Hidden down some stairs sits this wonderful, cozy, Italian restaurant. The main dining area is past the bar, towards the back half of the restaurant. It was a Thursday night, and there was a piano player (Marcia) who was performing, and giving their all out performance while under the weather. Other guests stopped in and performed with her, making the atmosphere lively. The servers were quick with greeting and taking orders. The food was good portions and was delicious! I've never had NY cheesecake in New York, and my first experience was here. I have to say, I will never be able to enjoy NY cheesecake like they had, as they set the bar high! The cheesecake just melted and was savory with every bite. If ever in NY again, I will be sure to return. read more

See all

every time i am in the great city of new york, New York i have to come to this fine establishment, i have been about 4 times and i will be coming back this summer. the decor and ambiance is just off the charts. it makes me think i am in Venice enjoying a view of the water at a genuine Italian kitchen, love it service is great, when we went to dinner before a play on Broadway came back after and were welcomed like family and had a delectable dessert. wait staff are always being great, bringing out more bread, getting anything when we need it, they are just great people. and in my opinion it makes the place feel more authentic. once when i was there the pianist, which they have one every day, let me come up and sing some billy joel. Great expirence. now onto the food( the best part ): I am always a sucker for any pasta with cheese and let me tell you, it satisfied my need for cheese. Very good. 2,346,731 out of 6 read more

Very hole in the wall italian restaurant. Just down a few steps from the street. As you walk in, the bar is to the right. We opted for a table. There was live music. Service was great. Our server was very on top of our table making sure we had everything we needed. Excellent menu. Very traditional Italian. We started off with the beef carpaccio. I had the spaghetti with clams and my husband had the chicken parm. They are actually known for their pasta with vodka sauce. Wish we tried that too because it looked amazing. Dessert was the best cheesecake we've had ever. It was light and fluffy with like a pound cake crust. This is what dreams are made of. So glad we found this hidden gem. Excellent. read more

See all

Tremendous experience!!! The appetizers, the entrees, the desserts The location: next to Book of Mormon, across from Chicago The owner and his wife are the friendliest people you'll ever meet Worth the trip. Come for dinner, see a show, come back for drinks. The quintessential Manhattan experience. read more

See all

Good was delicious huge portions ! Staff was friendly and efficient. Atmosphere was so nice , quite romantic. read more

See all

I found this treasure by accident when the AC died in Italian choice #1 near the theater. Ordered the Pasta Bolognese and a good glass of Montepulciano. Very generous portions of both. Should have taken a picture but dived in. The photo is my take home for tomorrow! Very good service plus a piano bar read more

Da Marino - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Came here with some girlfriends while I was in town. The food here was phenomenal! Bonus- scene from Sex & the City date night was filmed here. Lots of celebritity pictures to explore on the wall. Everything we had on the menu was delicious. read more

See all

Great place with friendly service! Like other reviewers mentioned, they honor reservations but you'll still have to wait a bit, as did others who arrived at the same time with a reservation. It's extremely packed inside with limited space per table, but manageable. The food was delicious and very reasonably priced considering the large portions (by Manhattan standards). They also had a live piano player when I was there, which was wonderful. As was his singing voice. I had the salmon bruschetta which was just okay. I didn't enjoy it enough to reorder. The rigatoni buttera was delicious and the tomato sauce was nice. The cheese ravioli with mushroom and asparagus was also nice, however I liked the rigatoni much more. They also had a lot of Christmas decorations which added to the fun festivities! read more

Da Marino is an excellent Italian place in the theater district, the perfect place to go before a show. It definitely feels like an old style Italian restaurant and there was live piano that set a great mood. They also have a lot of those celebrity photos on the wall. They have a great wine list, so we ordered a nice bottle of red. For starters, we started with the caprese which was outstanding with nice fresh tomatoes and the perfect mozzarella. For the main course, I ordered the lobster ravioli special that was in a butter sauce. This was excellent, the pasta was nice and fresh and the sauce was the perfect complement. I also tried some of the cheese ravioli in red sauce and this was great as well. For dessert, we had the cannolis. Simply wonderful. I was glad we had time for dessert with plenty of time to see Hadestown. Definitely worth visiting. read more

Da Marino - Lobster ravioli - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This is a cute little Italian spot with wonderful ambience. There's a piano player that adds a really nice touch to the whole experience. Service was efficient and friendly. The buratta is super delicious, but I wish it would've come with toast points or crusty bread, or something to put it on. The house bread is tasty, but it's too thick and soft to spread something like this on. I had seafood linguine and he had lobster ravioli with shrimp. All the pasta was perfectly al dente. read more

