We have eaten here on many occasions but we've always ordered pizza. Their pizza is my favorite, but today we were on a mission to try other items on the menu. Recently we had a white pizza and ordered a side of marinara. Turns out their marinara is homemade and very good! I ordered the made-to-order veal Parmesan and hubby ordered the meat ravioli. The veal was cooked very nicely; not overcooked like some places like to do. It was served with spaghetti but it must've been thin spaghetti because it was almost like angel hair with that wonderful marinara on top. The ravioli had five large pieces and hubby said he got his fill. As good as the veal Parmesan was, next time I want to try their homemade lasagna just because I want to try different things. Update: still love this place and tried something new today - steak and onion calzone with a side of that homemade marinara. Yum! The calzone is huge! I could only eat half, but hubby ate about three quarters of his and he has a big appetite. read more

Great food. We order about once a week. They helped me with an Uber eats order that got totally screwed up. It was remade and delivered hot. Great gnocchi. read more

I've only ordered pizza for take out here and it's pretty good. If you like a lot of cheese on your pizza and get the Sicilian. I'm giving this place four stars because both times I've gone in the owners are incredibly nice. On top of that, both times I've been in there hasn't been any customers. I'd like to see this place do better. There's very few restaurants on this area of US1. read more

Ordered from Uber eats. Everything in the order was wrong. I called the restaurant and was told they couldn't do anything about it. I needed to contact Uber. Extremely disappointed that the owner wouldn't make it right! And the food that we did get wasn't very good :( read more

This is the place to go for pizza in the Nocatee/Palencia area. Legit crust. If you go to Papa John's down the road instead you're crazy. Born and raised in NJ and this place is as close as it gets. I've only had the meat lovers and plain cheese take out and it's worth every penny. read more

I've heard about this place from my parents - always their first stop when they arrive in St. Augustine - not only for the food, but for the service. Well, we made it here in December and I had to say I was impressed. The staff recognized my parents when they walked in and while the inside is unassuming, they reserve the delight of the experience to the service and the food. Fresh, warm bread was brought to the table along with our small house salads (which are a hearty size!). We then shared a white pizza - which was delicious! We had enough to take leftovers home, and it was just as good reheated. Rich, and creamy and wonderful. Grazie Jonis Pizza! read more

This was an excellent Italian restaurant! We visited after reading reviews and it was even better than expected! It is a small quaint spot hidden away in a new shopping area so not much traffic and no wait! Great food and great service!!! read more

Do not go for lunch. You'll likely be the only ones in the dark restaurant (with the blinds pulled) with two owners (?) that just aren't that nice. Your entree will be heated in a microwave (yep!) and you'll want to leave ASAP to avoid the situation all together. read more

I just called this place for a pick up order. Was greeted by an extremely rude person who said "what do you want, we are about to close" (it was 8:05pm, website says 9pm). I stated my order she said very rudely "can you pay cash" I said "no". She proceeded to tell me they are closed again and when I told her the website days 9pm says replied "well that's changed." This place is near my house and we would have probably tried them out and used them again. But now we won't ever call or go in for dining after this phone call. Update your hours on your website and yelp before being rude to people. read more

One of the better pizza options around. Way better than the chain places and on par with the other New York style. Never gotten anything other than pizza. As far as the reviews that mention delivery, I have been preserving for 4 years and they have never had delivery. The place is dark but I treat it as a carry out not dine in. read more

Decent food at best. Ordered a pizza for pickup. Restaurant was dead and the guy working was pretty awkward and I was uncomfortable in the environment. read more

I went here to get pizza to go and on entering I was a little nervous about trying it. The place was dark, all blinds drawn, no customers, warm and all the fans were on. Against my better judgement, I decided to go ahead and give it a try. Ordered two pizzas and garlic bread. There was a dark hair in the garlic bread so that went straight in the trash. The white pizza was not good at all. Very little cheese or white sauce and a few tomatoes thrown on. Pepperoni pizza was below average. We will not return. read more

better half and I ate here last night . I had pasta and meatballs she had eggplant and pasta. Very good.

