The restaurant was filled with various pieces of decor, drawings, and prints that fit the eclectic vibe of the space. We had to wait 20 minutes even late at night, 8:30pm, so keep that in mind. We ordered two of their pizzas, the Happy Ending (square pizza- similar to a Detroit style pizza) & the Heat of the Moment ( a thin & crispy pizza). Both were amazing and equally delicious. We thought they were bigger than we expected and decided that we would have been okay just ordering one but we had leftovers so it wasn't too bad! 10/10 recommend. read more

See all

From CDs to VHS tapes, Good Old Days delivers nostalgia before you even sit down. The pizzeria and cocktail den is a carefully curated time capsule that feels cozy and deeply evocative, blending a lived-in warmth with playful, intentional design. A stone fireplace anchors the space while low, ambient lighting, wood tables, and leather seating create an intimate, inviting atmosphere. I was excited to learn that the bar featured Misguided Spirits' Howe & Hummel vodka from New York City. Stirred, it produced a martini with a subtle sweetness and a hint of cracked pepper, served in a classic cocktail glass with an angular bowl and slender stem. The design felt timeless, keeping the drink chilled while offering a crisp, polished presentation, with the Castelvetrano olives taking center stage. When it comes to the food, I have no notes. The wings were perfectly seasoned, with meat that fell off the bone; the Bibb salad was fresh and dressed beautifully with house lemon oil; and the thin, crispy pizza lived up to its name, with bright sauce and fresh toppings. This is a spot you won't want to leave and one you'll be eager to return to, familiar, fun, and full of character. read more

See all

AMAZING cocktails, such a cool spot. The inside is a total vibe. Maybe a little hard to find since it's underneath marigolds on main. The bubble gum vodka cocktail was weird and fun, we fully enjoyed everything about our time here. Highly recommend the deep dish pizzas. The lack of smaller menu options is a little disappointing but like I said, go for the pizza and drinks! read more

Good Old Days Pizza - Menu and cocktail - Pizza Near Me - Newtown, Connecticut

Great vibe. Gigantic working fireplace. Service was good and the Gluten Free (not my choice, but my wife is allergy prone with wheat). It was up there with thicker wheat based pizzas. We split a GF pizza and it was super. Recommend highly and we'll be back soon. read more

We got two pies. Top tier ingredients: homemade red sauce, perfectly charred pepperoni, tasty roasted garlic, and whipped ricotta. Crust is what keeps this from being a 5. Crispy but closer to the taste of a pita cracker than pizza dough. No character or texture outside of a cracker crunch. Stil, if I was local this would be my regular spot. The chocolate chip cookies the size of dinner plates are exceptional. Perfect with a stout. read more

Called for pick up. Was put on hold for five minutes. Called back and put on hold for 15min until they hung up. Project Pizza is where to go! read more

Really solid pizza with a strong sense of identity. The space leans full nostalgia as the name suggests, with its VHS tapes on the walls, retro artwork, and just the right amount of kitsch to feel cool without trying too hard. The crust is spot on: golden, crackly, and chewy in all the best ways. The La La Land with vodka sauce was the clear standout. It's rich and tangy without being too heavy, and we added sausage for that savory boost, precisely what the sauce wanted. The White Lightning (ricotta, garlic, pickled peppers) was also a win, though I found myself wishing for a drizzle of honey to round it out. And the Mexican corn dip? Unreasonably good. You'll want to ask for extra "Juan-ton" chips upfront. Why do restaurants always under-deliver on dip vehicles? Justice for dips. Didn't get to try the cocktails this time, but they looked promising. Still not sure how I feel about paying extra for parm... maybe I'll splurge next time and report back. read more

See all

Traveling from PA to NH and needed to find a place to stop for an early dinner. Found this place on Yelp and was only 5 minutes off route. Wow! Everything about this place was awesome! It's located in the back/basement of a building. The devote is retro and interesting. Our waitress was super nice. I was trying to decide between two drinks and she said she would recommend one over the other, but if I didn't like it, she would have the bartender make the other. We ordered the shaved salad. She said everything is made to order, so we left out the mandarin oranges. It was super flavorful. We ordered the Detroit-style pizza, half pepperoni, half sausage. It was SO, so good. The sauce was excellent. All the ingredients were well-balanced, not too much or too little of anything. Sliced in strips, so easy to hold. Very enjoyable. My Oh, Summer cocktail was excellent! It had watermelon and cucumber, refreshing. If you're ever in Newtown, worth the stop! read more

