Island Fish

3.8 (1.8k reviews)

ModerateSeafood, Tiki Bars, Breakfast & Brunch

Open • 8:00 am - 10:00 pm

Updated over 3 months ago

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Island Fish Photos

Island Fish - Super good oyster - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Island Fish - Women's restroom decor - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Island Fish - Blackened grouper with seasoned rice and veggies. - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

+2285

Island Fish - Dining room - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Business Info

Health Information

View Health Score

Island Fish Popular Dishes

44 Photos156 Reviews

27 Photos89 Reviews

24 Photos65 Reviews

Island Fish menu photos

See all

ISLAND FISH ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

Inside

186 Photos

Outside

511 Photos

Casual

Moderate noise

Happy hour specials

Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Island Fish

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos

Amanda S.

This was our second time dining at Island Fish for dinner and we had a great meal! We arrived on the earlier side (4:45) with two toddlers and were able to be seated right away- by the water! There are kids menus with crayons which is always a plus. My husband had a key lime coloda beverage which was very refreshing. I have never had an oyster and have been wanting to try one and had one for a starter! Not knowing what to expect- it was fine? But I don't know what the hype is about. For entrees my husband had the lobster roll which he reported to be very good and I had the blackened mahi on a caesar. The mahi was very good but the salad had a little too much dressing for me- I hate a soggy lettuce leaf. My son had the popcorn shrimp kids meal & loved it! It's a great place for dinner that has a nice coastal atmosphere but isn't too fussy. Would love to go back on another visit to Marathon!

Whether you want breakfast, lunch or dinner this place is always awesome! Service is great and the food is fresh and delicious. Highly recommended for the whole family.

Laura D.

Service was fast and attentive but food disappointing. Gulf oysters were fine. Grilled grouper had zero flavor and the salad that came with it had gross wilted pieces. The ahi salad was generous but the fish also was tasteless and I wish I had asked them to leave the blue cheese off - weird, yuck. They have a gf "guide" to their menu if you ask for it but it just involves omitting things, so nothing to be excited about. The outdoor seating of the location for enjoying a sunset is nice. The waitress Tara seemed unable to deal with our feedback, other than offer a substitute salad, and just laughed nervously when we said she might want to tell the manager the meal lacked flavor. She sent her trainee Shay solo to us to deal with the final payment.

Ericka G.

Before hitting the beach we needed a spot for breakfast. Low and behold we spot this packed place. Located on the water. Pull up by land,sea, or helicopter as we saw. Views are all of the ocean marina. Nice breeze coming in and the place is huge so choose your spot, the views will still be there. We looked at the menu and with so many options we decided to go a la carte and make our own. Bestie had eggs, bacon, hash browns and toast. I had black coffee with jalapeno corned beef hash, poached eggs and dry rye toast. Everything was cooked perfectly, bacon and hash browns were crispy, eggs poppable, coffee hot- no complaints. Also good to know they bake their bread in house so try the toast or French toast or a tasty sandwich or burger. You can't go wrong with anything on the menu. Enjoy your meal and take on the day!

Mike M.

This place was incredible! The view was amazing and we got to sit on the docks. The fish were out in schools and we saw a manatee! The food was delicious! We had the shrimp tacos, captains dinner, clam linguine, and the grilled mahi. Everything was fresh and pretty quick. The service was good. They were a little busy, so seating was a bit delayed but overall a great experience! 10/10

Ray V.

While out and about exploring the Keys, we stayed at a local resort on Marathon. We asked our barkeep for recommendations, and he suggested Island Fish Company. My wife and I are celebrating our 30th Anniversary, and we absolutely love exploring places and trying local cuisines. We thoroughly enjoyed our meal and drinks. First and foremost, it's hard to beat the Clam Chowders where I'm from, and I always have to sample others for validation. Admittedly, it's pretty damn tasty and I'd easily shell out some clams for this hearty cup of Chowda! After that, I went for the classic Surf n Turf with steak and Lobsta! Absolutely perfect. The steak was prepared how I requested it, and that buttery scrumptious chunk of crustacean tenderness hit the spot! We had excellent service, the place was hopping busy, and our views around the restaurant were breathtaking. Thank you for an outstanding visit and definitely recommend Island Fish! As always, Enjoy & Happy Eating!

Pic nic tables, nice view , someone's filleting fresh fish. The Conch ceviche mostly peppers. ran out of oysters but I'll return

Vicky S.

Pic nic tables, nice view , and I could see someone in the kitchen filleting the fresh fish. The Conch ceviche was mostly peppers, and they ran out of oysters but I'll come back

Martha V.

Oh my!! The food was delicious. My hubby and I bought the mango crab cakes and shrimp & lobster egg rolls. I did NOT want to share the Shrimp & Lobster egg rolls - they are a wonder! We ordered to go and wish we had more time to stay and eat! Gift shop had adorable items! What a happy stop!

Jeffrey G.

My wife and I stopped here for lunch after arriving in yhe Keys. We were seated immediately and our waitress (Emmalee) came right over to take our drink orders and answer questions. I had questions about the oysters since i had never tried them and she explained how to eat them and how to order. The oysters were very good and the sauce was also. For an entrée I had the fish tacos and they were big and really good with the cod fish. I also had the keylime pie, it was very dense and not very good. Overall we had a great experience and meal. Definitely will eat there again.

Marlys J.

The service was okay. Our server wasn't rude, but he also didn't seem very friendly or welcoming until he dropped off the check. It felt like the bare minimum rather than warm or attentive service. The outdoor seating by the water was the highlight of the visit. It was relaxing and made for a nice atmosphere. This definitely seems like more of a place to grab a drink and hang out than a spot for a great meal. The bathrooms are also very nice and spacious. For food, we started with the key lime baked oysters. They had potential but were smothered with too much cheese, which really overpowered the dish. I ordered the seafood lovers pasta and unfortunately it was a huge miss. It was honestly the worst pasta I've ever had. The noodles tasted bland and greasy, almost like they were coated in movie theater butter. I couldn't eat more than one bite and instantly regretted ordering it. My husband took over my dish, he didn't like it either but said it was edible. He ordered the coconut fried lobster sandwich, which was the best thing we tried. It was flaky, flavorful, and cooked well. For dessert, we shared the deep fried key lime pie. It was tasty, though I discovered I prefer the traditional version, but it was still fun to try something different. Overall, the setting was nice, but the food was very hit or miss and the service didn't stand out. I wouldn't plan to stop here for a meal next time I'm in the area but maybe would try again for some drinks at the bar.

