on emails and who sees what). That is something I hope they will work out. When the big day came, I walked into the room and noticed there were a number of chairs missing, so I counted the chairs. They had an incorrect number of chairs for adults and not enough high chairs for the toddlers. We had requested a specific number of these chairs (weeks prior and mentioned it multiple times in writing), and I thought it was safe to assume that this was a basic checklist item for events set up. I was dumbfounded in the moment. I couldn't help but wonder what else they were going to miss or mess up that evening. It was disappointing to have our family members wait while the staff scrambled to pull other chairs into the room. From the time it took to take everyone's order from the set menu, the time between courses being served, and the attentiveness for pouring water and wine - all of it was a miss. The level of hospitality that we expected from a restaurant so recognized for its incredible food and approach to sustainable sourcing was completely overshadowed by the lack of attention and care by its staff - since day one of planning this event. Even a few of our family members commented on this during the dinner. At the end of the day, we felt like an obligation rather than welcomed guests, and that is mainly why I'm leaving this review. We had been patrons of Shipwright's a couple of times prior to this event, which is why we chose this establishment - to represent the best that Connecticut has to offer, when it comes to a dining experience we could vouch for. We no longer feel that we can recommend this restaurant. If you care about hospitality, I would recommend looking elsewhere.

    Photos
    Interior
    Interior
    Smoked clam dip
    Smoked clam dip
    Steak Tartare

    See all

    Steak Tartare
    River Bar

    River Bar

    3.9
    (86 reviews)
    0.2 mi

    The River Bar is a great place to grab a meal weather your just passing by or are looking for a…read moregreat dining experience. Fast and friendly service and great drinks and beer selection. We stopped by for a quick snack of oysters and clams and a beer. We were very happy with our selections and choices available. When the weather is good they have an amazing outside patios section right by the river. We had a very enjoyable experience and will be back to try more!

    The River Bar in Westerly is the kind of place that instantly wins you over--equal parts stylish,…read morewelcoming, and delicious, with a happy hour that feels like a local secret you can't help but share. From the moment you walk in, the vibe hits just right. Warm lighting, a modern coastal feel, and a staff that treats you like a regular even on your first visit. It's the perfect after‑work escape or pre‑dinner stop, and the energy stays upbeat without ever feeling rushed. The happy hour menu is where River Bar really flexes. Thoughtful, well‑priced, and packed with flavor, it's clear they take just as much pride in these offerings as the main menu. The small plates come out fast, beautifully presented, and consistently delicious--exactly what you want when you're settling in with a drink and good company. Everything feels elevated but still approachable, the kind of food that makes you say "let's order one more" even when you know you're full. The drink specials are equally impressive. Creative cocktails, balanced pours, and bartenders who know how to craft something refreshing without overcomplicating it. Whether you're in the mood for something bright and citrusy or a smooth spirit‑forward sipper, they've got you covered. And of course--Nanas deserts.....If you know, you know. It's the kind of standout that becomes part of the ritual, the thing you tell friends they have to try when you bring them for the first time. Between the quality of the food, the unbeatable happy hour value, and the polished yet relaxed atmosphere, The River Bar has firmly earned its place as one of Westerly's best. A flawless five stars and an easy recommendation for anyone who loves great drinks, great bites, and a place that gets the details right. Cheers

    Photos
    One of the dining areas
    One of the dining areas
    Blooming onion absolutely delicious
    Blooming onion absolutely delicious
    Cocktail and beer

    See all

    Cocktail and beer
    COAST

    COAST

    4.2
    (33 reviews)
    4.9 mi

    On our way to Maine to visit relatives, my companion and I thought a stopover in the peaceful…read moreseaside village of Watch Hill, Rhode Island, with dinner at the famous Ocean House, might be the perfect start to our extended weekend. While the hotel offers several dining possibilities, there is no question in my mind that Coast is their culinary chef d'oeuvre. My dining partner and I found their New England-inspired cuisine to be not only beautifully presented but also absolutely delicious. Throw in an award-winning wine list, friendly & personable service, picturesque view of the Atlantic Ocean, and a most satisfying evening at table awaits. Be advised, however... What also awaits is a pretty hefty hit on your pocketbook, as our five-course prix-fixe Degustation Menu - with several choices included - was priced at $145.00 per person, plus beverages, tax & gratuity (there is also a similarly priced vegetarian menu). If you want to add the Reserve Wine Pairing, which I did, that will cost you an additional $125.00 per person (Grand Wine Pairing an additional $250.00 per person). Definitely not what you would call a cheap date. That being said, however, in my opinion - and that of my companion as well - dinner here is well worth the expenditure. Our first course was the Ninigret Pond Oyster "Pan Roast." Sourced from a local coastal lagoon that is linked to the Atlantic Ocean and Block Island Sound, Ninigret Pond is home to several reliable oyster purveyors. I must confess that I have never been an enthusiastic fan of bivalves in general - and raw oysters in particular. However, the pan-roasted representatives sampled here, smooth & buttery with a touch of sweetness and sprinkled with Royal Belgian Osetra Caviar, were quite good indeed. And the Ruinart Singulier 18th Edition, Blanc de Blancs, Brut Nature, Champagne, (France), proved to be the perfect libationary accompaniment. But even better was the outrageously delicious Bluefin Tuna Tartare. I have tasted this dish on numerous occasions; however, this particular incarnation was in a class all by itself. Gently caressed by avocado and kissed by golden kiwi and a beguiling carrot ginger reduction, the result was a presentation that was pleasing to both eye and palate, and a highlight of our evening. The 2019 Tegernseerhof Loibenberg Riesling Smaragd Wachau (Austria), of course, added immensely to the enjoyment. The next course presented us with a rather interesting conundrum... the choice between two equally appetizing possibilities. My dining companion, of course, went immediately for the Seared Scallops & Foie Gras. I, on the other hand, decided to side entirely with the carnivores... Kuro Farms Wagyu Strip Loin. Companioned by short rib, confit carrot, and Sicilian pistachios, this was a winner all the way... as was the wine selection, the 2020 Aslina "Umsasane," an enticing blend of Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc, and Petit Verdot from Stellenbosch, South Africa. The dessert course was especially noteworthy, a Blackberry Sudachi Entremet aided and abetted by white chocolate mousse, lavender, and raw honey sponge. A rather unusual denouement, I must admit, but a lovely presentation and irresistibly scrumptious. And, once again, the wine selection - 2018 Domaine Huet Le Mont Moelleux, a Chenin Blanc from Vouvray, Touraine, in France's Loire Valley - was right on the money. The Bottom Line: An exceptionally fine dining experience. Pricey, to be sure... but, in my opinion, worth every penny. A restaurant to which my dining companion and I would gladly return. Highly recommended on all counts.

    The room has been moved so that it is not next to the beach any longer. Portions were smaller than…read moreexpected. Food was good but not matching the price.

    Photos
    Jazz
    Jazz
    COAST
    Seafood tower, charcuterie and fruit

    See all

    Seafood tower, charcuterie and fruit

    Chillinghams Steak - steak - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...