We are originally from the south side of Chicago and was thrilled when we found Hillary's. Have not had a good pizza in awhile so Saturday night was the night. Ordered a large pretzel to hold us over till the pizza came. 2 small pretzels with a small cup of cheese out of a larger tub. (Cold) Waited almost an hour for our pizza. Our waitress told us they were running behind because one of the ovens was not working. The owner told the next table they had an unusual amount of carry outs and that was the hold up. When we got our Chicago pizza, tomato sauce had no flavor, the toppings (onion, green pepper and sausage) were very sparse, and the flavor was not what it once was! read more

From Midwest Indiana and finally found the best pizza in Florida! Sausage pizza was our favorite. Definitely will be back! read more

Hillary's Chicago Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Augustine, Florida

Best Chicago style pizza I've had in a while. The people were extremely kind and even went out of their way to help us navigate the area.

NG not anywhere what I expected . Pie was not Chicago by any means. Go to Chrystal burgers. Also sucks !!! TRUTH MY PEEPS

A real Chicago deep dish pie. Cozy little place, enjoy a local Florida beer on tap during the more than worth it wait. read more

Hillary's Chicago Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Augustine, Florida

We love Chicago pizza because my husband's from there and misses his chi town pie. We found this delightful dive in St. Augustine. Our server was sweet and pleasant. The place is pretty small with few tables but the owner is from Chicago and knows Chicago pie! We ordered sausage pepperoni. The crust was dead on perfect; sauce a wee spicy but good. Would definitely return when our ChiTown bug itches! read more

Hillary's Chicago Pizza - Yumminess! - Pizza Near Me - Augustine, Florida

See all

Being from Chicago, it's hard to find great pizza. Hillary has hit it out of the park with authentic Chicago Thin Crust Pizza. Come for the Pizza, Chicago Atmosphere, and a great pint of your favorite. read more

Hillary's Chicago Pizza - Chicago Thin Crust at it best in Florida, Yes Florida!! - Pizza Near Me - Augustine, Florida

True Chicago thin crust pizza (I think people would be surprised to find out we actually prefer the thin crust to the famous deep dish we became known for). Hillary's was the high point of our St Augustine trip and we will happily drive the 2 plus hours to return. Crust was just right (nice and crispy and the required squares) . The sauce is a slightly sweeter sauce than you find in other states (and again perfect), and the sausage reminds me of my childhood pizza memories. Thank you for an amazing dinner. read more

Growing up in Chicago I know what a Chicago pizza is and this place isn't it .. I ordered 2 sausage & pepperoni pizzas thin crust. They only make a 12" by the way, which right there is a red flag. Of frozen crust usually , anyway the pizza was terrible! Crust tough. Hardly no toppings and dry and actually smelled bad! Being completely honest " I would have rather had a Dominos for 38 bucks..i would really not recommend this place to anyone for pizza The restaurant itself looks drab and very small with limited space..workers really do not have any dress code and give the impression of very unprofessional and makes one wonder if the kitchen is the Same... read more

Hillary's Chicago Pizza - Tough ,dry ,minimum topping's pizza . - Pizza Near Me - Augustine, Florida

Great tavern style pizza straight from Chicago - thin, crunchy, cracker crust. We also had a slice of the deep dish and that was good too. Hillary's actually rivals pizza places located in Chicago! read more

Love this place! Great pizza, great beer and wine selection, great owners. Hillary knows what she's doing. The meatballs!!! So good. Delicious. read more

Hillary's Chicago Pizza - Wine - Pizza Near Me - Augustine, Florida

True Chicago pizza!! Every part of our pizza was delicious! We had pan, and ooooo that crust!!!! We ordered a beef to share as an appetizer while our pizza cooked. The beef is on Turano roll! We met fellow Chicagoans and chatted about our favorite spots. The owner is awesome .. she really cares about making true Chicago food down in Florida. The restaurant is clean and plenty of seating. We WILL be back! 4 hrs drive and fun in St. Augustine .. can't get better than that! read more

We went to Hillary's based on the star reviews we saw. It was the WORST pizza we have ever eaten. We spent $90 on 3 pizzas and one hot sandwich. The pizza had absolutely no taste. The sausage sandwich tasted and looked like a hot dog, dried out and unappealing. I don't know how reviewers could give them any stars other than a 1. They must not have good pizza where they come from. read more

Have you ever had the best pizza of your LIFE??? I did tonight and funny enough I got it included in my event ticket price! Hillary's Chicago Pizza was one of the caterers for a non profit fundraiser held at Manifest Distillery and their cook was someone I knew!!! Achef I took a class with and learned how to cook some popular Filipino dishes with! She's now with Hillary's Chicago Pizza turning out the BEST PIZZA EVER!!!!!! Funny- because that's why she jumped to work for this food truck- because of how gooooooodddd it was!!! Dah-mn! It was ah-mazing. I had a deep dish pizza with a spinach cheese, mushroom and more and I was in foodie heaven! Who knew I would go to a whiskey and bourbon event and have the best tasting pizza ever. I chatted up my chef a couple of times just enthralled in how good it was! PLEASE- run, don't walk to try this pizza!!! read more

