Fantistic little place in town with no wait and a huge parking lot outback. We went to other restaurants but parking is a nightmare or you have to wait 30-45 min to be seated. We walked right in and were seated immediately. Our table had a delicious crab cake sandwich to die for, french dip and chef salad. All really good. The baseball theme was kinda cool. Different from the ghost or Gettysburg history that others do. All in all, great friendly service and a good meal. Enjoy. read more

Good meal after several hours of walking the battlefields. Nothing spectacular but tasty and reasonable prices.

Best place in Gettysburg. Came here in 2020 and again tonight and my whole family is leaving happy again. Terry is a gem!

There is a good selection on the menu. Service is attentive. Food was hot and tasty. Frankly, it is better than many other places in Gettysburg where finding a really good meal is challenging. Bear in mind that it is a sports bar, so the noise makes conversation impossible. Good coleslaw. read more

My son and I visited here in early August and had read great reviews. They offered indoor seating and carryout. We opted to eat-in. They have a very extensive menu, definitely something for everyone. My son ordered chicken wings, they give you two flavor choices, which is nice. I ordered one of their specialty salads and it was very good. Portion size was very generous - enough for sharing or leftovers! It was a nice spot to visit that wasn't about the battle and had a fun nostalgic baseball theme for its namesake. read more

Very friendly attentive staff. The food was very good. Real crab, real jalapeños, a great burger and seasonal special sangria. Enjoyed our meal very much. It felt like a normal all-around atmosphere. read more

OMG this sandwich!!! You definitely get your dollar's worth here. Service was good and food was awesome. Glad I stopped after my tour. read more

Gettysburg Eddie's - New American Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Good food and staff . Local eatery big selection of food on the menu. Dinning area in front bar in the back. Family place to eat. Casual dress. Good drinks. read more

See all

0 Stars!!!! When we arrived there was no one else waiting so the hostess took our name and said we would get the next available table. After about 10 minutes a table near the window left and a few minutes later she and another employee cleared that table. We watched her then stand around but not seat us. A group of 4 came in (no reservation) and she them immediately sat them at that table. When questioned she said it was their policy to seat larger (4?) groups at the tables. Now keep in mind that 2 minutes earlier that table was empty and she didn't know that they were going to come in the door. We advised the bar manager of the issue and she seemed surprised that the hostess seated that group before us. We left and went somewhere else. Horrible Customer Service. read more

Came in for a sit down meal and cold adult beverages. Excellent steaks (actually pretty darn good steak/cake) bartender is really super cool. Stop in for good food and drinks you will not be disappointed read more

The food was really good. My grandson (10 yrs) and I really enjoyed the frIes! They were fried so perfect, nice and crispy. I had a hamburger and it was cooked very well and it was so big I i couldn't eat it all. My grandson had some chicken and it was so moist he wanted more. The waitress was so nIce, she was very sweet to my grandson! I really recommend this restaurant. We went after we had spent quite a lot of time at the battlefield and we were hungry!! read more

Great service and great food. Perfect stop to wrap up a long day of touring the battle grounds. We had beef fajitas, a mushroom burger, and Greek chicken entree. All were awesome! Highly recommend this place! read more

Small tavern in Gettysburg. Parking in rear. Hostess seats you. Waitress very friendly and recommended several dishes. She said crab cakes were popular as well as their cheese steaks. My husband had fish and chips. Served with one really large haddock filet. The dish included tartarr sauce and Cole slaw. Malt vinegar available on request. I had an Italian cheese steak. It was really good. Cheese steak with green peppers and onions. We would both order these dishes again. But we would want to try other dishes on the menu especially the crab cake. read more

Had lunch here. Got the..I don't remember. It was a sandwich that you can dip in au jus. The fries with it were tasty. The sandwich itself was also really good. I'm judging on food only with 4 stars. The service could of been a little quicker after the food came out but time to table was fine. Anyway, nice place for lunch. Will go again. read more

We came around 7:30 on a Tuesday evening and were sat immediately for a party of 4. We got our drinks quick and each one of our meals were great! I highly recommend the firecracker shrimp tacos. The chicken fingers my son got were very large and very tasty! Really cool decor inside too! read more

