The pleasant waitstaff was the only reason I didn't give a One Star rating, Over-priced and under-done crust. The toppings were sparse and not that good. Honestly, a frozen Red Baron would have been better. 31 bucks with 2$ tip for a 12 inch. Ugh!! read more

foods okay, cheesy breadstick sauce is atrocious tastes like mayonnaise. With that aside the ambiance and service was great!

Got the family deal for lunch today. Pizza and bread sticks were delicious!! Cesar salad had a bunch of wilted lettuce but over all out was all delicious. Staff was very friendly at pick up and offered extra sauces. Will definitely do it again! read more

Good pizza, make sure to use the app for deals. Skip the cheese breads nothing to brag about. Only ordered togo, and they have been really nice going in and picking it up. read more

I really enjoy the pizza from Farrelli's but the price is just not commensurate with quality for the last several visits. A large with two toppings on 1/2 the pizza cost around $32 and that seems unreasonable. The most recent photo I uploaded for this location shows that they could have been a little more generous on toppings. I don't have a problem paying $32 for a great pizza, but this time, and the last few times as well, Farrelli's has missed the mark. I do love that they have cashews on the menu full time now though. A+ on that one, guys. read more

See all

Pizza is delicious. Prices are high. But the quality makes all the difference. When you want to impress your guests go here.

I recently saw this restaurant and it's been on my mind to try it out anytime I have pizza, next. So I finally tried it! Due to no dine in, I called ahead to order my food and it was a great interaction. The man on the phone was pleasant and courteous and nothing changed when I went inside to pick it up, though curbside pickup is also available. I would love to dine in and see how the service is but for take out purposes, it was wonderful. The food was good - the chicken sausage ravioli was nothing special. I did like the sauce and the sausage but it wished that was the ravioli filling instead of it being on top. The ravioli, itself, was cheese based and quite dense. It lacked some flavor and pretty much bland. But if you like saucy things - this might be a good option for you. The next food item was the Blazzin' Chicken pizza and it was really good! I loved the pizza base itself - I am not a crust person but their crust was so good and cooked all the way through. The dough itself was light and well made. The pizza was a little dry, however, so that's the only negative, otherwise, it was a really well made pizza. Try it if you are around, there is something for everyone! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Ordered curbside delivery, waited several minutes after arriving. No one came out so I went inside to get my food. Ordered stuffed mushrooms, they were burned so couldn't eat them, bread that with them was burned and too hard to eat. Chicken bacon Pizza was burned as well, but I managed to find a couple of slices that were etible. I didn't feel like driving back to the restaurant so I just threw most of it away. I know it's a pandemic and resturants are struggling but this food should have never left the restaurant. read more

See all

Curbside pickup was horrible! Sent girlfriend in to get food and she proceeded to wait for over 5 minutes for our food that was ready and waiting. I blared my horn for service and still nothing. Ended up grabbing our own food and leaving. read more

Good food friendly staff.family friendly environment. Great at meeting specific needs like allergies. Highly recommended

This place is so inconsistent. Some days, the pizza is really good. Usually we get the pan pizza, but we've also tried the Buffalo chicken (not good at all), the NW traditional (honestly would be so much better without the weird cream cheese drizzle, and I love cream cheese on pizza), and the deluxe classic (not very impressionable bc I don't even really remember what it tasted like). Like I said, it's inconsistent. Some days the pizza is cooked perfectly, some days it's just undercooked and soggy AF. Sometimes it's burnt to a crisp on the bottom, and undercooked up top. Usually the apps are pretty good, but we've only tried just about all of them once except the fire stix and the cheesy stix which we've tried twice. But in our most recent order, the cheese stix were burnt, and not in the good way like a wood fired pizza would be. The entire bottom was blackened and the top was dry and bitter. The bottom of our pizza was burnt as well. And usually the stix come with marinara sauce, but they STRAIGHT UP served us a side of salsa and thought we wouldn't notice. Like, WHAT?! I feel kind of bad for this review bc the staff is always super nice and this place is relatively quick. But what pains me are the prices. Pizza time is just as fast, tastes pretty good, and is a lot more affordable. read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

