Had a wonderful experience at Casa D'Angelo! The staff was incredibly attentive, friendly, and genuinely helpful, especially with their recommendations. They shared some of their favorite dishes, which made ordering easy and made the meal feel more personal. We started with the Caesar salad and truffle fries, followed by the steak cooked medium rare, which was absolutely perfect--tender, juicy, and cooked exactly as requested. The Bucatini all'Amatrician was also delicious and full of flavor. We enjoyed a glass of Merlot with dinner, then finished with a macchiato and chocolate lava cake--the perfect combination to end the meal. The complimentary limoncello was a really nice touch and a great way to finish the evening. Great food, excellent service, and a welcoming atmosphere. The staff clearly cares about their guests and knows their menu well. Definitely worth a visit and a place I'd happily return to! read more

See all

We visited Casa D'Angelo and ordered a four-cheese pizza. Unfortunately, we were not big fans of it. My kids usually love pizza, but they barely touched it because the crust was very dark and tasted burned. I understand that some wood-fired pizzas are meant to have a bit of char, but this one seemed overcooked for our taste. On the positive side, the staff was friendly and attentive. We appreciated the complimentary fresh hot bread and a cold bottle of water, which was especially welcome on a hot day. The highlight of our visit was watching the chefs prepare dishes with fire and live cooking techniques. The guests at the table next to us ordered lobster and pasta, and it was fun to watch the chefs in action. Overall, the service and atmosphere were enjoyable, but the pizza did not meet our expectations. read more

Casa D'angelo New York - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

My personal experience outside of the rest of my group was a decent lunch. The chicken parm was good. The pasta was a bit on the al dente side, I would have preferred it cooked an extra minute personally. The sauce could have been a little more rich additionally. Not a bad meal at all though, but definitely Manhattan tourist pricing. Hugo Spritz was tasty! Would the convenience fee be waived had I paid cash? It wasn't explained, just added on the bill. One of my table mates had an issue with their meal, and the restaurant did solve it professionally, so credit to them. Food came out super fast. I don't mind waiting a bit longer for food cooked just right and perfectly instead of rushed out. read more

Crazy good food. Had a reservation. Showed up early. No big thing. Been dying for pasta and was not disappointed. Fettuccine with shrimp and JUST THE RIGHT AMOUNT of serving. Not too big like a chain and not to small. Just right. Great way to kick off our trip. read more

See all

We found this place on Yelp since we were in soho and it's convenient and my kid wanted steak and my husband wanted pasta. We ordered their special steak with pasta on the cheese wheel. The pasta was on a sweeter side. The steak was good with good texture and flavor. Sever was also very professional and attentive. I am not sure if it's a typical practice bc they charged us a convenience charge on top of tips without telling us before the bills. The appetizer scallops could skip bc it's very small and the taste was a little strange. read more

See all

The octopus salad was amazing, but their "house made pasta cacio e pepe" was terrible. I received a serving of average tasting (didn't feel house made) cold bucatini, floating in cream (not cheese). read more

No trip to New York is complete without an Italian dinner in Little Italy. There are so many restaurants to choose from but I ultimately selected the home of the famous cheese wheel pasta dish! The cheese wheel pasta was just as good as expected. The meatballs and arancini starters were good but they didn't really compare to the star of the show. This place is definitely worth checking out. read more

See all

Can't go wrong with their pasta.Quite a large place. Yummy Spicy Vodka pasta.Calamari could have been crispier.Tiramisu was delicious.If you are hungry and are in the area,this was good.Saw a neighboring table order the cheese wheel pasta,looked so yummy! read more

Casa D'angelo New York - Calamari Fritti - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I was craving my favorite pasta, Cacio e Pepe, and out of the several Italian restaurants recommended in Little Italy, Casa D'Angelo does it the right way, which is with Pecorino Romano Cheese, not Parmegianno (Parmesan). That's the way I've had it everywhere in Rome where Cacio e Pepe originated from. Cacio e Pepe is spaghetti-style pasta with black pepper and Pecorino cheese, and it is a wonderful, deceptively simple dish . The black pepper is what brings that spicy bite to the salty hard cheese to tingle the taste buds. Every bite is a delight here! Don't bother paying a lot more for this pasta from a cheese wheel like in a few places nearby, especially if it's a Parmesan cheese wheel. You pay a whole lot more and the pasta becomes overly cheesy and you lose the peppery nature of it. Stick with the traditional way of enjoying Cacio e Pepe. The restaurant is a very classic Italian restaurant. The only slight knock is while I love the olive oil and balsamic vinaigrette, the toasted bread was a bit on the hard side. read more

