Very beautiful diner located near Skaneateles lake. Customer service was excellent and our meals…read morewere even better! The Thai chili pork sandwich was very tender! We loved the additional of pickled red onion the flavor combinations paired very well. The bacon jam burger was simply AMAZING! I could eat Clovers bacon jam on any and everything!!! Overall I had a wonderful meal and look forward to returning very soon.

Reliable local dinner serving a friendly breakfast. Nice atmosphere, very clean (including the…read morerestroom)

Absolutely incredible food. A little pricy but you're in the…read morefinger lakes shorty! Nice and hot, great diverse flavor with an atmosphere straight out of Food and Wine. Service was great as our order was ready in half the time they said!

Line almost out the door! Super popular and clearly well loved staple of the area. Wonderful…read moreselection of baked goods on your left immediately upon arrival. Lots of beverage selections. It is a smaller bakery/Café so not a ton of seating however there is some available for a quick bite. Cute little donut, decorations around on the walls too! I got two different types of scones as well as a breakfast sandwich. I was starving, and it tasted delicious, however, it would've been nice if the sandwich could come with something small on the side like fruit, salad, or garnish of any sort. The sandwich itself was on a smaller side, but it was still delicious nevertheless.

We had a reservation for 16 today and could not have been happier. Our wait staff was outstanding…read more The food was delicious. Thank you for accommodating us. Your staff did a wonderful job managing 2 large parties simultaneously. My family has enjoyed your restaurant for the past four years as my daughter attended SU. It was only fitting that we celebrated her senior recital at the Sherwood Inn.

Our server was attentive, and I think the prices are reasonable for the location. Food was good,…read morethough I think with a few changes it could go from good to great. For instance the children's menu pasta was just noodles and sauce--no parmesan, no little piece of bread. Five stars for ambiance, assuming you get seated near a window. I'd give 4.5 if I could but will keep it a 5 since they deserve better than 4.

Food was great, service was totally spot on. Comfortable and rustic place…read more Ambience and view loved

Not sure about the 4.5 stars for this place... seems like a lot of local followers…read more The comment about the Eggs Benedict is ridiculous "Hands down the best" not even in my top 10 - Ham not Canadian Bacon and the hollandaise was a disgrace. Coffee is ok Service was fine but extremely slow.

This place... knocked it out of the park! The service was excellent... the ambiance perfect and…read morethe food was Exquisite! A 4 course Prix Fix gastronomic experience! We had the Grouper and the Sea Scallops... we added some oysters on the 1/2 shell... in addition to to the spring rolls & crab cake as apps. The salad course was a perfect complement. We finished up with 2 desserts which were sublime... a lime tort and a poppyseed & raspberry gateaux and a cup of espresso BRAVO!

An historic gem. Always top notch food and drink. From the porch to the bar area and dining room…read more Class but comfortable.

Two of us went here on a sunny Fall day around 10/16/25. The…read moreweather was chill, but Gilda's never disappoints! Warm atmosphere in a small space, Gilda's is always great for a bite. We split a pizza and a salad. Both were delicious, as usual. We sat at the bar, and had a friendly chat with the waitress and the others seated next to us. Altogether a nice place for a quick, delicious bite.

Base my reviews off what you pay:…read more *Place was busy on a Friday lunch. Price - N/A Food - 3/5 - OK, small portions. Service - 4/5 - friendly and quick. Ambiance - 3/5 - fine, boosted by the lake. Overall - 3/5 - may be misremembering but food was better the first time around. Burger is still a classic, best burger in town. Pizza is fine, Italian is fine. Do not get the Zucchini Gnocchi unless you are a diehard goat cheese fan. Service was better, quick, friendly, good service, no complaints. Ambiance is fine but can't go wrong sitting by the lake. Still a solid place but food is not as good as I remember. Best Dish - Burger Would Return - Potentially for burger

Good eats has some of the BEST coffee around for sure!! Such delicious pre-made coffee choices…read more Very kind staff as well :)

