First of all, I love bragging that I was born and raised in Brooklyn, New York, so with that saying I'm pretty damn sure I know what's good pizza when I taste it..! Food 5/5 the two slices that you get for this deal is extremely tasty and delicious. The cheese is butter, flavorful, and has the perfect stretch. The crust is cooked well done and has the perfect crunch. The sauce is rich and doesn't have big chunks of tomato in it.. It's just right. Service 5/5 there were two gentlemen behind the counter and immediately took me and my son's order(I took my son here to try this out with me). they were extremely polite and friendly and since the first thing I said to them was I'm from New York I hope it tastes as good as true New York pizza, they were anxious for me to tell them what I thought about their pizza.. amazing!! I believe they have a two slice and a drink deal for $5.99 and the slice is very big Ambience 5/5 when you first approached the small building there's a small parking area that could barely fit five cars first glance but little did. I know there were other parking spaces that were on the other side of the building. The inside just like the parking lot seems very small and personal but once you step inside, there's an extension in the restaurant that's very spacious and has many tables to serve a nice personal party or even a soccer team for kids. All I can say is if you're a true pizza lover, and you truly understand the art and making pizza then I would definitely try this place out. I've seen other people's reviews and I won't bash them. I will only speak for my experience eating the pizza I'm sure they have a larger menu. All you need is patience and a special place in your heart for pizza lol.. go try this place out. It's a small sign just before the corner of Dean Road and it's on E. Colonial Dr. check them out. I know you won't be disappointed! read more

See all

I love coming here for lunch. The special is 2 slices and a drink for about $5-6. I usually order a slice of cheese pizza (well done) + a side of sauce. So yummy and filling! The slices are a really good size and have a thickness to them. The staff are always nice, patient and festive :) read more

I love NYC Pizza - Slice of cheese pizza w/ sauce on top - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

All I can say is this is the closest I've ever had to New York pizza!!! Wow delicious & the crust was perfect. I loved how crispy the wings were I love when the wings are cooked well and don't taste half cooked! If I would've known they came without sauce I would've requested I didn't know since this is the first time we order. They were so kind and professional that they even called us to let us know they didn't have cheesecake, so we picked a tiramisu and of course had to grab Zeppoli's Im not a big fan of tiramisu but my son enjoyed it. Will definitely order pizza from here again! read more

See all

To start I don't mind paying 50 + bucks for good food. I ordered 20 wings and a pizza. First the wings weren't done. Still pinkish red at the center. Then the pizza taste like cardboard no flavor at all. The only Bright spot was the owner greeted me with a warm welcome. But they need New kitchen staff who takes pride in what they present for the public to indulge. read more

This is the best pizza place I've had in so long! I recommend ordering. Employees were so kind and I have no complaints. I truly love this place read more

I love NYC Pizza - Hot wings fried hard. 2 Slice Pepperoni Pizza and Drink Special - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Disastrous experience with I Love New York Pizza. Long wait for delivery, missing toppings, and an unwanted insect in the pizza. Will never order from them again. Avoid at all costs. read more

See all

I am from New York and the pizza brings back memories and for 2 slices and a soda 6 dollars best deal ever

We ordered from here this past week and were not expecting the pizzas to be so huge. My husband read that it was supposed to be 18 inches but you know NY pizzas 18 inches are way different. Anyhow, let's just say for our family of nine we had tons of pizza left over. The kids loved it. We had their cheese, pepperoni, white sauce with sausage & bacon pizzas. My hubby also ordered their Greek salad. It was all very satisfying. read more

See all

Friendly people, clean place. Crust was thin and crispy; sauce was very light and had no discernable flavor. Cheese was decent quality; overall it was better than chuck e cheese but I'd prefer a frozen pizza to this. read more

Definitely won't disappoint you and the pizza is very good. Awesome communication and definitely never leave anything out always making sure your satisfied read more

It's pretty good, a step above little cesars or hungry howie's and the slices are big, generous amounts of cheese and the crust itself was excellent. They're located where the old lechonera latina use to be so you already know parking will probably be an issue. They deliver but I have heard that delivery time is never under 45 min whereas if you pick up, you only wait about 15 minutes. They offer other things like Jamaican patties, wings, garlic knots and even gyros, but since I didn't see a spit with rotating gyro meat, it's a pretty safe bet that it's a frozen product. Apparently the jamaican patties are house made though and they're popullar so I'll have to try that at some point. It was a bit off putting however that the guy holding up the sign advertising their XXL pepperoni pizza for 10.99 was cursing worse than a sailor, for a minute I thought it was at me as I was driving up because he was extremely loud, shouting, and when I stepped out of the car I noticed he was arguing over the phone. I still wont stop me from returning but being greeted by a slew of curse words isn't exactly welcoming in my mind. I may do an update once I try other things on their menu. read more

