Okay y'all, this is another late review, and I'm owning it. I'm trying to get all of these out before the new year, and I promise I'm going to do better next year and post them when they actually happen. But better late than never. So I stopped by Crumbly sometime in the fall--definitely more October/November vibes because they had seasonal items--and I'm so glad I did. I grabbed an iced pistachio latte, a caramel pecan bar, and a pumpkin cheese danish, and honestly... everything was really good. Let's start with the danish because I am a danish girl. That pumpkin cheese danish was an unexpected favorite. It was soft, fresh, and just really well done. The pumpkin wasn't overpowering, the cheese balanced it perfectly, and it felt like the kind of fall treat you didn't know you needed until you took the first bite. Now the pistachio latte--I love pistachio, so I had high hopes. It did not disappoint. It's made with a pistachio cream, and the flavor was just right. Not too heavy, not too sweet, just smooth and delicious. I got it iced, and I would absolutely order it again. No hesitation. The caramel pecan bar was exactly what I needed in a sweet. Gooey, chewy, crunchy in all the right places. The caramel was perfectly cooked and sticky without being overwhelming, and the pecans added the right amount of texture. It hit that "just enough" sweet spot. I also really love the vibe inside Crumbly. It feels warm, cozy, and homey--very inviting. It's the kind of place you can just walk into, grab something comforting, and go about your day happier than you were before. The location is super convenient, and they offer a lot more than just grab-and-go treats--custom cakes, seasonal desserts, little pies, cake pops... all the good stuff. They also have a reward system, which I love. If I'm going to frequent a place and spend my money, I appreciate getting something back. That always matters to me. Honestly, Crumbly is a win. Seasonal treats, good coffee, cozy vibes, and thoughtful extras. Chef's kiss. Highly recommend--and I might actually be heading back there again very soon. it. I'm trying to get all of these out before the new year, and I promise I'm going to do better next year and post them when they actually happen. But better late than never. So I stopped by Crumbly sometime in the fall--definitely more October/November vibes because they had seasonal items--and I'm so glad I did. I grabbed an iced pistachio latte, a caramel pecan bar, and a pumpkin cheese danish, and honestly... everything was really good. Let's start with the danish because I am a danish girl. That pumpkin cheese danish was an unexpected favorite. It was soft, fresh, and just really well done. The pumpkin wasn't overpowering, the cheese balanced it perfectly, and it felt like the kind of fall treat you didn't know you needed until you took the first bite. Now the pistachio latte--I love pistachio, so I had high hopes. It did not disappoint. It's made with a pistachio cream, and the flavor was just right. Not too heavy, not too sweet, just smooth and delicious. I got it iced, and I would absolutely order it again. No hesitation. The caramel pecan bar was exactly what I needed in a sweet. Gooey, chewy, crunchy in all the right places. The caramel was perfectly cooked and sticky without being overwhelming, and the pecans added the right amount of texture. It hit that "just enough" sweet spot. I also really love the vibe inside Crumbly. It feels warm, cozy, and homey--very inviting. It's the kind of place you can just walk into, grab something comforting, and go about your day happier than you were before. The location is super convenient, and they offer a lot more than just grab-and-go treats--custom cakes, seasonal desserts, little pies, cake pops... all the good stuff. They also have a reward system, which I love. If I'm going to frequent a place and spend my money, I appreciate getting something back. That always matters to me. Honestly, Crumbly is a win. Seasonal treats, good coffee, cozy vibes, and thoughtful extras. Chef's kiss. Highly recommend--and I might actually be heading back there again very soon. read more