See all

Love the feel of this place. The pizza is delicious, so were the wings. We had the French onion pie, which is just different to begin with. It was delicious. read more

They don't call it Detroit Style on the menu. But Good Old Days Pizza in Newtown makes the best CT Detroit Style I've had anyway. So many Foodies rave about Good Old Days. I've wanted their French Onion pizza since I first saw it on Instagram. It was perfection. The awesome cheesy garlic bread vibes. The crispy side crust. The sweet sugary onions. The way the mixed Gruyère and mozzarella melts and tastes. The color on the bottom. Great pizza. The space is also very cool. I ate outside. Service was friendly. They have good beer choices. All good stuff. I don't know where people had Detroit Style this good in the Old Days. But they were lucky as hell. I don't live nearby, but I'll definitely make the long drive back. Five Stars read more

See all

Another great dinner we had the gorgonzola salad, which was just amazing and the beach body pizza! Outstanding read more

Good Old Days Pizza - This is the Bikini Bod Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newtown, Connecticut

Was crushed when we had friends drive out to try the Tommy and Dill pizza but we were pleasantly surprised by the Supersize Me and Spicy Italy pies!! The spicy vodka sauce on the Spicy Italy pies was out of this world. As bummed as we were to not get what we came for, we still appreciate how Good Old Days consistently uses fresh ingredients for all of their food! read more

See all

This was a gem in Newtown! The pizzas were phenomenal - we ordered the vodka and the Bikini Bod and both were excellent! Although the thin round pies were good as well, i definitely recommend the square pies for its quality, portion size and the price. read more

We had a party of 5 and were politely advised it would be about a 45 minute wait. Friday night. No worries. We went upstairs and had a nice cocktail. The hostess rang us up after about 45 minutes and we settled up the bar tab at Marigolds and walked down to the pizza parlor below. The place is intimate, cozy with a roaring fireplace, and quite welcoming. Menu is a true pizza menu. Starters include either a Ceasar or Beet salad. The rest of the menu is a selection of square and round pies. One in the party ordered a beet salad and was pleased with it. The table ordered a square French Onion pizza with bacon added. It was so good. Cooked perfectly with a nice crunch and crisp toppings All 4 of us were properly impressed. For me, it was one of the best pies I've had in Connecticut. Dessert menu is sparse but smart. We got a mix of the chocolate chip cookie and choco tacos. The coffee was hot and robust. Our server, Tess, was engaging and attentive. A very enjoyable evening. read more

absolute knockout. i tried the french onion pizza on thin crust and crust was crackery light and the detroit style ricotta hot honey sage pizza was completely perfect. damn i love this place. best of all a cool bartender and a really welcoming interesting ambiance read more

Good Old Days Pizza - pizza A Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newtown, Connecticut

We came back two weeks and got there about thirty minutes they opened, hoping it would guarantee us a square pie! Service was great, they are a pretty chill staff, not up in your business but the right amount of attentive. The French Onion pie was everything and more, not your average pie! The sausage pie also hits the spot every time, can't go wrong. Tip: since the square pies do take quite a bit longer, share a delicious salad, it won't disappoint! read more

See all

I have been hearing about Good Old Days for a while on Yelp and reading pizza reviews. My daughter and I took the trip up there to try there pizza. The restaurant was very welcoming with famous food chefs pictures and back in day memorabilia. What I loved about the restaurant was the old VHS tapes stacked up with the movies such as back to the future. We ordered a pizza with half Pepperoni and Cheese and we also ordered the Bikini Bod with Hot Honey Sauce. The Bikini Bod was very delicious but for me it was very decadent. I could only eat about two or the slices. The flavors are great and that hot honey sauce is the bomb!!! I would definitely buy a bottle of that and put it on Fried Chicken. The half Pepperoni and Cheese pizza was delicious. Very crispy and the sauce was very flavorful. My daughter loves cannolis and wanted to order some. I really didn't care for them. The chocolate on the cannolis in my opinion was bitter but my daughter throughly enjoyed them as she ate all of them. The customer service was definitely on point. Are waitress was new but she did a really great job with customer service. read more

See all

Their plain square pizza tastes like a saucy focaccia in the best way. It's like a tasty thick bread rather than a traditional pizza. It was actually better than the Heat of the Moment we also got, which was just okay. We had it for takeout, but my wife was impressed by the vibes of the "pizza den" right underneath the fancier Marigold's restaurant (near the flagpole). Their cocktails also sounded inviting. Will order more stuff from here in the future and my wife will probably offer it to her coworkers as an after-work hangout place option. read more