I love NYC Pizza - Their xxl pizza 10.99 - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

I came i on 3:14 day. Pi day . Got me two slices of pie & a drink for $5.99. I sad down and was able to enjoy my lunch break in peace . It's a must . And the pizza is sooo Yummy read more

Ordered today via Uber Eats. Didn't know anything about this place so I ordered an XX pizza. Driver delivered in less than 25 minutes. The pizza was pepperoni and yes it tasted like a New York pizza. I've been craving something greasy for a long time and I found my itch. This was definitely a good pizza and one of the closest to a NY pizza in Orlando. Thanks for the amazing pizza. It's simple and delicious. read more

We ordered today from this spot and got 10 wings with teriyaki sauce, XXL cheese pizza, and garlic knots. The price was very reasonable for really good food. Everything was fresh and delicious. I've read other reviews about the customer service not being great, but we had really good service and I most definitely will be coming back. read more

I typically prefer to go to non franchise restaurants to get authentic flavor in my food. This place is down the street from my job and anytime I want pizza, I go straight here. It's a small little place in a very tight parking lot but I make it work when I go pick up my order. I don't eat bacon so I don't typically put a lot on my pizza, so I normally just order pizza, while my coworkers eats pepperoni. I only add pepper flakes and Parmesan cheese to the pizza and It's very delicious! I also have ordered the wings a few times and they were decent sized with their hot sauce and it was pretty good. The wait time is usually accurate when I call the order in so I do not stress it. I crave this pizza frequently so I will definitely be here more often read more

I got delivery and the food tasted great! I have no idea what the place looks like but I can say for sure the food tastes good. We got the New York style and the supreme pizza. Yum! read more

Paid $40 for maybe $25 worth of food if it was even any good. Don't waste your time or money. read more

See all

Recently checked in to a hotel nearby and had to find a place to order some great food. Upon surfing my Uber Eats suggestions, I found I Love NY Pizza and decided to give it a shot. My boyfriend and I ordered a pepperoni pizza, a meat lovers pizza, an order of normal fries and deluxe fries, and some garlic knots. To be honest when the food arrived and when we ordered, we were just expecting the typical pizza place take out type food: where everything is kinda soggy and just "okay" due to it being take out. But seriously, EVERYTHING IS DELICIOUS!! The fries weren't even soggy! Starting with the garlic knots, we were a bit upset we only got three but they were so yummy! Next we went to the fries and seriously, they were crispy and hot! They have those crinkle fries that can be done horribly, but their fries are so GOOD. I love myself some crispy fries and these are some five star fries. Even 30 minutes after the food arrived while I am typing this they have the same amount of CRISP. The deluxe fries are not something I usually enjoy, but my boyfriend LOVES loafed fries and wanted to try them. He was hesitant, because crinkle fries are his least favorite, but the amount of cheese, ranch, and bacon loves up to the name "LOADED". He says they are delicious and the container they came in is completely empty because they were so good. AGAIN, I emphasize that even the loaded fries were NOT soggy, and we got it DELIVERED!! Amazing!! Now to the pizzas. The meat lovers pizza was for my boyfriend. He gives the pizza five stars as well!! My normal pepperoni pizza was just how I like it!! A nice not too greasy but just the perfect amount of good n greasy pizza! The crust was thinner and I live a pizza with not too much sauce. The pepperonis on this pizza are to die for!! And the cheese is top notch as well!! Kind of wish the crust was a bit thicker on the outside, but love the thinner crust on the topping portion over all!! Definitely a five star pizza for me!! Over all this is the perfect pizza place for takeout! I 100% reccomend it, especially during these quarantine times. Definitely check it out!! And thank you I Love NY Pizza for a great dinner! read more

See all

Pizza was great, I got the lunch special which was 2 slices and a drink. Workers are very nice, and the pizza had a northern vibe. Garlic knots were good too! Recommend 10/10. read more

Average pizza. Good prices, so good for big parties or get togethers. I don't have much to say since the service is not necessarily bad or good for that matter. The pizza is good but not great. Probably will return if I need pizza. read more

Better pizza better prices good food exelen attencion good wings oh 2 slice pepperoni pizza &dink $4.99 exelent we Delivery free slice for ladies affter 11:pm good good :) read more