See all

I passed the restaurant many times as it was near my hotel and every time I passed it, it was entrancing. Luckily, I was in the mood for penne vodka!! The ambiance is immediately cozy and warm as there is a live pianist/jazz singer. The paintings on the wall are so beautiful as well. The staff was small, but intentional and kind. It was all very authentic and my penne vodka was just what I needed. Definitely a hidden gem read more

Da Marino - Sex in the City Cocktail - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Love, love this place! It's quaint, intimate and authentic. The pianist is additional touch. The servers were great and the food is excellent! It's next to the Eugene O'Neill Theather so it's convenient to complete the romantic date! Broadway show and dinner read more

See all

The food and service are terrific, as is the music! There should be be a picture of Da Marino next to the definition of hospitality in the dictionary. I felt welcomed, as though a member of the family. The friendly and fun atmosphere could hardly be better. read more

My daughter and I ate here on Sunday after a mom and daughter date in the city. We were heading out to catch a show at 7. So we had a 5:15 reservation. We were seated promptly and the service was prompt with drinks and menus. We asked to have a salad and a rigotonj with meatballs but shared. They happily complied. They brought out 1 meal in two plates evenly split !!! The food was also delicious. My daughter ordered a virgin Shirley temple and felt so grown up. Then we decided to split dessert. We ordered the cannoli. It was good but missed the mark on tastiness. I've had better. The one complaint was service at the end. The food always came out quick but our waiter was slow to clear plates and take next orders. We were just waiting about 10 minutes with empty plates before a dessert was offered. I was getting nervous I'd miss the start of the show so k asked for the check to come out with dessert and it did. Alll in all. I'd come back again. The ambiance was super cute. My daughter has a bit of an obsession with Italian decor right now and the painting on the wall made her happy and impressed. read more

See all

Excellent food. Great atmosphere. Vodka sauce is fantastic. Staff very friendly. We went to a show near by and loved the experience. Highly recommend the rigatoni and meatballs. read more

Da Marino - Rigatoni Meat Ball - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Food was amazing, service was on point. We didn't feel rushed and the food was served hot. Staff was courteous and attentive. When I made the reservation, I made a note that it was for a birthday and they sang happy birthday without me asking or having to remind them. It was a wonderful experience. I would definitely go again! read more

Da Marino - Chocolate mousse cake - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

OMG is all I can say. It's a hidden gem where the ambiance is amazing and the food was authentic Italian. The waiter was very attentive. This is a MUST GO restaurant. read more

See all

Great ambience. The food is amazing. Had the bruschetta and the rigatoni buttera style. Would definitely eat here again.

Always wonderful food and attentive service. Robert has maintained this wonderful vibe that Pasquale established so many years ago. It's like you're stepping into Calabria w the cuisine and hospitality. Service remains strong and food keeps the quality standards set. All while the lovely and talented Marcia creates the mood with her piano playing and singing. She was able to accommodate our special requests as an added bonus. I'm so happy it's still opened after all these years. Xoxo read more

Da Marino - View of restaurant from Entrance. - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

The food was AMAZING and the service was excellent will visit again. The ambiance was beautiful. Even the bathroom was pretty.Highly recommend. read more

See all

What a great mom pop Italian hole in the wall! Was visiting NYC for the first trim and this place gets packed! Atmosphere is loud and inviting. Tom up front is genuinely kind! Spaghetti and meatballs were delish!! Make reservations! read more

See all

Had Christmas Eve dinner here, food was mediocre at best. My daughter got food poising from the meatballs, been up all night. I would avoid at costs. read more

This restaurant was so cute - great vibe, great food, great drinks. It is close to all of the broadway theaters, we told our waiter that we were going to a show so he made sure that we got everything in time to make it to our show. Would definitely come back next time I'm in the city for a show! read more

Every single time I come here I am reminded why I love it so much. The food is spectacular, the staff is extremely attentive and the atmosphere is perfect. It gives that classic east coast Italian but with a funky twist. Will be back again! read more

I had the lasagna and felt it was good. The wife had the chicken parm and wasn't impressed. The service and ambiance was good. Had someone playing holiday songs on the piano. Nice touch! read more