Jennifer J.

We had both breakfast and dinner here and both were good. The breakfast is the clear winner in that area. And the seating over the water makes it even better. The service can be a little slow, but everyone was friendly. The seafood eggrolls were a guilty pleasure win for all of us.

Lisa H.

This was a fun place to stop on our way south to Key West. We were on a hunt for lobster rolls since it was the start of mini lobster season. We had a warm lobster roll with butter in mind vs cold with mayo. i looked up this location before we arrived and was happy to find they were serving our dish. The parking was very easy in a large lot but seemed to be filling up fast. The atmosphere was "Keys inviting"with a large tiki hut covering the indoors, awnings and boats in the marina. It was a hot day with fans blowing cooler air above our table so it was pleasant enough. I noticed the gift shop, the very long bar and a good crowd of small and large families enjoying the last weeks of summer vacation. Our server brought drinks right away and the food came out fairly quickly. The lobster and drawn butter were seasoned which took away from the pure lobster and butter event..but it was very enjoyable and we had our fix. Price was MP and turned out to be higher than the average lobster roll at $36 each but as i said we were hungry, on vacation and committed to our mission. I noticed other reviewers were mentioning the higher price as well. I did not take the time to look over the menu so i am not sure of the prices in general. I would probably stop here again on a trip to the Keys and try another dish. After completing our mission we continued south to enjoy the rest of our day in Key West.

Carolyn J.

There weren't many places nearby to eat near our hotel, so we just randomly chose this place for dinner. The outside was deceptive - inside was HUGE! There were multiple rooms including a bar with a live band. And it was on the water which was cool, but it was hard to see the water because of the covers on the windows. Even though there were many seats we still waited 30ish minutes to be seated. Our server was super sweet. I got the mahi with mango salsa and black beans. I didn't eat much of it as it was .. wet? A very strange taste. The next day I had a little belly upset. Not sure if it was related. I ended up giving my mahi to the local hotel cat. And she loved it. haha This seems like a great place for locals, have some drinks and watch some bands play. My friends liked their food and didn't get sick, so.. ‍

See all

April L.

5 years ago

We enjoyed a great breakfast here. Our server was even better than our food. He was so fun and cheerful. It was quite an experience! We highly recommend eating here. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Vilia K.

5 years ago

The view and location was great. The food was a mixed review. The Peel n eat shrimp was good , but the pan seared hogfish had no flavor. Also the salad was a bit dry and old tasting. read more

Business owner information

Sandi A.

Thank you for your feedback, we do appreciate it and would like to…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nancy K.

6 years ago

Great place. Friendly staff. Draft beers cheapest anywhere in Keys!! Had Sunday Mexican special. So much food .. shared with husband. Very good. Can watch sunset from here or rent a boat. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Vida H.

9 years ago

Waitresses View Amazing Location Perfect Food? Meh Just okay It's Breakfast but not Good Breakfast read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jade M.

541

7 years ago

We are south Floridians and frequent the Keys. We were turned away because they don't allow dogs. Pretty disappointing considering we are foodies and the check (and tip) would have been substantial. You should change your pet policy or allow for dockside seating to accommodate those of us who travel with our pets. Food for thought. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lynh N.

134

247

16 years ago

This place is right on the water. You can dock your boat in the back. Or arrive via helicopter. The heliport is in the parking lot. We started off with the conch fritters..very good. Next I had the Gulf Oysters. They were not that good but I wanted to try oysters from the gulf. Entree was the grilled mahi sandwich which was just okay. For dessert, we got the key lime pie. Very good and very sweet! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Phil P.

14 years ago

Great breakfast on the water on out return from Key West. The service from our waitress, who originally hailed from Germany was amazing as well. We even got to witness a manatee swim by. read more

Island Fish - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Amanda S.

142

14 years ago

Nice bay view for the sunset. We were told we were getting fresh fish and seafood but it tasted like it was frozen. Tiny shrimp and scallops so skip the Seafood wrap. The Mahi sandwich was a good size but not as fresh as we've had at other places. Key lime colada was very tasty. Service was pretty slow and neglectful. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michael R.

11 years ago

Really beautiful location. Super food, drink and friendly service. Can't ask for a nicer way or place to relax and enjoy the view. read more

Island Fish - Second meal here in our three night stay. Good food and great location. - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Gricell D.

11 years ago

Pleasant atmosphere, nice bar. Grilled grouper sandwich was great. I never had fish chowder before and it was scrumptious. Will definitely be back. read more

Island Fish - Even on a gloomy day the view is nice - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Benjamin C.

238

11 years ago

Super cool atmosphere right on the water. Can't beat the views. Large menu, maybe too large, which I believe may lead to limitations in quality of food. The she crab soup was delicious but made with imitation crab, would have been the best if not for this fact. Oysters were delicious!! Sirloin burger somewhat over cooked but good all the same. Atmosphere pushes this Restraunt from a 3-4 but not overly impressed by food quality (other than oysters) read more

Island Fish - Oysters were bomb! - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Island Fish - Right on the water! - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Debbie C.

10 years ago

Delicious fresh Hogfish (pan seared) for lunch along with she crab soup. Our server, Betsy, was truly one of the best servers we have ever had! She was totally attentive, anticipating our needs and offering recommendations without hovering. A professional with a lovely personality. read more

Island Fish - Great atmosphere right on the water with beautiful views. - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kasey V.

7 years ago

The staff were very friendly and atmosphere was beautiful. Unfortunately, the food did not live up to the same way. It was just ok but definitely not worth the money. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mondo D.

7 years ago

Oh my god I love this place the best best service and great food and staff in that staff there is a guy named ray he touched our lives he needs a huge raise read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

David G.

