They're selling dollar slices for 2.50. Bad quality dough, bad quality sauce, and just all around bad slices. When I went to fold the slice it broke into three pieces becuase of how thin and crappy their crust is. The store isn't even nice. No pride in what they do. read more

First time I ordered from them was today, and I ordered a pepperoni pizza. They delivered a cheese instead. I said I didn't want it and politely refused the delivery, which I've never ever done before, but it was this big unappetizing slab of cheese and I'm straight up not gonna eat it, so I can't waste the money. I've never ordered a plain pizza from anywhere; there's no way I asked for the wrong thing. But I figured, no big, they wrote down the wrong order, maybe I'll try again sometime. BUT THEN they CALLED me, told me never to order from there again (LOL, don't worry, bruh, I won't), insisted there's no way they wrote down the wrong thing, and then hung up on me. So...maybe the food is good if you get the right order, but also they're total dickwaffles, so there's that. read more

The worst pizza ever after they got my order wrong and I asked for a new pizza they gave me a cheap pizza with the cheese sliding everywhere it looks disgusting I can't believe this place just disgusted read more

Disgusting customer service im placing a order asking the guy what beverages he has then tells me to hurry up listen its not my fault you might be overwhelmed with orders but im sitting here giving you my money least you can do is TAKE THE FUCKING ORDER without a attitude phone call wasnt even one minute 42seconds to be exact so fucking rude read more

The pizzas are good. But $3 a slice is really a little bit too much. The staff are so nice and funny. I feel so welcomed in there. It's definitely worth a visit though the slices are a little bit too expensive. read more

Why would you not stop here after an evening at the King's Theater on Flatbush. It is everything you might hope for. An old school, Italian, pizza joint....for slices. Nothing more. Good folks serving. One table for sitting. I dropped my pizza slice on the floor and they gave me another on the house. #supporlocalPizza! read more

This place is great, I get their pizza all the time. Their grandma slices are AMAZING! Seriously, I could eat them all day everyday and never get tired of it. Their plain slices are pretty good, nothing amazing but a pretty solid, traditional New York slice. Their eggplant parmesan is also pretty awesome- I tried ordering a small order once but ended up with a giant tin foil bowl thing full of it that lasted me DAYS (and I ate TONS of it each day). I live around the corner from here and always just drop in- the guys who work here are pretty cool. Oh! Also, during the warmer weather they have outdoor seating (moved inside for winter), which is pretty cool. read more

After I got my hot food in a paper bag with many other bags in my hand. I asked for a plastic bag. I was told they don't have any plastic bags after I just saw him give one to another customer. On top of that seemed like someone spilled juice and the floor was so sticky and dirty. Never again! read more

Just left this place and Cash was so pleasant. I haven't reached home yet to taste my food but I hope it is as good as their customer service. I will be back on pleasantries alone. read more

I don't know if these ratings are absolute or relative. RELATIVE to other New York pizza, this place and the others in the greater Flatbush/Prospect Lefferts Gardens/Propsect South area. They all suck. This is not very good pizza. The pasta is passable, but really, not that good. Its alright, certainly have had better. BUT for the neighborhood? In and absolute way this place is a three. In a relative way a two. Like most things in this part of Brooklyn, its good if you happen to be here but don't go out of your way. read more

The food I've ordered from here is good --- but I gotta say it's kinda expensive. If it wasn't for the price I'd give it more stars. I'm really irritated I spent $7.00 on mozzarella sticks and got five small frozen mozzarella sticks. Come on now. read more

Solid neighborhood pizza joint. Great thinnish crust, excellent sauce, and no ridiculous amount of cheese. Prices start at $10 for a (quite) large cheese pie and top out around 17 bucks for the works. Also, $2 slices and some neighborhood Caribbean specialties (beef patty, etc.) Word of advice (or forewarning): the "Gino's Special" includes among its 8 toppings spinach and broccoli. Not terrible, but not exactly what I expected on a pizza with the works! read more

