This is an important updated review. Eddies is now under new management but "new" doesnt mean better. With the portion cuts i witnessed firsthand my party and i immediatly began to panic because we thought there was an ongoing food shortage. Very dissapointed. read more

We visited here tonight. The service was really good but the food was mediocre at best. I wish we would have tried a different restaurant.

My food was awesome-philly cheese steak. Hers sucked; BBQ pulled pork that was bland and tasted like it was heated up from the day before. Our waitress noticed it wasn't eaten and asked about it; but still charged for it read more

I've been coming to this place every time I visit Gettysburg, and I usually have a lovely experience eating the food. However this time, I went to the bar in the back of the restaurant, and because of the bartender Katie, I'm sorry I ever did! One of the most passive aggressive and disrespectful people I have ever encountered. She treated the other patrons there with respect and went out of her way to make sure they were accommodated, but did no such thing with me. I've been around bartenders before and I've worked in bars, and usually the decorum when someone finishes their drink is you ask them if they would like another, I had one drink and ad soon as I finished it she simply says to me "goodnight!" In this nasty tone and passive aggressive manner. I don't know if she did not like people who are perceived outsiders, but I just find out to be really disgusting and disgraceful. I really don't know what her problem was but if you're from out of town, I would avoid Katie at the bar because she'll most likely treat you like garbage. read more

Stopped in for supper after a day of exploring Gettysburg National Park. Great and super friendly service! I had the Western Chicken and it was delicious!! The homemade coleslaw is the best I've had!! If you're looking for a great place to eat look no more!! read more

This is fairly standard pub fare. The wings with the bucket of sauces to try is a nice starter. We have had the dinners (scallops, fajitas and steak), but do not enjoy them as much as the sandwiches. The grilled chicken sandwiches are juicy and come with a lot of flavor. Save room for the warm gingerbread (I skip the lemon sauce) which is drenched in whipped cream. read more

Average food, good service, great location. Menu has a little something for everyone - as all tourist restaurants should. Portions are big. Parking in back. read more

Don't waste your money. Im all about pub food and i went here starving. After reading reviews on here, I figured its worth a shot. After waiting 10 minutes for a waitress, she pops up and says "ready?" We didnt even order our drinks yet. My boyfriend and I ordered the English sandwich, (roast beef w/ aus jus) and I had a cup of French onion soup, he had a cup of chili. The soups came out pretty fast for a busy night, but they were both cold. They were good, but cold! His son got the chicken Parmesan dinner, the cheese wasnt melted at all, and the whole thing was cold. He ate it anyway and we ate all ours too because we were starving! Our roast beef sandwiches were just ok. We were pretty disappointed. Not worth the 53.00 plus tip, so don't waste your money. And no, we didn't have alcohol. I have no problem spending more on a good meal. it just needs to be worth it! Sorry guys but we wouldn't go back. read more

Great pub food and great beer selection. The food is really fresh and well prepared. I had the crab cakes which were great my wife had salmon which she really enjoyed . This is a winner read more

Very friendly employees. Had the Philly cheesesteak sandwich. While not great it was pretty good, served hot and fresh. Large menu items and seemed to be a lot of locals there which is a good sign for a restaurant close to all the tourist activity. Would go back in a second. Oh and did I mention the really COLD beer! Easy walking distance to everything downtown and most hotels in the area. read more

Had reservations about this place. Loved the GInerbread man, that was here before this. Mnetioned it to the waiter, and he explained it was just a name and theme change, was still the same owner and good food. Food was very good, and the service was excellent, superb actually. I had a salmon BLT, and it was over stuffed with salmon. the bar area is a sahde dark, but we sat at the front by the windows, and enjoyed our meals and drinks watching the tourists go by. the drink menu is extensive, and certainly has something for everyone. I would think this establishment would be idea for the sports fantic, casual sports fan, and those that like a historical aspect as well. Will certainly eat here again.. read more

Restaurant smelled funky. Service was slow. Food was awful. No taste, could've had better out of the freezer aisle in the grocery store. Totally overpriced. Don't waste your time - find some place else! read more

I live in PA, however not in Gettysburg. We come to Gettysburg probably 6 times a year; sometimes more. We've just discovered Gettysburg Eddie's this year. We've been 3 times in the past few months. It seems like a lot of locals come here. Everyone is very friendly and the service is really good. The last time we were there the bar area was super crowded because a Toys for Tots bar crawl was starting there. The servers were very overwhelmed but they worked their butts off and worked well as a team and everything was handled perfectly. The food is pretty good. My husband has had the quesadillas which he really enjoyed and he had a philly cheese steak sandwich the last time. He said it was really good and the meat was stuffed into the french bread. I've had the seafood chowder (not sure what it's called) both times and I really like it. The first time I ordered a cup of it and the second time I upgraded to a bowl. I had chicken tenders last time. The fries were good and their homemade honey mustard sauce was really good. I believe the chicken was frozen, pressed chicken that they just fried up. It wasn't bad but not spectacular either. We feel really comfortable there and have enjoyed each meal. The prices are very fair and the drinks are really good as well. read more

Stopped here for dinner. We had the nachos and it was a wing night so we got 2 dozen. Nachos were good. Wings were excellent. They give you a variety of wing sauces to choose from which was really nice. Our waitress and the other servers were all excellent. They were attentive and helpful without being overbearing. I would definitely stop here again when passing through Gettysburg! read more

