I'm going to give this place a 4 star with an asterisk...
I've been coming here off and on for a few years. I used to live a half hour south of Birch Bay, and now I live IN Birch Bay and, after my visit today and considering my last few, I think I'm going to revisit my normal "There isn't one" to the question I get asked by people coming this way to visit, which is, "What's a good restaurant to go to in Birch Bay?" My question is usually followed up with "I mean CJ's Beach House is pretty good, but that's pretty much it, though The Beach just next door has some pretty good bar food and is much better than it used to be...the other two in town...avoid like the plague. Unless you want to have a bad day, then go nuts.
Look, I like good food. I'm picky (or at least not quick to rave if something isn't delicious), but I'm not a diva. I'm not going to lose my mind when the place is busy, especially during tourist season, and if I feel like I'm being ignored, I'm going to get off my rear and say, "Hi, we're over here...and we're starving." That usually works to light a fire under someone's bottom...should we have to do that? No. But if you've ever been in the service industry, you understand that sometimes restaurants have off days.
In the past, I've had issues here. I've had some service issues, usually with new wait staff, and it usually resolves itself.
But here's the "good": I chose them to put on a Christmas Party for about 30 employees of the company I used to work for a couple years ago and I had expectations as moderate as the budget I was given to throw this party. And they knocked it out of the park. Their food was amazing, their service was bar-none, and they kept the bar open late for us (win!). The literal only complaint was from one table that was near a vent with a draft and CJ's addressed that.
My husband and I had a burger there the other night, and it was one of the best burgers I've had in a long time - and that is saying something because there are some great burgers in Whatcom County (The Local in Bellingham, The Hilltop on Meridian to name 2). The owner of CJs also owns a steak house or two and their burgers are formed from high quality ground steak and they're fantastic and juicy (unless you ask for them cooked to death, then that's on you...I order mine medium and it has a little pink in the middle). I was this close to ordering a second burger (yes really).
I'm not usually a fan of sirloin steak (I'm a rib eye girl), but I just finished eating a flavorful, conservatively seasoned sirloin steak cooked to a perfect medium rare and, when I asked for vegetables only for a side, I was anticipating a pile of broccoli (which is "fine")...but, instead, was rewarded with perfectly roasted carrots and some indulgently buttered spaghetti squash. It made my night (yes, I'm easy, but seriously...it was delicious).
Has this restaurant had its issues? Yup. Have they all been addressed? I have no way of knowing.
But, in my opinion, they have come a long way and deserve kudos for a great little lunch and dinner spot (I JUST heard they started doing breakfast...will edit review once I've checked it out) while continuing to work on the occasional service (hiring?) issue. Honestly, with a few of the reviews - and I can't abide by deliberately nasty wait staff - I'm optimistic that they've addressed those servers and handled it accordingly (showing them the door if the review from the end of September is accurate, no excuse for that).
My answer to "Hey, what's a good restaurant in Birch Bay?" will be, "C.J.'s Beach House. They have occasional 'iffy service' (my earlier mentioned "asterisk") when it's busy due to the wait staff turnover that you see in restaurants in little touristy beach towns, but their food is spot on and they're a pleasure to dine with....and if you have a new server that seems to have forgotten you, grab the next restaurant employee you see, they'll get you taken care of." read more