Going with a 5 on the take out. First time at Uncle's and it was a most pleasant awakening! We can…read moreonly comment on what we ordered which was minimal but happy to share our findings. We went with a shrimp parm hero and a prosciutto and mozz hero (normally a panini but we subbed). Shrimp parm hero (purely an amazing Italian America creation) was perfection. Snappy breaded shrimp, delicious sauce, and the star...the BREAD! It's what's happening! Not sure if it's semolina but these soft and chew-some sesame seeded hero buns are perfection. Prosciutto hero was equally as inspiring. Always willing to pay the dough for quality and that is what was delivered. Can't wait to try the pizza and move on down the menu.

Great tasting pizza and pinwheels for great prize! Will definitely go back again…read more Overall great experience.

The Everest of pizza ,Hot Honey Pepperoni , simple and perfect brick oven fired personal pizza…read more Simone puts all his love in it. Scotto's, a long tradition in the hamptons and an iconic family with roots to our community always delivers the full gamut of Italian cuisine with a warm friendly hand. Here for the weekend , grab a pie (most certainly the perfectly balance Hot Honey Pepperoni) and stock up with the highest quality Italian fare and aged meat.

Scotto's recently catered our party and I would STRONGLY recommend you use another caterer! They…read morewere non -responsive and rude throughout the process and they misrepresented what they could provide. Their portions were unacceptable and the presentation of the food was weak; the salmon was a cut into tiny pieces as was the skirt steak. It looked cheap. . They charged a small fortune to provide set up staff that left early and didn't help with clean up. They omitted some dessert items, which was documented in an email, and claimed we had canceled them. They are clearly a food "drop off" service and don't know a thing about event planning. They lead you to believe otherwise. I regret using them and would NEVER recommend their services

I must say, the food is impeccable. The ultimate pancake dish was amazing, pancakes cooked to…read moreperfection, soft moist crispy edges!! Eggs fluffy as anything!! The sausage links were just what you would want!! Our group also got the chicken Caesar wrap and let me tell you, saucy cheesy all the things you look for in a wrap! The crunchy wrap and romaine was just melting in your mouth every bite! The shoe strings were not greasy at all! Perfectly cooked. Amazing music and definitely a must eat!! You won't regret it! The servers were on-top of everything.

My new favorite spot Outstanding menu with lots of options…read more Felt like I was back in Palermo with their margarita pizza. Friendly staff too. I'll be back

First dinner in the Hamptons and was happy with the food and view. By popular recommendation and…read moreserver recommendation, we got the chicken parm and spicy shrimp vodka rigatoni. The chicken parm was good but could have used some sauce so 3.5/5. The rigatoni was amazingly tasty and the shrimp cooked perfectly so 5/5. With the leftover vodka sauce, we used the bread to scoop and it was buenissssssimooooo

Place had a nice buzz when it opened and we were excited. Unfortunately didn't live up to the hype…read more Food expensive and mediocre. Lost their liquor license. Got cited for illegal wastewater drainage into our beautiful shinnecock bay- a common harvesting area for much of the shellfish we eat in the community. I can tolerate expensive and mediocre food, but can not support a restaurant which willingly contaminates our ecosystem. Also heard they opened in Claudio's in greenport and closed within one week. Wonder what the story was there.... :( Too bad the location is beautiful. Just need new and respectful owner.

Warning. Big change…read moreafter new owners took over the once reliable Pizza Place three years ago. One of the slices smelled way too fishy too eat for a calamari slice. Brought in to let them know. The som of the owner hid sheepishly by the ovens and .the manager came over to tell me he wouldn't exchange. They took it and Threw it out but no exchange or refund. Be warned. Food service requires trust that management will keep things fresh and stand behind their foos. Not here. Not meant to be in food service. Pies LOOKED good but Calamari was clearly not fresh and come to think of it the cheese seemed a little too white like some melting spread. There were lots of refrigerated rolls not selling but kept in the case. Pies were moving and tasted ok but would NOT return.