WOW! This quirky basement will become your go to place. It is a smaller space so be sure to get there early if you don't want to wait. They do stay open late and turns into a fun bar scene. The bartenders and wait staff are attentive and friendly. The menu features specialized, unique pizzas, salads and cocktails. You can opt for any pizza on thick or thin crust even if it's displayed on the menu otherwise. Although it is pricey, the taste is well worth it. read more

Good Old Days Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newtown, Connecticut

See all

I had to come see what the hype was all about and it did not disappoint!! I started with the vodka square pie, not sure why but I was really craving a square pizza specifically and it was so delicious. Definitely hit the spot! I can't believe I'm just now trying it after being so close. Next time I will go back for the French onion soup one!! read more

Good Old Days Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newtown, Connecticut

Cute spot with decor of people You would most likely know & love. Our waitress was welcoming and relaxed. I appreciated our waitress did not seem bothered when I asked ice for my water. My husband loves a thin crust pizza which Good Old Days has. However, hubby let me choose tonight and I like a thicker pizza. I opted for the Plain Square Pepperoni. The cheese was ooey gooey and perfect. The pepperoni cupped and plenty of it. We'll be back to try the thin crust. Until next time Good Old Days! read more

Good Old Days Pizza - Square pizza - Plain cheese with pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Newtown, Connecticut

See all

Food was very good. Service was friendly. The outdoor space was nice and comfortable. But space was limited and as the tables filled up it was difficult not to be drawn into a group conversation. If the weather was not great the space would not be great either. The interior of the restaurant looked and felt like a pub. read more

ORIGIN: Good Old Days bravely opened in late 2020, led by chef/co-owner Matt Stanczak, who spent many years at Danbury's Stanziato's. It is one of several Newtown restaurants for which Woodbury residents, Clark and Kate Neugold, are co-owners. (The other two being The Foundry Kitchen and Marigold's on Main.) CONCEPT: Good Old Days describes itself as a "pizzeria and cocktail den". Indeed it is... unique, expertly crafted cocktails + pizzas served in the walk-in basement of an extended historic Main Street home that is adorned with references to culinary greats (Child and Bourdain), popularly broadcasted television shows (Golden Girls), and decor (1970s butterscotch stained glass chandeliers and wallpaper) of days past. EXPERIENCE: Finding or hearing about Good Old Days can feel like a special, little known discovery, one found via word of mouth or by chance upon entering the back parking lot of Marigold's on Main. While that may not be the case, the small sign, tiny restaurant size, and side basement door entrance evokes the notion that you are among a few, lucky discovers. Once inside, the feeling is amplified, with plush upholstered bar stools and a large fireplace casting warmth and light awaiting your arrival, and an inviting, interactive front and kitchen crew. The food and beverage served help characterize Good Old Days as a special find. This is not a place where good pizza and traditional cocktails are goals -- this is a place where the bartender and chef strive to offer a creative menu that leverages their expertise, insight, AND solicited guest input! Cocktails have fun names, adding to the den's vibe, such as "In the Mood" and "Planet of the Apes". Pizzas of various forms are reimagined, with the "square" pies taking inspiration from multiple traditions -- Detroit, Grandma's, Sicilian -- combining into one outstanding and unique conception. There are legendary pizza joints across the state, but here you can find French Onion pizza, topped with caramelized onions and Gruyère cheese that evokes French Onion soup, as well as Bikini Bod, in which dollops of whipped ricotta and a drizzle of hot honey add complexity in both taste and texture. TIPS: Expect live music on Friday evenings. Long wait to pick up pizza or long line to dine? Enjoy cocktails upstairs in Marigold on Main lounge area. Mocktails and gluten-free pizza are available. The menu changes in response to guest suggestions and visiting chef's contributions. This invites an element of surprise, discovery, and opportunity for engagement for guests. However, the chef will prepare items that are no longer on the menu as long as ingredients are at hand -- just need to ask. Not on menu, but knots of pizza dough and a side of tomato sauce are available. Makes for a nice bar snack. Add bacon on the French Onion square pizza -- over the top ! Toppings described on menu for round and square pies can be prepared in both forms (e.g. a round, crispy, thin crust rather than square, chewy, thick version of French Onion pizza). There is a $5 Happy Hour wine and beer special before 6 PM and ALL day Sunday. Some cocktails are available to go (* on menu). Open Mondays (as of March 2023), closed Tuesdays! read more