152

7 years ago

Do not have the words the place is amazing, the food was absolutely top notch. Fresh hot and Great. Our waiter Robison was attentive funny and checked on us often. The prices were fair for the quality of the food would absolutely go back. The oyster shooter with the take home shot glass was a nice addition. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Amy P.

128

10 years ago

I absolutely loved this place! The service was amazing and the atmosphere was very welcoming and family oriented. I will definitely be back! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Gabie O.

5 years ago

The service was really good they accommodated to large groups. The dude with a ponytail was super welcoming he made me want to come to this establishment all the time. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Traci P.

5 years ago

Always rely on Yelp. Unfortunately y'all got it totally wrong this time. Views and location was on point, but it ended there. Food was mediocre at best, bland, no flavor, small portions of main dish, lots of chips and rice to fill in gaps. Service was terrible, pretty much non existent. Very slow from start to finish. No drink refills, had to ask for plates for appetizers, etc. We sat so long at end of meal and after flagging down server to pay was asked to wait....again. To add insult to injury, server "lost" our credit card while accidentally charging another party's check to our card. Skip this restaurant, nothing special here at all. read more

Business owner information

Sandi A.

Traci, we're so sorry to hear about your experience. We strive to…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joe L.

5 years ago

Beautiful spot! Had the Grouper platter, which was very tasty. Beers were good and the service was friendly and prompt. All employees wore masks and I didn't see any customers not wearing masks when they should have. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dawn M.

142

7 years ago

Food was excellent!!! Service was great! View was awesome.... slight mishap with the bill.... but after it all got straightened out, everything was fantastic!!! Would definately recommend and will be back!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Faith F.

134

5 years ago

Amazing food, great views with outdoor seating, and an amazing server! He was very attentive and helped us with any questions!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Steph L.

7 years ago

Had high hopes as this place was recommended by our dive master. Oysters were not fresh. Ordered blue point and the grilled garlic lime oysters. Ate one blue point and sent those back. Then tried the grilled. Not fresh and beyond that they were poorly prepared. Dry and flavorless. Sent them back. The kids popcorn shrimp came out of a freezer bag and the fried shrimp dinner was tough and again, flavorless. The only good meal at our table was the Ahi Salad. The tuna was fresh but full of connective tissue. SS Wreck and Gallery Grill is the place to go for seafood in Marathon. Ate there last night and everyone's meal was delish! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jennifer M.

5 years ago

We've eaten here three times while on our vacation in Marathon . The food is delicious ,but the entire staff is what makes this place amazing . I asked the host and one of the servers today if the management was good at this restaurant and they told me yes . Even more so that they're all like family . It shows that they work cohesively , like a family . They're happy and even more so they're happy the customers are there . We can't say enough good things about this restaurant and the people !! Give them a try , you'll be glad you did . read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Carrie F.

364

7 years ago

We came for the view, which did not disappoint. This restaurant is in a gorgeous setting. The food and the service was lacking. Our waitress was not friendly and acted like we were inconveniencing her when asking for something (utensils, mustard, etc). Then, our food came out and the main course had a hair on it. She reordered it and the second came out fine. I was astonished when she still charged us for the sandwich on the bill. We were in a rush to get to the airport (and quite frankly wanted to get out of the restaurant ASAP) so we did not argue, which I regret. Will not be returning on my next trip to the Keys. There are too many other great restaurants there. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

David C.

14 years ago

My family of 5 loved this place! It has something for everyone. The nachos are an obscene pleasure, which top off awesome toppings with a deep fried tortilla bowl. Angioplasty not included! The fish was great, including nice fish and imaginative preparations featuring fruits. The sea life keeps kids amused. Save room for key lime pie. Say hi to slash in the parking lot. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Carla V.

13 years ago

Our 1st dinner off property and we were pleasantly surprised by this low-key, picnic table dining on the water. The calamari is not to be missed. It is not your standard style. Bananas peppers on top and sprinkled with a lime mayo - AWESOME!!!! I had the coconut crusted fish with a pineapple salsa. it was divine. Others had grouper and were not disappointed. The kids enjoyed feeding the fish on the pier while we waited for the food. All were happy. Great views for picture taking after dinner. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tom R.

12 years ago

Awesome food and service. The view is just icing on the cake. A must stop for lunch. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Aubrey W.

12 years ago

Great conch fritters and stone crab claws! Great seafood all around along with shrimp tacos and fillet mignon. Would highly recommend for family or small group. Easy and friendly wait staff making it fun and enjoyable. Great selection of beers and margarita flavors and tequila choices. Would come back in a heart beat. read more

Island Fish - Conch fritters - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Gayle V.

11 years ago

Ate lunch here 2 days out of 4 so that has to say something! The first day we got seated right next to the waterfront which had an amazing view, super service and no wait at all. We had the stone crab and fish stuffed with crab. Both were amazing. The second lunch was muhhha. Long wait, service was poor...long wait for waitress, service ware, water. Lunch was ok..had the clam chowder and conch fritters. Couldn't get out of there fast enough on the second lunch. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michelle B.

11 years ago

Zach is awesome. Great food. We visited them twice this trip, once for breakfast and once for dinner. Sunsets are beautiful by the way. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cecile C.

11 years ago

Came here after staying at Hawks Cay. It's just 3 miles away. It has a wonderful view and really the best shrimp and grits!!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Maddy E.

110

10 years ago

Very good breakfast. Loved the smoked bacon with scrambled eggs and fruit. Delicious! Also love the amazing view from almost anywhere in the restaurant. Can see the ocean and it is beautiful! The service is very friendly. read more

Island Fish - View into the restaurant from the side next to the water. Love the tiki hut roof, very fun. - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Liz W.

10 years ago

Wow, wonderful brunch and great service even on a July 4th weekend. View is splendid looking over the bay. Highly recommend the Shipwreck Mary to start the day! read more

Island Fish - Excellent breakfast choice! Eggs Bennie with asparagus was to die for. Shrimp and bacon in grits was awesome. - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

Island Fish - Shrimp and bacon on grits - Seafood Near Me - Marathon, Florida

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Oshun H.