See all

I am so happy with the service from Crumbly. I ordered a custom cake for a bridal shower and sent them an inspiration picture of what I was looking for and they matched it perfectly. Plus the cake was delicious. Everyone loved it! Would definitely use them again. Thanks. read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Loved this tiny family run bakery in UES. They have a good collection of pasteries. Their hot and cold bevereges are great too. Very friendly staff. Freshly made stuff and very welcoming vibe!! read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Checked out their baked goods for my work holiday event! It was easy to order ahead online. The banana cream pie was cream forward with fresh banana slices. It wasnt too sweet and had a nice crumbly graham cracker like crust that retained its integrity/not soggy after being refrigerated for a day! I treated myself to a pistachio latte and it was FIRE! They utilize some sort of pistachio butter or paste and they really blend it with the espresso/milk. As a result it really frothy and thick with a strong nutty flavor!! Loved how it wasnt overly sweet either! The kitchen sink cookie was better than expected! I like how it was extra toasty on the outside with an extra crunch. The parmesean and leek bistro was good but nothing stood out. Staff were really nice. They had some issue seeing my order so they had to work on it on the spot. Store itself is small with mostly outdoor seating. Love the wide selection of drinks and baked goods! read more

See all

I really wanted to love this bakery since I'm always on the lookout for delicious pastries that can satisfy my evening sweet cravings. I had a very specific craving for chocolate chip muffins, but my go to options were unavailable, so I decided to order from Crumbly based on its decent reviews. After placing my order, I got a call from the bakery letting me know they were out of chocolate chip cookies. I was like... no I need my chocolate chip muffins So I placed an order from a different Crumbly location (this one) that was farther away. I ordered three chocolate chip muffins, but to my disappointment, I received double chocolate chip muffins instead. Unfortunately, they're just too sweet for me, and I don't like the balance between the muffin and chocolate chips. As for the other items, the vegan quinoa croissant sounded interesting, but it was so stale that I couldn't enjoy it. The regular croissant was nothing special. That said, I did appreciate the careful packaging. read more

See all

Cute place, they were closing when I stopped by. I just wanted an espresso n they accommodated me, so nice. Espresso was yum! read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Espresso - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Purchased this Oreo pudding, walked home all of one block and when I went to eat it almost immediately after returning home I opened the lid to a rather thick layer of grown mold. read more

See all

This is our first time in NY. I walked to this bakery bc it said it had gluten free options but it didn't have very much at all. No breakfast options only a chocolate chip cookie and a brownie. It was a cute place but very small not very many options. read more

Has the most AMAZING cheesecake in New York City! Served by a staff so friendly you'll forget you're in New York City. read more

Crumbly Café makes delicious cakes and has great customer service, as well! I ordered a 9 inch red velvet cake and a 6 inch Oreo cheesecake for a birthday celebration. The red velvet cake is 3 layers and thick! The cake was really fresh/moist and not overly sweet. They wrote a message on the top for free. The oreo cheesecake looked tiny compared to the large red velvet cake but it was equally as tasty. The cheesecake wasn't too dense which I prefer - this one was more whipped/airy. The chocolate crust was decadent. Both desserts were a huge hit with my group. I exchanged a few emails with the bakery prior to placing my order - they were super responsive and helped troubleshoot some issues I had inputting our delivery address. I would definitely order from this bakery again and recommend it to my friends. read more

See all

I was hoping for so much more, but when I just purchased one of their double chocolate chip muffins and it was dry it left me feeling sad. A dry muffin is terribly disappointing as I was expecting soft moist deliciousness and instead was subjected to cardboard blandness. Sorry, but I can't go along with all the gushing 5 star reviews here. It was pretty bad, and it was early at noon when I purchased it so it's not like it sat around all day and got stale. I ate it as soon as I got home a few minutes later. With terrific bakery options such as Black Star, Michaeli, and now Avenue Bakery in the neighborhood I really have to judge against the quality of those and honestly Crumbly is behind them based on my sad muffin experience. Maybe I'll come back to try something else and update. read more

See all

This location is super cute. When I stepped foot in here it smelled like fresh pastries and that morning coffee smell. The person who helped me was very nice and sweet. I had an iced latte. Tasted good. They have some interesting coffee flavors too that I have yet to try but have heard they are tasty. read more