See all

This place has been all over the foodstagram so when the girls & I were heading down to Newtown for a lil wine day nearby, I knew exactly where to recommend for dinner! The vibe in here was awesome! Tucked in the back of another restaurant, you will almost miss it. The walls are covered with photos and knick nacks you'll feel like you're down in your neighbors basement! So cozy. We got seated right away around 4:30 on a Saturday. We definitely beat the rush because it was packed shortly after! Turns out, they do happy hour on the weekends so beer & wine was only $5! Even our server was a delight! We started with the Doughknots which aren't on the menu anymore, but from pics on Yelp, we knew about them. They come served with their famous vodka sauce that you could easily just drink itself, but more on that later. We ordered 3 of their "square pies" which are Detroit style with crispy edges. We got the French Onion, Bikini Bod and Vodka pie. ALL. WERE. AMAZING. The whole group agreed and we couldn't stop talking about how tasty they were as we devoured them. The vodka pie was the real star - that sauce is something special and it was covered in it. The house made hot honey that topped the bikini bod also made it a perfect pie. I was most excited about the french onion but it didn't stand out for me. There were some perfect bites don't get me wrong, but I think the other pies blew this out out of the water. All in all, you need to get here! Even though it's about a 40 minute drive, you can bet we'll be back. Everyone is still talking about it weeks later! read more

See all

Awesome Detroit style pizza in a quaint low-key set-up. Really enjoyed the vibe, the service and the food. Will come back!

First time here husband's work friends recommended. Got to say it was really good. I suggest you make reservations BUT they did have room at the bar. Great service. The bartender was fun to watch. Atmosphere was great they played some really good music has a movie playing just good vibes. We started with nachos they had the plain square pizza we just wanted to try. Both were very good we will be back. It's a great date night place. read more

This is by far the best pizza place anywhere in Connecticut ANYWHERE. I have never had a pizza be this constantly good anywhere else in Connecticut which is surprising coming from a place so close to New York. The service is always great lovely people, and ambience feels as if I'm in a basement with friends eating home made pizza pie. read more

This place is a hidden gem that I stumbled upon from you would not guess - a TikTok microinfluencer. Upon entry I was immediately greeted and told about the approximate wait time. There is a grand fire place right to the left of the entrance, so my mom and I stood there to warm up as we waited. Though, it was a tight squeeze due to the layout of the tables. From here, we were able to see into the kitchen and watch the chefs throw the pies into the brick oven. This was nice to pass the time. I would probably not recommend coming here in a large group, or at least would suggest calling ahead to inquire wait time. The interior is small and does not fit many tables, and it is evident that they are often busy (with good reason). The service was also good. We came in knowing what we wanted - the deep dish vodka pizza as well as the pepperoni. On the menu it warns that the wait time for the deep dish is 25 plus minutes, but it did not feel that long. The pizza was yummy, crispy, cheesy, and seasoned well. Be warned that due to the size of the space, it is a bit noisy and hard to have conversation, but overall good experience. read more

Good Old Days Pizza - Top: Plain - Add Pepperoni Bottom: Vodka - Pizza Near Me - Newtown, Connecticut

Went last night for a cocktail with the wife. Cozy place, cocktails were good. But they let this slob, most likely a regular, prop his gross sandaled feet up on the barstool next to us like he owned the place. Total turnoff. read more

Still the best pizza around! The crunch of the crust is perfection and the cheese is always a perfect melted balance or I smear the ricotta around. Ingredients are fresh and they have gotten some new menu items to try including some fun cocktails. I will say thought I typically order the same thing because it's consistently good! Nice people work there and the decor is fun and whimsical. read more

See all

Loved this place before tonight's experience. Pizza is good for Newtown but overpriced for what you're getting. If you're celebrating and excited and a person of color not the spot to go. Which makes sense for newton lol. People actually told us to "STFU" for saying "wooo". Won't be back. read more

Good Old Days Pizza - $20 rose bottle - Pizza Near Me - Newtown, Connecticut

We had always heard great things about Good Old Days and their French onion pizza specifically, but WOW. We were beyond impressed! I think it's great that they have a more limited menu focused on the pizza so that they can master what they do well. Loved the vibe - it was cozy but eclectic. Staff was great! We warmed up here after a night at the igloos at the nearby winery, so it really hit the spot. We'll be back because the French onion is in the top 5 best speciality pizzas I've had in CT! read more