Casa D'angelo New York - Cacio e Pepe - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Very disappointing experience, especially because I was dining with my family. The steak was clearly listed on the menu at $75, so I ordered it based on that price. However, when I received the bill, I was charged $169 for the steak. What makes this more frustrating is that the waiter did not mention or clarify the significantly higher price before placing my order. I understand that prices can sometimes vary depending on size or preparation, but a difference of $94 from the menu price is something that should absolutely be disclosed to the customer before the order is placed. I feel this was very misleading and completely ruined what was supposed to be a nice family dinner. Customers should be able to trust the prices shown on the menu and should be informed clearly if the actual charge will be substantially higher. I would not recommend this restaurant based on this experience. read more

Disappointing return to Mulberry Street at Casa D'Angelo I was super excited to visit New York and go back to Little Italy on Mulberry Street. I saw the original Angelo's had reopened as Casa D'Angelo, but I left very disappointed. The bread was excellent -- that was the highlight. Unfortunately, the rest didn't hold up. The spadini, which used to be one of my favorites, was three times as thick as it should've been and raw in the center. The spicy vodka rigatoni had no flavor and the pasta was mushy, the veal parmesan was just fair, and the spaghetti was halfway decent. I was so let down that I didn't even stay for dessert. Really hoped for better on this return visit. read more

See all

Fantastic food, great atmosphere and get the table side alfredo for sure. This is home style food - enjoy the pureness and delicious simplicity. read more

See all

Husband has visited multiple times in his visits to NY but this was my first time and I see why he enjoys it so much. We were welcomed warmly and got a table outside on a warm May night. Lumi did a great job serving us and we shared the seafood pasta for two, which came in a big paella style pan - could have served all four of us! I loved my veal piccata and the wine list is extensive. Limoncello to end the night was a nice touch. A great spot in an iconic part of town that is fun to explore. read more

We were in little Italy and decided to try this place ! First, service was amazing , they deserve all stars for service. They have casual Italian ambience. Food was good. Burrata : This is an amazing appetizer for vegetarians. Burrata was very fresh and flavorful. The base is chopped and cooked eggplant and sautéed with some vegetables. This whole thing totally work as a combination. Tortellini de ricotta : This was recommended by server. We enjoyed it. The sauce is creamy and buttery. Pasta with chicken ( pollo Fransence) : This is spaghetti noodles with very nice lemon butter sauce. Chicken was bit chewy and I did not enjoyed the taste. This place may not have been a standout for me but I can see how others are enjoying ... it has a cool vibe ! read more

See all

This place was delicious. We were looking for real Italian food, and they delivered. Everything was amazing. My son had the pasta in Alfredo sauce that was cooked in a cheese wheel with truffles on top. It was terrific. I had a risotto with mushrooms. Definitely one of the best I've ever had! Prices were pretty reasonable. Service was good. Only odd thing was a guy taking pics and then trying to sell them to you for $20. Definitely cheapened the experience. read more

Casa D'angelo New York - Prices for various dishes - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Little Italy NY Treasure!!!!!! We had lunch her. A group of 5. We were greeted and drawn in by a fun and friendly gent. We walked in and were quickly seated. The ambiance was very Italian and full of life. Our server was incredibly informative and helpful. The food was AMAZING!!!!! We had different pasta dishes all made fresh right there. We enjoyed watching one of our dishes made in the cheese wheel and topped with truffle oil and fresh truffle slices. Desserts were superb!!!! A must try when in town!!! read more

Casa D'angelo New York - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

I stopped by on a recent trip to NYC. I was in the area, and this restaurant had good Yelp Reviews. I was very disappointed in the food. I think it's possibly because of what I ordered and not the food itself. I did enjoy the house wine that was very affordable. The free bread was also delicious. I enjoyed watching the waiter make and serve the alfredo sauce from a cheese wheel for another guest. Unfortunately, I wasn't able to try that dish because of my dairy limitations. If I was back in NYC again, I would probably skip this restaurant for something else in the area. Sorry Casa D'Angelo. read more

See all

Amazing! We had the best lunch at Casa D'Angelo. The staff was friendly and incredibly accommodating, and every dish tasted fresh and thoughtfully prepared. The steak practically melted in our mouths. Already looking forward to our next visit. read more

