The food was amazing. I never had a quesadilla like this one in a long while. The quesadilla was quite filling and i'm 6'2, 230lbs, and I was full. It tasted out of this world. I can only imagine how the other food would taste, but i'm going back for the quesadilla again. read more

The grilled fish tacos from here are yummy and filling. I ordered a side of rice which is also yummy and had to take the rest of it along with my second taco to go... the only thing I will say is that the fish taco was a bit salty but was still good and I wish they had shrimp tacos on the menu. The guacamole is also delicious but the chips were bland. Also the prices are great, you get a lot for your buck. read more

This place was actually pretty tasty! I mean it's not Chipotle, but let's be honest, nothing beats Chipotle!!! HUGE portions, well seasoned and sweet and accommodating staff. The wait was kinda long and I wish they had tabasco, but other than that we were pretty satisfied! read more

Such a great find! Got the guac, steak quesadilla, and fish and steak tacos and all were really good. Reasonable prices and legit food will definitely be returning. read more

Good prices, better food. A few small tables. I had the fish burrito. Nice array of hot sauces to choose from. Appreciated the eco friendly reusable silverware, wish more restaurants would do that. Lots of Mexican options in the area but this one was just right. Also tried the steak burrito bowl and that tasted amazing as well. Would definitely recommend this place. I'll be back. read more

Luckily i have to give one star to leave a review. CUSTOMER SERVICE HORRIBLE; We placed 2 orders at the same sitting and gentlemen at the register only took one order, after watching multiple people place orders and leave with their purchase we questioned where is the 2nd order the register dude says i thought it was only one order BUT WAIT 1 order was 2 tacos and the 2nd 3 tacos...... incredible BUT I have to say the 2 tacos that did come out were horrible they fell apart upon biting into them (soft tacos); thank god I didnt get the other 3, the SERVICE DESTROYED MY APPETITE !!!! Good thing i SAVED money though, TACO BELL would be my preference before this place, the other patrons next to us had mutual feelings..... ENJOY ! ****LET ME NOT FORGET ONLY TAP WATER (WITHOUT A COVER TO THE CONTAINER ON TOP OF THAT) NOT EVEN BOTTLED WATER FOR PURCHASE HAD TO GO TO DUNKIN DONUTS NEXT DOOR (great way to increase your revenue) 2 cans of ginger ale 5 cans of coke and diet coke in the frig, never mind they dont provide you straws you have to get up and get them yourself, where are the beverages SMH..... i wont continue.... again, ENJOY (TRAVELED ALL THE WAY FROM QUEENS FOR NOTHING) read more

I usually go to the Fatty Daddy's on 9th street, but I was having a bar crawl with some friends and we were in this area and I know that this place never disappoints. It's the perfect spot for good, fast mexican food, priced well with great service. I got the chips and guac for the first time, and they were AWESOME. The chips were crispy and salty, just how I like them. It's a good thing this place is a little bit of a walk from me, or else I'd be here every single day. read more

I couldn't make sense to how or why their food tasted so damn good. I got the chicken torta and it was the best $8 I've ever spent.

Great service and atmosphere. The food was delicious, inexpensive and you'll definitely have leftovers. Steak burrito, al pastor and the portabello burrito were all enjoyed by our group. Happy to have fast Mexican again on Smith street. read more

Authentic Mexican food, the best tacos ever. Very busy place, but great service. The only thing I don't like is the music. Mexican restaurant need Mexican or Hispanic music. read more

Good tacos to takeout. Good guacamole as well. Place is small inside but If your planning to eat there can make do.

Great tacos. Some of the better I have had on the east coast and definitely the best in the neighborhood

I LOVE Fatty Daddy Taco and I'm so sad I no longer live in a neighborhood where they deliver to me. The food is impeccably fresh (more-so than most restaurants), and the flavors are balanced. Delivery is fast. I really liked being able to customize my order. I swear, if I could, I would eat their food 4 days a week. I'm not joking. Try it! read more

Their steak bowl puts the likes of Chipotle to shame. Fresh, delicious, great portion, and good prices.

best tacos i've had in ny! ¡delicioso!

High quality for good price. Had a delish chicken taco for $3.21 including tax. Didn't expect to have fresh guac, piping hot fresh chicken and soft warm tortilla. Really good. Can't wait to try rest of menu. read more

Hands down the BEST guacamole and Vegetarian Tortilla Soup ever.

Amazing food. Rude-as-hell service. REALLY unnecessary. The shit always comes from the top - someone needs some therapy methinks

I had the Mexican chopped salad with chicken. It is what you would expect from a fast food Mexican place. Also had the guacamole with chips and was good. I would recommend this place if you are looking for take out. read more

Fatty Daddy Taco - Mexican chopped salad - Mexican Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I've eaten at a number of burrito places since my original review of Fatty Daddy (Smith Street location) and I always find myself saying the same thing after eating someone else's burrito: Fatty Daddy's is better. I stick to the 9th Street location, though ;) read more

INCREDIBLE fish tacos! I was with a large group of people from out of state and came here solely because of the Yelp reviews. So glad we did. Everyone loves everything they got! Great vibe and great little hole in the wall place! You'll be glad you came! read more

I ordered cheese quesadilla's and they are made with yellow American cheese???? Not happy at all. Grilled chicken taco's are ok nothing to scream about, mines are better. Will not be ordering from them again read more

As a San Diego native who grew up eating good, inexpensive Mexican food, I was excited to try Fatty Daddy when it opened last year. After several visits, I am writing to say that this place is a big disappointment. The grilled chicken, chicken fajitas, and steak fajitas are all quite dry and make for an almost inedible torta. The 'grilled steak' is nothing like the carne asada I expected, and it is very telling that the most frequently ordered item is a simple cheese quesadilla. Service is chaotic and disorganized (a 'help wanted' sign is permanently affixed to the storefront), and seating is extremely cramped and limited. Ultimately, Fatty Daddy may be the best Mexican option on Smith Street right now, but that's kind of like being the best baseball team in Finland -- it doesn't mean much. AVOID read more

The food was sooo delicious and full of flavor. I had a grilled chicken burrito and my wife had the grilled chicken burrito bowl w/sour cream...Loved it! read more

Get it for lunch so often i wanted to rate them. Pretty good taco joint. Tacos are on point!