5 years ago

Upon leaving Tiffany the bartender yelled out "thanks for nothing cheap bitch" when I turned around she insisted on repeating herself by yelling and saying "cheap bitch" and even proceeded to follow me outside. I am in the process of filing out a case and will be following up with owner as this was verbal assault read more

Business owner information

Sandi A.

Oshun, the owner of the restaurant would like to speak with you…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Miriam D.

7 years ago

Lovely establishment! This was our first restaurant stop while in the keys, and we really enjoyed the water front view while we dined. We ate about 12pm so it wasn't busy and we got to sit right there on the little marina and watch all kinds of fish swim around. Service was great and friendly, food came out fast too! I had the fresh catch grilled Mahi, which was definitely worth the price! Their conch chowder was also exceptional, and I was pleasantly surprised with it since I had never had anything like that before. My mom had the conch ceviche, which she also loved. If your looking for water front dining and excellent fair-priced seafood... look no further! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Harris L.

5 years ago

Stopped for lunch on the way to Key West, food was great, service was very good, right on the water. I would recommend if to anyone.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Laurie K.

8 years ago

My favorite local restaurant. Great staff, friendly service. I cant think of a time I have ever been disappointed here.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Stephanie W.

5 years ago

Atmosphere and food were delicious the hostess and the staff were short and rude though.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kevin B.

5 years ago

Best Breakfast on our vacation. Food and service were excellent. We had an omelette, pancakes and breakfast sandwich and everything was great! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

June G.

8 years ago

fresh food , great view. Friendly people. Love this place very much! I would like to visit here again during our next Key west trip. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 29 of 45

12648 Overseas Hwy
Marathon, FL 33050
Directions
(305) 743-4191
Call Now
Visit Website
https://islandfishco.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Island Fish open?

Island Fish opens at 8:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Island Fish close?

Island Fish closes at 10:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Sun 8:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Island Fish take credit cards?

Yes, Island Fish takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Island Fish have catering options?

No, Island Fish does not have catering options.

Does Island Fish have a happy hour?

Yes, Island Fish has a happy hour.

Does Island Fish serve alcohol?

Yes, Island Fish serves alcohol. Full Bar

Indoor Amenities

Does Island Fish allow dogs?

Yes, Island Fish allows dogs.

Does Island Fish have TVs?

Yes, Island Fish has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Island Fish have bike parking?

Yes, Island Fish has bike parking.

Does Island Fish have outdoor seating?

Yes, Island Fish has outdoor seating options.

Does Island Fish have parking?

Yes, Island Fish has parking options. Private Lot Parking

Other Amenities

Does Island Fish allow outdoor smoking?

Yes, Island Fish allows outdoor smoking.

Does Island Fish have free WiFi?

No, Island Fish does not have free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

The Island Fish Co. invites you to sit back and relax while enjoying locally inspired dishes, fresh seafood and cool tiki favorites that will quench your thirst. Our spectacular sunset views and tropical waters will make your lunch, dinner, drinks and desserts that much more pleasurable. After eating, mosey through our gift shop where you will find Island apparel with original artwork and our exclusive logo on quality tank tops, t-shirts and sweaters. The mercantile shop is packed with great gift ideas to remember your trip to the Keys or make your friends who didn't come along jealous. If you are looking to just relax and enjoy the scenery, pull up a bar stool to the longest tiki bar in the Florida Keys. The bartenders are sure to put a smile on your face when you sip on one of their frozen favorites or cold draft beer. Happy Hour is from 3 to 5 PM, seven days a week.

History

Established in 1987.

Sunsets, Florida Bay views and great food can be found all in one place in the heart of the Florida Keys at Mile Marker 54 Bayside, Marathon. Come join us for breakfast, lunch and dinner serving the freshest fish and coldest cocktails in our casual atmosphere. Reservations are not accepted but we have plenty room and plenty of activities for you to do while here at The Island Fish Company. Afterall, it's what you came to the Keys for!

Meet the Business Owner: Gregg C.

For over 25 years, my wife, Cindy, and I have been welcoming thousands of locals and visitors to our establishment. We're proud to offer an extensive menu with the freshest fish and coolest cocktails of the Florida Keys. Whether you're traveling solo or with family or friends, you're sure to have a great time at the Island! We hope to see you soon!

More Info

Health Score

Island Fish Reviews in Other Languages

Ask the Community - Island Fish

Are there happy hour food specials, or do they just offer specials on drinks?

Yes there are app specials in the happy hour in addition to drink specials

View question details

Is this handicap accessible?

Yes

View 4 more answers

Delivery to jolly Rodger rv park?

No it doesn't

View question details

Is the restaurant dog friendly?? (Small well behaved 15 lbs dog)

Call first, but it's all outdoor seating and there's a beach area off to the side that would keep you out away from other diners

View 2 more answers

Are dogs allowed?

No. I called to confirm today 11/28/19 and the woman that answered said no dogs allowed regardless of size (mine is under 5 pounds).

View question details

Are they open after the hurricane?

Yes. We ate lunch there 2 weeks ago on Sat, Sept 30

View 3 more answers

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

You might also consider

Barnacle Barney's Tiki Bar

Horrible Key Lime Pie. Great location for a sunset and cold beer though. Wouldn't order food…read more Server was nice enough but lied about the "really good" pie.

Pass on the Giant Pretzel, not giant and so dry. Didn't taste any Rum in my pina colada. Pretty spotread more

Photos

Great spot for sunset

Marina and private island behind the Tiki Bar.

See all

Tiki Bar at Amara Cay Resort

4.3

(6 reviews)

25.6 mi

A nice place to grab a bite while at Amara Cay Resort. Located in the pool area, this tiki bar had…read moretasty food and friendly staff. The food took a bit of time to come out to us, but when it did, it was tasty and their draft beers were also good.

Amara Cay is one the fancier resorts in upper keys Always good. Love the fish sandwich.read more

Photos

Tiki Bar at Amara Cay Resort

See all

Tiki Bar at Amara Cay Resort

La Isla Taco Grill

4.4

(116 reviews)

3.4 mi

Awesome Food Truck & Tiki Bar in Marathon Key (FL) Great…read moreTacos Beers & Live Misic A Must-Stop in Marathon.

