We ordered for dinner. We got the cheesesteak Stromboli added pepperoni, delicious! They also made…read moresure you have enough sauce. The fried sampler, that was also delicious! Also garlic knots, guess what? delicious! Service was great! The place was clean.

Takes over 2 hours to get my food every time it always comes cold and soggy and the delivery driver…read moresuck! Very rude I wish they did better I used to love this place! Update it's actually been three hours and this is what we got: Cold Italian wedding soup Soggy salad 2 Rock hard pizzas And whatever you want to call the picture (supposed to be a s'mores pizza) I would not recommend this place to anyone!!

ATTENTION: THEY HAVE MOVE to new location in east stroudsburg 3 min away!!! new address:…read more 246 n courtland east stroudsburg, pa Number to call is the same as it presented here, it has not changed. I had the pleasure of Lunch and dining at Palumbo Pizza, and it exceeded all my expectations. This place truly brings the essence of authentic Italian pizza to your plate, and it's as close to traditional New York City pizza as you can get without venturing into Manhattan. The family-owned atmosphere adds a warm and inviting touch to the dining experience. What impressed me most was the lightning-fast service; it's evident they take pride in providing excellent customer service. The menu boasts a terrific selection, and the fact that everything is made fresh to order ensures the highest quality. Palumbo Pizza is a gem, and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a taste of both Italy and New York City right in their neighborhood. I can't wait to return for another delicious meal!

Palumbos has long been our favorite pizza place. I have to drive past other places to come to get…read morethe best ! They do a great job to customize our pizzas. In addition their wings are good and saucey.. we always get good service and have gotten several things off the menu including delicious sandwiches. They have specials on certain days.. I recommend them !

Oh my God, what an incredible find. Absolutely delicious pizza and I have had pizza all over the…read moreplace. Thin crust, firm under body great flavor .....beautiful sauce loved it.

As a New Yorker I am always skeptical when an out of NY place advertises NY PIZZA usually it is…read morenot. This place is amazing!! (1)The slice is enormous (2) sauce had flavor, as in not just tomato (3) sauce was not sweet (4) staff is friendly. We liked it so much we came back the next day Decor is great... bunch of goombas on the wall!

Walking around the main street in Stroudsburg, we stopped in to this pizzeria for something quick…read morefor dinner. I ordered two slices, the pepperoni and the grandma. They were heated up quickly and brought out to us. I really liked the grandma slice - the sauce was great and it tasted fresh, and I liked the thicker Sicilian style crust. The pepperoni was alright, the cheese congealed a bit and it was a bit too oily than other slice.

The best Pizza in the Pocono's! Me and my dad been here multiple times because the food is that…read moregood, the service is wonderful as well, and it's one of the few places where they actually give you a pizza 'buy 10, get 1 free' coupon that you can through with repeat visits. Definitely a must visit if in the area just for the food and wonderful staff! PS. My favorite is a large meat lover's pie they make which is bigger than my countertop : )

Taco meat made with carrots!! With 3 toppings! I didn't order carrots! Are they Mexican or…read moreItalian?? New guy running into ground! I miss my local pizza parlor! I'll be going back to Alfies good food good prices. Not ever returning.

Their food is always so fresh and so good. VERY generous portions. Prices are average and the…read moreworkers are so nice.

I didn't like the previous pizzeria, but willing to try the new owners pizza. The regular pie and…read moreSicilian were very good the first time, it was fresh. The second time it was different, the Sicilian dough was dry. Same problem with all the pizzerias around here, they are inconsistent. I will give them another try.