This place has a pizza oven but it is not pizza they are serving. Not even close and not good at…read moreall. I stopped here on my way out east for a slice and received an extremely hot slice of poorly prepared, cheap ingredients with an over abundance of flour. I had asked that the slices be just warmed, so my young daughter could eat it and the man nodded, and sent out these boiling hot slices. Also, I did not feel welcome here at all. I received no smiles from anyone, no hello, no goodbye or even a thank you for coming. Not recommended.

Love the gluten free options for my husband! When you walk in, it feels like a family reunion with…read morehow comfortable they make you feel.

So much hype around this place and fell flat for me…read more Maybe because it was before closing around 8:15, the quality that I was expecting from pics of the meatball pie was not the same. I saw big slices of meatball all over pie earlier when walking by and in the pictures, what I got was like crushed up all in the center and very floppy/sloppy soupy... was falling apart The taste and ingredients were def good but not my kinda pie I guess. Just more disappointed that I didn't get what looked to be amazing walker and why I went in the first place. I felt like I got the end of the night scraps

So beautiful! The outdoor terrace and bar is so lovely. Food was great and flavorful. I had the…read morelamb and it was fantastic. Super friendly staff servers seem very green but they got the job done with a smile. Cheesecake was out of this world!

Disappointing experience. Took over 30 minutes to receive an overpriced simple salad I ordered and…read moreit arrived salty.

Cuisine: 6 Service: 7…read moreDecor: 4 Value: 7 Overall: 6 Simply put, the pizza crust was like cardboard. I'm definitely not a fan of the undercooked and under seasoned dough, which this pie was. The sauce was actually quite tasty and cheese was fine. However, as a whole, I would consider their pizza just average. On the other hand, their chicken roll was not bad. I also ordered some Latino food to go from the deli side of the shop. The beef soup I heated up the next day was delicious. I would totally get it again. The kielbasa was thick cut and decent, but rice and beans were just okay. There are a few tables and seats in the shop, so large groups don't really work. All the staff members were relatively friendly.

East Quogue Pizza has the best football pizza in the area, IMHO. Just the right amount of flop, a…read moredecent salt and cheese ratio, crust on the chewier side. Walking into this place you would not expect the pizza to be that good. Outdated, a little grungy, relatively clean. The service here was super fast - we had our large pizza, 12 wing and 12 garlic knot special in just 15 minutes. The wings here are decent, could definitely be crispier though. Garlic knots are light and fluffy with ample garlic. They give blue cheese, not ranch with the wings which is the right way to do things. If you're craving pizza and don't want to spend $45 on a single small pie down the road at Francesca's, this place is the answer.

Delicious food for a group of 4 last minute summer reservation for an outdoor table. Nice staffread more

This place is a 10/10 for me. The view is amazing, the food is outstanding, the drinks are strong,…read morethe service is friendly - what more could you want? Came here on a Thursday night and was able to grab two seats at the bar. I started off with a cosmo which was made perfectly, served in an insulated martini glass to keep it nice and cold. For starters we had the charbroiled oysters which were unlike any oyster dish I've ever had. Topped with garlic, parmesan and sriracha, the sauce that comes off of these bad boys gets soaked up with the focaccia its served with. Honestly one of the best things I've ever eaten. We also had fried calamari which was solid. For mains, I had the veal Milanese which was perfectly cooked. Crispy, topped with fresh tomatoes and arugula plus shaved parmesan. My brother had the lobster pasta which I tried and was out of this world. The shitake mushrooms in this dish really add a depth of flavor you don't normally find in a lobster pasta. I haven't stopped thinking about those oysters and will absolutely be back. Everything in the Hamptons is expensive, but this place is where you want to spend your money.

Stopped here for a slice on our way to Sag Harbor to see a show. It's inside a dunkin' donuts so we…read morealmost didn't see it. Plenty of parking in the back. Unfortunately the counter service was pretty unfriendly. Not sure if it's off season or what. The pizza was OK. They advertise "clean bathroom" in big letters on their sign outside but the bathroom wasn't really clean and it had a broken soap dispenser. Wouldn't stop here again.

Great little pizza joint! Had their "peters drunken grandma" slice, pepperoni rolls, and garlic…read moreknots. All was tasty. Service was outstanding, the guy behind the counter was so kind and friendly. Even gave us italian ice samples to try!