This place was ok. I wouldn't say it was bad, but I also wouldn't say it was memorable. I was originally very excited for my night off and to drive about 45 minutes to Gettysburg. That excitement quickly waned. I felt like I had not been able to enjoy a rare Friday night off with my family. For starters, when my family came in we were taken up to a table upstairs. Up two flights of steps and in a room with approx 8 tables in it. This should be some sort of large party room, not for walk ins. I've been in this industry for 9 years and to expect people to be okay with sitting what feels like inches from other guests, all the while hearing literally what everyone else in the room is saying (no music/tv/white noise), is very awkward and strange. Not to mention the servers who have to carry trays of food up those steps. Talk about a silly idea. Are the margins not that great to want to squeeze a couple more hundred dollars in sales a night in that room? Idk, that may sound presumptuous but so does expecting guests to feel comfortable in what has an attic feel to it. I don't feel I'm exaggerating, you can look at my others reviews and they're mostly positive. This isn't all negative though as I try to be fair with my reviews. No complaints about the fajita or the filet. Both were enjoyed thoroughly. The waffle fries were also pretty tasty as well, for the kiddos. And I always feel it's nice touch when a place has a menu with things to color on and keep them busy. However the steak and crab (12oz sirloin) could be prepared A LOT better. For a $30 meal I would expect the crab on top to be at least warm and the steak flavorful. Like I said I have experience in restaurants (mainly seafood) at many levels and there are a variety of ways to improve that steak. Maybe add some hollandaise/old bay to the top? Please consider this recommendation. I legit felt bad for the servers upstairs as it was Friday evening and only about 4/5 tables were up there to be shared. How do you expect them to make any money on the busiest day of the week? This makes it look like management doesn't really care about them or catering to a group of 4. I felt put off in that room. Other people did as well as they literally got up and left. That room, and the steak did not do the two good servers any favors. Overall we most likely won't be back because it was a drive away but even if it were next door, nothing screamed for us to come back. read more

This is a good place for lunch if you are in Gettysburg. Something for everyone. We really liked the wings that come naked and you can put whatever sauce you want on them at your table. Most places in Gettysburg only serve Pepsi products. The Philly cheesesteak, the fish basket is definitely a must try. read more

My gf and I love coming here for our traditional last dinner before leaving town! The service is good, the food is excellent, and the portions are huge! It is the only thing we look forward to at the end of our Gettysburg trips. We can't wait for our next visit! read more

We had a group of 20 they were excited to have us and made room immediately to accommodate us. The food was excellent and the service was also. It was within walking distance from our hotel. Nice place for a bite to eat. Debbie K. read more

Very happy with our meal and service while in town for a visit! Great burgers, chili and server

We drove by, turned around and walked in. Terry greeted us and had so much information about the place and so sweet. Ryan was our waiter... could not ask for better! Knowledgeable and professional. Great food, great service and a great environment. Thank you all for making our trip here great!!! read more

Finally, a kind waitress and a warm welcome by what I presume was the owner when we arrived! The decor is very neat, minus the 360 mirrors in one section (way to remind me how fat I am while I eat) (lol) and the menu has some great choices. Also, they have Buzztime on the TV's which entertained my husband (even though I whooped his butt). My husband had the Mexican Salad which was fabulous and I had a perfect club. Also, the spicy fried pickles were great! My only complaint can't even count because it was on our dessert - it was free from our stay at the America's Best Value Inn down the street. I chose the hot fudge brownie and there is no way that was a brownie - it was chocolate cake!!!! Where's my chewy chocolate goodness?? Oh well, at least it WAS real hot fudge and that was delish. Plus, it was a HUGE dessert! One of our favorite meals the whole trip - go there! read more