Hillary's Chicago Pizza - Omg- this slice had EVERYTHING - Pizza Near Me - Augustine, Florida

See all

Went here with my parents when they came to visit. I got a pizza with vegan cheese, my dad got a meat lovers, and my mom got a deep dish. The two regular pizzas were horrible. The crust was like a cracker and not pizza dough. The sauce wasn't special either. The deep dish took so long that we had to take it to go an hour after we ordered it. I know deep dish takes a long time to cook, but this was excessive. The service was fine, the inside was very dingy and not clean. Have not and will not return. read more

Went for the first time yesterday (9/7/24). Great find, good "deep dish" Chicago pies, more than ample amount of craft brews on tap! Met the owners, who were very nice and appreciated us dropping in. Jan at the bar was delightful as well! Give this place a try, you won't be disappointed! read more

Authentic Chicago thin crust pizza served Tavern Style (cut in squares for easy sharing). 25 beers on tap, also! Do yourself a favor and go and try it. As we say on the South Side of Chicago, "It's Da Best!" read more

Hillary's Chicago Pizza - Hillary's Thin Crust Sausage, Onions & Green Peppers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Augustine, Florida

See all

Thin crust was awesome. I'm not a deep dish guy so no evaluation there. Sausage crust and sauce were Chicago prime. read more

I highly recommend Hillary's Chicago pizza. I love Chicago deep-dish pizza And chi-town. I love the corn meal crust that they make for this one. Everything is on point and delicious. I love the Chicago decorations in the bar. I grew up around Chicago and have had lou malnatis, giordanos, pizzeria due and others. This is just as good if not better. Unique signature style. If you aren't familiar with deep-dish Chicago pizza it is more thick, has more crust, sauce and toppings. More casserole type. They also make a thin crust which is excellent as well. Thank you Hillary, Bruce and staff for your attentiveness and great service. read more

This is THE real deal Chicago pizza and right here in NE FL. Don't be in a rush, the pizza takes time, it's a small mom and pop, but so worth the wait. Best deep dish I've ever had, in fact never really liked deep dish much before having Hillary's. The owners are the best too. Great little spot with a solid beer selection. Take and bake options for those that want to enjoy a pizza at home. Hillary's is a must stop for any pizza lovers visiting St Augustine. read more

Food and service are outstanding! I've spent a lot of time in Chicago over the years, and this is by far the best I've had. In addition, they have thin crust and it's incredible! I highly recommend it. The restaurant is a small business, but has great character, and the owners and staff are so accommodating. read more

Amazing place with amazing food ! Needed some Chicago pizza since moving from Chicago area to Florida 7yrs ago and Hillary's brought it! Be sure to hit up this delicious place read more

Hillary's Chicago Pizza - Deep dish ... this is yum! - Pizza Near Me - Augustine, Florida

See all

We were very excited to go and try hillaries chicago style pizza. We knew we had to wait an hour and that was not a problem at all. Our pizza did not look anything like any of the pictures of this page. After just one slice and the pizza did not make it into the to go home box. Please give it a try, I could have gone on day the kitchen staff was off on their game. read more

Visiting Hillary's Chicago Pizza was a great experience. The pizzas really bring a piece of Chicago to St. Augustine. The pizza was fast and the best pizza I've eaten in a long time. read more

New joint with very limited hours. WONDERFUL DEEP DISH ZA!!! I'd love to add some pictures, but I'm fat and ate it all along with my smoke show wife and Todd and Matt (neither said they like Chicago deep dish but both loved it) as did sexy Lynn. A must try read more

Place is small and order takes little longer to serve But food is awesome Waitress is friendly and helpful Very good experience

Excellent Chicago Style Pizza. Formerly from Southern Illinois, we visited Chicago and Champaign often and I love Chicago style pizza. While kids were at UIUC we frequented Papa Dels in Champaign. Son currently lives in Chicago and Giordanos and Puquads are our go tos. Hillary's ranks right up there. Not a lot of tables but nice size bar with local feel to it. read more

This is an amazing business and I love the owner. The owner is very kindhearted and is open to all customers which is a plus. This business is like a second to me and I love coming here. I specifically love their pride, themed cheesecake! read more

