The best pizza in the treasure valley. The pizza is always cooked to perfection. It's never soft or soggy. I hope they come to Middleton one day. read more

The gentleman was very polite that delivered the pizza delivery was hot and made good time. I appreciate having good food and great service. Thank you!!! read more

This might be our new go-to delivery place. Super friendly, service has been quick, and the pizza is always fresh, tasty and the price point is great too. We also love the pizza twists, and feel like they are a must try if you are ordering. We haven't gone to the location, so can't speak on the ambiance, but we would definitely go check them out in person just based on the quality of their delivery. It's not the best pizza we have ever had, but it's good and a great option for a game night or movie night with the teens for sure. read more

Great local pizza spot! The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and loaded with toppings. The crust had a nice texture, and everything tasted like it was made with quality ingredients. The staff was friendly, and the service was quick. Definitely a place I'd come back to when I'm craving pizza. Highly recommend! read more

See all

Food, just ok. The salad bar was a mess. Friday night, 5 o'clock, they should have that set up and ready for the crowd. The place was empty, and there was probably 15 people back in the kitchen. They could barely all squeeze in there I got a personal Pepperoni pizza with a salad bar and a drink and the salad bar was my first experience. They didn't have all of the items, it was a mess in that food was all mixed together. The salad lettuce had a lot of brown pieces I had to pick out. I was able to scrounge a decent salad out of it, but it took some work. Thankfully, they had beets and my macaroni salad so I was good. My pizza came a good while after. Flavor was good, but the edges were burnt. Overall, the pizza was OK. The floors and tables were very clean. Well maintained. The fountain area was clean and all stocked up. The service was nice. They were very helpful. Pleasant people greeting you and taking your order. I would not return to this location, nor would I recommend it. It was adequate for the moment. read more

This is pretty much the only pizza place I get pizza from and it's always great! I typically call for pick and the employees that take my order are wonderful. (Might need to fix the poor call connection) read more

Great pizza, friendly people and clean restaurant and nice atmosphere. Prices were very reasonable with fresh ingredients.

Went in to sit down dine tonight vs just ordering take out. I was very surprised at the limited options for the salad bar and how old everything looked. We had to pick through stuff, because everything seemed like it's just been sitting there all day. The pizza was okay and can't really comment on the service, because you don't really receive any except when ordering upfront. read more

We ordered a Sun Valley Delight (vegetarian), a mushroom and olive pizza, and an Idaho Supreme. The veggie was very good! A nice garlic sauce covered in tons of veggies and fresh tomatoes. The other pizzas were enjoyed by the rest of the family with no complaints. The service was good, the staff seem to be mostly teenagers but all of them were working hard and making sure the tables got cleaned and wiped off as soon as customers left. The restaurant was big, with lots of seating and space for larger groups. I'm from out of town but definitely would go again. read more

Idaho Pizza Company - Sun Valley Delight Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

We just tried this place because I haven't found a decent pizza place in my city. We have been a few times now and the pizza is great! The sauce, the garlic bread was awesome! The only negative is that they could update a bit on the inside. Also clean the sidewalk outside the front door. It was so dirty and I had to be careful not to step into whatever was on the ground. Other than that, the food and quality were great! This will be my go to pizza stop! read more

Arrived into town, a couple hours before a scheduled oil change...hungry and saw this joint. Masks are still required (as of 5-8-2021) and tables spread our, quite a bit. TBH I am not a pizza person at all, I usually dispise it. This place was delicious. I ordered a personal 2 topping and my little girl had a personal one topping. We also ordered the twist dessert. We both really good our meal. For a non pizza fan, this was so freaking good. Friendly employees. By the pictures mounted on the walls of this business, they are a proud military establishment. Which was beautiful to see. I'd definitely eat here again. Pizza was freshly made and tasted amazing. read more

Idaho Pizza Company - Personal one topping pizza for my little gamer. - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

See all

So good there are a lot of pizza places to visit around here but this one is so good. Quality pizza fast service and welcoming to families. The lunch buffet is fresh and spot on. read more

The Idaho special, no onions, was done on original crystal which was not too thick an made eating by hand easy, since the delivery person forgot plates, forks and knives and took 15 min. I did not see the restaurant, so I cannot comment on the ambiance. read more

Idaho pizza company is round table pizza for a better price. If you're familiar with round table, it's a thinner style crust, quality ingredients, and a thin flavorful sauce. They run a monthly special that changes, currently it's a large 2 topping pizza and 3 garlic/cheese twists for $20. Great, quality pizza, we love the twists too. Great ranch!! Thin and flavorful, perfect for dipping. They also have a very reasonable lunch buffet, $8.50 for a drink and pizza, $9.50 includes the salad bar. read more

See all

Don't order for pick up and expect on time service. At Idaho Pizza Company, "be ready in 15 mins is actually 60 mins". Who would have thunk it? And it's not a great day at the Idaho Pizza Company. read more

Always great food. I love the salad bar. The lunch specials are great. They also have party rooms if you need a place for a gathering with a pretty reasonable minimum amount of food that you have to buy to get the whole room! I did my daughter's baby shower at one of the Idaho pizzas and it was a hit read more

Best bang for buck and the pizza is just as great or better than the popular pizza chain restaurants. I have been to the Boise, Meridian, and Caldwell ones, and their customer service at all three were exceptional. The staff are very attentive and even if it is during the lunch buffet or dinner, they engage with customers and try to provide the best dining experience possible. read more