I love NYC Pizza - Zeppoli's - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

My roommate and I ordered delivery from here through the beyond menu app. The delivery took 2 hours, and they called us twice, both calls 45 mins apart, because they needed more information about our order. They were unapologetic. I ordered an Italian sub and it was serious pathetic. Would not order from here again. read more

I love NYC Pizza - "Italian" sub - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Just arrived in town for the snowbird season, food looked good on line, ordered a medium Calzone (meat lovers), and was super good and will definitely be a lot for future orders there!! read more

Their business card has I love NY Pizza, another restaurant that was in Orlando for a few years. So looks like a new name. Anyway its the seedy part of fifty across the street from the park in an auto repair strip mall. Not the nicest building, and the surrounding area is questionable. When you walk in they have some specials on real sized pizzas, like an 18 inch, up to 28 inches gotta love that. The prices are good as well. $10.99-11.99 for 18 inch one topping. The pizza I would say is average, the crust is a little thinner then I like and had a different texture then I am used to, but good enough. Calzone had no taste but the pizza sauce that comes with it was very good. Now the bad the interior is run down so dont eat in, the service was pretty slow as well. I dont think they could handle a rush even takeout. The atmosphere is run down, dingy and the customers appeared to be low income, not so friendly folks.Kind of reminded me of some parts of NY. The people running the place were nice enough, I dont live near it and would rather go to another shop in the future, just gave it a try because it was new. read more

Your review helps others learn about great local businesses. We placed an online delivery order to I Love NYC Pizza through the OrderUp app. After waiting for over an hour, we finally called them but were told that they had no record of our order. We tried to explain the situation to the man on the phone but he was pretty rude and told us we had to talk to someone else about it. I even tried to give him the order number from my confirmation email, but he wouldn't even let me finish speaking. I'm currently working with OrderUp to get a refund, but I'm posting this to let other people know about the issue. This establishment may have good food, but I definitely recommend calling to make the order, instead of ordering online. I'm giving 1 star based on poor customer service. read more

Worst food I ever ordered I through a large pizza away it was so greasy it wasn't edible.

I love the pizza here. But just the other day I decided to try a special they have. An extra extra large pizza with 2 toppings 18 wings 6 garlic knots and a 2 liter drink. Not only was it super affordable less then $30 for all of that. But it was absolutely the best pizza wings and garlic knots i have ever had in my life!!! And that is not an exaggeration. If you have never tried the food here I highly recommend it. You will not be disappointed. read more

I love NYC Pizza - The is a picture of the crispy yet very juicy wings I had. Aren't they mouthwatering!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Been here a few times, haven't had a bad experience. I would recomend this place too everybody who likes some good pizza. The staff is great people with good vibes will be back next time I want some delicious pizza. read more

I love NYC Pizza - Pepperoni pizza with garlic knots. - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Do not bother going there in person. I was almost turned off by my first experience. They sometimes are out of things too which can be pretty damn annoying. However, I give them the four star rating for their gyros and Philly cheesesteaks. I cannot comment on their pizza as I do not like pizza much in general these days. (Ordered way too many where they're all starting to taste the same to me. Grad school lol) The gyro meat is thick and juicy with a good sear. Not that skimpy boxed thin sliced junk. And for me, their tzatziki sauce is probably oneo of f the best in the area. Mediterranean Gyros near by is too minty, and Hallal Gyros further down on Colonial is too oily. And 5.99 is not a bad price. The odd kicker is, the Philly cheesesteak. I like philly's and I like them on philly bread, toasted with good seasoned steak and melted whiz or white american depending on my preference that day. They don't have either of those cheese, or at least that's not what comes with it. To be honest, it's more of a steak and cheese hoagie as it comes with lettuce tomato onion and mayo, but I'm not one to be a label whore. Either way, my "Philly"was both tasty, well seasoned but not overpoweringly so, and the cheese I'm guessing is what they top their pizzas with, mozzarella. ((Weird. But worked)) I gave 4 stars for these two sandwiches. 1 star off for their parking at the restaurant and delivery times. read more

Delivery was on time and prices are good but I really wouldn't reccomend the pizza or delivery. Once I got my food , it was cold and didnt taste good . read more

The service has gone from great to poor in a flash, not sure if business was sold but they don't ever have what you want from a simple slice to a specialty pizza that was clearly posted on a menu left at my door just 2 days prior. Was great pizza but willing to take my business elsewhere, two strikes was enough for me to never give them my business again read more