I am loathe to have to update my review on this pizza place. But I do hope it helps someone else avoid the terrible experience we recently had. We've been a customer of this place for years. At least 5. And the service had been generally decent. The pizza was good, and we overlooked the occasional mishap. But we just can't anymore. It's definitely gone downhill. We ordered the same thing we always order. Every weekend. 7pm. At 8pm nothing has arrived. We call and they say it's out for delivery. At 9pm, we're starving and they give us the same story. It's on it's way. They are obviously covering up their mistake and lying to us. So Grubhub calls them and refunds us our money. Then we call again because we still don't know when our food is arriving. I ask who I am speaking to, and he says "this is Gino". The owner? I ask when we will get the order and he says it was cancelled. I say that I am the customer and I absolutely did not cancel the order. I remind him that we order consistently nearly every weekend for the past 5 years, and he responds in silence. I say, "what are you going to do about our order", to which he replies "nothing". I repeat, "we are a long-time customer, you've lied to us for 2 hours that our order is on its way, obviously something got messed up, and how are you going to make this right?" To which he responds, "there's nothing I can do", and hangs up on me. So there you go. Loyal customer means nothing to them. And after waiting over 2 hours for an order they messed up, giving them the benefit of the doubt, and getting treated the way we did... not to mention having to go out at 10pm to pick up a pizza order from another place, because we weren't about to wait on yet another delivery place at that hour... I really can't justify ever ordering from this place again. And I hope this review helps others avoid a similar situation. read more

This is very solid NY pizza. I think that these guys might be the only Italians in the neighborhood. Actually, I have no idea whether they're Italian or not, but they're definitely not Trinidadian like the majority of their clientele. The cheese slices are huge and the topped pizzas are loaded. $9 8 slice plain pie cannot be beaten. I die a little everytime my bedfellow orders Papa John's when places like this are so nearby and awesome, but then I get over it and eat it, because really, either you like pizza or you don't. Still, Gino's is great. They don't have all the extras you'll find in other neighborhood joints (read - NO ZEPPOLI!!!), so keep it simple, I guess. read more

I think Gino's Pizza is the best! Not only is it the place where my fiance and I went on our first date, but they have the best pizza. I went to Gino's recently after spending over an hour at the Modell's across from the new Barclay Square basketball stadium at Atlantic Avenue after trying on about ten pairs of running shoes and leaving without finding the right pair. Needless to say, I was hungry. I ordered one slice of pizza, and believe it or not, an authentic Nathan-like square potato knish, replete with deli mustard (but alas, no sour kraut). The pizza was delicious, thick cheese, nice amount of yummy tomato sauce, and good dough. I added pepper and oregano. Mmmmm. Still hungry, I ordered a hot chocolate (the weather was damp and rainy) and a small slice of cheesecake. The cold cheesecake and the hot chocolate complemented each other in my mouth giving a delicious contrast of taste and temperature. The owner and other server behind the counter were quite cheerful and polite and I was able to watch the news on the big screen TV while I ate. Gino's is my favorite pizza joint! read more

I got a decent pie delivered more than 30 blocks away within 25 minutes. That counts for something. But as for flavor and texture, it could have been a bit better. This pizza was much better than your average fast food or 99 cent varieties, and it comes cooked from a brick oven which is always an upgrade. But the sauce needed some more sweetness and herbiness. The crust was the weakest spot; a bit too chewy for me. But overall the pies are reminiscent of the ones you get from more famous pizzerias , but with something missing. It's pretty cheap, $10-15, so for that kind of money it really is A-OK. read more

The pizza here is decent and you get good taste for a good price. They use a good amount of tomato sauce and they always make their pizza fresh from scratch. The cheese melts right in your mouth. They serve different pasta dishes, The staff are very warm and friendly, the place is big with a television set in the heart of prospect park. Anyone looking to stop by for a slice of pizza should look no further and stop at Ginos pizza. Once you try their pizza you would want to come back for more. Not to mention it is near the 2,3 B,Q Trains and there is always people here so that means its a good places. read more

This pizza is just awesome. The grandma is my favorite. So much so that I drive 20 minutes to get it. The regular slices are good too. Sauce is just right, a little sweet but chuck full of crushed tomatoes. The only downside is there is no ambiance to sit and eat. Better to go to Roma in Park Slope for that. Otherwise this is the best I have had in a while. read more

My fave local pizza, since courtelyou places won't come up here. The crust could use work but the pizza is consistent. And I'm in love with their white slice. read more