Pricy. Average, flavorless, chain style bar food, nothing fabulous. A big menu is usually a red flag and most everything we tried was pre-packaged then heated fare. This is Pennsylvania, food should be off the hook and amazing!!! Especially in a farming town like GBurg. If Blue and Gray and the Dobbin House have a scratch cooked kitchen, any bar can. How tough can it be to hand cut your french frys from a potato, or bust open an onion for your rings??? Hell you're paying the staff in the kitchen, the menu is expensive, be fantastic for Christ sakes! Self-centered owner was the former manager when the location was a chain, was friendly after we pressured him to warm up. Employees myopic-ignoring, don't give a damn toward visitors they take as tourists. A little friendliness would juice their tips,, but they don't care, you ain't coming back so screw you. Tips not appreciated. Clean and well staffed. Though pricy, we'd return for drinks. You can get institutional, college dorm re-heat n serve food and catatonic service anyplace. Go to the Blue and Gray at the traffic circle where they don't treat you like a tourist, better prices, and good food. read more

Great place to grab lunch or dinner while in the town of Gettysburg! They have a great menu selection and wide assortment of bar offerings! The fried pickles were great to start off our meal. I had the crispy fish tacos. They were fresh and very good. It comes with a side as well. Do yourself a favor and get the waffle fries! They are super crunchy and come out piping hot! My dinner partner got the Mushroom melt. She loved it, describing it as a marinated mushroom in a grilled cheese! Do not write this restaurant off as a tourist gimmick! It is a real deal restaurant with awesome food and a great setting! read more

See all

This was our first stop after arriving in Gettysburg. Friendly, fast service. Very clean and inviting restaurant. My wife and I shared the delicious crab dip, which is served in an enormous bread bowl. My roast beef sandwich seemed to be inspired by beef on weck as it was served with horseradish and au jus. It was topped with melted Swiss cheese as well, very good sandwich. I really enjoyed the side of creamy cole slaw as well. As a bonus, this place was located within walking distance of our hotel. We were able to enjoy some drinks without worrying about driving. Good beer selection too. read more

Overview: A great restaurant with a wide variety of options, priced decently. Food: I have tried nearly everything on the menu, with the exception of the pasta dishes. Everything I have had has been very good and with good-sized portions. However, I find the French Onion Soup to be on the salty side. Their mixed drinks are also quite potent. Recommend: Without a doubt, my favorite thing on the menu is the Southwest Salad. Absolutely delicious. Their wings are also very good and their sandwiches are all very hearty. Atmosphere: It can get crowded on the weekends and evenings, but generally a happy, friendly atmosphere. I particularly like the baseball theme. Service: I have always had very good service, with friendly waitresses and bar staff. read more

I was in town for day on Easter and was bothered to discover that pretty much every place was closed. Sure it's the off season but you'd think that for a tourist town that more places would be opened. I have been to Gettysburg a few times and had never been to his place before and would gladly go again. It was a little pricey but the food was good. When I'm there again I will gladly go again. read more

Very big menu but it's not a late place to eat they close at 10 o'clock . It's a sports bar and restaurant very big sandwich menu and specials every night . The theme is baseball it's all over the place the staff is friendly I recommend the chicken wings 10 for $10 and the Italian steak sandwich is pretty good ask for Steve the waiter he's pretty good friendly and full of stories read more

Gettysburg Eddie's - New American Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

This is a great place to go if you're looking for good food and good drinks. I have been here a few times with family when they visit from out of town, and with friends after shows at a local theatre. Everyone seems to love this place. The drink menu is outstanding. They have shots/shooters, frozen drinks, margaritas, martinis, potent cocktails, classic cocktails, and your usual beer and wine. The Girl Scout Cookie, Orange Creamsicle, and Long Beach Tea are all excellent. Foodwise, my go to is the Southwest Salad. It comes with blackened chicken, black beans, corn, tomatoes, homemade tortilla strips, etc. The veggies are always fresh, and the dressing(honey-lime vinaigrette, I think?) is delicious. GE's is located on Steinwehr Ave. in a pretty busy area of Gettysburg. It's a great place to check out of you're looking for a drink or a bite before or after one of those famous ghost tours. :) read more