(I wrote this in a private Facebook group first) So, as most…read moreof you know, I was going to review the old Amadeos pizzeria, which is now Pocono Pines pizzeria and restaurant. Well, here's my experience. (Aside from this experience, I did go once before just for a slice; wasn't that amused with the staff, but the pizza was decent.) Me: Hello, can I place an order for pickup? Clerk: Sure, what would you like? Me: I'd like a large half pepperoni and cheese, and a large vodka sauce pizza. Clerk: Okay, that will be $43. It will be ready in 20 minutes. Me: Okay, see you soon. I walk into the restaurant. Me: Hello, I ordered the 2 pies. Clerk: Okay, that will be $43. Are you paying with cash or card? Me: Card. Clerk: Okay, here is your receipt. The pizza will be right out. Me: (stands around for another 10 minutes) Clerk: Here's your pizza. Have a good day. Me: Thank you. As I walk away with the pizza, I'm thinking to myself that they are very heavy. I walk to the car and open them up, and what was supposed to be the vodka sauce pizza was a white vodka sauce with fried chicken and penne pasta. So, I head back in to get this fixed. Me: Hello, this isn't what I ordered. There's chicken and penne on this pizza; I just wanted a vodka sauce pizza. Clerk: Okay, sorry about that. I'll see what they can do about this. Me: Thank you so much. Now, here's where it gets interesting. Clerk: Do you want them to just pick the chicken and pasta off the pizza? Me: Um, no. That would completely butcher the pizza ‍. Clerk: Okay, um, do you want a new pizza? Me: No, it's okay. I'll just take a refund. Clerk: Okay, let me talk to the manager. Manger says he can't give you a refund. Me: yes he has to or I will be calling my bank and making this a fraudulent charge. Clerk:I'll be right back Manager: I CAN'T GIVE YOU A REFUND. THAT'S $24 THAT I HAVE TO GIVE YOU. EVERYONE IS MAKING $24, AND NOW I HAVE TO GIVE YOU MONEY. HOW DID YOU PLACE THE ORDER, PHONE OR ONLINE? Me: Over the phone, and yes, you owe me $24 because that is not what I ordered, and I'm not walking away with the pizza. I want a refund. Manager: (huffs, yells at the clerk, and tells her that she put the order in wrong) Tells her to refund me. Clerk: Here is your refund. Would you like a receipt? Me: Oh yes, indeed. I come home with just the one half pepperoni and cheese. It's a thicker pizza than the slice I had one month prior. The bread was doughy, and the cheese was meh. There was a little bit of good flavor in the sauce though. Curious to know what kind of ingredients they are using since they can't afford to give me a refund and questioning the freshness of those ingredients. It's safe to say, I don't need to go back there and I'll keep my business with AJs.

I have gone to the Original Palumbo's a few times before in Stroudsburg and wanted to check out…read morethis one in the Bartonsville area as well. Went early on around when they opened for the day. The man working inside was friendly and the slice was just over $2 or so which is standard for the area. The slice was good. Minimal flop and a nice little char on the bottom. Sauce to cheese ratio was solid and the sauce had good flavor. Couldn't speak to the rest of the menu as I just grabbed a slice to go, but the cheese slice was solid.

[1154] 2/2021…read more We were staying a nearby hotel so decided to check this place out. There is no indoor dining due to Covid but that was fine with me since were taking it out. The staff was nice The single slice I ordered was tasty. Kid didn't like his nuggets

We decided to order pizza here again, there's something about this place, they are so welcoming,…read moreand treat each customer like they are family. They do there best to remember your name, so they can call everyone by there first names when there coming in for there orders. We ordered a large Sicilian pizza, half with pepperoni and half with meatballs, order of mozzarella sticks and a small order of garlic knots. Everything was just coming out of the fryer and oven when we got there to pick up our order. So , yes everything was hot and fresh. The only thing I can say is the mozzarella sticks are nothing to call home about, but we still ate them. They did have a sign on there door, stating as of January 1,2023 they will start being closed on Mondays.

My favorite pizza place- when my grandbabies come in from NJ-they need Bono -nothing else-Hot…read morewings-pizza garlic nots-Gyro and stromboli. To say in the least- when we come in, they know us and we always get what we expect-LOVE THIS PLACE AND THE PEOPLE. Py peeps are coming today-I can't wait