See all

Pizza is amazing. Love getting the vodka and French onion square pizzas. We always have more than enough to take home after dinner. Drinks are always good and service is quick and prompt. read more

We are spoiled in Connecticut, there is so much good pizza around. Depending on what type of pizza you like you can throw a rock and hit a really good place but this restaurant is unique in my opinion. They have both thin crust round pizza, and they have Detroit style Square pizza. The vibe is 70s themed and they have a really good cocktail bar in the back that's always playing good movies on the TV. The decor is really cool and unique to this restaurant and they have live music on the weekends. The pizza is truly exceptional and offers a menu with many different flavor combinations. Our favorite is the Detroit style bikini bod, which is melted cheese, whipped ricotta, hot honey and I like to add sausage. You also can't go wrong with a thin crust pepperoni with vodka sauce. This is definitely my top three places for Pizza in Newtown. read more

See all

This place was recommended by a friend who swears that it's the best pizza in the area. We went on a Tuesday and it was closed (every Tuesday, so we've learned!) so we tried again. The pizza and drinks did not disappoint. Definitely a fun vibe with their decor and the staff was very friendly. We can't wait to go back to try the French Onion pizza! read more

Good Old Days Pizza - Mushroom Mayhem w chili oil on the side - Pizza Near Me - Newtown, Connecticut

See all

Not your typical pizza or pizza place, but they make one of the best pies you can get! My favorite is the "White Lightening". Regardless of what you like, try any of their pies - they have something unique and tasty to experience! read more

One of my favorite places to go on a weekend night for good food, friendly staff, and good vibes. Their cocktails are the best I've ever had and the bikini bod is out of this world. read more

Pizza is consistently good. Staff are friendly and the decor is retro funky. I highly recommend this small pizza restaurant near the flagpole in Newtown, CT. read more

Was disappointed in the pizza Piled both topping in the center of the pie instead of of spreading them out all over the pie. Resulted in a pizza soggy middle and you could not pick up a slice to eat. read more

Finally got to try this place as we have seen the rave reviews and lines of cars going into the parking lot. We are a pizza loving family so we were excited to see what all the hype was about! I am also a huge fan of "different" ingredient pizzas which I had heard Good Old Days excel at. We went in for a weekend lunch to eat inside as it was a hot day. Perfect time to come, not busy at all and they were easily able to accommodate our party of 6 with no issues. Because it is the basement level of the place, it is on the cooler and dimmer side which was perfect/refreshing for a warm day. They also have outdoor dining tables with a pretty set up if the weather permits. Cool inside decor, art work, and comfortable seating areas. Our waiter was friendly and attentive, great service! We ordered quite a few pizzas to sample all they had to offer so I can give a good rundown because I did take at least a bite of them all..... We started with the chopped vegetable salad with Gorgonzola. It was fabulous! I typically find it hard to rave about restaurant salads as I make pretty good ones at home but this was a real shining star. They loaded it with a variety of vegetables and took great care in how they sliced, diced, and presented them. They spiraled the beets, thinly sliced cauliflower, shaved the radishes..... I could go on and on but the main point is it was a delicious, well flavored, and a healthy dose of vegetable goodness. I would in a heartbeat order this salad again for dine in and for take out.... because honestly I don't have the time to put that detail into my vegetables. However, kudos to Good Old Days for taking the time and effort- it made the salad taste that much better and looked so darn pretty! The pizzas- oh the pizzas! Our Boys went with the plain cheese pie (shocker). We had heard the pizzas were on the smaller side so we ordered two for them but we still had a-little over a half pie leftover. Needless to say they enjoyed it and will have the rest as leftovers. We also got some of their specialty pies- the Real Slim Shady was great. Good quality goat cheese, onions, mushrooms, mozzarella and the added touch of rosemary....Thin crust and just yummy. We also tried one of their square pies which is thicker crust. It was the vodka pie with sausage. Great vodka sauce.... just a more filling piece so you can't eat much. Other pies we tried were the Heat of the Moment and White Lightening for the guys at the table wanting the spicy pies. Equally delicious and the Lightening pie was presented so nicely- they put dollops of the ricotta on top. Nice job! Nice specialty cocktail, wine, and beer list. I enjoyed the "juice cleanse" which was a rum drink with a few other ingredients. Beautifully presented and the right balance or tasting the rum and other flavors without being overpowering. Overall this place definitely deserves the props it is getting. Their pizzas are flavorful and unique. The salad and drinks are wonderful. This will easily be in our dine out/take out rotation moving forward. read more

See all