It's a bar. It's somewhat dark. They have beer and liquor. They have bar food. The bar is a homage to local legend Eddie Plank, a member of baseball's Hall of Fame and former resident and student of Gettysburg. The photos and memorabilia on the walls are interesting. They do have great wings. I like the way they serve them. They come "naked" and you get 6 ketchup bottles filled with various sauces including Hot, Buffalo Ranch, Jamaican jerk, Honey BBQ, Honey Sesame Garlic, and Teriyaki. I've never been a big fan of sauced wings so this is perfect for me. I also had a side of onion rings and I ordered the "1/2 foot". They were delicious and were even better when I dipped them in the blue cheese that came with the wings. I would like to see some healthier choices on the menu. Like most bars, the fryer goes into overdrive on a daily basis. I suppose that keeps the overhead low. One very good side note, Gettysburg Eddies is a certified green restaurant. I love that. read more

Good food, large portions, reasonable prices. Couple these with friendly staff, and I can easily recommend it. The down side is parking. It can be tough to find a spot in downtown Gettysburg. read more

Terrible service. Was there on July 2 for dinner. Sat at bar. Waited 40 minutes and food never came. Bartender with big butt said she would check but didn't. Don't go here. read more

What a great place! Nice selections, our food was delicious! #ilovehotbacondressing !!! The brownie pan dessert was over the top and most if all the service was outstanding ! Our server Sarah was very attentive. She made some nice suggestions for lunch, our table was bussed during our meal and answered all of our questions about the area :) Great dining experience !!! read more

Gettysburg Eddie's came recommended from a local and we decided to give a shot. Their menu is extensive and there is arguably something for everyone. Our waitress was great, the place is clean, and their "drink menu" on the place mat was a good conversation piece. Their chili cheese fries were good but i was disappointed in their use of process cheese topping rather then real cheese. Mrs. and my entree were very tasty and offered good portions. I thought the prices to be slightly more expensive then style of dinning. All in all I would gladly go back. read more

Sweet waitress, really good food. All 3 of us left stuffed to the brim for under $60. Greek Salad was amazing and gorgeous! read more

Gettysburg Eddie's - Greek Salad. Best salad presentation I've ever seen! - New American Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Sports bar-like atmosphere that seems to be quite popular even during off times. The food is average to good, nothing really spectacular, but not bad. For simple burgers, sandwiches, and other like dishes it's a good choice for a restaurant. Our sever, Missy I believe her name was, was extremely nice and genuine in her attitude. On whole, a fairly good place to eat at, though not the most deep impression making. read more

I was about faint and after passing 2 of "Gettysburg's finest pizza places" we stopped here. It was crowded about lunch time on a Saturday and the hostess asked if we'd mind sitting at a table for two in front, that everyone coming in would lean on and bump into as they were passing by. I politely refused and asked if we could sit at the bar in the back. I liked the decor of of this place and loved the lady at the bar with her purse on one stool and her bags on another. No room at the bar so we sat at a high top. I ordered a Coke my wife got a Shocktop, the bartender (Cute... I can say that because my wife doesn't read my reviews) gave us menu's and I needing food NOW just ordered a med. cheddar burger w/ the pasta salad my wife feeling rushed ordered a veg. portobello thingamabob. It was good, cheap ($) pub food and I'd go back. PS don't get me wrong the hostess was very nice and probably had been offering that table to no avail all day. The lady at the bar left about 10 minutes after we got our drinks but she didn't trip on her way out. Shucks. read more

Nice atmosphere. Friendly staff. Just ordered some small side salads and waffle fries but fairly pleased. Salads weren't fancy, but average for a pub/bar. Waffle fries were very tasty! read more

Gettysburg Eddie's - New American Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

A nice family restaurant in the historic area of Gettysburg. Food was good. A little pricey for what you get. Interesting decor about Gettysburg Eddie and his sports history. It's worth a try! read more

Our server was wonderfully attentive. The interior retains much of the same charm of the building's previous eatery. The food was nothing exceptional. I bit underwhelming. The favors, for the most part, were bland. It was okay. Not worth a return trip. The Gingerbread Man..which was here before Gettysburg Eddie's was a much better experience. If you are coming from out of town and are expecting a similar experience....sorry. read more