Stopped by this taco truck for some lunch. They are next to a tiki bar if you want drinks and have…read moreshaded seating. Service was prompt and friendly. I got the mahi taco. It was basically a fish stick in a taco which was different than I was expecting but still pretty good. Affordable lunch so no complaints!

Photos

Stake

See all

Burdines Waterfront Marina and Bar & Grill

Being from Florida and a very frequent visitor of the Keys we really wanted a burger. Well let me…read moretell you this place was A M A zing! We sat outside over looking the bay, which was nice. I didn't see any indoor sitting but hey, it's the Keys. Our server was so nice. He was very quiet and consistently smiling! Now let talk food! The hush puppies were absolutely perfect!! They served them with raspberry dip amazing. We both got the bacon cheeseburger. It was perfectly done, charbroiled, so juicy so good highly recommend. My favorite pie is a true key lime pie!! I took a leap and ordered the fried key lime pie....yes yes yes yes!!!! We will be back!

We were served from some rude foreign guy wearing a NY Yankees hat. Honestly we should have been…read moresurprised when we saw the hat. This server was honestly the worst I have ever had and his tip reflected that. The place doesn't have a real bar which sucks. The food is edible but not worth going here for. The best item on the menu is their French fries.

Photos

Deep Fried Key Lime Pie

Best hush puppies ever!

See all

Sunset at Burdines.

Tiki Bar at Hawks Cay

Decent food, decent drinks, decent service. If not for the drunken wedding party, this would have…read morebeen a excellent experience.

Came here during the day, bar tender was rude and not pleasant to order from! However, came back…read morelater in the evening to get drinks and Gustavo was amazing! He was friendly and made our drinks too our liking! Hoping for the Oasis to be open today as the bar tender there is nicer!

Photos

Tiki Grill Menu

Night shot

See all

@SaltwaterExp quick stop on the way to #KW

Havana Jacks

Visiting from New Orleans and had an impromptu lunch for 14 people. They sat us down and the…read moremanager personally made sure that we were taken care of. The wings were delicious, but so was all of the other food as well. Definitely recommend

It is a chill spot, great ambiance and it was nice to listen to live music. Child friendly, which…read morehelps when you have a little one. The service was quite slow when we got there, it took a bit to get seated even though we were the only ones waiting with numerous open tables. Once we got our table we had to ask multiple times for a kids menu and high chair, but our waitress eventually showed up and got both for us. The high chair was broken but we made it work for our little one. Our server was efficient and friendly, even though it took a bit for her to get to us. The food was good, not the best meal, but definitely good tiki bar food. I got the fish tacos which were good, and fries, they were the best part. We wanted to get dessert but there were so many flies it made us want to leave. To no fault of their own, it's unfortunate, and to be expected at an outdoor spot, but it was an overwhelming amount and we just didn't want to deal with it any longer. I think its a good spot to grab a drink on the water at the bar! Definitely brings a good vibe.

Photos

Coconut shrimp and prickly pear margarita on the rocks

See all

Great outside patio

TJ's Tiki Bar

3.4

(8 reviews)

5.3 mi

TJ's Tiki Bar has an incredible view of the sound and that makes it worth the visit. The drinks are…read moreon the pricey side, but they taste really good. It's a little tricky to get to since it's tucked in the back of a private resort and parking is very limited. The bartender seemed disinterested, but the view and drinks made up for it. I probably wouldnt go back but their key lime pie cocktail was very good.

I canNOT recommend TJ's Tiki Bar. We stayed at the host resort, so we tried it twice. Both times…read moregave us bad food. Some things were so bad, I can't believe they felt comfortable serving them. Maybe if you want to eat pizza and curly fries by the pool or beach, you'll be fine. But I would skip the fish tacos, burgers, salad, and smoothies. The fish tacos were overcooked so much they were like jerky. And the tortilla chips On the side were so stale, they were chewy. The salsa was slimy as though it had been made last week. An absolutely awful dish. The burger bun was LIKE A ROCK. You couldn't even pierce it with a fork. Like I said, I can't believe they served us that food. The "smoothies" are just ice and syrup. The setting right on the beach is lovely. And the service is fast and friendly. But I'd recommend almost anywhere else for bar food.

Photos

See all

Paloma

Cruisin’ Tikis Key Largo

5.0

(100 reviews)

43.9 mi

Was here for a wedding these guys are amazing. Captain Johnathan is the man. Thank you guys.read more

We just landed after a 90 minute cruise with Captain Jim. It was so worth it and an amazing time -…read morehe knows Buttonwood Bay, the birds, the iguanas, the manatee's & dolphins. We saw hound fish, barracudas and more. Learned that this whole bay is 3-5 feet - and today it was SO clear! Jim's co-captain, Mako was so well behaved and frankly I'm kinda sorry the cruise is done - till next time!

Photos

4th of July Tiki Cruise 2023

Key Largo Sunset Tiki Cruise with Captain Ryan

See all

4th of July Tiki Cruise 2023

Tiki House

We had a few birthday celebrations in our group, so we decided to stop into Tiki House for drinks…read moreand a little dancing. The vibe for an early Friday afternoon was really good. The DJ was playing some great music that kept the dance floor going, and the bartender did a solid job keeping up with orders and taking care of everyone quickly. No complaints from our group at all. Everyone had a great time, and we'll definitely be back next time we're in the area.

Fabulous experience and such a cute little tiki bar in Key West. Lives our bartenders and we'll be…read moreback next time we visit. We ordered delicious food and drinks and everything was great !

Photos

JungleBird Bowl

Inside

See all

Brass Monkey

A great bar, looks shady from street but once inside is great. Clean, great bar staff and general…read morevibe. Would recommend for sure

If you don't stop by the Brass Monkey did you even come the keys? The real folks can be found…read moresharing a drink and a dance to the sound of a live band in the realest bar in the keys, Dirk is the best bartender you can ask for.

Photos

Great late night spot!

Bar area

See all

Food menu

Herbie's Bar and Chowder House

our bartender, Mallory, was amazing. care of accommodating…read more we loved the restaurant! great wings!

