I've been here a number of times over the years. Pizza quality has always been decent but it seems that the staff is quite sullen. You can dine in, several tables are provided, but the dining area is poorly lit and the soda machine not well maintained. Yesterday an incident occurred that made me question why I bother to go out of my way to go here when there are other good pizzas in town. When I ordered a large pizza, the cashier rang me up for three dollars more than the posted price. I caught it and called him on it, so he reluctantly adjusted it to the price it was supposed to be. Made me wonder how often that happened on a daily basis. It could add up to a substantial sum over time! So next time I need a pizza fix, Garlic Jim's may or may not be under consideration. read more

Worst customer service. Don't bother ordering here. Food is good but the employees suck big time. They don't answer their phone and demand you order online only. read more

TLDR: As most of the reviews below state, this is 'pretty good' pizza. Definite standout from the sea of pizza chains, but it's a pricey alternative. Placed a medium mushroom-sausage pie order for pickup. Restaurant is pretty basic, a few tables and mostly designed for takeout. Staff was friendly and service was prompt. Toppings were fresh, decent cheese and sauce. A cut above a lot of chains. I'm a little mixed on the crust. Nice and doughy with a bit of chew, but overly thick at the rim, making the sauce and cheese pool towards the center. (See the picture, I'm not joking!) Overall, a good pizza but overpriced at +$20 for a two-topping medium. Still, since the quality was there, I'd give it a firm thumbs-up. This place scores a 4 out of 5 on the 'CTJ Scale', as noted below. 5 out of 5 stars: Come-to-Jesus good. Would be OK passing away after finishing a plate here. 4 out of 5 stars: Come-to-Mary good. Would be OK having a nosh here with Mother Mary. 3 out of 5 stars: Come-to-Joseph good. Would be OK having a beer here with Jesus' Dad. 2 out of 5 stars: Come-to-the-Apostles good. Meh. Wouldn't have my last supper here. 1 out of 5 stars: Come-to-Nobody good. I wouldn't have my penultimate supper here, either. read more

See all

Large pizzas but okay. Southwest and garlic chicken. I can literally count the chicken pieces on two hands and will be left with few to spare. I am not kidding. $24 for a large pizza and you skimp on the toppings. It donot leave a good feeling. Service was slow that day. Poor fellow was the only one working. Just one person. It was a take out for us. read more

I normally don't do reviews but I ordered a pepperoni pizza and got no Pepperoni, just cheese. First time trying it and will not be buying here anymore. read more

Garlic Jim’s - Order was made wrong. - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Someone recommended it to me recently so I thought I'd try it. Online ordering was a little confusing. Website looks like it was designed by a third grader in 1998. I don't know why they need my phone number AND email address for the order. After I finished, the site said I'd get a confirmation. Never did. Went to pick it up. Restroom looked like it hadn't been cleaned in a while. Staff was friendly. Pizza tastes pretty good. Sauce has a nice flavor; toppings were fresh. I have a little issue with hand tossed crusts. I like them, but they never seem to spread the sauce out far enough. A couple of the slices were only three bites. Seriously. Have a look at the picture. That's a lot of real estate that could have used more sauce and cheese. I would go back though. Maybe get a different type of crust. read more

Garlic Jim’s - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

They make quality pizza quickly and at a reasonable price. The service was excellent as well.

Not really a $24 pizza. They charges $2 extra for extra cheese and $2 for extra "fresh" basil. Flavor is okay, but it was a "ready made" crust...not at all fresh. Don't think I'll be back. read more

Garlic Jim’s - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Good food, ambiance and service. Really good quality pizzas. I would recommend. Easy ordering online.

Online ordering is easy and fast, pizza is made fresh and I have never had to wait. The size and portion of the pizza is good. We have had it many time and it is consistently good. read more

10/10 the pizzas be so good. The wings are great also. I've ordered two times in a week. At least three times.