So I've been dutifully impressed with Farelli's until today... Ordered a Mt Tahoma, a favorite - always has come out great. Well today I get a sausage and pepperoni pizza and a container of arugula and a cup of balsamic. So essentially a $10 pizza with a salad. I paid $20 for the Mt Tahoma, not what I got, it's about a product, not convenience. The champs also decided to skip me on my honey too, it's cool, as an involuntary employee of Farrelli's (conscripted as I picked up my food), I assembled it myself and then managed to find honey in my cabinet... What's going on here? read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

I've been coming to this place for a while now and it never disappoints. Great place for date night

This review is for my order today. My husband and I usually order and pick up from them. This is upsetting to me. My husband went to pick up a medium mt. Tahoma and some fire sticks. Look how disappointing the pizza is! Menu says that there should be arugula on it. But it doesn't taste or look like arugula... read more

Farrelli's Pizza - I don't remember mt. Tahoma looking like this... so disappointed! - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Solid wood fired pizza, and a good kids menu. Good for the area, not many better pizza options around.

Went into this evening around 6pm and sat in the bar with my boyfriend. Megan was our server and she made what has been a shitty week of being with my Grandfather as he died, a little brighter with her kindness, recommendations, care and of course the yummy food she brought to us timely and fresh. She is a great asset to you all there and if you are lucky enough to be seated in her section you're going to have a great meal! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - F-Bomb and mug o beer - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Great place for Happy hour, not crowded, friendly staff, awesome Cosmos! Good music. Perfect! And great appetizers too. read more

See all

So went for the first time to Farrelli's. I will say the service was very good and I would recommend their strawberry lemonade. However their boneless wings are nothing more than chicken nuggets that your paying 14 dollars for. For are pizza we had the 16" james favorite 31 dollars for this and in my opinion the pizza didn't have any really outstanding or amazing taste to it and instead was just rather plain and also the biggest issue with the pizza was that the dough was undercooked thankfully not raw but definitely undercooked. read more

Farrelli's Pizza - James pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Shout out to Jason the manager. He has always been nice and present in his position. He's a solid at the 176 location and asset to their staff. read more

My favorite pizza in Wa. The spicy sausage and pepper pizza is da bomb!!! So tasty. Has a spicy jalapeño cream cheese base. Topped with cashews. You've got to try this pizza. Farrelli's always has specials if you buy three pizzas. You can always save some!!! read more

We ordered for curbside pickup, was told it was going to be about 20 minutes. Called when we arrived about 15 minutes later. They seemed a little busy so we were trying to be patient but 20 minutes of sitting in a running car later I finally went into the restaurant where I found that our order had been just sitting there and was now cold. Bonus: when we got home, we found our order was incorrect. Rather than own the mistakes or even apologize, the girl at the counter had one excuse after another for their ineptitude. Edit: my sister apparently got a refund from the manager. They kept the tip. Classy. read more

Great chow, great service, food is hot and the beer is bubbly. The waiter recognizes that most people don't want to talk about how great their meal is when they're shoving food in their mouth, and arrived at all the right times. A little expensive but what isn't these days? read more

I've never had a bad experience. I've tried most of the pizzas, up until about 4 months ago. All are amazingly delicious. so if they added anymore I'm going back pronto. Great staff to. read more

Super great Pizza parlour for all ages. Birthday or a luncheon or dinner you will be happy with the price and most of all ...the flavors. Sodas are a little bit but always good. read more