Herbie's Bar & Chowder House in Marathon has been operating under that name since 1963, with roots…read moregoing back to the 1940s as Maggie's Chowder House and later Fishnet's. It's legitimately one of the oldest continuously operating restaurants in the Florida Keys, which gives it a lot of built-in credibility before you even sit down. Walking up to it, you feel that history. The exterior, the gravel lot, the signage--it's pure roadside Keys. Inside, it leans into that "local bar meets tourist stop" vibe: long wooden bar, TVs, stickers everywhere, taps lined up. Then you open the menu and it pivots in every direction--New England chowder house, BBQ joint, burger shack, seafood spot. It's not clear what it wants to be, and that lack of focus carries straight through to the food. We started with both chowders. The clam chowder looks right at first glance, but the texture tells you everything--thick, almost gluey, clearly roux-heavy. The flavor leans aggressively fatty, closer to margarine than butter, with very little clam presence. No briny backbone, no pepper, no lift. We ended up dumping in black pepper and hot sauce just to make it remotely acceptable--but even then, that heavy fat note kept pushing through. Nothing about it reads as New England. The conch chowder fares a bit better. You can actually see a decent amount of conch, and there's a peppery edge that helps. But the broth is thin and lacks the chunky, stewed tomato depth you expect from a proper Keys-style conch chowder. After having it done right earlier at Key Largo Fisheries, the difference was obvious. Then there are the Texas Twinkies--and the photo really says it all. On paper, this should work: jalapeños wrapped in bacon, stuffed with brisket, pulled pork, cheeses, and sauce. In execution, it's just too much. Too much cream cheese, too many competing sauces, meats chopped into a soft, indistinct filling. It collapses into a heavy, muddy bite that feels more overwhelming than satisfying. Looking back at the menu, the simpler move--burger, ribs, even wings--probably would have been the right call. Instead, we ordered straight into the identity crisis. And that theory held up. We went back and grabbed a burger later--cooked a proper medium rare, with well-done, crispy fries--and it was easily the best thing we had from them. I wanted to like Herbie's. There's history, personality, and clearly a loyal following. But between the confused concept and uneven execution, the move here is simple: stick to the basics.

Photos

Screened porch area. Two inside rooms also.

Burnt ends

See all

Mussels

Dockside Bar and Grill

4.2

(108 reviews)

4.4 mi

Excellent food - I recommend the conch fritters and the ahi tuna. If you only have room for 1, go…read morewith the ahi! It's an appetizer, so it's not massively filling, but it is super delicious. Margarita was great, too! Ambience gives off loud, locals mixed with cool tourists. Great dock location. Highly recommend.

Yessir this is where you want to go to relax and have some great food and drink! The 4 of us went…read moreon 12/29/2025 and were so happy to be there again - we've patronized this joint several times over the years and keep coming back. The drinks are made perfectly and there's a large menu to choose from. In addition, the prices are very reasonable. When you first walk in, there's a large wrap-around bar that is usually full to the brim with happy patrons. But don't worry - walk to the other side of the bar and there's a large patio chock full of additional seating. Thankfully, the view from any angle is beautiful because you are... dockside! You are right on the water! Check their social media accounts to see the who and what - because the place is always offering some type of live music act. If you need a low-key, super casual, and relaxing environment - but also want great drinks and fare - then go to Dockside Bar and Grill.

Photos

The outside bar.

Thinnest piece of Mahi on the cheapest hamburger bun for 16.95... charge me 22 and get me more than 3.5oz of meat

See all

Inside

Bongos Botanical Beer Garden

4.6

(112 reviews)

5.5 mi

EASILY some of the BEST food I've ever had in my life -- no exaggeration…read more We went all in: shrimp tacos, chicken tacos, carne tacos, the shrimp po' boy, and the fried pork... and EVERY. SINGLE. THING. was unreal. Like, not one weak item on the table. But let me be clear -- that shrimp po' boy??? ABSOLUTELY STOLE THE SHOW. I'd go back for that alone. The whole place has that perfect outdoor Keys vibe -- laid back, great energy, just straight-up good times. And the service?? Top tier. Olivia and Mikey were on point the entire time -- super friendly, nailed the order, and made the experience even better. Huge respect to the kitchen too -- Marcus and Chapel are putting out some seriously special food. You can TASTE the effort and care in every bite. This place isn't just good... it's the kind of spot you think about after you leave. A spot you talk about until you go back. We'll 1000% be back. Probably way too soon

Food was good and fresh. Ate the tune poke bowl and the ceviche…read more Wasn't a fan of the ceviche, was a bit spicy and made in some sort of Jamaicans rule recipe. The tuna poke made up for it though. Tune was very fresh.

See all

Blu Bistro and Bar

4.2

(16 reviews)

4.2 mi

The food is excellent. Service a bit weak. Good music. Greek themed food. Nice pool setting.read more

Great chicken and meat skewers they don't hold back on the French fries salad was good needed a…read morelittle more sauce but besides that the food was good. I ordered 4 skewers and only got 2 but could have been an honest mistake we also got a burger as well and it was over cooked for my liking but the service was great and a wide variety of seating arrangement

Photos

Front sign

CHICKEN TACO

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

66 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Angela O.

