Fantastic (seriously, that's the only word) restaurant with great food. We made reservations for dinner prior to attending a Broadway show. Joey was amazing, friendly and helpful, the seared halibut was out of this world, and I don't have enough adjectives to do justice to the cheesecake. Highly recommend this restaurant for the ambience and atmosphere as well as for "date night" or special occasions. P.S. Try the coconut martini! read more

Gatsby's Landing Times Square - Coconut martini - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Had an amazing dining experience at this midtown location. I like it even better than the one located in Roslyn. The decor is beautiful, the food was absolutely delicious, my cocktail was tasty, and dessert was out of this world. Even the staff was fabulous. A nice touch was when the waitress found out it was my birthday, without being my asked she added a sparkler candle to my dessert and 4 of the staff members serenaded me by singing Happy Birthday... and theirs voices were lovely (probably Broadway actors). It was truly lovely! read more

See all

What a beautiful restaurant with a great location, right near a few big Times Square theaters. My friends and I went to a late dinner after a show in May and had a wonderful experience. Though we didn't try any of the cocktails, they all sounded very fun and cool with great names related to The Great Gatsby. And we loved the whole art deco vibe and decor. Our food was amazing...the cacio e pepe was outstanding! I would absolutely go back! read more

Fantastic food! Staff was very friendly and made great recommendations. We had a steak, fish and ravioli and all were very good!!! And reasonable price for wonderful food! Not a long wait and we went on a Saturday night! Located close to Times Square and Broadway shows! Loved it! Will go again when we visit NYC in the future. read more

See all

And there we were in Times Square where upscale restaurants are comparatively far and few between. Gatsby's Landing was a great find. Upscale, quality food and pleasant and efficient service. Started with Fried Calamari served with two dipping sauces, one red and one white - both excellent. Moved on with two beautifully prepared entrees. Halibut and Branzino were fresh and very tasty. Pre- dinner cocktails, although priced a bit on the high side, were prepared by a very capable bartender who made them with her own twist. Definitely worth a visit. Plan to Visit the Long Island location in the future. Great choice for s pre- theater dinner. Make a reservation. The restaurant was full! read more

Gatsby's Landing Times Square - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Returned to Gatsby's Landing for dinner on a late Saturday evening when the restaurant was relatively quiet. Started with the Baby Roasted Beets and the Crispy Calamari - both excellent. For entrees we had the Lamb, the Duck and Duck Carbonara - all were good with the Duck especially standing out, nicely prepared. Our server Katelyn was terrific - friendly and helpful. Overall great food and friendly service in a comfortable environment. read more

See all

My hubby and I visited the Gatsby Landing for a Pre-Dinner Theater stop. It's extremely convenient if you're going to see a show at (name theater). Our server was well-versed on the drink and full menu, and it was clear that he really liked the place where he worked. I'll start with the drinks. We ordered the Tropical Coconut Martini and the Limoncello French Martini. The coconut Martini was rich and flavorful, and the sweetness of the coconut was lovely but not overpowering. The Limoncello French Martini was definitely my favorite. It was a great balance of sweet and tart; it was a great flavor pallette. For food, we ordered the Lamb with a Pistachio, truffle crumble. The lamb was cooked the perfection. While I enjoyed the crumble, I really didn't taste the truffle flavor. My lamb came with a side of potatoes that, when I ate them with the lamb, were a nice pairing, but when eaten alone, they were slightly underseasoned. My hubby had the Lasagna. The dish had a wonderful consistency, with the distribution of cheese and sauce. But the secret ingredient that sent that dish over the top: Mexican chorizo mixed in with the meat. That set the Lasagna apart from other Lasagna plates we've had at other restaurants. Chef's kiss! While I chose this restaurant mostly because of its distance from the theater I was going to that evening, I found Gatsby Landing to be a lovely surprise in the Theater/Times Square District. read more

See all

Been here twice back: I got the blackened halibut special and it was fine but wouldn't necessarily get again. I thought the Pimento on the side was delicious though - cheesy with good texture. I got lunch prix fixe for the first time on a different occasion. I actually don't remember how much I liked the salmon but the soup of the day (seafood chowder?) wasn't to my liking. The cheesecake though was good again, contrary to when I had it the 2nd time. Perhaps, the last time was just an anomaly. read more

Gatsby's Landing Times Square - NY Strip - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Delicious and good-sized cocktails. A bit pricey ($20) but a tradeoff for a spacious bar area that is usually not too crowded. Friendly bartenders. No idea about the food lol. My go-to pre-show or post-show drink spot. Shhh!! read more