The crust tastes like cardboard and the cheese hardens to a really weird consistency. The delivery was fast, but if rather wait a little longer for actual pizza. Never ordering from here again. read more

Damn, paid $3.50 for a slice of the buffalo chicken pie that filled me up as if it were a full meal. Delicious chicken, buffalo sauce, and bread, plus a blue cheese dressed drizzled on just hits the spot. Thanks, Gino! read more

Who in the world puts globs of melted cheese on pasta and meatballs? I had it delivered and then had to walk back to the store and ask them to remake it. The manager copped an attitude and the deaf guy, who apparently has a rep for being unsanitary with his hands when he makes the pizza (see Google review), gave me back the order w/ about three to four "halves" of meatballs. Then they forgot to add knots to my order. Instead of having to go there again...I'd thought make this review. The place is dirty even if I always thought the food was decent. But after this experience and other bad experiences from years back, I've decided to never go there again. Shame because I'm only a block away. Owner seems to be the problem in not knowing how to train employees and teach them how to respect customers. read more

The pizza was very good. But every time we order from them for delivery their drivers do not talk english and they do not know how to get the the correct address ! read more

Mediocre pizza. Spent 14 bucks on a large pie with mushrooms and olives. Other toppings might be better but the cheese, sauce and crust were not good enough. read more

An average pizza joint, with average tasting pizza.. There is two tables with benches, rather small, and the inside is not really appealing to look at, the menu board is rather old and discolored, and in my opinion the pizza on display looks kind of stale... read more

Gino's has delicious, authentic New York style slices. It's definitely a hidden-gem here in Flatbush. You'd be missing out if you didn't give it a try! read more

Pizza is good and straight forward but customer service is ridiculous which ends up overshadowing the food. I tried ordering from this place several times and each time the person that answers cannot be understood, much less understand my order. That being said, the last time I attempted ordering they sent me to another pizza shop that is also owned by the owners of Gino's. Even though I explained that I wanted food from this site, they promptly hung up on me. If you get pizza from this place, you have to walk in and hope for the best. read more

Best pizza ever plus friendly people and clean!

Not only is the pizza good here but they have great pasta dishes and really good philly cheese steak. I like the Gino's special pizza that comes with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, spinach and broccoli, really good combination. Their baked ziti and stuffed shells are awesome too. The delivery is fast and they're always really friendly. read more

Do you know about Chef Boyardee dehydrated pizza in a box? Google it. It's 1lb for $2.49 and it tastes like sadness and hard times. Gino's Pizza is like that but it's $12.50. read more

Mediocre in every sense -- both this place and the one just south of Lincoln Road. For pizza in the neighborhood, you're much better off with Family, which is just north of Parkside. Family does the classic New York thin crust right. (they don't deliver, though.) read more

Great food BUT you need to call one number for entrés and another phone number for pizza. I like to have an entré and my kids like pizza so I need to make 2 phone calls and hope they get the order correct. Billy's pizza doesn't make you do that! Gino's food is great but this is not worth the hassle. Sorry Ginos, lost another one. read more

This is a great local pizza spot. There are several different pies available for quick order slices when you walk in. they now have on line ordering. you cant go wrong for an $11.00 large pie. The white cheese slice is excellent. read more

Haven't tried their pizza but the pastas are an awesome deal. You get huge portions for very low prices. While the food itself is no frills classic, every pasta dish I've ordered has been great. Garlic knots are hit or miss in terms of quality (read: garlic quantity) but I usually get them anyway. (They're only $1.25! Toss 'em in.) read more

I ordered pizza and pasta from Gino's. I found a roach in my pasta while I was eating. I was very disgusted and would never eat from this place again and do not recommend it. read more

I have been ripped off so many times from this place. When they make their pies fresh that day, they are reasonably good ! However, I have had home delivered pies, on many occassion, that are just stale rotten! Usually its the basic cheese one, but I have had other toppings too. They clearly recycle their left over pies at the end of the night and refrigerate them, pull them out the next day, and they are beyond STALE! I made the mistake of stopping by there the other night for a slice. I hadnt even ordered when I was issued a slice of cheese pie. "thats mine"? I asked. "yes cause its fresh" so stupidly I took it. Only to be duped again by this joint! Crust was as hard as a shoe sole. I asked other patrons and theirs was clearly fresh. Buyer Beware !! read more