This place is an absolutely gem! My partner and I came here during the summer and we loved it. The interior was a quaint English-style pub and it's very clean! Our server, Cassie, was knowledgeable and very sweet, giving us very good recommendations. We ordered a shrimp and crab bisque ($6), crab cake sandwich ($18), and a Philly cheesesteak ($14). She was made aware of my love for Long Islands and she claimed the bar made a very good one. I ordered that as well and my goodness, she was right. If I ever find myself back in Gettysburg, I would definitely come back here again! read more

Gettysburg Eddie's - Crab Cake - New American Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

Love this place. Great atmosphere and super clean and food was so good . Effortlessly staff! They know their customers. Great sports bar!

I was a little disappointed in this place. It wasn't bad but wasn't great either. It was really hyped up and a long wait to get in. Food was kind of expensive and portion size was small. Maybe I ordered the wrong thing. read more

Gettysburg Eddie's - Chicken sandwich and a couple of fries. - New American Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Delicious burgers, cooked perfectly. And, they have plenty of seating when the other restaurants have a long wait. Good bar drinks, too. read more

Shrimp tacos and fish and chips were both good. Good and friendly service. . A basic bar that serves good food. Not very healthy. Everything cooked in soybean oil. read more

Service was great. Friendly staff. One of my diners had the portobello burger & loved it. I had the Italian Cheesesteak. I thought the handheld would be thinly sliced steak, just like a Philly, with Italian sauce & cheese. It was definitely NOT. despite the server checking and declaring it was. It definitely looked like chopped meatballs... not thinly sliced steak. The side order of Broccoli crowns were less than al dente. My guest requested olive oil sprinkled Broccoli. read more

Burgers are some of the best in Gettysburg. Nice menu options with a good drink menu to boot. Perfect location and helpful staff.

Ate there twice this past weekend. Very busy weekend in town and the servers were awesome!! Great food. We got wings, chili and salad. All delicious!! It's a go to every-time we are in town!! read more

Nice and efficient server but crummy food. The menu was pretty unappealing so I only ordered a bowl of onion soup...the soup was tasteless, the crouton was mush and the cheese was ok. One cousin had a salad with very dry overcooked bacon on top and the other had what looked like frozen fried shrimp. The get together was great, the food not so much. read more

Good spot for lunch before hitting the national cemetery. I had the cheesesteak sandwich which was really good. The fries were very crunch and had a good seasoni mbh on them. The sandwich had their homemade cheese sauce on it, so good! I could pour that cheese sauce all over those fries and go to town. Daughter had a turkey avocado salad- really fresh and the veggies in there were perfect. The bacon was thick and crispy, delicious. My son had the crabcakr sandwich, he said it was great buy I didn't taste it. Would definitely go here again. read more

My husband and I always have lunch/ dinner here after riding our horses on the battlefields. There's adequate parking behind the building as well street parking out front. Everyone is always so nice and the food is really good! There's usually always room at the bar and that's where we sit. The drinks are always made perfectly. My favorites are definitely the margaritas, crab cakes, wings and crab pretzel! If you're in town this is a good place to grab a bite to eat or even some drinks. read more

Gettysburg Eddie's - New American Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Great food. Great pricing. Good service. I was server was very nice. The food came quickly.

Recently went to Gettysburg Eddie's for lunch and really enjoyed it. I had the buffalo chicken quesadilla and it was awesome. Service was great and good atmosphere. Highly recommend this place if you're in town looking for a quick bite. read more

Great food and great service. The shrimp tacos were great! Everything was prepared well and served quickly

Upon arriving at the restaurant, we were greeted by (2) hostesses, of which communicated there was a 30 minute wait for two of us. One hostess proceeded to explain there was room at the bar downstairs and upstairs and started talking so fast, I had no idea what she was saying. Out of nowhere, a waitress explained there were high toppers available and proceeded to show us in the bar. She was exceptionally nice and I tipped her for understanding and being nice. The bartender was our waitress and she was FANTASTIC from start to finish. The memorabilia is incredible in the restaurant, clearly depicting the era of when Eddie Plank played and what he meant to the community. Excellent environment, food and service! read more

Food was good- it's not blowing you away, but it's good pub food. My firecracker shrimp tracks were delicious, as was the spicy slaw that came with it. The ambiance is exactly what you should expect for a pub. The service was the best part. Our waitress Michelle (?) should be training others, though her gifts are likely just innate. She predicted our needs and was quick with the extra things. One of the better options in Gettysburg. read more

We were visiting Gettysburg with my kids for a school trip. This place was able to accommodate not only our vegetarian dietary preference but also our two picky eater kids. Service was great. Ambiance was cool. Would recommend! read more