Great Italian restaurant and excellent experience here, everyone was super nice and accommodating. Love the ambiance and the food was amazing. It was very busy for a Thursday night. For appetizer, my friend and I shared the burrata, definitely a must have. I ordered the rigatoni alle polpette, very good but wished it came with more meatballs, only came with two. My friend ordered the tortellini di ricotta. I enjoyed this pasta more, I would definitely recommend this one. For dessert, we had the tiramisu, we thought it was very good, perfect way to end our dinner. Fabio even showed us the kitchen where they make pasta, this was very cool. I look forward to coming back to try their other dishes. read more

See all

I came here with my friends during the San Genaro festival. We were looking for a place to sit down and eat. This place looked clean and the staff seemed very friendly. We ordered a few drinks, I had a spritz and my friends had margaritas. The drinks were good. The ambience also was nice. Everyone around us was enjoying themselves and laughing. The waiter was kind and explained the specials in detail. read more

Casa D'angelo New York - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great service and delicious food! Beautiful outdoor dining experience. Friendly staff and clean facility. Great end to our NYC trip!

Fresh homemade pasta and great people watching. The staff are lovely and service is exceptional. Try one of the pastas in their cheese wheel and get a seat outside on the patio. The vodka rigatoni and chicken piccata were delicious! Reservations are not needed, while it gets busy you can still grab a walk-in table. The restrooms also look newly removed and are very clean. read more

See all

Friendly service and outdoor seating in Little Italy. The bread was warm and they offered mocktails and cocktails. The pasta was gummy. read more

See all

We had the BEST experience here. Good wine, good food, great service, fun atmosphere. I loved every minute of it. Honestly I can't say anything negative, you won't regret this stop, it tasted very authentic and we got plenty to eat! I loved the mushroom risotto, and the lobster ravioli was great! We had a big party so getting a nice experience like that is so fun. Thank you to the owners and staff! read more

Casa D'angelo New York - Mushroom Risotto ai Funghi Selvatici - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We came to celebrate my Aunt Daisy's birthday and were seated immediately at a lovely table with a beautiful view of the diners outside. The lighting and ambiance were perfect. Our head server, Salvador, was outstanding--he explained the specials in detail and helped us choose the perfect wine. Everything we ordered was absolutely delicious. We started with baked clams in a lemony sauce--so good we couldn't even stop to take a picture. I had the Osso Buco served with a light pasta; it was tender and full of flavor. My sister ordered the ribeye with pasta prepared tableside--absolutely fantastic. Aunt Daisy and Nelly both had the shrimp scampi, and there wasn't a morsel left on their plates. The bread with dipping oil was irresistible--so good that we probably ate too much of it, leaving me unable to finish my entrée (but happily taking the rest home for lunch tomorrow). I wholeheartedly recommend this restaurant. The food is truly authentic Italian, every dish we had was exceptional, and we will definitely be coming back. read more

Florin took amazing care of us for my daughter's Sweet 16 dinner! We arrived about 30 minutes early for our reservation and were still seated immediately. The bread was fresh and delicious. We had meatballs and mozzarella for appetizers (the mozzarella is huge) and both were delicious. Our entrees were pepperoni pizza, fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp, spaghetti with meat sauce and meatballs, and two cheese wheel pastas with truffles. The cheese wheel pasta stole the show but all of us were very happy with our choices. Dessert was tiramisu and cheesecake. Everything was delicious and just what we wanted in Little Italy. Casa d'Angelo is a wonderful, intimate, traditional Italian restaurant and I highly recommend it. read more

See all

We came across this place while walking through little Italy and they caught us with the fresh pasta made in a cheese wheel. It did not disappoint. We started with the anti-pasta Italiano and it was amazing. The fettuccine out of the cheese wheel with the black truffle was to die for. Just a nice quaint little restaurant with great food and service. Our server was amazing as well as all the other additional staff even gave us a free champagne when he found out we were on our honeymoon. Highly recommend this restaurant. read more

See all

Food was phenomenal and service was even better. We got one of the specials where the pasta was mixed in a cheese wheel and they invited me to get up close because I was curious and saw I was a photographer. I was so excited and they were so incredibly kind, warm and welcoming. The pasta was all so fresh, and the flavors were fantastic. Great outdoor seating when we went in a cute little area of Little Italy. read more

See all

Service was excellent and food delicious. We had the lasagna and cheese wheel pasta, which was made table side. Would recommend! read more