Gatsby's Landing Times Square - toasted coconut martini, limoncello french martini - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This place came highly recommended by several colleagues in the area! The Italian food is delicious. You wouldn't assume that from the name of the restaurant! The staff was very knowledgeable on the menu and accommodating. The place is clean. The margarita pizza was delicious and fresh. Could've been a bit more crispy. The toasted coconut martini was to die for. The chefs market special pasta (shrimp, broccoli, cream sauce) was delicious, warm. The portions are huge. read more

See all

Sat at the bar for lunch/drinks before maybe happy ending (right across the street!). We shared the burrata and crab cakes and some fries. Enjoyed everything and the espresso martinis were perfect. I asked for not too sweet and the bartender listened. Husband got it reg and also enjoyed that. Highly recommend for an easy convenient bite before a broadway show. Great vibe as well. read more

Gatsby's Landing Times Square - Espresso martinis - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Pretty room and a great place for pre-theater dinner. Went with a friend before a show, and shared a chicken vodka pizza and an appetizer order of meatballs. The pizza was delicious and had plenty of tender and not overcooked chicken, and the meatballs were moist, well seasoned and tasty. We will come back again... read more

Lovely spot for a business lunch or dinner in the theatre district. Lunch prix fix was a good value and the dishes came out very quickly! Everything tastes great. read more

This is a very beautiful restaurant. The decor is fantastic. This would be a great place for a date night. Joey was a great server. He was very knowledgeable about the food and made great recommendations. The food was tasty and very filling. I'll definitely will be back. read more

Just happened to pass on a walk, and stopped in for a surprisingly good breakfast. We were fortunate to be here on a nice day, and the outdoor seating is perfectly shaded and provides a lot to observe. Just here for brunch so can only really speak to eggs and wine, but both were excellent. Service was attentive almost to a fault. read more

Gatsby's Landing Times Square - Frittata - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Had a great pre-show experience here. Our server Joey was great and the food was very good and very reasonably priced for the quality and quantity (especially for NYC). Easy to recommend! read more

My first trip to Gatsby's was so positive, as I reflected in my original review -- my second time was, unfortunately, a disappointment! A friend and I went for lunch before a weekend matinee performance. This time, I had the Cacio e Pepe pasta; the sauce was almost a gravy, and way over peppered. We decided to share a dessert, the Bombolini, filled with Nutella. The doughnuts themselves were thick and heavy, and we could hardly taste the Nutella. Sorry to say we probably won't return. read more

This place has some great food and is walking distance to most of the theaters around Times Square. You do have to make a reservation through open table. The service was great and the ambiance is very laid back and goes with the jazz/flapper vibe. Our party enjoyed the food and the appetizers are worth getting. The octopus was cooked perfectly but can be a little spicy for some people that don't prefer it. The pork chop was worth getting and the brussel sprouts were seasoned well. read more

See all

Amazing experience! The atmosphere was the perfect pre-Theater vibe. The interior reflected the grandeur of its Literary inspiration. I order the Old Sport cocktail which was sooo good! The primary flavors were lemon and elderflower so it was refreshing and bubbly. The oil and bread were top notch- the olive oil was the most delicious I've ever tasted and I've dined at amazing restaurants in Italy! I ordered the seared halibut with seasonal veggies, while my husband ordered the Lasagna with Chorizo. Both were exquisite! Finally, we ended with the Tiramisu which was LEGIT. It had the perfect balance of espresso (bitter) and marscapone (sour) with the sweetness of the chocolate and lady fingers. Our server and the floor manager were perfectly trained in hospitality! I was so very impressed! read more

See all

This place is near my office so I decided to return one day for a late lunch. I ignored the reasonable Prix-Fixe menu for items that I wanted to try instead so it ended up rather expensive (over $100 before tax & tip)! The waitress was friendly & I asked her for recommendations. I started out with the Pink Colada mocktail (coconut cream, pineapple juice, coconut water, cranberry juice) which was delicious, and the crab cake app (which was a single, large crab cake with salsa verde & roasted red pepper remoulade) that was very good. For my entree I had their Ravioli of the day, which was a chicken/ricotta/cottage cheese ravioli in a brown butter sauce. The waitress had said they make their pastas fresh, and that this would be creamy because of the cottage cheese, but it tasted dry & grainy & overly salty to me. I found this dish to be disappointing. The waitress, who kept checking in to see how everything was, apologized (and hopefully gave feedback to the chef?) that it wasn't enjoyable for me. I finished with a lovely creme brûlée (topped with raspberry sauce & toasted almonds) & a cappuccino. Except for the ravioli, the meal was tasty, though pricey. The ambiance & decor is very nice and the service is good. A good option in the heart of Broadway/Times Square (right across from where Maybe Happy Ending is playing now) and I expect I will return. read more

See all

Wonderful service and great food. The calamari was a hit with my group. I ordered the rigatoni, and wow, the pasta was amazing!