Tender cheesy ravioli pillows topped with a flavorful Italian sausage Bolognese sauce made a delicious pairing that I was not expecting from a pizza parlor. It was refreshing to see that they had a dedicated sauce verses using pizza sauce. I wasn't fond of the garlic bread that was served with the ravioli. It literally had no garlic flavor. Aside from that, it was a good mea. Good food. Good service. Fast. Friendly. I'd eat here again. read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Ravioli - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Man o man! Some of the best pizza I've had in awhile. The creativity they put into each pizza, really can be tasted and appreciated with every bite. This place isn't for cookie cutter domino loving weirdos. Here you can try a craft pizza and pair it with one of their many on tap beers or, just with a mix drink. The happy hour is pretty decent and well priced also. If you're lucky enough, there is a girl by the name of Kristen who works in the bar! GET HER AS YOUR SERVER!!! She is very professional and pretty damn good at her job! She's also is very pretty. I went through the other reviews on this thread and most of them don't even make sense. They were probably just some cookie cutter weirdo looking for a quick slice of pizza, and doesn't appreciate a chef's touch. Any ways, give this a place a try!! read more

Where the heck is my slice of pizza I have been coming to your establishment for years. please ensure this does not happen again... read more

Farrelli's Pizza - I came home to this ridiculous I have been a resident for over 40 years here never had this happen to any pizza I bought this from the bar - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Great pizza, full menu, and our server Abby Jo is the bomb! We always enjoy eating here, but can't decide what to get, and Abby Jo made our evening even better by suggesting we could do a half and half pizza, and try two very different styles. read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Love the service and the pizzas. The food is great but make sure you have enough money. Very spendy. But for a once a month visit it's worth it. read more

Ate dinner there last night and the food portions were back to normal as was the service. I retract my earlier review- must have just gone there on a couple of "off" nights. read more

Came for late lunch. During happy hour. Service was a little slow initially. Ordered a hefe beer and Manny's Pale Ale beer and the lunch special. Came with 12" pizza which we ordered as the Chicken Bacon Ranch. Also came with a soup (Tomato Gorgonzola) and a side salad. Soup was ok and my wife described it as "Hospital style soup." Salad was ok. Pizza ok but not great. Overall disappointed. Will not be back. read more

See all

I recieved my togo pizza barely cooked but I hadnt eaten in a day so i slowly ate the pizza. It made me really nauseous after two slices but I thought it was my upset stomach from being hungry. Nope, i got food poisoning!! Been vomiting and feeling woozy the past two days as a result. Also the pizza was really disappointing and almost gross. Maybe dont try to build your own or any of the chicken or bbq it was super iffy. read more

Waited 10 minutes in a slow bar to get ignored. Food has been good in the past but service is lacking...

I absolutely love this place the only reason i give 4 stars is because two pizzas gonna cost you 70 dollars and i get it.... Quality cost money. Favorite pizza tho! read more

Went there on Tuesday had chicken strip appetizer $ 13:49 for 3 pieces of chicken no fries $ 550 for a very very weak drink read more

Farrelli's Pizza - This is my $13.49 doughy chicken strips - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

We walked in and was greeted we let them know we wanted to sit in the bar well needless to say once we sat down we sat for 10 minutes not one person came by. They did know we where there as 2 different folks just looked at us. Go to a different place like the one in sumner. read more

We loved the promt service and the quality of the food that we got. Will definitely come back! read more

Farrelli's Pizza - Our pizza had the perfect amount of cheese on it! - Pizza Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

The pizza here is real good, and really love the Calzones they have here, the Calzones are perfect for one person. I also love the beer selection, and that they have Peps products, which is a plus in my book. The service here ALWAYS has been real good, and the prices of the food and drinks is reasonably priced. I would highly recommend any Farrelli's pizza store as havent had a bad place so far. read more

See all

What happens when you're the only black man in Farrellis. You get no service. Wow! Thought they were local but wow I'm disgusted. Literally no service!!!! read more

We LOVE our Frederickson Farrellis! The staff is awesome and remembers us when we come in. The food is incredible and we love to try the monthly featured pizzas. Also, incredible happy hour, which is nice for occasional kidless date nights. read more