Gettysburg Eddie's - Alfredo dish. - New American Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

This was my first time here- it is worth going back! We arrived around 4pm at the start of Happy Hour. We started with the Spicy Fried pickles, delicious. The dipping sauce is different but very good. I ate the Eddie's Hero, very good on a Ciabatta roll. My fiancé had the jalapeño burger, he said it was really good, and my mom had the Eddie's pulled beef hoagie. We would not get that again, as it was a sweet beef and as a personal preference we prefer a less sweet beef. All-in-all the service was great, atmosphere was great as well. Location and parking (in the back) are all conveniently located in Gettysburg. read more

See all

Great service. Great food. Was there on Sunday 11/20 with a party of 4. The waitress was amazing and checked on us frequently. She was very sweet. Don't remember her name. I had an excellent burger and fries that were piping hot. We also had the wings, the shrimp and the hot grinder. Everyone loved their food! Used the bathroom and it was also up to par. You can't go wrong here. We had tried to come here the night before and they were packed with a 40 minute wait so we went somewhere else but did come back! No complaints and 5 stars given! read more

Ambiance- crowded, busy, jammin' in a good way. Service was good. Food and drinks were good and reasonably priced. App tacos were filling and very reasonable. Good place to spend time with a small group. read more

Great place for a quick byte with plants or selections for a family lunch or dinner. Friendly and efficient service won't keep you waiting for long. read more

Outstanding restaurant with good food and atmosphere! The upstairs is a real plus! The history is unique!

We had such a delicious snack and dessert at Gettysburg Eddie's. Our waiter was Terry and he was so nice and attentive and had great recommendations but OMG the homemade ginger bread is off the chain run don't walk to this wonderful restaurant. read more

Gettysburg Eddie's - Home Made Gingerbread - New American Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Had a delicious sandwich from this restaurant English Beef sandwich, great atmosphere and outstanding service read more

Gettysburg Eddie's - English Beef Sandwich with mushrooms red pepper.. - New American Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

See all

We were just there end of August 2023 on a Friday night. It was busy but not standing room only. There is parking behind the restaurant, which is great. My husband got the jalapeno/bbq/cheese burger and I got an order of fried pickles and the cheesesteak sub. He was amazed at the size of the burger! Could have fed two people! Fries were really good. They had a coating on them that made them really crispy. Fried pickles came with a buffalo/ranch sauce that was just hot enough. The cheesesteak was good and filling. Overall a very good place. It's decor is dedicated to Eddie Plank was a MLB player around the turn of the 20th century who was born in Gettysburg. read more

This place has great food. Even with how small the restruant is, it's still pretty peaceful when busy. I highly recommend the wings.

My family and I were Gettysburg, after a great day of exploring the battlefield until it got dark and no one was permitted in the park. It was a Tuesday and we were starving, but we couldn't find a place where the kitchen was still open until we came across Gettysburg Eddie's. I'm just going to start off by saying that I CANNOT WAIT to go back. The atmosphere is great for everybody, whether you want to go and sit at the lively bar with all the TVs in the other room, or you'd like to sit and have a meal with family and friends. The kids' menu is very good, with the usuals to choose from, such as Mac and Cheese, grilled cheese sandwich, and the chicken fingers that my son got, amongst others. I started off with the crab and shrimp bisque, which was out of this world. I've only ever had crab bisque, so this mixture with the shrimp was delicious! The signature drinks are great, with a nice fruity kick to them. I had the HOUSE HERO, which I cannot recommend highly enough. With all of the Italian meats, provolone cheese, lettuce, and tomatoes, it's beyond delicious. It's also huge, so you really get a bang for your buck (it tastes just as good when you bring it home)! My husband said the cheeseburger was the best he's had in a long time. The servers are all very kind and attentive as well. Despite it getting closer to closing time, we never felt rushed. If you are in Gettysburg, you need to try Gettysburg Eddie's! read more

Food, ambiance and service were excellent. We will heading back to Gettysburg Eddie's.