This is great hospitable restaurant. Everyone was polite and friendly the moment we walked through the door. The server equally was great. The food was good. We enjoyed the Sliders starter. You get a nice size flavorful patty. The Filet was great as well as the Cabonara which was unique with the duck. One day we'll try the Roslyn location when in the area. read more

See all

Just had an amazing dinner here at Gatsby's Landing. The service was impeccable-from the hostess at the door, to our waiter Joey, everyone was welcoming and attentive. A classic Italian menu with the usual choices such as Cacio e Pepe, Lasagna, Calamari, Meatballs, etc. Cute ambiance and they even have a little private room off to the side for a more intimate setting. If you're in the Times Square area, give them a try! read more

My friend made a reservation here simply because it was close to a show we were going to - and we were so pleasantly surprised! All of our cocktails were exceptional (and so pretty), but the food was next level. I wanted to lick my plate after having the duck carbonara - and my friend said the same about the safe brown butter sauce in her ravioli dish. The pastas were light, but decadent. We were near the kitchen and saw many meals pass us throughout the night and honestly everything looked delicious. We also shared the creme brulee (yum!) and one of their pizza specials with a delicious pistachio honey crumble on it...BIG YUM. We truly were not expecting to have such an amazing meal so close to Time Square, but will certainly be back when we come to the city again! Greg, our server, was absolutely fantastic, made great recommendations and was just a joy to chat to. (Give him a raise!) read more

See all

Went here for a birthday dinner and it was a lot of fun. The venue itself is great, beautiful interiors with a couple of different seating areas so you don't feel crowded and could come for a more formal or more casual event. I made a reservation for a large party on kind of short notice and appreciated how easy they made it. Some of the dishes are absolutely out of this world, like the duck and the lamb, and some of the dishes are just very good like the pastas. The banana split for dessert was a little weird but overall everything was very enjoyable and the service was great. read more

See all

This restaurant was booked and recommended to us for dinner by our hotel. To start, the text messages that we received from the restaurant for confirming our reservation did not have information that matched what we were given and heard when this was reservation was being booked which made visiting confusing. Upon arrival, the restaurant was very dark and even though the restaurant was busy, it was super quiet like in a library. Our server was friendly but as soon as she took our order we did not see her and had a hard time getting anyone's attention for refills on our waters, more drinks, etc. The food was presented beautifully and cooked perfectly. The meal was full of flavor and depth. I wish we would have had more time to try a few more items and had more attentive staff so we could have tried dessert. read more

See all

Katie was our server and she was amazing! We were headed to Harry Potter and she was quick and efficient but didn't rush us. I suggest making a reservation- I can see how it would get really busy with all the shows. Great location and easy to walk to any show or time square. Food was delicious, can't go wrong! The highlight was Katie's recommendations on non alcoholic beverages for my husband who doesn't drink. Thanks Katie read more

The restaurant was nice. The waiter was professional and upbeat and helpful. The food. The salmon was good. The pasta was good and the lasagna was good. We also had piece of cheesecake. The problem I have with this restaurant is they want 3.2% if you use your credit card now, how many people in New York City bring cash? I have been to seven restaurants since I've been here this week and not one of them had that!!! that's makes me a very unhappy customer. I feel if there after it there service responsibility to pay the fee of the credit card, which I'm sure wasn't 3.2 I hope this is just one of many because I would not be a happy customer in any restaurant that does that and I mentioned it to the waiter and he had attitude about it read more

See all

Good food, good service and wonderful atmosphere. Will definitely go back. We went after theater and had appetizers which were ver good.

Great food and service. The restaurant is convenient to many of the theaters. We started with a crab cake appetizers. Excellent taste and presentation. We both had pasta specials, I had one with tenderloin tips and asparagus, my wife had a ravioli with sweet corn and butternut squash. Both dishes were well prepared and presented and very filling. We shared a creme bruli for desert. A very nice place to go prior to a show. read more

Another fantastic visit to Gatsby's landing. As always, the food was incredible, the atmosphere was inviting with turn of the century decor, and the service was top notch. Gatsby's landing never disappoints. read more

See all

We had matinee tickets and wanted a fabulous place for light bites and a drink to celebrate the second day of 2024. I saw good Yelp reviews and as a Gatsby enthusiast, was eager to try Gatsby's Landing. Beautiful interior with that Gatsby mansion feel! The burrata with pesto was really tasty. The creative cocktail menu is fun. My cosmo with white cranberry juice was great. My friend had one of their other fruity ones. So pretty. We shared some shrimp cocktail and a cheese and salami plate--perfect for pre theater dining. Of course we chatted it up with our very nice bartender. Had to take her photo! She makes wonderful cocktails, that's for sure. Restaurant is currently obscured by scaffolding. Once inside, it is so lovely. We will definitely go back. Cheers! read more