10 years ago

WHAT IS WORSE THAN ONE? I want that option. Have been to the Island Fish Company many times and, although nothing spectacular, we never had a bad experience however that all changed tonight. Our 2 year old daughter said she didn't like the kids spaghetti but we figured she was just being picky like every other 2 year old. We had just receive our entrees. Two seconds later she is projectile vomiting all over the table, my 7 month pregnant wife, the floor...anyone with children understands. The waiter comes by to check on us and sees what is going on. He doesn't offer napkins, a towel, a HAND...nothing. So, I get up and run over to the waitress station and get napkins and then run out to the car and get a pack of baby wipes. Finally, I asked the waiter if he had a garbage bag for my wife who was cleaning the entire booth....7 months pregnant!!! Not once, did anyone ask if they could help, could we maybe warm your food up, make you something fresh, NO, instead I got the check. I asked to speak to the manager and Andy, the manager on duty, came over and told me that we made a mess of his booth....WHAT??? I bit my tongue and explained to him that we can't exactly eat our food and that my daughter said the spaghetti was bad. What did Andy say you ask, "I have served 15 of those tonight and they have been spot on". He then continued with the "mess" we had made. Finally, I could take no more. I informed Andy that we would be happy to pay for what we ate and nothing more. What next you ask, Andy called the police!!!! Three cop cars pull up and my wife goes over to speak with them. Andy says that we were walking out on our bill. WHAT? We waiting for 30 minutes for the police. Our other two kids were on the restaurant dock feeding the fish. Walking out?!?!?! The Monroe County Sheriffs office could not have been nicer. Andy spoke to the police horribly! They explained to Andy that they could not make us pay. After listening to this "manager" go on and on for 15 minutes, my wife just said she would pay the bill to get out of there. The police explained they could not force her to do so but with a crying baby in the car full of puke, my wife did the right thing and chose our kids over Andy. The police offered to escort my wife back into the restaurant so that Andy could not be mean to her anymore. The police said they would write up a police report even though that was uncommon in this type of situation so that if we chose to fight this, there was a record of it. Thank you Monroe County Sheriff's office for making this horrible experience a little better. Finally, we spoke with the concierge at our hotel on arrival back and they said, "these guys treat tourists terribly". Lesson learned, speak with locals first! read more

Anna B.

1 year ago

When we first arrived, our waiter seemed friendly, but his attitude quickly shifted when I inquired about a military discount. I offered my DD214, but he insisted on a specific ID and was unhelpful in resolving the issue. I wasn't sure if I had my disabled VA card with me, and mentioned it might be in my car. He told me I had to go get it, even though I had already offered my DD214 and driver's license, both valid forms of ID. Later, when I spoke to him about it, he told me he had "gone out of his way" to help me get the discount. I replied, "No, I had to go out of my way because you wouldn't accept any form of identification besides my disabled VA card." Then, in the middle of our conversation, he rudely handed us the check over the top and between our heads, saying "Here you go," which felt incredibly disrespectful. We had returned because the food had been excellent the previous year, but this visit completely soured the experience. We spent a lot on what was meant to be a special evening, only to leave feeling unappreciated. While the manager was kind and tried to address the situation, the overall experience had already been tainted. If they want us to believe this was a one-off, they would need to prove it--that they don't operate like this and don't accept behavior like this from their staff. If you want to enjoy their amazing food, order out. But if you're looking for both good service and great food, go somewhere else. I can't recommend this place, especially to fellow disabled veterans. read more

Jeff S.

13 years ago

Great place!!! We stopped here for lunch on our way down to Key West. We are use to seafood since we live in Miami, but crave seafood when in The Keys. I had Panko Hogfish on flatbread and my husband had blackened shrimp in a wrap with mango-pineapple salsa both were delicious. What set our meal over the top to make me want to post a review, which I never have done before, was the appetizer cracked conch. IT WAS AMAZING!!! Extremely Tender and the key lime tartar sauce was perfect to compliment the conch. Needless to say our entire trip in Key West we could NOT find another restaurant that could even come close to the same. We ate our last night at The Conch Republic in KW and theirs was good but chewy!!! Island Fish's cracked conch was SO GOOD that on our way back home we stopped and picked up 3 orders to take home!! Lol. So worth it!!! Yum read more

Jennifer V.

945

2 years ago

We absolutely love Island Fish Co! One night, we got there and found ourselves craving pasta.... Do we decided to give their offerings a try. We were pleasantly surprised by how incredible their pasta dishes were; we thoroughly enjoyed every bite! Gail opted for the traditional spaghetti and meatballs, which was rich and flavorful, while I went for the linguine and clams, a dish that was equally delicious and perfectly prepared. We were both impressed by the generous portions--so much so that we left with takeaway boxes filled with enough food for two more meals! Each dish came beautifully served with a fresh salad and warm bread with butter, making for a satisfying dining experience. If you're in the mood for pasta, don't hesitate to visit Island Fish Co. You'll be delighted by their delicious offerings! read more

Suzanne C.

6 years ago

Not the first time at this restaurant. Visited on another trip. View is great! Was seated immediately. Great evening and friendly staff. Ordered crab cakes and calamari. Calamari was not the best, batter flavorless and no sauce. Did like the banner peppers on the calamari The crab cakes were more bread than crab. The drinks were fair to say the least. But server "my name is Nathaniel but you can call me Nate" was good. Ordered shrimp scampi and the shrimp were delicious but swimming in oil. Couldn't eat it all. Hubby had the grouper with veggies and rice. Grouper fresh. There was not much social distancing going on. Signs were up and masks were required until you sat at the table. Bar was packed and seating in the dining area was full. Every table was being used. No major cleaning between patrons. read more

Heather C.

3 months ago

Went to dinner for anniversary. Ordered smoked dip for appetizer. The smoked dip tasted like it came out of a can, no flavor at all. Husband ordered fried grouper platter and I ordered a petite filet minion and lobster. Was served with sweet potato fries and mixed veggies, the steak was not cooked the way I wanted it the broccoli was cold. The lobster was good and not too rubbery. I told the server I was not a tourist so give it to be straight if this dish was good and I think he was just saying yes cause of the price$45 for the plate. I was disappointed and I'm not much of a complainer but this was sad. I hate wasting money on food that is low quality! I will stick to my other favorite spots and give this restaurant a rest. Maybe they can get it together read more

Diana R.

5 years ago

11/22/2021 4:00pm We went for happy hour and no one attended us when we said we want to take advantage of happy hour. They made us paid in full price even if we ate our food by the bar area. Bunch of racist people (I am Asian and my husband is Hispanic). I told 2 ladies that it's our first time and if she can give us more information, she said she doesn't have any information about their pricing etc. One totally ignored us and continuously served and attend to the next table. Don't come here if you don't want to ruin your vacation time. My family watched me ate my food as no one came to take their order. It's our first time coming here and just disappointed of how bad people can be. There are bunch of better restaurants! read more

Tania D.