Was told to try it, went loved the atmosphere pretty! Service was real good. Fish tacos were ok, one in the family got fairly good shrimp fettuccine . The other one got terrible shrimp fettuccini. Was watery and looked terrible after stirring. I think it took on the color of the portabella mushrooms (yuck) on the color of the The waiter must have known when he sat it down cause he kept asking. We should have net it back but everyone else was already eating or about finished. The Mexican salad was good but mushrooms(?) in it? The blue cheese burger was good and the waffle fries were real good. But for around 94$ for 5 people was not a good buy. I thought it was too expensive for the meal. Big helpings of fettuccini was great but yucky ! Overall not going back !but left a good tip anyway wasn't the waiters fault read more

The food is alright, a bit expensive. It has a baseball air about it, but is like every other pub in town.

Typical pub place. Pretty good beer selection, and food was alright.

We had lunch here twice during the 4th celebration. Great sandwiches, draft beer and super decor inside. Park out back and enjoy. We will return when we return. read more

The service staff is really slow and the restaurant was super crowded and noisy. I got a tossed salad and it was pretty good; filled with crunchy lettuce and veggies. When we did get out meal (after 45 minutes if waiting) it wasn't wow but it was okay. The chicken was really dry and the food was cold when we got it. My Grammie got the Mexican salad and she said that it was greasy because they left it waiting too long. Gordon Ramsey would be appalled. read more

I was so disappointed with this restaurant. I came here because I had loved its old version, The Gingerbread Man, and saw they still had the dessert I wanted. However, I was so upset by dinner that I left before dessert. There were over 70 shots/mixed drinks yet terrible beer selection. Chicken wings were dry and charged extra for blue cheese and celery (celery?!). Chicken parmesan over linguine had un-breaded checken, mushy pasta, and sauce that was clearly from a jar. Even the garlic bread was terrible- I could see the salt on it and that's all I could taste. Who screws up garlic bread? At least the waffle fries were good. The waitress was friendly, but didn't check on us for such a long time that I gave up and ended up leaving once she finally came back to give us a check. Other waiters saw us searching for our server and didn't offer to help us or find her- so unprofessional. read more

My wife and I ate here on our last trip to Gettysburg, mostly because it was one of a few places open on Sunday in the off-season. Our experience was very average. My French dip sandwich was rather bland, and her salad just normal. The service was OK, but slow given what we ordered. All in all there wasn't anything terribly wrong with Gettysburg Eddie's but nothing special either. read more

I kind of like the bar here; the bartenders have low-key personality, and the crowd is usually an interestingly lively mix of tourists and a few locals. The TVs are awkwardly placed, though. The draft selections usually include some decent locals and microbrews. The dining experience is ok. The food that I've had has always been acceptable, and there are even touches of creativity, like the interesting pasta salad or the Jack 'n' Bleu cheese sticks, which are such a better idea than mozz sticks that I'm mad I didn't think of it first. But clearly they spend more time and energy on the branding of the restaurant than on either the atmosphere or the menu; the overall feeling you get is that you're in a place that is selling to the one-time visitor, the Gettysburg equivalent of eating at the Hard Rock Cafe. In addition, the service is not great... the waitresses are chatty but only infrequently attentive, and the owner/manager seems to veer back and forth over the line between charismatically interacting with customers and pompously causing drama with the wait staff. I'd like to give it 2.5 stars, because I honestly don't hate it. It just seems like a place that could be so much better (like, as others have said, The Blue & Grey, or The Garryowen). But, as long as the unique branding keeps sucking in the tourists, I suppose that there's not really an incentive for them to try any harder. read more

If you're interested in a loud rowdy place with foul mouthed drunken college kids this is the place for you! My husband and I just came from here. They placed us upstairs with a few other people and a large group of loud obnoxious kids. The service was good, food was ok, but we were unable to enjoy our food at all. After we got our food we didn't hang around long. The noise was unbearable they were so loud pretty much screaming. One waitress after others had left asked them to quiet down which lasted about a minute. We went for dinner on our anniversary weekend thinking it was a nice restaurant but instead got a rowdy club atmosphere. Don't waste your time or money! read more

Nice attentive staff, Okay food, Decent prices.

If you have tastes buds DO NOT eat here. Poor Eddie must be spinning in his grave right now. The only saving grace was our accommodating waitress. They seated us upstairs and immediately entering the room you are greeted by a lovely urine-like aroma. It is also stiflingly hot. The mozzarella sticks were like mush on the inside and inedible. I had to return my steak twice and usually I am not the type to return food unless it's really cooked wrong. Requested medium rare and the first one was well done, the second one was very unevenly cooked(one side bone dry the other completely raw in the middle)and had alot of connective tissue or a filet mignon cut. I gave up and ate my bread and side salad which were perfectly fine. It would have been nice to get some butter that wasn't frozen solid though. I watched my friend pick sadly at her spaghetti and meatballs which really looked gross so I was afraid to ask her how it was. Another friend had diet restrictions so the only thing he could eat really was the spaghetti with garlic and olive oil, which was fine by him(by the way it was listed as spaghetti on the menu but they were both served linguine). It was flavorless and he got sick shortly after we left. I'm sure it's a fine place for a pint and some fries but beyond that I would not trust anything else they make here. read more