I am not sure what the hype is about this place. The service and ambiance were great. But the food? Nope. The bread and lentils were great. The meatballs were cold and horrible. Tasted like the gross frozen meatballs I bought in store. The vodka sauce was just okay according to my son. My granddaughters trout was good. I wanted the eggplant Rollatini appetizer but they said it would take 25 min. So, we were not impressed and would not go back. But the table next to us was saying how they enjoyed the food. read more

This is one of those restaurants where you don't think it'll be great because its near Time Square and so it must be a giant tourist trap right? Well shockingly no because this place was actually so good. Made a reservation day of and was able to get a good dinner time spot. Walked in and there was live music playing in the background, swoon! - Linguine Carbonara - The best carbonara in NYC in my opinion is at Olio e Piu, but I have to say that Da Marino may have the second best carbonara in NYC. The pasta was made perfectly al dente and there was so much of the yolky sauce covering every bit of it. Also, the portion sizes were huge! - Grilled Branzino - I love fish, period. Anyways now that this is out of the way, the sea bass was grilled quite well, but the star was definitely the sautéed spinach which was so weird because I never thought I would ever say that, but that spinach was crazy. It was so full of meaty flavor, I loved it. I feel like usually I only associate sautéed vegetables being made well in Asian cuisine so this surprised me a lot, but I'm glad I learned something new. - Calamari - At first I was a bit skeptical about the calamari because it didn't look like it was fried particularly well but it was actually so good. The marinara sauce had chunks of tomato in it which I loved and the squid was incredibly tender. What a surprise. - Arugula Salad with Goat Cheese - Can skip. I guess if you're looking for something light to go with all the other heavy dishes, you could order this to give your palate a refresher. Overall, regardless of the location, this place is legitimately good. Will definitely come back to try more of their dishes! read more

Da Marino - Arugula Salad with Goat Cheese - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Good ambience. Food is good and staff very attentive. Highly recommended. A bit pricey but it's worth it

We had this place recommended to us by a good friend of ours, and decided to check it out while we were on vacation in the area. We had just finished a show off Broadway, and the walk to the restaurant was only a few minutes away, a great location especially in the cold. Immediately after arriving, we were greeted by their manager, Tom, who welcomed us with a warm smile and kind demeanor and allowed us to sit wherever we wanted. Lovely live music was playing on this Friday night, and we were promptly given service once we sat down. We figured we would be more hungry by the time the show ended, which was such a disappointment considering how delicious all the food was! I wish we could have finished it all. I ordered a wonderful, creamy Penne Vodka, which they allowed me to add pancetta to, as well as my fiancé who ordered the Pasta e Fagioli. Service was great and attentive, everything you could ask for. We will be returning to this cute Italian spot the next time we visit. A big thank you to Tom, who clearly puts a great deal of care into making sure his employees are well knowledgeable and his customers are satisfied!! read more

Da Marino - Penne Alla Vodka, Pasta E Fagiol - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

I used to like "Italian" food. At least I thought I did. Big family night? Go to the Olive Garden. Sigh. (Living in Southern California will do that). Then I spent two years of my Navy career working in Naples, Italy. Now when my family says they want Italian food, and my Daughter says "let's go to Olive Garden," I just shake my head. We have actually found a few very good Italian restaurants in the Southern California area, but none are as good as Rome or Florence, or Da Marino. We recently helped our son move to NYC, and while there, was referred to Da Marino by a friend who had been there several times. Now, when my wife says she wants Italian food, I almost start looking at tickets to JFK. It's THAT good. I have had the best food Italy has to offer, from Florence to Rome to Naples to the Amalfi Coast. Our visit to Da Marino put us in the heart of Italy (the country with the best food on the planet), and they met the standard. Conveniently located a block from Times Square and in the heart of the Theatre District, perfect for a pre-Broadway meal. The owner Craig is also a retired Navy veteran, so we had some commonality there. Frequent guests to the restaurant are a veritable who's who of NYC and Hollywood, with Martin Scorcese and Robert De Niro (among others) known to dine there, and countless other signed photographs from notable patrons adorn in the walls. If Scorcese and De Niro find Da Marino to be up to the standard for Italian food, I'd say that's a ringing endorsement. Upon entering, we were taken with the old-world look and feel of the decor, and greeted by Tom, the most gregarious and likable Maitre D' in the Big Apple. The hospitality of the entire staff is exceptional. There is a full cocktail bar (at which was produced an impeccable martini), there's a robust wine list (house Chianti was exceptional) and the appetizers were magnificent (Caprese and Calamari). Dinner was beyond compare, we ordered Pappardele Bolognese, Linguini with Clams and Linguini di Mare, which were all amazing. Linguini with clams was the best I have ever had, and I am very particular about that dish. Live piano music made for a perfect ambiance, and our sever Josh was wonderful. Dessert was cannoli and tiramisu; I had basically given up on tiramisu outside of Italy, but have now found the one place in the US I can really enjoy it. Light, delicious, ...perfect. Tom said the cheesecake is always extremely popular, but we had no room ... so we will be back for that. I rarely if ever write restaurant reviews of this length and detail, but Da Marino was well worth the effort. It was the finest Italian restaurant experience I have enjoyed outside of Italy. Can't recommend this wonderful restaurant strongly enough. read more