See all

Had a wonderful experience with Crumbly Bakery! They were super friendly and helpful with taking my order and most importantly the cake was absolutely delicious and looked stunning! Thank you for helping us celebrate a very special birthday! read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Chocolate cake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Crumbly is going to have to work their way up to Five Stars because they just opened. Crumbly is definitely a fun addition to my neighborhood. Now I don't have to walk as far to the First Avenue location. (I walk by here a lot!) I like the daily fresh baked items. The customer service is fast and friendly. Naturally since they just opened last week everything is clean. Please give them time to settle in to this new location. If you love cookies and pastries you will love Crumbly. I always want one of everything. This place is a special treat now and then, I won't enjoy stocking up for winter. Knock yourself out. They open 7am week days and 8am on weekends. I added the business and hours to Yelp. More Photos coming soon. read more

See all

Hubby has been eyeing this spot since they opened two weeks ago! We stopped by to pick up a crumbly cake and a small chocolate cake. Hubby loved them both! For me, it was way too sweet. However I will go back to try some of their gluten free option, which consists of brownie and cookie. We are so happy to have a bakery that actually bakes their products there! read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Small chocolate cake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

They made my daughters 2nd birthday cake as well as her first. This two tier Elmo cake was such a hit!!! It was beautiful and delicious! They delivered it too which made it so easy and stress free. I love crumbly cafe and bakery ! Not to mention they have the world's best warmed chocolate chip cookies. read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Crumbly cafe and bakery is so cute and brings a smile to your face when you walk in the door and you talk to the wonderful workers. I have been multiple times and my consensus is that I absolutely love some things and others leave me wanting more and disappoint me. Just to touch on the ones I really like are spinach and feta bistro! WOW INSANE! I Am not one for the crumb cake and the pistachio croissant as the croisssnt was just really burnt. The coffee really didn't hit the spot for me as it wasn't my favorite. All in all a really cute spot and 100% worth a try when you are in the area! read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Apple Crumb Cake Spinach & Feta Bistro - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We love this bakery. Friendly, kind, and absolutely delicious. Nowhere else we'd get a cake. We couldn't have dreamed up more perfect cakes for our son's birthday. The subway themed cake was pure perfection. The cakes looked spectacular and tasted incredible. Thank you, Crumbly! We also love their cookies, muffins, and borekas. Yum. 10/10. read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The classic crumb cake will not disappoint you! I came here to order a few sample desserts to bring over for a dinner and they absolutely loved it! I got the following: * Classic crumb cake * Apple crumb cake * Oreo cheesecake * Fridge brownie The crumb cake and oreo cheesecake were my fave!! Their signature crumb cake is fluffy, sweet, and will have you wanting more. I also treated myself to a salted caramel iced latte, which was the perfect mix of salty and sweet! The gentleman who helped me with my order was very nice and made sure to give me proper instructions so that the desserts would be at their best later today! This is one of my favorite bakeries on the UES! It's so cozy and I will be back to try the rest of the menu :) read more

See all

This is my favorite coffee/pastry shop in my neighborhood. The cakes/pastries are delicious and baked daily. Lots of variety too, including savory -their parmesan / leek pastry is to die for. Oh, and don't get me started on their chocolate vanilla cake which I took to an event where everyone raved about it! read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - chocolate vanilla cake - to die for! - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Welcome to the neighborhood! Dropped by to pick up a small pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving and I'm so happy that I stopped by. The moment you walk in, the smell hits you and you're left lost with all the delicious options in the case. The small pie was perfect to share for two but it can EASILY be devoured by one. The crust is butter-y and the filling was made with just the right amount of spices and sugar. Maybe it was just the small size but crust and filling is evenly 50/50. Not complaining because I am a fan of crust. The owner/employees were nice and patient with me while I took my time deciding between two pies. Will definitely be dropping by again! read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Pumpkin Pie (small) - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Our custom ballerina Minnie cake exceeded my expectations! It was absolutely gorgeous that we didn't want to cut into it! When we did, we were met with a moist vanilla cake and chocolate frosting. Everyone said it was beautiful and delicious! Will continue to get our custom cakes from Crumbly as it has been such a wonderful experience! Thank you Crumbly team!! read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

I live near the original (I think original?!) location in Midtown East and I'd be amiss if I didn't try this new location on the UES! Just as good as the Midtown East location and loved the Christmas decor inside. Enjoyed the double espresso, and my boyfriend and I were able to sit inside the cafe as there are 2 round tables and limited seating. Thank you! read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Christmas Cake! - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