Casa D'angelo New York - Cheese wheel pasta made table side - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We came to celebrate my wife's birthday ..our first time in Little Italy and chose Casa D'Angelo's, drawn in by its rich history dating back to 1902. From the moment we arrived to the moment we left, everything was wonderful. The food was absolutely delicious!! We split everything.. We ordered the minestrone & miso salad, the beef carpaccio, and the seafood for two, which could have fed for ppl in my opinion... all of which exceeded our expectations. We also shared a bottle of wine from their private cellar, and it was worth every penny. Our server, Fort, was amazing, attentive, knowledgeable, and made our experience even more special. The restaurant is stunning both inside and out. If I ever return to Little Italy in New York, this will definitely be my first stop. read more

See all

Although when you are walking down mulberry street or in little Italy everything may looks very touristy and there are people outside a lot of the restaurants trying to get you to come in I really don't think this place is touristy at all Cavernous space extending back into the building there appears to be plenty of seating We did make a reservation before hand though The service was friendly and prompt It's interesting history for this space particularly . This restaurant reportedly at least per the staff was first opened in 1902 The restaurant burnt down in 2015 and then subsequently reopened I tried the classic pasta in the cheese wheel (flambés in the wheel with some cream sauce) a la denté and delicious but very buttery and very creamy topped with generous black truffle shaving The lasagne was quite rich, soft and filling read more

See all

We got a 9:30pm reservation because we booked the day before. We arrived probably just in time and they sat us immediately. A group of 10 of us (including kids). The waiter, Edwardo, was wonderful! He kept checking on whenever we were ready to order with food and drinks. We started calling out his name, and he was completely fine with it because after 2 hours, we were all family. We even took a picture WITH him. At one point, we noticed the restaurant was emptying out and asked if we should leave, he told us we were just fine! We ordered the specials, which were all delicious. I ordered pretty basic, the spicy vodka pasta and we got ravioli for the kiddo. Everything came out quickly tasting perfect. He tried to explain to me that if we were getting specials we were ordering too many meals, but when I explained that I was veg, he was 100% on board and got it ordered. read more

We thoroughly enjoyed ourselves at this classic Italian restaurant in Little Italy. The bruschetta was fabulous! Everyone's meals were delicious, though it wasn't my daughter's favorite (ever) lobster ravioli. My shrimp fra diavolo was one of the best (ever). The special was a truffle pasta prepared tableside and, while pricey, it delivered! For dessert, they delivered a cheesecake and a song for my sister's birthday and shots of limoncello. Service was impeccable and the ambiance was also great. While a slightly more expensive option for dinner, Casa D'Angelo was well worth it! read more

See all

We visited durning the San Gennaro festival for lunch. Service was as on point but more importantly the food was truly outstanding. We got the cannelloni and the steak special which was two petite filets and cheese wheel pap read more

We went for dinner and then lunch the next day. The service was impeccable. We did both outdoor and indoor dining and they were equally attentive with both. The meals were enjoyable. Ours consisted of veal piccata with a mussel appetizer. For lunch, we had the pasta wheel which was a fun experience. This meal was fairly pricey considering there is no meat. Both the plain and truffle versions were well prepared. read more

See all

The atmosphere was absolutely fantastic. My date and I had already decided to eat here but as we walked over, a man outside started waving at us and pointing at the restaurant, which solidified our decision to eat there. We really appreciated his work ethic and it elevated our experience. The server was incredibly helpful and food did not take long to come out at all. He even helped us out with the glaring sun by opening the awning they have outside of the restaurant. When we forgot to alert the kitchen of an allergy, our waiter assured us that it would not be a problem to switch out the plate, and my date's replacement meal came out when my plate was still hot! Very impressed and we will definitely return for the famous cheese wheel pasta everyone is raving about. This restaurant gets the prestigious Wooly Throckmorton award of approval! Huzzah! read more

This was one of the worst places I have ever been to. We ordered the cheese wheel pappardelle and it was cooked with so much added cheese and heavy cream and no seasoning. On top of that, the waiter did not indicate the special included truffles or that this was a $65 dish. So bland and overpriced. Don't waste your time, money or calories. Never again. read more

We were Warmly welcomed and seated immediately (we had reservations). The service and Christmas ambiance were fantastic. My daughter had a cheese pizza and it was amazing! Great pizza sauce and a good size. My other daughter and I split the table side fettuccine Alfredo and steak. Cool experience watching them make it table side. My husband's bolognese was tasty too. The drinks were great! Limoncello spritz! read more

See all

Walking down little Italy, we saw many many outdoor restaurants. Usually these are tourist traps but I can safely say I was very mistaken. The food was delicious, the service was incredible, and the staff was extremely helpful. Would recommend if you are in the area! read more

See all

Love the food!!! Will certainly come back and we were even serenaded which added to the experience!