See all

We had a wonderful time at Gatsby's landing. We came here before a show and they were nice enough to ask us when the show was to avoid any delays. The service was top notch! We had many employees bring us drinks, taking our order, asking us how everything was. The food was good and the drinks even better. We got the brick chicken and the vegetable lasagna. The seasoning was great on the chicken but lacked something with the lasagna. It tasted ok, but needed salt. We didn't have any on the table so I just let it be. The place was very nicely decorated. It was dark in the restaurant which I didn't mind but it might bother some. All in all a solid place to go before a show! read more

See all

An amazing place with great food and even better service! Katelyn was our server and she really made our visit spectacular. I had the lasagna and the wife went with the Panzanella Salad and Cheese Ravioli. Can't go wrong with either of those choices! read more

This was a lovely dinner! Super great food and our waiter was top notch and showing us the splits and very knowledgeable about gluten free options. One of the best meals we had in NY! Editing to add - our awesome server was Wyatt and you can really tell he loves and is good at his job. Thanks Wyatt!! read more

Very cute atmosphere with friendly waitstaff and great food. Got the octopus as a starter, perfectly cooked and delish! Lamb chops with the pistachio were DEVINE. I was a bit skeptical about the nuts, but it added a perfect sweet crunchiness. It's expensive, but for lamb, it was a really good portion size. The potatoes/carrots on the side were buttery and yummy. And you can't beat the location for pre theater dinner! read more

Gatsby's Landing Times Square - Lamb - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Decided to hop on the train and head into the city for Christmas in NYC. After Rockefeller Center, headed to Gatsby's Landing for a late lunch. Upon entering, the decor was modern and fresh. Had a 3:30 reservation, arrived at 3:00 and surprisingly we we're sat. We had no problems going to the bar and chilling, but they put us at our table...nice! Started off with a few appetizers and salad. My daughter was a fan of the Burrata, more so the garlic toast. The pesto was flavorful, Burrata could have been creamier tho. BBQ wings were tasty. I'm a fan of roasted wings, plus these were fat. The BBQ sauce war meh. Also grabbed the Baby Roasted Beets Salad. The candied walnuts we're the star and complimented the vinaigrette nicely. Followed up with Margherita and Wild Mushroom pizzas. The Margherita was decent, perhaps the sauce could've been more flavorful. The mushroom pizza wasn't bad. The comment at the table was, "the chef could've showed the mushrooms some love before putting on the pizza." The Gatsby Burger was on point! Can't go wrong with a short rib burger. Also mine was cooked to perfection and the sautéed onions were tasty. One of the specials was the chicken parm with homemade fusilli. I must say the pasta was very good and definitely made fresh. The chicken was juicy, again the sauce could've used a little more zing. Save room for deserts. Although, I didn't partake, grabbed coffee and certainly fresh. My oldest daughter had a couple margaritas and had no complaints. Decent beer and wine list. For the heart of Times Square, one of the better restaurants, especially if not looking for one of the many typical chain spots. Puts some points on the board with a long field goal!! read more

See all

My boyfriend and I came to Gatsby's Landing to celebrate our one year anniversary. The staff was very happy to celebrate us, which we appreciated. Everything about this place is amazing and Gatsby is themed, which is one of our favorite movies. Also, there is a theater across the street and Lion King was also a short walk away. If you're looking for good service, good food, a good atmosphere, and a short walk to the theaters, this is the place to be! read more

See all

Pros: - delicious, wide selection of food - friendly, quick service - easy to make reservations on Open Table - located in midtown and are respectful of people's showtimes (we alerted them ahead of time) - Instagrammable decor - loved the Christmas decorations that were still up Cons: - they did not check me in on Open Table, despite me giving them my name when I checked in with the hostess and later on I had to verify with Open Table via my receipt that I actually was there in order to get my Open Table points - my lunch partner requested pickles be removed from her chicken sandwich, waitress was aware and went to kitchen to confirm - sandwich was served with cornichons/gherkins regardless (thank goodness it was a food preference and not allergy) - there are two single, unisex bathrooms which the staff uses too so there are people waiting on line adjacent to tables as everyone rushes to use the bathroom before their show - it's on the pricier side but that is expected given its location We Ate or Drank: burrata scallops special grilled chicken sandwich peach sangria gatsby's mule This is not a part of my scoring but I think it's really funny that they have a celebrity guest section on their site but it also presumably includes two red carpet photos of celebrities who did not want their picture taken with the owner (I'm assuming that's the guy in the pictures)? It's just two separate photos of Jake Gyllenhaal and Christian Slater that were placed up there even though they're not photos of them at the restaurant. Also, if anyone who works at the restaurant sees this, the site spells Matthew Macfadyen's last name wrong. The "y" comes after the "d." read more

See all

Good service and good. Nice place for dinner. Near theaters. Homemade pasta and good drink options.