I LOVE this bakery! I just ordered a cake, and the staff was so friendly and the cake was so cute!! And so yummy! We will definitely order here again. read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Cute little coffee shop. I got the salted caramel latte and it satisfied my caffeine cravings. The espresso didn't taste as strong as other lattes I've had, so it had a more milky flavor. read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Salted Caramel Latte - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

I would have give this place 6 stars if I could, Ama knows how to make one the best matcha I've had in nyc, not too sweet to not bitter but just right. Her service was impeccable and she's really funny too. She even gave me a sample of her pink lemonade that will be coming out for summer. read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Iced Matcha Latte and Iced Salted Caramel Latte with the pink lemonade samples - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

These guys were awesome did an amazing cake for my son's communion and birthday unfortunately I forgot to take a picture before they were thoroughly demolished ! But couldn't recommend highly enough read more

Enjoyed my espresso and strawberry cheese danish at Crumbly Cafe & Bakery. There is limited seating available if you want to eat or drink your treats quickly. The staff was quick with serving. I'll definitely be back to try more items! read more

Crumbly Cafe and Bakery is my go to spot when I am in the city on the upper east side. Great congenial service, great coffee and a selection of great baked goods, from croissants to sliced cakes. I enjoy sitting in the outdoor cafe whether Winter or Summer because their delicious coffee keeps me warm or cool if iced. read more

Lovely new bakery on this side of the upper east! Soo many options! i tried the marbled cheesecake brownie and was impressed. Can't wait to make this my regular spot and slowly try everything out. read more

See all

Everything I've tried from here has been amazing. Highlights for me are the Nutella cookie pie, brownie, cake pops, and banana pudding. Of course, the crumb cake is excellent as well. read more

This bakery is great. I called in the afternoon to have a cake made for my engagement party that night and even with the short notice they didn't hesitate to take my order. I picked it up perfectly on time and the cake was delicious, it was a big hit at the party! I would recommend this bakery to anyone and I will be going back for future events. read more

The staff here was SO lovely - very friendly and helpful. The sad part was I tried a cake and it was very dry and pretty bland. I'll go back again and try something else because of the kind staff but maybe not the cake items... read more

After entering the door you will realize that the staff is so friendly and the coffee and pastries are so fresh. All fresh baked goods that are prepared daily. You will never look at those large coffee houses the same. I had a morning fresh apple turnover and they included 2 Almond cookies that were heavenly. I also had a decaf latte. Yummy . No preservatives in this food. What a great find. Thanks On 2nd Ave and 89 th street read more

We got the most amazing pistachio iced lattes from Crumbly, and we will definitely be getting again! They were delicious and just the right amount of sweet read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Phenomenal coconut layer cake. Chocolate chip cookie was good but I prefer them to be a little softer in the middle. I will definitely be back for more cake. The service was very friendly. read more

St. Patrick's decorated cookies are amazing!!!! Service is very good as well! Coffee is the best in the city! read more

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - St.Patricks decorated cookies are amazing!!! - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Really good coffee and solid pastries. Got an iced salted caramel latte and really liked the balance of flavors (not too sweet, not too bitter). Cheese danish had a nice sweetness and tartness to it. read more

I came across this bakery while looking for pistachio desserts and was so pleased with the variety of their baked goods like their pecan bar and pistachio lime cake. Nothing was overly sweet and they were soft. When I walked in I was immediately hit with the warm scent of desserts, such a cozy thing for the fall. The staff here was incredibly kind and I was treated to freshly baked cookies straight out of the oven. I will definitely be returning and hope to try all of their yummy treats :) read more

Their small Yorkville location had a good selection of pastries, muffins & cookies. Friendly guy (French, maybe...?) behind the counter. I had the chocolate-chocolate chip muffin. Unfortunately, it was very dry and way too dense. I ate only half of it. My husband had the cinnamon roll which he said was good. On the bright side, our coffees tasted delicious. read more