Sometimes you just want a pizza. This town is full of pizza joints on every corner. Garlic Jim's stands out from the crowd! It's nestled into a strip mall off of 1604 and Hausman, so it may be often overlooked. They are available for dine-in, pick up or delivery and I found out the hard (or easy) way that if you accidentally set your order for pickup and you meant delivery, you can easily call and ask them to deliver with no hassle. We've had a few different pizzas from Garlic Jim's but our favorites are the Cheeseburger and the famous Nutty Chipotle. The cheeseburger is topped with bacon, beef, cheddar cheese, classic red sauce, mozzarella cheese, red onions, Roma tomatoes and drizzled with Thousand Island dressing. I don't think it tastes quite like a cheeseburger but it is tasty. I think if they add some shredded lettuce on top that would be a nice addition. Then there is the Nutty Chipotle. I have never heard of such a thing but it is a very interesting choice. It comes with zesty chipotle pesto that is topped with spicy Italian sausage, pepperoni, red onions, tomatoes, and cashews. Cashews, you say? Yes, cashews. They are roasted right on top and you hardly notice them until you taste this interesting crunch from time to time. I add black olives to ours to gild the lily. In the past, we've had the Hercules (all meat) and enjoyed it as well. You have choices on the crust: hand-tossed, garlic thin, and gluten-free. We've tried the hand-tossed and garlic thin and I just can't decide which I like the best. I'd love for them to add a deep dish, but I'll stay happy with the other choices. Staff and delivery people have always been pleasant and accommodating. We don't order pizza very often, but when we do, it's usually Garlic Jim's. It's just a bit different and a good choice in a sea of Papa Johns, Dominoes, Pizza Hut, etc. read more

Garlic Jim’s - Nutty Chipotle with Black Olives - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

The pizza was way too salty. Within a few minutes of eating 2 personal size pizza slices, my stomach started gurgling. I won't order from here again. read more

Had the hand tossed Big Jim. It wasn't bad. A little doughy still. Topping were a little under cooked as well. Not the worst pizza I have had, but nothing special really. read more

Garlic Jim’s - The Big Jim - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

This is the same as Pizza Hut, domino's, and papa john's. If that's your style of pizza then you're in for a treat. Pass for me. read more

Good food, loaded the Hercules pizza with toppings. Good prices, nice ambiance, excellent service!

Not bad. Surprisingly they use fresh toppings and make a good pizza. It's even better if you reheat when you get home in an air-fryer just to perk it up. Overall ... good ... did the vegetarian and added a few things in the reheat. read more

Delicious supreme pizza. Reasonable with lots of toppings. I would definitely recommend this place.

Foods okay but their website order page doesn't confirm you paid or they received your order. Have ordered delivery from the one location in San Antonio on Hausman Rd for over a year and they tell me I'm 2 miles outside of their delivery zone???? Additionally the person answering the phone could not understand English making the entire process of trying to make sure I wasn't charged for 3 pies instead of one trying to get their payment webpage to work. Good food, not worth the hassle:( read more

First time having it a few months ago, my pizza was super cheesy which I love. It had lots of flavor and the prefect bite. I order some buffalo wing, they unfortunately were not what I was expecting but the flavor was there. I would order pizza from here again. read more

Clean establishment, friendly staff, a variety of pizza options and other foods to choose from. One of the better pizza places in the area. We'll be back. read more

Garlic Jim’s - Breadsticks with cheese served with a buttery garlic sauce and side of marinara - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

Really solid spot for Pizza, wings and Toasted sandwiches. Got a Large Cheese, Italian Sandwich and Boneless Wings. Every was good, real good. Can't wait to go back and try some of their signature pies. The Italian was full of flavor & large for the price. The two guys working were great. Robert on the cashier and a very friendly cook, Zack maybe. Darn I forgot but either way, these guys rock and super friendly. See you soon guy read more

Amazing quality pizza and salads. Definitely worth trying again. Customer service was also excellent. Can't wait to go back. Went there for lunch with my wife. Glad I did. read more

I picked up pizza and bread sticks for late dinner and was pleasantly surprised. The breadsticks are thin and light and very flavorful... trust me... get the garlic dip! My pizza was loaded with my chosen toppings and very good. I will go back! read more

Did a takeout order for the first time and I will say the staff was friendly and knowledgeable. I tried this place because there was a coupon buy a large specialty and get a medium 2 topping pizza for free. The crust was fresh and had the right crunch. I'll try this place again read more

See all

Tried Garlic Jim's for the first time last night. We were caught in the middle of a downpour and in the process of moving so we needed to carryout dinner. The young ladies there were very polite and courteous; answering my questions about particular menu items. I left with a large Big Jimmy, large pepperoni, Buffalo wings, and cheesecakes. We all enjoyed the crust on the pizzas even though we're diehard NY-Style pizzas. They were filling and proofed with flavor. The sauce on the Big Jimmy wasn't as good as I anticipated. It tasted very much like it was made with pre-cut, bottled garlic instead of fresh, but that didn't have any bearing on my review. The loss of a star is due to the price and wings. Our meal cost is $65 and the wings were pretty underwhelming and baked, which is never a good thing in my opinion. I'll definitely be back though as our overall experience was pleasant. read more