I love it here! It's definitely a little pricier but the food is so fresh and yummy. I go here…read moreoften for lunch for work and it definitely gets busy. I would say the one downfall is how hard parking can be between 11-1pm. However it doesn't stop me from coming. Their employees are the kindest! If you're short on time they have a great mobile ordering system. They always have the food ready at the time your mobile order says it'll be ready. It's really hard to pick a favorite menu item! I love their seasonal drink offerings and their regular menu is amazing as well. Their pesto bowl is great, dans hangover is good quick fix, and their bagel sandwiches any of them are good. To give you perspective, I start eating before I even think of taking a picture

We had a late dinner here on a Tuesday night in early May, before Skaneateles gets the large summer…read morecrowds. Seated immediately, and given our choice of tables. We sat out on the porch, with views out over the water. Our server, Amy, was really attentive. Food was very good. We got the Bavarian pretzels appetizer, and the mustard sauce was delicious. Our server brought out a warm loaf of bread to go with the salads, which was a nice touch. Our entrees were exactly as described (Bluewater burger and Crab Cake sandwich), arrived just as we finished salads, and very good. The prices were totally reasonable. Appetizer, salad, two sandwiches, two soft drinks was around $65 for dinner. All in all, we were very happy with the meal.

My wife and I had lunch on Thursday, the restaurant was busy but not crowded. We had a bowl of…read moreLobster Bisque and Scallop chowder. The Bisques was barely warm and had no taste. A few pieces of lobster placed on top. The Chowder was warmer and was ok. We both had Arnold Palmers that were also tasteless. It was not to sweet but just sweet enough but had no flavor. With my eyes closed I could just barely tell the difference between it and my glass of water. We shared the Tuna appetizer. It had a seaweed salad. This was a delight and delicious. The service was mediocre at best. The waitress only came back to ask us how our meal was, just as we were finishing the Tuna. We are avid dinners at the Sherwood Inn and was disappointed with the BWG considering they are under the same ownership umbrella. As far as the ambiance of the grill it is boring and it felt like it needed updating.

A beautiful sunny day to sit on their little outdoor patio. It was a bit chilly, but still nice…read more They have a really nice selection of pastries and sweets for a small bakery. I decided to try the apple tart and the rugelagh. The apple tart was flaky and the filling was classic apple pie flavor. The rugelagh was a different type of pastry but equally as good. They are take out only but there are so many places to sit and eat ( when the weather is nice) and the views of Skaneateles Lake are amazing. If the weather is bad, take it home or just eat in your car!

There's a lot of nice things about Skaneateles. Add this one to the list…read more All I kept hearing about was, "stretch bread", "stretch bread", "stretch bread"... that's a lot of pressure to put on someone and someplace. Challenge met! Absolutely fantastic. If there's one place that I have found that rivals Columbus bakery (it's very close) it's here. Oh, they do offer other breads and pastries. Those will be will tried on our next trip. Enjoy!

Base my reviews off what you pay:…read more *Place was busy on a Saturday evening. Price - ~$60-$80 (appetizer, entree, drink, tip) Food - 4/5 - tasty and massive portions. Service - 4/5 - great recs, friendly. Ambiance - 3/5 - nicer downstairs. Overall - 4/5 - the spot to go to for Mexican in Skaneateles. Have had better Mexican before but the food us tasty as hell and the portions will leave you stuffed. My girlfriend couldn't even order an entree after appetizers lol. A ton of tequila options. Definitely order the Birria Pizza, but beware of its size. Service was great, Devin was very sweet and gave great recommendations. We did not feel rushed at all. Inside is fine, nothing really crazy. Great place and one of the Skaneateles staples. Best Dish - Birria Pizza, Lalo Tequila Would Return - Absolutely

I am very impressed with this restaurant. My family was visiting from out of town, I brought them…read morehere. It was my first time as well. We were immediately seated for a late lunch on a Saturday. There was a large staircase to the second level so be aware of accessibility. Our service was off to a slow start but everything was too delicious. We shared the triple dipper (salsa, guac and queso) amongst 5 people, it was plenty to share and they offered to bring more chips. We all got tacos (steak, chicken and carnitas) the other 2 guests ordered chimichangas. Everyone thought their food was delicious. The chimichangas were humongous and could probably feed you for a week The restaurant itself was very clean. It had tons of natural lighting and very trendy decor. It photographs well and has a unique look for a Mexican restaurant