Would recomend!! Smaller place for sure and could easily pass it, but very good. We only tried one of the deep dish and a thin crust pizza. Now I am originally from New England area, so I know good pizza. I have never in my life had deep dish pizza, but this was great! Very filling and I enjoyed every bite. Only recommendation would be if a topping is chosen to include in the deep dish, then MORE of that topping should be added - we asked for pepperoni and felt we didn't have enough pepperoni, but still very good. The deep dish pizza is smaller in size but that is because it is filled so don't let the box deceive you. Would not recommend their flat/ thin crust pizza. The SELLING POINT IS THE DEEP DISH!!! read more

Being from Chicago, and recently have moved to Florida, we have been looking for authentic Chicago deep dish pizza. Hillary's did not disappoint!!!!!! Best deep dish this side of Chicago. Will be returning again and again. Thank you Hillary's for a delicious taste of home. read more

This is the true Chicago style pizza and the homemade sauce is OUTSTANDING! I would have given this a 5 rating but my pizza came out still cold in middle. But I HIGHLY recommend -this is only their second week-so I think these kinks will work themselves out. I also hated eating this deliciousness on a paper plate. It needs and deserves real plates. Overall the pizza was worth the time, money and drive! read more

Hillary's Chicago Pizza - Half a "shared" sausage pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Augustine, Florida

The deep dish Chicago pizza was amazing. We got it partially cooked and then brought it home and finished it the rest of the way after a card game we take turns hosting. We also had a thin crust and it was awesome as well. We will definitely be back to Hillary's!!!! read more

The real deal!!!! Just like back in Chicago. Order ahead, it takes a while but worth the wait

I've tried nearly everything on the menu and I'm obsessed. This is family/woman owned business who stays true to their Chicago roots. It's a laid back atmosphere with great food, beer & service. read more

First a disclaimer. I have been fortunate enough to have enjoyed New York Pizza for a long time but I have also wanted to try Chicago deep dish pizza. 2 days ago we went to Hillary's and I was blown away. The pizza was delicious and the lunch special sure was better than 2 slices and a soda in New York. Hillary and Bruce have a great piece of Chicago here in St Augustine and Katie at the counter is a great ambassador for the brand read more

We were looking for a good Chicago style pizza and Hillary's didn't disappoint. Great place.

This is strictly a review on the pizza and not service/establishment. Anyone who says this is true chicago pizza has never been to chicago. Or maybe they have, but idk where all these 5 star reviews are coming from. My bf and I go out to eat a lot and not everything is always great but we always leave complimenting something we got. When we left, we genuinely wished we got our money back for this pizza. We got the deep dish and it tastes like that old refrigerator taste. There was like five pepperonis on it. The sauce was watery and tasted like chemicals or beer I couldn't distinguish. The crust was hard and not buttery or with any flavor. Such a bummer. Go to Chicago and get pequods, life changing. However the half off wine bottles was great and the bartender was super sweet and the atmosphere was nice! read more

On the South End of St Augustine, away from all the tourist attractions, is a this gem on the side of a strip mall. Having taken over what used to be the old Beers and Dawgs bar, they have kept the decor and kept the excellent beer list but chucked the food out and are now serving great pizza. Hillarys Chicago Pizza makes great Chicago Pizza, period. I had their MFW (Mother F$&%ing Works), which for me is a Classic Chicago Deep Dish. It was fantastic. The tomatoes were excellently flavored, the toppings and cheese superb. The crust was delicious. And let me warn you, the individual is big enough for two people. It is a meal. I saw another diner having their Chicago Thin Crust and it looked fantastic, nice thin crust, a bit blackened as it should be. They take advantage of the prior occupants beer focus by running a wide selection of tap beer from local and non local breweries. Plus wine and other drinks (I was not paying attention to see if they had a full bar). The decor is definately funky and fun, and it is very low key. The staff is really attentive, helpful and friendly. If you go, use your GPS. They are still waitiing to change the signs so just look for the little sign on the sidewalk telling you you are there. With pizza like this, it should not be long before they can get a new sign. read more

Where do you even been on reviewing this literal piece of heaven? From the crust that is just the perfect consistency and tastes like a warm southern biscuit with butter to the crushed tomato sauce on top with a little spice kick to get your palette awake! To the large amounts of delicious toppings they add to your pizza to the perfect size of slice to fill you up(but you want to go for seconds)-Hillary's pizza is beyond delicious and a deep dish pizza not to miss on your journey for the best pizza in Florida! The menu is small which honestly is perfect because their focus is on the pizza which clearly is shown! And Hillary and her husband Bruce are fun, easy going owners who we had the pleasure of having a few conversations with during our visit! It's a small restaurant/bar with not a lot of tables but has a local charm where you feel like family! The pizza does take about an hour so make sure to give yourselves plenty of time! But we had so much fun just hanging and chatting with our family and the other patrons/owners that the time passed quickly! Can't wait to come back again soon!! read more

Pizza was not that good and it was pricey for large pizza that looks more like small size. We didn't enjoy it so not going back again.