Named after local baseball Hall of Famer, Eddie Plank, it's a baseball oriented sports bar. As such the menu consists of a lot undescriptive but catch named foods like The Grand Slammer, Home Run Sandwich, Double Play, Triple Play, Extra Bases and so forth, basically bar foods which I tend to avoid, but here, I found them to actually be rather good. I start off with their Caesar Salad which consisted of a good crispy romaine, a creamy Caesar dressing, topped with a parmesan cheese and croutons. Then, went for their Philly Cheese Steak which though not prepared in keeping with the traditional style of a Philly Cheese as one might find at such Philadelphia cheesesteaks landmarks of Gino's or Pat's, as the bread was more hoagie like and the cheese, not a mixed in whiz but American melted on top. However, very good in flavor. Both the dining area and bar area have a much better atmosphere than do most sport bars with the dining be set off and separate from the bar. read more

See all

Had dinner at Gettysburg Eddie's. The restaurant is a tribute to favorite son Edward Stewart Plank, a baseball player from the early 20th century. He was the first major league southpaw to win 300 games, was the 1913 World Series MVP and was inducted into the Baseball Hall of fame in 1946. Enough about that. Gettysburg Eddie's is a nice cozy restaurant; it has the atmosphere of a neighborhood tavern. For dinner, my wife had the grilled Greek chicken and I had the Reuben sandwich. The grilled Greek chicken was topped with sautéed onions, tomatoes, Calamata olives, Greek dressing and melted feta cheese. With my Reuben I had the steak fries as my side; the portion was generous. We both enjoyed our dinners. The food was good, the service was attentive and the prices reasonable. Gettysburg Eddie's is a good choice if you're looking for casual dining. read more

Gettysburg Eddie's - Reuben sandwich with steakfries - New American Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

This was perhaps the best meal I had on my trip. The food was great, the staff were very friendly, I loved the pleasant atmosphere, and the historical content was very interesting. I decided to be brave and try the Black & Blue Burger, instead of a more standard option, and was delighted to find I liked it! And this place pleased me so much, I decided to do something I've never done before: write a review. If I ever go back to Gettysburg, I will be sure to stop by again! read more

We attempted to take our party of 8 to eat here and they turned us away because we had a baby with us. The hostess was incredibly rude and though it was obvious they had room to serve us, they told us they did not. be aware this is a very small place, not suitable for larger groups, and not suitable for children. we were super disappointed. read more

Great atmosphere- for a late lunch stop. Chef was accommodating for a GF crab dip meal! Excellent crab shrimp bisque. Salads were good. Nice beer selection! (Would prefer more GF options.) read more

Gettysburg Eddie's - New American Near Me - Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

Delicious! The roast beef au jus sandwich ch was stacked high with meet. The cheese sauce on the Philly was delicious. The service was super friendly. read more

Great burger and great beer! The inside of the pub was very homey. Great service! If you are in the Gettysburg area would highly recommend a burger and beer from here. read more

The place was okay it was very crowded to where we had to go upstairs the waiter was excellent didn't miss any of our orders and remembered everyone's drinks but the thing we didn't like is how pricey everything was I got a simple cheeseburger and still paid over $13 for it. The cheapest things they have are the appetizers and they was still $10. It was pretty clean but if your looking for a good priced place with good food I wouldn't recommend this restaurant especially if there's more then one person eating cause you'll be paying an arm and a leg for it read more

See all

This was a mediocre place for lunch. The service is excellent. We were seated immediately and our waitress checked in frequently. The menu has a wide variety of choices and drinks. I was not impressed with the food. My shrimp and crab bisque had undercooked potatoes and no taste of crab. My filet mignon sandwich was decent and they cook the steak to your liking. The coleslaw for me had too much vinegar. I only had one bite. read more

See all

This restaurant is located in Downtown Gettysburg and is one of the few without a Civil War motif. It is named for a Baseball Hall of Famer from Gettysburg named Eddie Plank, a left handed pitcher with 300 wins. Anyway, on with the review! We went there for lunch after touring the battlefield. It is important to note that they were practicing safe social distancing during the COVID-19 pandemic. I have to give them some kudos for that. Limited seating and masks were the order of the day. We ordered nachos and some beers when we arrived, club sandwiches, and a crabcake. All of the food was what you would expect from a typical bar-like restaurant. Solid, filling, perhaps not spectacular but certainly not bad. The service was good and we left there feeling like we had a decent meal for the money. Again, it is important to note that my four star rating is based upon my expectations of bar food as well as the fact that they were open safely during a pandemic. I have to give them a little bump for that. If I am ever back in Gettysburg, I will certainly return. read more

We went to the famous battlefield town and after a day of travel, we searched for a late take-out restaurant and discovered few options. Our order consisted of chicken, shrimp and potato skins. The food was ready when they advised, we took it back to our hotel and ate almost all of it as it was very good. If I return to this area, I would stop in again as it was a good value and delicious! read more

Fantastic ambiance and amazing food. I highly recommend Gettysburg Eddie's! The food is FRESH and portioned well! I was also impressed with how clean the entire restraint was. We sat upstairs at the bar and I always peak behind the bar...not a spec of food on the floor. The restrooms were also clean. We'll be back!! read more