Wow; just wow! I called in to make a delivery request and got a small sawtooth special and a medium Idaho supreme. The pizzas were great and so delicious! They even threw in a few candies with the order which was so sweet. I never had a pizza place do that for me before. Delivery was smooth and Matt (the delivery person) was able to find my place despite it being in a new complex. I will be ordering again in the future. Thank you for the local pizza. I loved it! As always, if you have the means to do so, please tip the driver if you're ordering with delivery. Or if you go in person to order and/or pick up, please don't forget to tip as well. read more

See all

Idaho Pizza Company is a longstanding local Pizza chain, and I think was actually the first Pizza I ever had in Idaho, so I have a soft spot for the place. I know some folks reviewing the place had some inconsistent experiences, but they've always been great when I've come to visit. The pizza is a traditional thick crust pizza, definitely a cut above Pizza Hut or Dominos, but just slightly more expensive, so the value for the money here is fantastic in my opinion. They also kind of sit between some of the other pizza places in the area, having mostly traditional pizzas, but a few of their own unique creations. The service in this restaurant is also very good. The servers are friendly and efficient and we like the bartender. However, the seating arrangements are kind of weird. For example, if you mostly just want to get a drink at the bar and a quick bite, the seats aren't all that comfortable and the bar seemed very narrow. Some of the booths are a little cramped or strangely high up (i.e., watch that first step exiting some of the booths). In general, however, the restaurant is very clean and they seem to keep the place in good condition. Overall, it has what I like to see in a restaurant, a locally owned, friendly clean place with good food and good value for the money. read more

Great spot to hang out for family, friends or team parties ... the atmosphere is open, warm and inviting ... an old time pizza spot. All their pizza's are spot on, portion, ingredients and combinations were perfect. We added the salad bar which offered a great variety of side items as well ... our only complaint here is they didn't make it easy to get a new plate for round two. Nice selection of cold beer that was reasonably priced. The place was extremely busy the night we were there and they seemed under staffed and the staff that was there seemed a bit frazzled. The cashier who took our order was also the person handling call in orders and pickup, playing bartender and cleaning tables ... all with people still lining up to place orders ... this may account for why the staff was a little less than friendly this night. We will definitely be back though for great food and drinks!! read more

Idaho Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

Terrible service. They couldn't even give extra of what we asked even when we specifically asked over the phone when ordering. Then wanted to charge even extra. Very rude. Do not recommend read more

They never fail to create high quality pizza. I always recommend the buffet with salad bar. Fresh ingredients. Never leaves you wanting. read more

Idaho Pizza Company - No words need. Full mouth, full tummy, and full heart. - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

If we could give more than 5 stars we would. We are traveling and staying in caldwell overnight. Found the Idaho Pizza Company on yelp and because they deliver we called them. Excellent service and pizza. The wings and breadsticks are also great. Delivery was not just on time but early. Exceeded our expectations and recommend them. read more

We were visiting extended family in Boise, and got two large pizzas and large salad. Excellent quality! Probably twice as much dressing as we needed but who's complaining. The everything/works, I forget the name was fantastic. Enjoy! read more

This was quality pizza. Family oriented environment and good old fashioned pizza restaurant.

Good quality. Quaint atmosphere. Decent prices. Good for families. Service is okay, usually run by high school/college kids.

First and only time I went here I was verbally and physically assaulted (employee shoved the pizza at me) by the low brain cell excuse of an employee. Complained to the manager and they just shrugged their shoulders like it was no big. The pizza is only passible at best and was not the best I've ever had. Thoroughly unimpressed. read more

We've ordered pizza here several times during our visit to Caldwell. The pizza is good and the staff was friendly and accommodating. Their monthly specials seem like a good value. read more

I was in Idaho for business coming from Texas and decided to try this place out. The best pizza I've ever had! I can't wait to be back in the area so I can have it again read more

We ordered the Idaho supreme. Pizza sauce was good, vegetables were the freshest we've had on a pizza. The only reason they didnt hwt 5 stars was the sauce could have used more flavor. Garlic cheese bread was perfect . Staff was friendly and atmosphere reminded me of how pizza parlors used to be. read more

Idaho Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

Service sucked pizza was terrible Maybee to was because they were very Bussy. But i would not go back read more

Waited 70 minutes for a pizza the other day, when I asked for updates they first said they forgot to put it in the oven, then said they forgot what I ordered. In the end I got a half hearted apology from a high school student. Very strange. read more

totally screwed our baseball team pizza part! T bag or Tyler or Travis whatever his name said they couldn't take the order during the happy hour special time frame, because there was only 30 minutes left or it was 4:30 ... well lost our business and we had been buying for the teams for years.. hello Chicago connection! it's better anyway... thanks for nothing read more

Pizza was good but the girl up front forgot to tell the cooks my order so it took half an hour before I got my food

Love the gluten free options and the salad bar....one of my favorite places to eat! Fast and friendly service, quality food!

Great pizza! The garlic bread twists are amazing. Fresh ingredients. Best pizza I have found in the area.

This is an average pizza but still enjoyed it. We got the vegetarian. I Liked the salad bar also.

Great pizza and friendly staff! Love their pizza twists and homemade ranch! So yummy. Amazing salad bar with full customizable toppings. I will admit my salads end up being more toppings than salad lol. Love this family owned place! A hidden gem of Caldwell for sure! read more

I have never had a negative experience with Idaho Pizza and have been there countless times over the years. I love going on Wednesday for double punch day! Their variety and quality are both excellent. read more

It's pretty solid pizza at a great price and a great buffet. It's also well ran and usually you get your pizza your choice pretty quickly.