Good pizza. We got a mushroom & garlic pie. Quick Nice & friendly staff. Always a nice place.read more

Always enjoyed the food. Do not like that the woman at the front decided to put $5 of my change in…read morethe tip jar on her own, even though that is what I would have done myself. To do that and run to the back is sneaky. Don't think I didn't notice. I recommend bringing exact change. After careful consideration, I will no longer contribute to their tip jar.

I am alone now. My husband & I tried every pizza in town, Gara's is the BEST pizza in town! I go…read moreonce a week so I don't have to cook. There sauce is perfect, specialty pizza has perfect amount of dressing, (barbecue & ranch) pizza is perfection. All the girls are so curtious, thank you. Michele ​

Best pizza in the area!! The sauce is very good, cheese is fresh, n the crust is perfect. Great…read morecombination of the three ingredients for a perfect pizza. I grew up near NYC n Gara's tops most other places.

It's been many years since I had pizza here. I heard that…read morethey changed things around, So because we're in the area and hungry for pizza we decide to stop.Our margarita pie was delicious. The sauce was top-notch and we will be back!!

My gf and i decided to dine here for dinner on a wednesday simply looking for pizza. This place…read moreseemed promising from the outside but upon entering it was immediately apparent this place is just a simple pizza joint. I read some older reviews and learned the previous owners had a horror themed pizza joint that many visitors enjoyed but i guess the new owners changed the vibe to something more casual. Service was on the slow end but to my knowledge staff was either short or it's a small team and overall the service was good no complaints there. But now we get to the food and it's neither good or bad just.. right in the middle with the middle being.. standard. We shared one large (16 inch) Pizza with Mushroom on the whole pie then getting one side sausage and the other broccoli and a side of 'pizza fries' that were ordinary unseasoned fries topped with a mess of Pizza sauce and mozzarella cheese. It wasn't inedible but i can't say i'd order it again. the pizza was good woth the sausage being pretty decent and the mushrooms being very bland and that's because they're from a can, i use to make pizzas for a local pizza joint i get it so i won't flame the flavorless mushrooms. The crust was surprisingly crisp and delicious, it's very rare i finish my pizza crust i usually just give mine to my gf but the pie was alright. My biggest take on nicolosi's is the prices. pizza is expensive i get it but honestly the price for the quality is slightly off and i say this with experience from many different pizza places on both the east and west coast. would come back for a pizza in the future.

The most unprofessional experience I have ever had in my life. I wasn't even a patron here and the…read moreunprofessionalism reached me. Their delivery driver who drives the Red Honda passed me at 50+ mph on Dumont road, not to mention with double yellow line. He then proceeds to cut the corners like he's driving a race car at dangerous speeds in close proximity to a residential neighborhood, Greenwich Chase. I observed him turning into the plaza by Home Depot still driving erratically, and blows through the stop sign by the Home Depot, all of this while not using a blinker, going at least 30+ mph at this point through the parking lot. I followed the car as, I was right behind it, and lo and behold....he delivers for Bella. I went into the restaurant to make a comment about how he drove. As I was leaving, after telling the workers what I just encountered, he rolled his window down and was screaming profanity and insults at me from across the parking lot as he's driving away. The words I will not specifically mention here. Just a hint....Words that started with F's and B's. Not to mention there was a child in my vehicle, who unfortunately had hear his profane language and was visibly shaken from what had just happened. I grew up right down the road from this place on 519, and my family has been in the area for generations. Our family has been patrons for over 15 years. I have never in my life been so appalled by someone's behavior. I am extremely dissatisfied with how this employee carried himself. I have had family members that have worked there in the past few years, and it was not like this. It is a shame this is who bella has working for them. I will most definitely be taking my business elsewhere after this experience, and I'll be sure to tell my friends and family the same. I am sorry to have to leave this review, but I couldn't fathom the acts of the delivery driver. Especially knowing the reputation they have had in the Stewartsville area for a long time as a good local business.

My family gets pizza here almost every week during the summer. My brother lives and breathes off…read moretheir buffalo chicken pizza. I have to say it's pretty good, the few times my brother let me try it (he takes a whole pie to himself). We recently tried something different this weekend and got the chicken calzone and spinach roll. Spinach roll isn't something I would try again, but I'm glad I tried it. It's very watery if that makes sense. However the chicken calzone will be something I will get in the future. Great service and restaurant!

I've been stopping by this Pizzeria since coming to to almost a year ago. I've had the Buffalo…read morechicken, Margarita pizza and plain Sicilian. Just a little on the oily salty side. Just the way I like it. The Sicilian crust was nice and crunchy and the sauce was flavorful. Full selection of Joes Ice teas along with typical sodas. Staff are attentive and polite. Menu is still being worked on and I must say, I'm looking forward to my next order.

Everything I have ever ordered from George's Pizza has been delicious. I totally recommend them.read more

Diarrhea twice from this places food. My husband ordered a…read morepizza half pepperoni. It was an old pizza they threw pepperoni on half. Pepperoni put on a fresh pizza is melted into the cheese; these pepperoni fell off when you try to eat it. It was obviously reheated, cheese covered in grease tainted orange, the crust was burnt litteraly black from overheating. When we order by phone everything was fine and I felt fine, the pizza was ok. However when my husband orders in person the food is horrible and get a stomach ache a few hours after. This is the second time this happened and it's obviously racism. We won't be going here anymore. Maybe this place should treat all their customers the same. Fresh made food shouldn't be burnt and cause Diarrhea again this ONLY happens when he orders in person. We used zero coupons, paid full price and left a tip. SHAME on this place.

We tried their meals to go first, vodka la penne with sausage, and mussels marinara with meatballs;…read moreboth come with bread snd salad. The portions were very generous! Three days later we stopped in for a slice. We tried their supreme and really enjoyed it. I have a favorite place for pizza that is in the opposite direction, but this. An easily replace them if I'm in this direction. We will be back.

Awesome pizza! Super nice guys working at the store. We loved the buffalo pizza and everything else…read morelooked delicious. Thank you, Bella Pizza :)

The best pizza!! So delicious food ,…read moreWith friendly staff .. High recommend great place

This was the worse pizza we ever ate. We ordered the Brooklyn pie. It was sauce on thick crust…read more No cheese in sight. We couldn't freeze the leftovers as we usually would because it was just sauce so we threw it out. We wouldn't anyways since it was the worse pizza we ever ate. $35 down the drain

We just moved to Phillipsburg NJ and we decided to try out some pizza places. Let me tell you!…read moreAbsolutely DELICIOUS! We ordered a cheese pie "the big one", waffle fries, garlic knots, & sweet chili wings. Everything was amazing! The garlic knots are big and fluffy. Service was amazing. The guys were very welcoming. Place is cute! They have couple of tables to sit inside and a small variety of drinks to choose from. They also sell pasta and marinara sauce. Please check them out!