I work in Jacksonville, FL and Jonis Pizza is few a miles nearby the area I work at. I drove past it a few times, but never dined there until today. I enjoy good Italian food as well as pizza and decided to give them a try. I came by for lunch today. The place was empty and the owner greeted me and offered me a menu. Prior to arrival, I viewed their menu online and decided upon what I wanted. I ordered the fried calamari, chicken Marsala, and a drink. The owner rang up the total at the counter. I asked if they take debit, but oddly the owner asked if I had cash; however, he accepted my debit card payment. I sat myself at a table. The owner brought me my drink and went into the kitchen. I observed the owner and at least two other people in the kitchen prepare my order. My appetizer of fried calamari came out first. The marinara sauce was warm. I couldn't tell if the calamari was homemade or possibly frozen. I couldn't tell either way based on the breading, but it tasted very good and I will say it tasted better than the fried calamari served at Olive Garden, but not as good as the one at Carrabba's. The marina sauce was warm and tangy. My chicken Marsala entrée came out a bit afterwards before I managed to finish the calamari. The portion was average. It was two portions of chicken and appeared as if it was a chicken breast sliced in half to make it appear generous. A fairly decent amount of marsala sauce with mushrooms were provided and served over regular spaghetti. The flavor and taste was fine, but the spaghetti could have been better drained. It was not bad, but average. After I finished my meal, the owner and I chatted a bit. He was keenly interested in my take on the meal and I told him it was fine and I would come back to try out his pizza the next time I'm in the area which I will. I critique/judge an Italian restaurant based on its chicken Marsala and pizza. Thus far, Jonis Pizza in terms of its chicken marsala is average and I look forward to trying out their pizza and see if it's worth continuing to visit. The interior is completely unassuming, but one major observation is that the location is somewhat hidden in a mostly empty strip plaza mall off the highway that can be easily overlooked short of regular patrons who know where it is. read more

Good NY style pizza in St. John's county at a good price. Glad we tried it for take out. Will order here more often. Pesto cheese bread was good too! read more

I wanted to try this out, but that was a mistake. The cold, dark atmosphere and empty restaurant should have given it away. Beneath the excessive grease on both a pizza and calzone I ordered, it was obvious the meat and cheese were off and the vegetables uncooked. I could tell from the first bite. Having tried pizza from many pizzerias in NYC, this shouldn't be in the same category for comparison. I will not be returning. read more

I love the food at Jonis Pizza. My husband and I get a pizza from there most weekends and it is always delicious! We love the crust and the toppings are always ample. The price is very reasonable, too. I've also had the lasagna, which was also very good. A very fresh side salad came with the lasagna. Yum! I highly recommend this restaurant! read more

This is an amazing place. , delicious food, best gluten free pizza around ! Quiet very casual Love Joni's

I have ordered pizza from here 3 times since moving to Nocatee in late September. The first two times, the pizza was average. Tonight's pie was really good. I have also ordered a dinner from here but that was nothing to brag about. I will stick to ordering pizza and hope it continues to turn out like tonight's pie. read more

called at 7:30 on Sunday 11/13 but no one answered.. yelp shows their open until 9pm bummer!! was really in the mood for Pizza

Joni's is simply the best pizza in the area. It seems most of their business is take out so you can always find a seat. Good atmosphere, really nice owners. read more

Used to drive to Palencia to get good NY Style pizza until one day I didn't want to drive that far, and I was very happy that I got great NY Style pizza closer, cheaper, hotter and with more flavor. Nice post-baking seasonings added to the top of the pizza. I am a NY Style pizza purist, if you fold it and it droops its good pizza and it droops every time. The pizzas is always quick and ready when I arrive. A friend of mine says that the Eggplant Parm is the best she's had in the area. I cannot bring myself to order it because I like the pizza so much. Also the zeppoles are authentic, most of the time they don't even make it home, deep fried dough is just not the same reheated anyway. read more

We moved here from another state and have started looking for all our new favorites ... Jonis Pizza is a keeper. We ordered take out - wings, pizza and a child's ravioli. Everything was hot and ready when we arrived. We ordered mild wings - just enough spice to make them interesting and not dry and overcooked as some places make them. They were perfect. We ordered a white margarita pizza. The crust was awesome...thin and fresh. The toppings were in perfect balance as well. If the empty plate is any indication, the baked child's ravioli was great as well. We will definitely be a return customer. Just as a side note: they prefer you pay in cash. read more

Great NY style pizza. I have only ordered out, but there is inside seating. I find it to be the best in Jax area. Better than Al's pizza.

This was my first time ordering and the food was good however the woman answering the phone was very rude. I ordered a pizza and cannoli and didn't receive the cannoli. She was rude while I placed my order but when I called back asking about the cannoli she argued saying I didn't ask for it. She was so rude to the point I had to hang up the phone. Not a good first time experience! And I definitely will not be going back due to the lack of respect for customers. I will be informing my neighbors as well to avoid this place unless they like being disrespected. read more