Good pizza!! I usually get the veggie or the triple pepperoni. Love the crispy crust! Also love their salad options! read more

I wish I could give 3.5 stars because 3 is honestly low but 4 is to high (in my opinion). My husband and I actually did not agree on the food, he really enjoyed it where I was slightly disappointed. First I'll start off with the wings: the Buffalo sauce they use; amazing. It tastes so good and is actually a little spicy compared to most places where Buffalo wings are so vinegary. The blue cheese dressing they provide is also super yummy. I don't know if it's homemade but it sure does taste like it to me. With that being said, I didn't like the actual wing part because they were super "soft", I don't know if that's the right word. I'm used to really crispy wings and so I think it was just a preference thing. This was the one of two things my husband and I agreed on, we regret buying the wings. The Garlic Pizza: we both didn't like this pizza at all. I wish I could get my money back for it. It lacked so much flavor. Didn't taste any garlic, and honestly wouldn't have been able to tell you it had basil anything. My husband said it just tasted like dry bread to him which is disappointing since it did have tons of toppings. The other two pizzas my husband LOVED. The Sicilian was his favorite, he loved the flavor combos, loved how thin it was and said it was perfectly balanced; I thought it was meh. Cheeseburger pizza was probably the best out of all of them. I mainly only tasted salt but there was one part where I got the sauce and meat together and it really did taste like a cheeseburger. I think this pizza is a fun one and definitely worth trying. Overall, I think this place is okay. It's way better than dominos or Pizza Hut in my opinion BUT it wasn't worth the $94 spent. I wish I could get my money back and spend it elsewhere. read more

Garlic Jim’s - Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

Excellent pizza and super friendly employees . I got the Jimmy Special with a couple of substituted,. It was delicious! I'm looking forward to having the rest for breakfast tomorrow!!!!! read more

Garlic Jim’s - Yummy pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

Delicious! The prefect breadsticks! Perfect crust ! Really good customer service will definitely be back next time to try the pizza ! read more

Garlic Jim’s - Garlic Butter Breadsticks with jalapeños - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

There's absolutely nothing to complain about! Friendly staff.. food was excellent .. the pizza the ribs and the wings! All very favorable with no complaints between the 6 of us! Go see for yourself! read more

See all

Have driven by this place many times and always have wanted to try it. Today we did. Excellent pizza. Great sauce, loved the triple pepperoni pizza with garlic. Can't speak to the service or ambiance as we got it to go. Food was great! Will be back. Well done Garlic jim's read more

Great food and truly gluten free The whole family can eat what they want. Good prices also read more

Just tried this pizza spot for the first time. Gotta say the pizza was pretty tasty. Pizzas were very flavorful and not too saucy. Definitely our favorite pizza spot we've found here in San Antonio so far read more

I love the responses from Nikia! She is cut-throat! There is no way this place should get a low rating... I got a delivery from door dash from this location. The thin crust cheese and mushroom pizza was phenomenal. This can not be compared to the pizza "chains". You get what you pay for... DELICIOUS gourmet pizza . My friend had the chicken wings which were tasty and came right off the bone. read more

Helllllllllll yeahhhhhhh, this is my first time having pizza from this location. Absolutely delicious! If I could give more then 5 start I would. read more

Garlic Jim’s - a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

The triple pepperoni pizza was good! We got regular crust. The breadsticks were okay, not that good. read more

Garlic Jim’s - Cheesy Breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

I had the triple pepperoni smackdown. It was really good. But for me kinda salty. My hubby got the Garlic Jim's ultimate. He said it was very good. The right amount of sauce. The crust is very good. We bought two medium for $11.99 each. One is 8 slices . With 2 drinks we paid $41.09 . I will try them again. read more

Garlic Jim’s - This is our first visit. We were greeted as we entered. The cook came out to talk to us. There is a pokemon gym there. - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

We ordered the spinach artichoke pizza and the triple pepperoni pizzas. The spinach artichoke pizza made me remember what a good pie should taste like. Delish! The pepperoni pizza was very good. My husband loved it! We ordered for delivery and they arrived fresh and hot! We will for sure be ordering again. read more

We ordered from Garlic Jim's about a week ago after my pregnancy cravings for pizza kicked in. We recently moved to the area and were curious about the pizza scene here in Helotes. I have to say that I really enjoyed our takeout pizza from here so much! There was a bit of a garlic taste, but garlic is a flavor I don't mind at all (also hence the name). :) We ordered a large Sicilian pizza and it did not disappoint. I loved everything from the crust, gooey cheese, and plentiful toppings. Exactly what I wanted. read more