I think the food is delicious but they need to figure another way to deliver burritos. A hot burrito in an aluminum container makes the burrito steam and the wrap soggy. Hopefully they'll read this and look into other options. Have ordered delivery probably about half a dozen times since you guys opened on Smith. Again, love the food -- it's just the tortilla could use some love in an oven for a few minutes to crisp slightly? read more

Good food but I hate that they don't have a bathroom and encourage you to use Starbucks bathroom :( I love the rice & beans with cheese, fish tacos and quesadillas. They have a decent lunch special. Would definitely come more if they were more dining in friendly- I don't particularly like Mexican food take out. Overall a great place for a quick taco read more

Used to be, the burritos here were reliably good..and the delivery fast (which is to be expected when you live 6 blocks away). But lately, there have been problems. The last time I ordered, the steak in my burrito was tough and impossible to chew. And the delivery took an hour. And they forgot to include the hot sauce we requested...which made the grisly meat in the burrito even less palatable. Sad to see a good place go down hill..I sincerely hope that's not what's going on here. Very disappointing. read more

$4.5 for a non-authentic taco is not worth it. Save your money for the real tacos w/ cilantro and onion.

Love this place. We only get takeout, but the food is fresh and delicious and the service is great. Highly recommend.

Had a veggie burrito and got very sick soon after. That is my main reason for writing this review. However, even if I had not gotten sick, I would not have returned. Burrito was just average, nothing great about it. They charge extra to add guac, and they even charge for sour cream! A big tub of sour cream must cost them hardly anything, yet they have to charge customers a dollar for a tiny cup. Anything to make a buck, it seems. No homemade salsa like most other places, but they had an assortment of bottled hot sauces. Big disappointment. read more

I am a huge Mexican food fan! And this place has it done the best way possible! Food is on point! I had a burrito!! And the staff is cool too, friendly people. Enviroment is also a cool, relaxed place. Nice and chill. I highly recommend this place! read more

Whenever I come into the city I stop to enjoy their wonderful selection at their other location. Now they have a location that is close to where my family resides. The food is just as good and the service is impeccable. I highly recommend the grilled chicken quesadilla. read more

They could use some help with a person who can calculate the bill right and have a better customer service. They got my order mixed up (I ordered 3 chicken taco, five steak taco, 2 fish taco and chips & salsa but I got 3 chicken, 6 steak, 1 fish taco and fish & chips instead and they forgot 3 sodas that came with the specials so i went back). i should be the one who should be annoyed with their sloppiness but it ended up they accused me trying to get money out of them! They overcharged my bill by almost $8. The guy at the counter insisted that the amount was right initially and my son got embarrassed and I had my ride waiting so i left but when i went back to pick up sodas that they forgot, i asked how much the order should be and a different person at the counter told me it was around $37. I mentioned to them that I was overcharged and they told me to bring the receipt. When I went back with my receipt, a young woman who seemed to be a manager and was visibly upset (shaking hands), told me that I should have brought their itemized receipt WHICH THEY DIDN'T GIVE! She accused me that I am omitting items that made up to $47! Who in the world would go back two times to try to clarify the bill??? This is absolutely appalling customer service. I was one who got overcharged, got my order mixed up and three times, they undermined their customer and accused me for defrauding them. The whole thing robbed me of my appetite and I will never support this shop. read more

I really really really wish this place was even OK. It's very close to where I live and I've given it probably half a dozen chances to do anything but suck. It has failed each time. Horrible service. The food is a pathetic attempt at Mexican (or maybe LA?) taqueria fare. Avoid. read more

So bland... tacos had very little flavor and the salsa tasted like ketchup. It tastes like something you'd find at a chain restaurant. Really disappointing. read more

I like spicy, and my kids can handle a little bit of heat, but the chicken (not even the stewed) had both of them in tears with their fingers in their mouths. I wouldn't expect a kids burrito to be THAT spicy without some sort of note on the menu. They ate cereal for dinner instead. read more

This is some of the worst food and service I have ever received at the hands of a human being. I would have rather been served a pile of steaming shit from a baboon barking in my face. This place, without a doubt, is definitively the worst place I have ever eaten (and hopefully will ever eat). read more

I ordered the lunch special which was 2 tacos and a drink for $7.45. Tacos are filling for me personally, but you may need to side. I thought the sides were all a bit expensive. $6 for chips and guacamole and $6 for rice and beans I feel is way too expensive, but I guess it's all about the location. I added guac on both tacos and my bill came out to $10 and change which I thought was a tad ridiculously, especially when the guac was not out of this world and nobody told me they charge for guac per taco. The flavor was good, and the atmosphere was nice. Decor very fun, the the guy at the register was very very sweet. The girl could definitely smile more! All in all, I had a good experience! read more

The taco was good but the quesadilla was strictly average. Love the ambience and decor though.