Elite 26

199

520

1 year ago

Chill Keys Vibes & Fried Key Lime Surprise Stopped by Island Fish Restaurant in Marathon for a laid-back lunch with my cousins visiting from North Carolina. It's got that classic Keys charm -- breezy water views, casual vibes, and seafood-forward fare. The Lobster Roll hit the spot, and the Grouper was solid -- nothing mind-blowing, but tasty and fresh. The real standout? Fried Key Lime Pie. Yep, fried. A crispy, tangy twist on the classic dessert you'll see everywhere else in the Keys -- definitely worth a try. All in all, it's a great place to relax, take in the views, and enjoy that easygoing Keys feeling. I'll be back next time I'm in town. read more

Martha D.

9 years ago

This is the most convenient place to dine in Marathon and it hosts the greatest views of the marina. Its open late so no rush after a long day outing, you can look forward to some special drinks because they put some TLC behind the bar. A cool breeze off the water on a hot night is always refreshing in the Keys and they have that covered. Don't forget the shrimp dishes here because I think I had everyone while I was in town. I really enjoyed the relaxing breakfast watching the pelicans sipn on a Bloody Mary reading the local. read more

K J.

5 years ago

We went there twice I last week. They were on point both times. The service was great and the food was on point. We were staying at Hawks Cay and tried the Angler and Ale one night. There is no comparison, the Fish House is better by a grand slam in all categories. The service is far better and the food taste better and is a better value. From the chicken Cesar wrap to the seafood pasta, the calamari app is the bomb. The coconut shrimp was also fantastic. If your in the area is a must stop. read more

Ed L.

10 years ago

My wife and I began to dine at the Island Fish Company since 2009. Every time we pass thru the keys this is a must stop. The view is spectacular. Try the She Crab soup it is second to none, the Oysters Rockefeller are a must and the Conch Ceviche will blow your tastebuds!!! Wash it all down with a Mai Tai or a Mohito and you are in paradise. Stop on by the Idland Fish Company today and enjoy the best eatery in Marathon, FL!!! read more

Ashley S.

5 years ago

We had an amazing lunch at the island fish. Our food was great, the atmosphere was beautiful and our waiter had us laughing and having a great time from the moment we sat down. Not to mention, I have been trying to get this man to eat raw fish for the last four years..... marathon, FL, an amazing waiter with a a great sense of humor...... he ate raw tuna and we have the pictures to prove it. read more

Carlos C.

110

9 years ago

The conch fritters were amazing and you definitely have to try the Coconut crusted yellow tail it was out of control. All of the staff and most of all our waitress Logan she was the best first she made great suggestion for us to eat. Then refilled our drinks before I had to ask super polite friendly. I would highly suggest this place a big thumbs up from a very pick customer. read more

Ana J.

12 years ago

I was at this restaurant with my family over the Christmas Holidays. They have a captured Iguana in a tiny cage, just outside of the restaurant, which is extremely off putting and sad for anyone with an ounce of compassion. My family and I do not support exploitation of animals for human entertainment and would never go back to a place that does such a thing. Horrible! read more

Julia H.

231

11 years ago

Cup of coffee 2.50. No refills offered. One piece of toast 2.00. Cold mushy grits, uncooked potatoes and extremely poor service. My bacon and eggs were all that was edible. Cost 26.00. I'm so disappointed because I used to bring my children here when they were little. Too bad I won't be coming back. :( read more

Jimmy M.

10 years ago

Really enjoyed this place. Great menu and great atmosphere. Brought a 6-year old and 4-year old and they had a great time. Try the fried Key Lime pie, but ask for a scoop of ice cream with it! I will definitely be going back next time I'm in the keys! read more

Lazlo M.

10 years ago

Great food, fresh catch fish, perfect for boaters to dock, and great view. I often come here whenever I am in Marathon on the way to Key West. I definitely recommend this spot to anyone, especially tourists staying in the area. read more

Cari T.

9 years ago

This place was delicious and fast! I loved the conch fritters and the peel and eat shrimp. My kids enjoyed walking to the marina and seeing all the fish too. Great family pictures with the sunset too read more

Jerry Z.

11 years ago

This place used to be great. Now just a tourist trap. Mahi sandwich has 1/4 thick piece of fish and no flavor. Too bad about this place. They let it go to hell. Overpriced and low quality. read more

Kelli S.

152

4 years ago

We enjoyed this place twice on our trip. Service was good. Food was tasty and plentiful. We tried a few other places but enjoyed the atmosphere and prices and food. read more

See more unrecommended reviews

Island Fish - seafood - Updated July 2026

People who viewed Island Fish also viewed

Square Grouper - Islamorada

742 reviews

$$$

Lazy Days Restaurant

2268 reviews

Mahina

135 reviews

Salt + Ash

39 reviews

Burdines Waterfront Marina and Bar & Grill

1262 reviews

Atlantic's Edge Restaurant

111 reviews

$$$

Blue Waters Bar & Grill

21 reviews

Sunset Lounge

27 reviews

The Rhum House

55 reviews

The Dining Room

48 reviews

$$$$

Island Fish

Island Fish Photos

Business Info

Island Fish Popular Dishes

Island Fish menu photos

ISLAND FISH ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Island Fish

Reviews With Photos

More info about Island Fish

Payment methods

Food & Alcohol

Indoor Amenities

Outdoor Amenities

Other Amenities

Island Fish Reviews in Other Languages

Ask the Community - Island Fish

You might also consider

More businesses like Island Fish

Barnacle Barney's Tiki Bar

Tiki Bar at Amara Cay Resort

La Isla Taco Grill

Burdines Waterfront Marina and Bar & Grill

Tiki Bar at Hawks Cay

Havana Jacks

TJ's Tiki Bar

Cruisin’ Tikis Key Largo

Tiki House

Brass Monkey

Trending businesses in Island Fish's area

Herbie's Bar and Chowder House

Dockside Bar and Grill

Bongos Botanical Beer Garden

Blu Bistro and Bar

66 Island Fish reviews that are not currently recommended

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

66 reviews that are not currently recommended

Island Fish - seafood - Updated July 2026

Best of Marathon

People found Island Fish by searching for…

Browse Articles

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Trending Searches in Marathon, FL

People who viewed Island Fish also viewed