We've been going to Da Marino's in NYC for years - whenever we visit the city. We loved the food, ambience, staff...all through management changes. It always had that old, Italian NYC vibe. However, it appears management has once again changed(?)...And there is something missing now. The old classic music has changed - replaced by a seemingly wannabe show tunes (so-so) singer. The food was also so-so as was the staff. There are so many really good Italian restaurants in NYC. Sadly, we probably won't be going back to Da Marino's again. read more

Food was delicious and great service. Very traditional Italian restaurant experience in a moody setting with live piano.

I tried vodka pasta for the first time in my life here, and it was incredible. Nothing ever comes close to your first.

horrible experience local live around the corner go to this restaurant all the time it's our fifth year going there for and we left not even keeping our reservation because the on duty manager that night was so rude vulgar and words all because we questioned him about our table. If local tourist stay away go to better food just down the street row at least they treat you like great valued guest this place doesn't care. read more

You would never dream that this place is in the busiest part of Times Square - it's tucked away down a few steps and you enter a truly wonderful and sometimes loud, fabulous restaurant! Years ago I found them when they had a placard on the street saying Chocolate pasta. Well...I lost all desire for where we were headed and walked down into Da Marinos. You enter into the galley bar to the hostess stand. Used to be we never had to wait, but wow, now you HAVE to have reservations or you sit at the bar, IF all those seats aren't taken already. I have to be honest, I've never had a thing off the menu except the chocolate pasta with shrimp. It's making my mouth water just thinking about it. Everyone I've been with laughs at my choice and they get traditional Italian dishes. I'm assuming, having never been to Italy, that chocolate pasta isn't a regular dish but who am I to say that?? It's delicious! My friends and family never have had a complaint about their dishes and also never complain that I always want to go here, so I'm taking from that that their dishes are as delicious as mine! Sometimes there's a pianist at night! I try to sit close to him because I'd rather hear piano than my neighboring tables conversations. A great decision. You get bread before dinner and can barely move after my pasta so I haven't had desserts here. Their wine list is a winner and they also have a full bar. Bathrooms are clean, but not huge, of course. And parking? Seriously?? I wouldn't survive driving around Times Square on any night of the week. Uber or subway if you value your life! Please go see what I'm raving about but don't tell too many people - I need my chocolate pasta!! read more

Da Marino - a woman sitting at a bar with a bowl of soup in front of her - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

TL;DR: worst carbonara ever Rating: -4 Not a huge fan of carbonara. It tasted like clammy creamy instead of the yolk sauce you'd expect. I would go back in time to get my ravioli. Also there was a slight smell but I'm chalking that up to it being underground. They had stale bread and lentils for a pre dinner snack. No garlic bread?? Would much rather have gone to Olive Garden or cheeecake factory. Would not come back for overpriced, bad tasting carbonara. Gets 2 stars instead of 1 because portions were big and their vodka pasta was decent read more

See all

The weather outside was nice so didn't experience any issues with comfort. The piano music and environment was cozy. Great pasta and good service. We really enjoyed our time there. read more

See all

I came here for my birthday this year because I saw the restaurant on Sex in the City and the male host (sorry completely forgot his name) was so charismatic and made the night a lovely experience. Definitely recommend going later in the evening around 7pm when it gets quieter if you like a cozy/chill vibe. Live music was a nice touch and of course the food was amazing! I had the bolognese and it was the perfect portion size and tasted great. read more

Classic southern Italian pasta and entrees in a fun setting. Piano bar is a nice touch.

Small and tight, loud and rumpus, and we loved every minute of it. Friendly and laughter everywhere. The Rigatoni and meatballs were amazing. You definitely should have reservations as the place was full. We highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Da Marino - Rigatoni Meatballs - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all