I'd give the pizza a 4.2 out of 10, which guy wouldn't give me a simple cup of water after ordering food from that business! I told the guy that it's unheard of to not receive a free cup (could be a Dixie cup for all I care) of water after purchasing from that restaurant. Since the inside of the "restaurant" is 5 feet big and fits 1 and a half people, I'm now forced to scarf down a few slices of mediocre pizza in my car with some warm water I left in my car from 2 days ago. Probably and hopefully my first and last yelp post of all time, let's make it count read more

Ordered online and they said 45-60 mins, it came in maybe 25!! Cannoli was delicious! Pizza was good, as a native New Yorker I am hard to please but I would order again. The thing that confused me was I ordered a baked ziti and it wasn't ziti noodles but spaghetti, the taste was still okay though! Great garlic knots. Will order from there again. read more

See all

EDIT: I am editing this review because my wife and I ordered from here again. She got 10 BBQ wings, I got 20 Teriyaki - The order took 75 minutes. Read that again... an order for 30 wings took over an hour and ten minutes. Her BBQ wings? Amazing. Delicious. My Teriyaki wings? Overcooked with the sauce sitting in a pool at the bottom of the box. Here's the icing on the cake: My wife specifically noted in the comment section "last time we were shorted 3 wings and the wings were overcooked". This time? Yea, my 20 wings were really 19. And they were overcooked. Think about it.. think about every order of wings they sent out where they skimped 1 wing off of each individual order of 10... think about how much that could save the owner over time. Now, imagine that practice applied to everything else they do. My old review was 4 stars, after this crap, AGAIN with the missing wings, and the 75 minute delivery time... me thinks not. Sorry. Such a shame too, because the wings are actually decent. OLD REVIEW: My wife and I both came home after working double shifts with 0 energy to cook. We called and ordered 3 x 10 wings. Unfortunately each box of wings were missing 1 wing each and I was really pissed. I called up and thundered off at the owner who agreed to send out a new box. They sent 10 piping hot fresh wings with all 3 sauces from the original order. The wings were delicious, fresh, and the garlic parm seasoning was ridiculously good. I definitely took my long day out on the owner for a small mistake, but the customer service and quality more than made up for an order 3 wings short. read more

I absolutely love this pizza!!!!!!!!!!! Every time I call I get great customer service. Sometimes they are super busy but they get my order right every time and never late. There garlic butter and bbq mixed wings are amazing as well. Try them out. read more

my boyfriend and i ordered a cheese pizza and galric knots, VERY simple order. 2 hours pass. I was in contact with the store. they gave no explanation of where their driver was or why they were taking so long. They tell us we can drive ALL THE WAY to their location 2 HOURS after we ordered to pick up our order. We were not refunded the delivery charge. 5 hours after we placed the order, i get a call from the driver saying they cant get into my apartment complex because its actually a rehab center and its closed? there is no rehab center near my complex. i cannot even begin to explain what happened here. the food wasnt even that good. This happened a while ago, and it took me some time to find this restaurant on yelp because they had gotten SO MANY bad reviews that they completely renamed their restaurant. to say that this restaurant, their owners, and their employees are incompetent is a wild understatement. read more

Pizza taste like regular chain restaurant pizza...Hungry Howies to be exact lol Save your money! This is NOT NY style pizza. My order was missing the garlic knots I called and called no answer, and voice mail full. Needless to say I will never order from this place again. read more

I grew up with I Love NY pizza in Troy, NY and this is not related. Tastes the same as every other fast food pizza chain like preservatives and cardboard with fake cheese. Thanks for helping me stay on my Paleo diet. read more

So I probably should just post with pictures of food but unfortunately me and my kids where starving since I burnt dinner on the grill so we decided on pizza I typically go for papa John's or pizzahut but omg I was amaze by their cheese pizza it not so greasy but just right and the cheese is so melted that omg it was just a party in my tummy and as well for my kids we had a order of hot wing and it wasnt so spicy but it taste good just wish I could gotten some blue cheese with it and garlic roll I couldn't taste their not my thing but my husband and kids enjoy them plus with the cold soda made it just right read more

Ordered using Slice App. Took 75 minutes to be delivered and tasted like cafeteria food. There is no resemblance to New York style pizza. I got a pepperoni pizza, garlic knots and garlic wings. Garlic knots tasted stale and dry with mild to no flavor. Garlic wings were cooked well but again zero to no flavor. Overall not a good taste and too long of a wait. read more